Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 64508 (KAR)
GENERAL MANAGER v. VANITHA W/O DHANAJI @ DHANRAJ BERADAR
MFA/201416/2023 · 2025-07-09
K S Hemalekha, Mohammad Nawaz
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64508 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64508 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#"
$ %# &'
%()#
$$
*+, -& $$ ./
$$ . . $$ .! -
&
! " "
# $
! %
Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
"
"
! "
&
"
"
&
'
! ! "! ! $% (
"
)
) ! "
! "" (
# $
"! &* %
&$%! % !'') +
! " + %
+ ! '') + ! "
! (
- 3 -
./-
&
! " "
# $
! %
! ,
&+
,
&
,
+ &"
"
$%&
-". (-. ! -. (
"
)
&
$
%
- 4 -
-". (-. ! -. (
"
! "
! "" (
# $
"! )%
&$%! % !'' +
! " + %
+ ! '' + ! "
! (
. .-
&
" / )
# $
! %
- 5 -
,
" ,
"
)
+& ! (-. " "
) ))
,
" ,
"
& +& ! (-. " ")&'
) ))
& ! "
!"" (
)
" )
"!! )
- 6 -
"
"
))
"
"
" #
$ ! %
&$%! % !' +
! & %
& !' + ! ! (
.!-
&
" / )
# $
! %
- 7 -
,
! (-. " ")&'
& ! "! ,
, $% '
! (-. " ")&'
)
& ! +
! "
! (-. " ")&'
)
) !! $ % )
)
! "
- 8 -
! "" (
'
" )
"!! )
"
"
))
"
" # $
!* &0'
!%
&$%! % !' +
! & %
& !' + ! ! (
! 1
1 2 3
2
"
"
- 9 -
# $1 2 3%
45 6789:5: ;< =45 >98 >5?:67@ 5@68=:?=6;7 ;" & 4?8 A:5<5::5B =4585 ?AA5?C8 ?@?678= =45 D9B@E57= ?7B ?F?:B B?=5B & A?885B 67 ! ;' + GF ' + >H =45 ;9:= ;< BB6=6;7?C 576;: 6I6C 9B@5 ?7B BB6=6;7?C 6B?: ?7B =45 D9B@E57= ?7B ?F?:B B?=5B + A?885B 67 !
;'') + F '' + ;7 =45 <6C5 ;< =45 ;9:= ;< 576;:6I6C9B@5?7BBB6=6;7?C 4?CJ6
5 4?I5 45?:B =45 C5?:75B G;9785C :6 8A?CC6 ?AA5?:67@ <;: ?AA5CC?7= ?7B C5?:75B G;9785C :6?7584?6J?AA5?:67@<;::58A;7B57=8GC?6E?7=8 & ; & & 68 A:5<5::5B ?@?678= =45 D9B@E57= ?7B ?F?:B A?885B 67 ! ;'') + ; )' & 68 A:5<5::5B ?@?678= =45 D9B@E57= ?7B ?F?:BA?885B67!;'' +; )&) & 68 A:5<5::5B ?@?678= =45 D9B@E57= ?7B ?F?:B A?885B 67
- 10 -
! ;' + ?7B ; )+ & 68 A:5<5::5B ?@?678= =45 D9B@E57= ?7B ?F?:B A?885B 67 ! ;' +
) 45<;9:B5G5?85BF5:5=:?I5C67@67?8F6<=G?:
>5?:67@ 5@;
"+&+ ;7 ) + ?= ?:;97B & ?E F457 =45 8?6B G?: E5= F6=4 ?7 ?GG6B57= ;7 9E>?6 HB5:?>?B ;?B 75?: "?C? ?:9=6 =5EAC5 B95 =;
45?B ;7 G;CC686;7 F6=4 ? >98 >5?:67@ 5@;" & 45 GC?6E?7=8 7?E5CH =45 C5@?C 456:8 ;< =45 B5G5?85B <6C5B :58A5G=6I5 GC?6E A5=6=6;78 >5<;:5 =45 :6>97?C 45 ?F?:B8 A?885B >H =45 :6>97?C ?:5 7;= G4?CC57@5B>H=45GC?6E?7=8 ;F5I5:=45789:5:;<=45 >98?@?678=F4;E=45C6?>6C6=H68<6K5B>H=45 :6>97?C4?8 <6C5B=4585?AA5?C8
45 G;7=57=6;7 ;< =45 C5?:75B G;9785C <;: =45 ?AA5CC?7=
:6
8A?CC668=4?=6=F?8?45?B;7G;CC686;7 >5=F557 =45 =F; I546GC58 ?7B =45 GC?6E?7=8 67 !
;8' +?7B' +4?I5?BE6==5B=4?=>;=4=45
- 11 -
I546GC58 ?:5 :58A;786>C5 <;: =45 ?GG6B57= 457G5 =45 :6>97?CF?87;=D98=6<65B67<6K67@=45C6?>6C6=H;7CH;7=45 789:5: ;< =45 >98 7 89AA;:= ;< 468 G;7=57=6;7 =45 C5?:75B G;9785C 4?8 B:?F7 =45 ?==57=6;7 ;< =45 ;9:= =;
=45GC?6EA5=6=6;78?7B=455I6B57G5;<?7B 67 !;8' +?7B' +
' 5?:75B G;9785C ?C8; G;7=57B5B =4?= ?CC =45 GC?6E A5=6=6;78 ?:;85 ;9= ;< =45 8?E5 ?GG6B57= 4;F5I5:
=45C5?:75B :6>97?C67!;8'' +?7B'') + 4?8 ?F?:B5B 67=5:58= ?= =45 :?=5 ;< 'L A5: ?779E F45:5?867!;8' +?7B' +4?8?F?:B5B +L67=5:58=
5?:75BG;9785C?AA5?:67@<;:=45:58A;7B57=8 ;7 =45 ;=45: 4?7B 4?I5 G;7=57B5B =4?= ?7B 4?I57;F45:58=?=5B=4?==45?GG6B57=F?8;7?GG;97=;< =45 <?9C= ;< =45 B:6I5: ;< =45 G?: 67 F46G4 =45 B5G5?85B F5:5 =:?I5C67@ ?7B 5I57 ;=45:F685 =45 GC?6E?7=8 G?7 GC?6EG;EA578?=6;7<:;E;75;<=45=;:=<5?8;:?845CB>H
- 12 -
=45 ;7.>C5A5K;9:= 5G;7=57B5B=4?=G4?:@58455= 4?8 7;= >557 <6C5B ?@?678= =45 B:6I5: ;< =45 G?: ?7B G;786B5:67@=45E?=5:6?CAC?G5B;7:5G;:B=45 :6>97?C4?8 :6@4=CH <6K5B =45 C6?>6C6=H =; A?H =45 G;EA578?=6;7 ;7 =45 ?AA5CC?7=789:?7G5;EA?7H
54?I5A5:985B=455I6B57G5?7BE?=5:6?C;7 :5G;:B=687;=67B68A9=5=4?==45G4?:@58455=F?8<6C5B ?@?678= =45 B:6I5: ;< =45 >98 >5?:67@ 5@;" &BE6==5BCH?7B =45GC?6E?7=867! ;' + ?7B ' + ?:5 7;= =45 5H5F6=758858 =;
=45 ?GG6B57= 45H 4?I5 7;= 8A5G6<6G?CCH 8=?=5B =4?= =45 ?GG6B57=F?8;7?GG;97=;<=45:?84;:75@C6@57=B:6I67@;< =45B:6I5:;<=45G?: 45?AA5CC?7=4?87;=5K?E675B?7H 5H5F6=7588=;A:;I5=4?==45B:6I5:;<=45G?:F?856=45: 8;C5CH:58A;786>C5;:=45:5F?8G;7=:6>9=;:H75@C6@57G5;7 468A?:=67G?9867@=45?GG6B57=
- 13 -
+ 45 ;7.>C5 A5K ;9:= 67
!" #$%#&' &! 4?845CB=4?= 67 =45 G?85 ;< G;EA;86=5 75@C6@57G5 =45 GC?6E?7= 68 57=6=C5B=;895>;=4;:?7H;<=45D;67==;:=<5?8;:?7B=45 57=6:5 G;EA578?=6;7 G?7 >5 ?F?:B5B ?@?678= =45 8;C5 6EAC5?B5B =;:=<5?8;: 5 <67B =4?= =45 D9B@E57= ?7B ?F?:B A?885B >H =45 :6>97?C <6K67@ =45 C6?>6C6=H ;7 =45 ?AA5CC?7= =; A?H =45 G;EA578?=6;7 68 67 ?GG;:B?7G5 F6=4 C?F ?7B B;58 7;= G?CC <;: 67=5:<5:57G5 ;F5I5:
G;786B5:67@ =45 H5?: ;< ?GG6B57= ?7B 67 =45 <?G=8 ?7B G6:G9E8=?7G58 ;< =45 G?85 F5 ?:5 ;< =45 I65F =4?= =45 67=5:58==;>5?F?:B5B67?CC=45G?85884;9CB>5'LA5: ?779EGG;:B67@CHF5A:;G55B=;A?88=45<;CC;F67@1
$6% ; )&) & ?7B ; )+ & ?:5 $ 45 D9B@E57= ?7B ?F?:B B?=5B & A?885B 67 ! ;' + F ! ;' + ;7 =45
- 14 -
<6C5;<=45BB6=6;7?C
576;:6I6C9B@5?7B BBC 6B?:68# 45GC?6E?7=8 67 =4585 A5=6=6;78 ?:5 57=6=C5B <;: 67=5:58= ?= =45 :?=5 ;< 'L A5: ?779E 678=5?B ;< +L ?F?:B5B>H=45 :6>97?C $66% ; & & ?7B ; )' & ?:5 # 45 D9B@E57= ?7B ?F?:B B?=5B + A?885B 67 !
;8'') ?7B '' ;< + ;7 =45 <6C5 ;< =45 576;: 6I6C 9B@5 ?7B BBC 4?CJ6 68
" !# $666% 45?E;97=67B5A;86=84?CC>5=:?78E6==5B=;
=45G;7G5:75B :6>97?C
0- *&', #
0- * , #
" 68=;1
C;1&