- 1 - ! "# $" % %!"" &' ! "# $ % %! & % '### ( &&"# &&"# &&"# $ ! Digitally signed by PREMCHANDRA M R Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) & ((' ((& & & ) & *+,-+ ,.+/ 012345/ 61* .75 85.+.+135* ,39 *+,//+:,*;23 ,72:,* 61* .75 *54813953.4 7,-5 ,885,*59+385*413 ( 712<7 .75 =,..5* +4 /+4.59 .19,> 61* 8*5/+=+3,*> 75,*+3<+.+475,*9 75 0,8.+1359 )*+. 5.+.+13 +4 6+/59 455:+3< .75 61//1?+3<*5/+564 + 4425 , )*+. 16 5*.+1*,*+ .1 @2,47 .75 +=82<359 5391*45=53. 9,.59 #'#(#( 8,4459 A> *54813953. 1 ,2.71*+.> -+95 335B2*5 *5624+3< .1 0134+95* .75 0/,+= 16 .75 85.+.+135* 455:+3< 95/5.+13 16 8*17+A+.+13 0/,245,.01/2=3 116.7585*.,+3+3< .1/,391685.+.+135*+3> 1'' C =5,42*+3< #(,0*54#(<23.,416,/,9:5*+ !-+//,<561* - 3 - ?,3. 16 ,-,+/,A+/+.> 16 1*+<+3,/ *501*94 +3 .75 166+0516*9,39.7*54813953. ++ 4425 , )*+. 16 ,39,=24 9+*50.+3< *54813953.4(.1.10134+95*.75<*+5-,30516 .7585.+.+135*2395*.75*58*5453.,.+1349,.59 ##(#(# ##(#(# ##(#( ##(#( ,39 ##(#( -+95 335B2*54 .1?+.7+342074.+82/,.59.+=5 75471*.6,0.416.750,45,*5 .+44.,.59.7,..7585.+.+135*+4.75,A41/2.51?35*16.75 /,39A5,*+3<> 1'' C .1,35B.53.16#(0*54#(23.,4 12.16.1.,/5B.53.16#0*54(23.,44+.2,.59,.,/,9:5*+ %+//,<5,/2:,39+4.*+0.+9,*.+442A=+..59.7,..75/,394 +3 > 14'' ,39 ' 16 %+//,<5 ,/,9:5*+ ?5*5 .75 42A;50. =,..5* 16 *,3. 2395* 50.+13 16 .75 ,*3,.,:, ,39 561*=4 0. D' +3 6,-1* 16 .75 85.+.+135*E4 6,.75* 3,=5/> *,88, 17+-,88, ,/13< ?+.7 7+4 A*1.75* 7,39*,88, 17+-,88, ,39 7,3:*5??, ) 1,3,=,3.7,88, +3 &+/5 19,.59('#D".+44,+9.7,.12.16# 0*54(23.,4,35B.53.16#(0*54#(23.,4+44.,39+3<+3 - 4 - .753,=516.7585.+.+135*,39*5=,+3+3<5B.53.16#0*5( 23.,4+44.,39+3<+3.753,=5167,3.7:2=,* 1,.5,3+: A5+3<.7541316.755/95*A*1.75*16.7585.+.+135*3-+5?16 .750139+.+134+3.751*95*16<*,3..75*5+4,353.*>+31/2=3 1 16 .75 501*9 16 +<7.4 *565**+3< .1 8*17+A+.+13 61* >5,*4.1,/+53,.5.75/,392395*.758*1-+4+13416.75,*3,.,:, ,39 561*=4 0. D' 3 -+5? 16 .75 01=8/5.+13 16 8*17+A+.1*>85*+19.7585.+.+135*=,95,*5@254.+3.7561*=16 *58*5453.,.+13.1.7544+4.,3.1==+44+135*+9,*F.75.7+*9 *54813953. 61* 95/5.+13 16 53.*> +3 1/2=3 1 *5<,*9+3< 8*17+A+.+13 16 >5,*4 16 ,/+53,.+13 ,459 13 .75 *58*5453.,.+13 =,95 A> .75 85.+.+135* .75 612*.7 *54813953. 42A=+..59 , *581*. .1 .75 .7+*9 *54813953. ,2.71*+.> 455:+3< 350544,*> +34.*20.+134 +3 .75 =,..5* 3 *5481345 .1 .75 8*1814,/ 42A=+..59 A> .75 612*.7 *54813953. .75 .7+*9 *54813953. 9+*50.59 .75 612*.7 *54813953. .1 *542A=+. .75 8*1814,/ ,/13< ?+.7 1*+<+3,/ *501*94 85*.,+3+3< .1 .75 42A;50. =,..5* . +4 4.,.59 .7,. .75 612*.7 *54813953. ,2.71*+.> 42A=+..59 , 8*1814,/ 13 ##'(#( ?+.7 ,3 1A45*-,.+13 .7,. .75 1*+<+3,/ *501*94 85*.,+3+3< .1 .75 8*10559+3<4 +3 &+/5 1D ,*5 31. ,-,+/,A/5 ,39 75305 .75 - 5 - 9102=53.4 62*3+4759 A> .75 85.+.+135* *5/,.+3< .1 .75 4,+9 8*10559+3<4?5*542A=+..59.1.75.7+*9*54813953.,2.71*+.> 1?5-5* .75 .7+*9 *54813953. *5;50.59 .75 8*1814,/ A> *5.2*3+3< .75 6+/5 42A=+..59 A> .75 612*.7 *54813953. -+95 1==23+0,.+139,.59#'#(#(61*?,3.161*+<+3,/*501*94 395*.75450+*02=4.,3054.7585.+.+135*+4A561*5.7+412*. 12345/ 61* .75 *54850.+-5 8,*.+54 2*<59 45-5*,/ 013.53.+134 *+,-+ ,.+/ 012345/ 61* .75 85.+.+135* +3 8*5453.+3< 7+4 ,*<2=53.4 -575=53./> 013.53959 .7,. .75 011*9+3,.5 5307 16 .7+4 12*. +3 ) 1(#### (#( 9+4814591613(D#(#(7,9+44259<535*,/9+*50.+13.1.75 *+30+8,/ 50*5.,*> 5-5325 58,*.=53. .1 +4425 350544,*> 9+*50.+134.1,//.7501305*359166+05*4+3.75.,.516,*3,.,:, .1 4850+6> +3 .75 5391*45=53. +3 01/2=3 1 =,95 +3 82*42,305 16 , <*,3. .75 9,.5 6*1= ?7+07 8*17+A+.+13 01=54 +3.1 61*05 ,39 .75 9,.5 13 ?7+07 8*17+A+.+13 01=54 .1 ,3 539 ,399+*50.59*54813953. 1,2.71*+.>455:+3<01=8/+,30516 .75 4,+9 9+*50.+134 5 ,*<259 A> 4,>+3< .7,. .75 ,2.71*+.+54 01305*3597,-51-5*/11:59.75<535*,/9+*50.+134,4?5//,4.75 - 6 - 0+*02/,*,395**135124/>*5;50.59.758*1814,/4,>+3<.7,..75*5 ,*5 31 1*+<+3,/ *501*94 12345/ .75*561*5 42A=+.4 .7,. .75 )*+. 5.+.+13=,>A5,//1?59 ;24.+6+59 .75 ,0.+13 13 .75 8,*. 16 .75 *54813953. ,2.71*+.+54,398*,>5961*9+4=+44,/16.75)*+. 5.+.+13 ' 5,*9 .75 ,*<2=53.4 ,39 85*2459 .75 )*+. 8,85*4 ?+.70,*5 75 6,0.4 ,*5 4266+0+53./> 4,+9 ,39 91 31. *5@2+*5 *5+.5*,.+1375+44256,//4?+.7+3,3,**1?01=8,44,39*5/,.54 .1*5=1-,/16.750139+.+1316313,/+53,.+1361*,85*+1916 >5,*4+31/2=3 17585.+.+135*7,462*3+4759.75*501*9 16*+<7.4.+431.+39+482.5.7,..7542A;50./,39?,4<*,3.59 +3D"?+.7313,/+53,.+130/,24561*>5,*4758*17+A+.+13 7,401=5.1,3539+3DDD 85*24,/16.751*95*8,4459A>.7511*9+3,.5530716 .7+412*.0/5,*/>958+0.4.7,.,<535*,/9+*50.+13?,4+44259.1 .75 1-5*3=53. 16 ,*3,.,:, .1 +4425 350544,*> 9+*50.+134 .1 ,//.7501305*359166+05*4+3.75.,.516,*3,.,:,.14850+6>+3 .75 5391*45=53. +3 1/2=3 1 =,95 +3 82*42,305 16 , - 7 - <*,3..759,.56*1=?7+07.758*17+A+.+1301=54+3.161*05,39 .759,.513?7+07.758*17+A+.+1301=54.1,3539548+.5.75 9+*50.+13 .75 ,2.71*+.+54 01305*359 7,-5 31. ,001*959 .75 *5@254.16.7585.+.+135*3.751.75*7,39.75>5**135124/> 8*105595962*.75*+3.75=,..5*,39*5;50.59.75*5@254.16.75 85.+.+135*13.7541/5<*1239.7,..751*+<+3,/*501*94,*531. ,-,+/,A/5 75 *5;50.+13 +4 23424.,+3,A/5 +3 /,? 75*561*5 955= +. 8*185* .1 @2,47 .75 5391*45=53. 9,.59 #'#(#( +44259A>.75.7+*9*54813953.-+95335B2*5,39,=24 +4 1*95*59 9+*50.+3< *54813953.4 ( .1 .1 0134+95* .75 *58*5453.,.+13 42A=+..59 A> .75 85.+.+135* ,39 *5=1-5 .75 5391*45=53.*5/,.+3<.1313,/+53,.+13+3*54850.1685.+.+135*E4 /,39?+.7+3,85*+1916612*?55:46*1=.75*505+8.1605*.+6+59 018>16.7+41*95* " 542/.,3./>.75)*+. 5.+.+13+4 () &%!""' % % +4. 1/ 1