Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

2025 DAILYLAW 6466 (PNJ)

NIRMAL SINGH AND ANOTHER v. CHANDER SHEKHAR KHARE CHIEF ADMINISTRATOR HSVP AND OTHERS

COCP/4051/2025 · 2026-03-12

Nidhi Gupta

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

IN TH 211-I Nirmal Sin Chander Panchkula 211-II Subey Sing Chander Panchkula 211-III Kamlesh Chander Panchkula COCP Nos.4051, 4058 & 4227 of 202 IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJA AT CHANDIGAR COCP No.4051 o Date of decision al Singh and another Versus nder Shekhar Khare, IAS, Chief hkula, Haryana and others COCP No.4058 o y Singh and another Versus nder Shekhar Khare, IAS, Chief hkula, Haryana and others COCP No.4227 o Date of decision Versus nder Shekhar Khare, IAS, Chief hkula, Haryana and others f 2025 (O & M) 1 UNJAB AND HARYANA IGARH 4051 of 2025 (O & M) cision :-12.03.2026 …..Petitioners Chief Administrator, HSVP, …..Respondents 4058 of 2025 (O & M) …..Petitioners Chief Administrator, HSVP, …..Respondents 4227 of 2025 (O & M) cision :-12.03.2026 …..Petitioner Chief Administrator, HSVP, …..Respondents VIJAY ASIJA 2026.03.19 09.31 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document CORAM: Present:- NIDHI GU alleging vi P-1) passed titled as “P are being d directed as COCP Nos.4051, 4058 & 4227 of 202 AM:- HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NI Mr. Sandeep Sharma, Advocat for the petitioners. Mr. Nitin Gupta, Advocate for Mr. Harmanjot Singh Gill, Ad for the respondents-HSVP. GUPTA J. (Oral) Since all these contempt p ing violation of the common order da passed by the Division Bench of this as “Pradeep Kumar vs. State of Hary eing decided by way of this common o Vide order dated 14.02.2022 ted as under:- “Keeping in v proposed plan and the a direction is being iss Courts in the State of H taking any coercive step carved out a plan for d amount and the Refere compensation as per plan. Learned couns further informs that du with respect to the pro compensation througho that the land owners respect to the deposit o schedule stated above. to the respondents to f 2025 (O & M) 2 E NIDHI GUPTA dvocate ate for ill, Advocate mpt petitions have been filed rder dated 14.02.2022 (Annexure f this Court in CWP-20384-2021 f Haryana and others”, the same mon order. 2.2022 (Annexure P-1), it was n view the above detailed the interest of the land owners, g issued that all the executing of Haryana are restrained from steps, as the respondents have or depositing the compensation ference Courts will accept the per the above said proposed ounsel for respondent-HSVP t due publication will be made proposed plan for depositing ughout the State of Haryana so ers may be made aware with sit of compensation as per the ove. A direction is being issued ts to comply and make the VIJAY ASIJA 2026.03.19 09.31 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document reports dat way of af Gurugram on record. petitioner(s petitioners file any wr was dispos as the co concerned. order dated Supreme C vide order d by Hon’bl reproduced COCP Nos.4051, 4058 & 4227 of 202 payment in accordan proposed plan/priority l Learned counsel for the res rts dated 11.03.2026 (in COCP Nos.4 of affidavit of Shri Rakesh Saini, gram on behalf of respondents No.1 ecord. Copies thereof are supplied t ioner(s). Learned counsel for the resp ioners herein were not parties to CWP ny writ petition. It is further submit disposed of as rendered infructuous, v he compensation amount was disb erned. He further contends that som r dated 14.2.2022 passed in CWP- eme Court in SLP(C) No.4832 of 20 order dated 31.10.2023. The relevant portion of the ord on’ble the Supreme Court in SLP duced as under :- "In so far as th where the payment has that the restraint imp through the order dat with the execution sha land-loosers will be proceedings including recovery of the amount. f 2025 (O & M) 3 rdance with the above said rity list.” he respondents has filed status Nos.4051 and 4058 of 2025) by Saini, Estate Officer-I, HSVP, No.1 and 2. The same are taken plied to learned counsel for the e respondents contends that the CWP-20384-2021, nor did they submitted that CWP-20384-2021 ous, vide order dated 02.5.2024, disbursed to the land losers at some persons challenged the -20384-2021 before Hon’ble of 2022, which was disposed of the order dated 31.10.2023 passed n SLP(C) No.4832 of 2022 is s the remaining land-loosers, has not been made, we clarify imposed by the High Court dated 14.02.2022 to proceed shall stand vacated and the be entitled to initiate such ing execution proceedings for unt. VIJAY ASIJA 2026.03.19 09.31 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document to the deci this Court another vs similar issu were cons 05.09.2025 Copy there It is submit COCP Nos.4051, 4058 & 4227 of 202 In cases where have been closed in passed by the High Cou have the liberty of petitions, which shal executing court and the further in accordance w Needless to men are still agitating their the compensation in res been lost by them, the e the other courts where initiated, shall keep in matter and proceed expeditiously as possibl In so far as the c are said to be pending, now take note of th accordance with law. With the above stand disposed of a application(s), if any." Learned counsel for the respo e decision dated 05.09.2025 passed b Court in COCP-3601-2025 titled her vs. Chander Shekhar Khare, I ar issues and facts, as involved in the considered and decided. A copy 9.2025 has been handed over in Court thereof has been supplied to learned submitted that the present cases are sq f 2025 (O & M) 4 ere the execution proceedings in view of the earlier order Court, the decree holder would of seeking revival of such shall be considered by the d the matter shall be proceeded ce with law. mention since the land-loosers eir rights to seek for receiving n respect of the land which have the executing courts as well as ere the proceedings have been ep in view this aspect of the ceed with the matters as ssible. he contempt proceedings which ing, the Courts concerned will f the same and proceed in ove clarification, the petitions of along with the pending y." respondents has further referred assed by a co-ordinate Bench of titled as “Jagdish Singh and are, IAS and others”, wherein in the present contempt petitions, copy of the decision dated Court, which is taken on record. rned counsel for the petitioners. are squarely covered by the said VIJAY ASIJA 2026.03.19 09.31 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document decision da identical. L view of the of this Co dismissed. the above f co-ordinate involved i decided. were not p disposed of delivered to court vide with the entitled to for recover made by le rendered by 05.09.2025 dismissed COCP Nos.4051, 4058 & 4227 of 202 ion dated 05.09.2025, as the facts and ical. Learned counsel for the respond of the order dated 05.09.2025 passed is Court, the present contempt pet issed. Learned counsel for the petit bove facts; as also the decision render rdinate Bench of this Court, wherein lved in the present contempt petitio Heard. A perusal of the record shows not party in CWP-20384-2021 and sed of as rendered infructuous, since ered to the land losers concerned. Th t vide order dated 14.02.2022 in CW the execution stood vacated and t led to initiate such proceedings includ ecovery of the amount. In view of the facts noticed a by learned counsel for the parties, ered by a co-ordinate Bench of this C 9.2025 on similar facts, the present co issed. Rule stands discharged. f 2025 (O & M) 5 cts and issues involved herein are spondents further submits that in passed by the co-ordinate Bench pt petitions also deserve to be e petitioners does not controvert ered in COCP-3601-2025 by erein similar issues and facts, as petitions, were considered and shows that the petitioners herein 1 and the said writ petition was since compensation amount was d. The restraint imposed by this in CWP-20384-2021 to proceed and the land losers were held including execution proceedings ticed above and the submissions arties, coupled with the decision this Court in the judgment dated ent contempt petitions are hereby VIJAY ASIJA 2026.03.19 09.31 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document of. connected m March 12 Vijay Asija Whether spea Whether Repo COCP Nos.4051, 4058 & 4227 of 202 Pending application(s), if any Photocopy of this order be p ected matter(s). 2, 2026 r speaking/reasoned Yes / No r Reportable Yes / No f 2025 (O & M) 6 if any, shall also stand disposed r be placed on the file(s) of the ( NIDHI GUPTA ) JUDGE VIJAY ASIJA 2026.03.19 09.31 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document