- 1 - !!"!!#!$ % $&"$"$ '""( ! " # $ %! & ' ! ! ! !! ( $ ! ) Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! ) ! * + ! )$ % ! & * ' ! $$( $$# ! ' + ! ! ! #$$ $$$(! $$ & , ' + $$ $$ ! & , +' ' ! - ! ! . - 3 - . / * ! &! ./ * ' 01 2134345617 48 91:571 3048 5;73 811<46= :5>>5?46= 71>41:8. !!"#"$%& ###'#()*# ! ##'#()*# &#'#( $# *! +,- ./ # 0#1 + . &!' &$2 / 0#1 +3 4/ *5.6 / - . $ !134345617 48 ?57<46= @8 301 471A357 5: 4B@7 68343;31 5: 1B4A@> A416A1 ?04A0 48 @6 ;3565C5;8 68343;31 71=483171B ;6B17 301 @76@3@<@ 5A413418 1=4837@3456 A3 "( 0@D46= 438 1C57@6B;C 5: 885A4@3456 ;>18 1=;>@34568 @6B E1>@?8 01 718256B16350@8:7@C1B3014B@768343;315:1B4A@> A416A18 4B@7 ;>18 @6B 1=;>@34568 $ F017146@:317 71:1771B35@8301G;>18$ -:57971D43EH?04A0@71@>85 - 4 - 71=483171B ;6B17 301 5A413418 1=4837@3456 A3 0;8 ;>18@6B1=;>@34568@6B301E1>@?8@71@22>4A@9>135 @>>3011C2>5E1185:301718256B1635$ 64D17843E01 718256B1635$9E@7185>;3456B@31B #$$2@881B 46 048 83 5@7B 11346= 7185>D1B 35 05>B @6 16I;47E ;6B17 >@;81 &(' 5: 301 ;>18 $ @=@4683 301 2134345617 56 A173@46 @>>1=@34568 56 @BC464837@34D1 @6B :46@6A4@> @821A38 E 301 8@4B 7185>;3456 301 5D17646= 5;6A4>275A11B1B35@225463@48374A3 6I;47E::4A17653 91>5? 301 7@6< 5: 48374A3 *;B=1 !;78;@63 301715: 301 718256B163 5 3@31 488;1B @ 6534:4A@3456 B@31B $$ @8 217 661J;71+ @22546346= @ 713471B 48374A3*;B=1B471A346=35A56B;A330116I;47E@6B8;9C43 301:@A3:46B46=712573?43046 B@E8301715:!13434561748 91:57130485;739146=@==741D1B9E3018@4B7185>;3456@8 ?1>> @8 301 6534:4A@3456 275B;A1B @3 661J;718 @6B + 71821A34D1>E - 5 - 74 0@=?@3 >1@761B 16457 5;681> @221@746= :57 >1@761B A5;681> :57 301 2134345617 3075;=0 D4B15A56:1716A18;9C43830@33012@8846=5:7185>;3456@3 661J71 48 A5637@7E 35 ;>18 $ 6 30@3 01 821A4:4A@>>E71:17835;9;>1&'5:;>1(5:301;>18 $ 35 A56316B 30@3 30171 ?@8 65 I;57;C 5: 301 5D17646= 5;6A4> :57 301 2;72581 5: A56B;A346= 301 C11346=171:1771B358;97;>1&'@6B&('5:;>1 5: ;>18 $ 35 A56316B 30@3 301 16I;47E 57B171B 9E 301 5D17646=5;6A4>7;68A5637@7E353018@4B275D484568@8 30116I;47EA5631C2>@31B;6B178;9;>1&('5:;>1 5: ;>18$ 0@8359171@B46A56K;6A3456?430301E1>@? 5# 275D4B46= :57 B48A42>46@7E @A3456 ?04A0 46 3;76 A5631C2>@318 :5>>5?46= 5: 301 275A1B;71 >@4B B5?6 46 301 @76@3@<@ 4D4> 17D4A18 &>@884:4A@3456 56375> @6B 221@>' ;>18 "# F017146@:317 71:1771B 35 @8 301 G &';>18-:57971D43EH171:17835;>1 5:301 &' ;>18 @6B 8;9C438 30@3 301 48A42>46@7E ;305743E - 6 - 6@C1>E 301 5D17646= 5;6A4> 46 4683@63 A@81 91:571 275A11B46=35@225463@6 6I;47E::4A170@835:7@C1301 A0@7=184C2;3@3456 :;76480 301 B13@4>8 5: 301 8@C1 @6B 56>E 30171@:317 275A11B 35 @225463 6I;47E ::4A17 0@3 656A5C2>4@6A1 5: 301 8@4B 7;>1 ?5;>B D434@31 301 163471 275A188 1 8;9C438 30@3 46 301 4683@63 A@81 301 7185>;34560@89116@22@7163>E84=61B56>E9E307115:301 C1C9178 ?0171@8 301 353@> 83716=30 5: 301 C1C9178 5: 301 5D17646= 5;6A4> 48 1>1D16 ?04A0 :@>>8 :5;> 5: ;9 ;>1&'5:;>1(5:301;>18$ 0@3301@225463C1635:301 6I;47E::4A17653 91>5? 301 7@6< 5: 713471B 48374A3 *;B=1 ?4305;3 :57?@7B46= 301 @734A>18 5: A0@7=184C2;3@3456 35 301 2134345617 @6B 811<46= 1J2>@6@3456 @6B 30171@:317 :57?@7B46=301C@3317:57 6I;47E::4A177;68A5637@7E35 ;>1 5:301 &';>18 - 7 - ( 1 :;73017 8;9C438 30@3 301 6534:4A@3456 B@31B $$ @3 661J;71+ 46 301@9816A15: A5C2>4@6A1 35301@:5718@4B71I;471C163A@6653918;83@461B16A1 811<8:57@>>5?46=5:30121343456 # 6 71825681 >1@761B BB43456@> BD5A@31 1617@> @221@746= :57 718256B163 5 8;9C438 30@3 305;=0 301 353@> 6;C917 5: 5D17646= 5;6A4> 48 1>1D16 5;3 5: ?04A0 :5;7 25838 @3 >5 " @6B @71 D@A@63 ?04>1 56>E 14=03 C1C9178 @71 @D@4>@9>1 46A>;B46= 301 21343456170@346301 83BC464837@34D111346=30@3?@8 01>B 84J 5: 301C 46A>;B46= 2134345617 ?171 2718163 46A1 301 275A11B46=8 ?171 85;=03 35 91 46434@31B 56>E @=@4683 301 2134345617 01 ?@8 1JA>;B1B >1@D46= 301 83716=3035:4D15:?04A0307115:301C0@D184=61B301 7185>;3456 ?04A0 C1138 301 71I;471C163 5: C@K5743E 1 :;730178;9C43830@3@225463C1635:@6 6I;47E::4A175: 301 7@6< 653 91>5? 301 7@6< 5: 713471B 48374A3 *;B=1 48 A5631C2>@31B ;6B17 ;9;>1 &(' 5: ;>1 5: ;>18 $ @6B 71I;471C163 5: 488;46= @ 6534:4A@3456 9E 301 - 8 - 5D176C163 48 @8 217 301 275D485 35 8@4B ;>1 &(' 5: ;>18 $ 0171:571 01 8;9C438 30@3 65 17757 57 4>>1=@>43E 46 718256B163 @;305743418 46434@346= 301 275A188 5: A56B;A346= B48A42>46@7E 275A11B46=8 @=@4683 301 2134345617 ?@77@6346= @6E 46317:1716A1 @3 0@6B8 5: 3048 5;73@6B811<8:57B48C488@>5:30121343456 1@7B!17;81B30171A57B8 " 01714865B482;315:301:@A330@3213434561748 @61C2>5E115:301718256B1635$68343;31?04A048 =5D1761B ;6B17 301 ;>18 @6B 1=;>@34568 275B;A1B @3 661J;71 @6B 301 E1>@?8 275B;A1B @3 661J;71 1>1D@633571:1735;>1 ;9;>1&'@6B&('5:;>18 $ ?04A071@B@8;6B17. 780)' ' .. 9 1/ :9 6 . ... . / 9 /. 9 / / . 0, 0,2 . / .-:9 6 ... . ; ' < ) / - 9 - / .. . / 9 /; /' ' .. :9 6 . :9 6 ... . . / ../= 3 48 @>85 71>1D@63 35 71:17 35 E1>@? 5# ?04A071@B8@8;6B17. 7 >+ ' . / # /.//;/ ./ .. . ? ; 6 9 . $ 9 06. - 6 . #.@.-A= !17;8@> 5: 301 @:5718@4B 275D484568 ?5;>B 46B4A@31 30@3 B48A42>46@7E 275A11B46=8 A@6 91 46434@31B @=@4683 3011C2>5E11 46A>;B46= 3012134345617 017146 56>E ;256 301 7185>;3456 35 91 2@881B 9E 301 5D17646= 5;6A4> 46A1 E1>@? 5# A5631C2>@318 275A1B;71 5: 16I;47E 35 91 @8 217 301 &' ;>18 71>1D@63 35 71:17 ;9;>1 &(' ;>1 5: &' ;>18 ?04A0 71@B8@8;6B17. 70,)' . /# /..- # /- # /-+ - 10 - 0 / . 9 B 0 / - /- /:9 9B 0 / - /- + .0B 0 9 9 9 . 9 / + . 0 :9 9B 09/ 74 C = $ 0;8 8;97;>1 &(' 5: ;>1 5: &' ;>18C@6B@31830@34:301B48A42>46@7E@;305743E27525818 35 05>B @6 16I;47E 43 80@>> :57?@7B 301 8@C1 35 301 16I;4746= @;305743E 301 @734A>18 5: A0@7=1 @6B 301 83@31C163 5: 4C2;3@3456 5: C48A56B;A3 C48910@D45;7 A52E 5: 301 ?743316 83@31C163 5: 301 B1:16A1 4: @6E 8;9C4331B 9E 301 5D176C163 817D@63 A52E 5: 301 83@31C16385:?436188184:@6E71:1771B35463018;97;>1 &' 1D4B16A1 275D46= 301 B1>4D17E 5: 301 B5A;C1638 71:1771B35468;97;>1&'353015D176C163817D@63@6B @A52E5:30157B17@22546346=301G!71816346=::4A17- - 11 - ;9;>1 &' 5: ;>1 ( 5: 301 ;>18 $ 71I;4718301C11346=5:3015D17646=5;6A4>@6BI;57;C 5: 301 C11346= 5: 301 5D17646= 5;6A4> 653 35 91 >188 30@6 L ;97;>1 & $' ;>1 ( 5: ;>18 $ A5631C2>@318301C@331780@>>91B1A4B1B56301C@K5743E 5:D5318017148@>8565B482;315:301:@A330@3301 83 BC464837@34D1 11346= 01>B 56 #$$ 275B;A1B @3 661J;71 ?@8 2@734A42@31B 9E 84J C1C9178 5: 301 5D17646= 5;6A4> 8 71=@7B8 35 71I;471C163 5: I;57;C 5: 5D17646= 5;6A4> 48 A56A1761B 5;3 5: 1>1D16 84J 5: 301C0@D12@734A42@31B46A130711258385:301C1C9178 5: 301 5;6A4> ?171 D@A@63 301 I;57;C 5: 301 353@> 6;C9175:301C1C91785:1617@>5;6A4>4871B;A1B35 14=03 ;3 5: 30181 14=03 84J 5: 301 C1C9178 0@D1 2@734A42@31B46A>;B46=3012134345617?04A048461JA1885: L 5: 301 353@> C1C9178 5: 301 5D17646= 5;6A4> 8 @>71@BE 6531B @95D1 846A1 301 2134345617 48 301 561 @=@4683 ?05C 301 7185>;3456 48 85;=03 35 91 2@881B 0@8 83@E1B @?@E 0171:571 301 71C@4646= C1C917 5: 301 5D17646= 5;6A4> ?5;>B 91 :4D1 ?04A0 48 834>> @95D1 301 - 12 - L C@7< 5: 301 353@> 6;C917 5: C1C917 5: 301 5D17646= 5;6A4> C1C9178 01 7185>;3456 35 05>B 301 16I;47E@8A5631C2>@31B482@881B@6B84=61B9E307115: 301 C1C9178 0171:571 ?430 301 :4D1 5: 301 C1C9178 ?052@734A42@31B307115:301C0@D184=61B?04A0C1138 301 71I;471C163 5: ;>1 ( ;97;>1 & $' 5: ;>18 $ ?04A071I;4718C@331783591B1A4B1B9EC@K5743E53048 1J316330171A@665391@6E:>@?:5;6B?430301275A1B;71 @B5231B 9E 301 718256B163 ) @;305743418 46 2@8846= 301 7185>;3456@3661J;71@C1488;83@461B 46A1 301 16I;47E 275A1B;71 48 A5631C2>@31B ;6B17 E1>@? 5# @8 6531B @95D1 35 91 46 @AA57B@6A1 ?430 301 275D484568 5: &' ;>18 ?04A0 @71 1J37@A31B 017146@95D1 301 6534:4A@3456 @3 661J;71 B471A346= 301 6I;47E ::4A17 6@C1>E 301 713471B 48374A3 *;B=1358;9C43301712573?43046 B@E846301@9816A1 5: A5C2>4@6A1 35 8;97;>1 &(' 5: ;>1 5: &' ;>18A@6653918;83@461B 630@3D41?5:301C@3317301:5>>5?46=M - 13 - ! 743!134345648 7B17534:4A@3456@3661J;71+48I;@801B 18256B163@;305743E48B471A31B358374A3>EA5C2>E ?43030171I;471C1635:;>1 5: &';>18 46 301 6@3;71 5: B7@?46= ;2 5: 301 8;983@6A1 5: 4C2;3@3456 5: C48A56B;A3 57 C48910@D45;7 4635 B1:46431 @6B B48346A3 @734A>18 5: A0@7=18 13A @6B 30171@:317 0@6B 5D17 301 16I;47E 35 301 6I;47E ::4A1746301C@6617<65?635>@? >>A5631634568@6B=75;6B8@71<1235216 ")* '$"$( &! ** 4835. >5. $ .!