- 1 - !"# $ % & && '"( ) ! "## $ % & ' !( # ' ' )# !( " # $ ' * (((#% Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - '' $%' # ## # # ' ) (( # ' ) + )# !& ( ## ' ) , , - )# % ./0122314/05/436789.3:41/;1<91=1/<099.3 >?6=;3<9 1<6 1@1A6 61936 (( 21003678 9.3 66/9/B<14 3</BA /C/4 )?6=3 1<6 3;73A + />1812?A1 D5BA 0.BA9 EA/7?<14FG /< B!& ( 033H/<=3<.1<:3;3<9B5:B;23<019/B< .3/<>?A36:41/;1<91=36&831A0;39@/9.1 AB169A155/:1::/63<9B<(!( 1<60?091/<36=A/3CB?0 /<>?A/303<:3.35/436:41/;239/9/B<735BA39.3A/7?<14 033H/<= :B;23<019/B< B5 0((((( .3 A/7?<14 1593A :B<0/63A/<= 9.3 3<9/A3 3C/63<:3 B< A3:BA6 1@1A636 9.3:B;23<019/B<B5 0&!!(( @/9./<93A30919!I23A 1<<?; 5AB; 9.3 6193 B5 239/9/B< 9/44 A314/J19/B< 1<6 - 3 - 6/A3:936 A302B<63<9 B<0?A1<:3 B;21<8 9B 218 9.3 :B;23<019/B<==A/3C36789.301/6BA63A9./0122314/0 2A353AA36 31A6 1A=?;3<90 B5 7B9. 9.3 21A9/30 1<6 23A?0369.3;193A/1401C1/41743B<A3:BA6 & .3;1/<:B<93<9/B<B59.3:41/;1<9/09.199.3 A/7?<14 .10 1@1A636 ;31=A3 :B;23<019/B< ?<63A 144 .3160 9 /0 :B<93<636 78 9.3 431A<36 :B?<034 5BA 9.3 1223441<99.199.3:41/;1<9.103K1;/<369.3A9.B2136/: ?A=3B<10#@.B.10632B0369.199.3/<>?A/30.1C3 1553:936 A/=.9 4B@3A 4/;7 1<6 6/55/:?49/30 /< 0L?199/<= H<334/<= 0/99/<= :AB00 43=* 091<6/<= B< B23A1936 4/;7 5BA 4B<= 9/;3 0917/4/98 :B;2B<3<9 :B<09/9?930 I 6/017/4/98 A/=.99./=.;?0:430@109/<=:B;21A39B4359I6/017/4/98 1<6 10030036 I 9B &I 6/017/4/98 9B A/=.9 4B@3A 4/;7 7?99.3A/7?<14.1091H3<B<48I6/017/4/989B9.3@./43 7B68 9 /0 140B :B<93<636 9.19 :41/;1<9 @10 31A</<= 0((( 23A ;B<9. 7?9 9.3 A/7?<14 .10 <B9 :B<0/63A36 9.3 01;3 1<6 9.?0 A3L?30936 5BA 3<.1<:/<= - 4 - 9.3:B;23<019/B<@/9.I/<93A30923A1<<?;/<09316B5 !I 9 /0 0?7;/9936 78 9.3 431A<36 :B?<034 5BA A302B<63<9 B M <0?A1<:3 B;21<8 9.19 9.3 :B;23<019/B<1@1A636789.3A/7?<14/0>?091<62AB23A 1<6<3360<B/<93A53A3<:3 ! < 9.3 1::/63<9 10 23A K#! M B?<6 3A9/5/:193:41/;1<9.100?091/<369.35B44B@/<=/<>?A/30, 223441<9 @10 16;/9936 9B 9.3 .B02/914 B< !(!( 1<66/0:.1A=36B<!(( .?0.3@10 /<219/3<9 5BA ( 6180 # M B:9BA /00?36 K#! M /017/4/983A9/5/:1930919/<=I9B&I6/017/4/989BA/=.9 4B@3A 4/;7 B<0/63A/<= 9.3 3C/63<:3 B5 9.3 B:9BA 1<6 B9.3A A343C1<9 ;193A/14 9./0 B?A9 5/<60 /9 A310B<1743 9B - 5 - :B<0/63AI6/017/4/989B@.B437B68/<09316B5I91H3< 789.3A/7?<14 '?A9.3A 9.B?=. 9.3 :41/;1<9 091930 9.19 .3 @1031A</<= 0((( 23A;B<9..3.10<B92AB6?:36 1<86B:?;3<99B2ABC39.301;3::/63<9/0B59.3831A ( 023A9.3=?/634/<30/00?36789.31A<191H19193 3=143AC/:30?9.BA/989.3A/7?<14.10A/=.94891H3<9.3 <B9/B<14/<:B;3B59.3:41/;1<919 0( 23A;B<9. 5BA 9.3 831A ( @./:. <3360 <B /<93A53A3<:3 ::BA6/<=48 9.3 :41/;1<9 /0 3<9/9436 5BA 4B00 B5 5?9?A3 31A</<=10?<63A, 0( KK KIN 0 ((( B<0/63A/<=9.323A/B6B5.B02/914/J19/B<<19?A3 B5 /<>?A/30 1<6 B9.3A A343C1<9 51:9BA0 9./0 B?A9 5/<60 /9 A310B<1743 9B 1@1A6 1< 1;B?<9 B5 0((( 5BA 21/< 1<6 0?553A/<= 0((( 5BA 4B00 B5 1;3</9/30 1<6 0(((( 5BA 9A1<02BA919/B< 3K9A1 <B?A/0.;3<9 1<6 1993<61<9 :.1A=30 '?A9.3A 6?3 9B /<>?A/30 9.3 :41/;1<9 - 6 - ;/=.9<B9.1C31993<6361<8@BAH19431095BA123A/B6B5& ;B<9.0 .3<:3 9./0 B?A9 5/<60 /9 A310B<1743 9B 1@1A6 0&((( 5BA 4B00 B5 /<:B;3 6?A/<= 41/6 ?2 23A/B6 B@3C3A 9.3 :B;23<019/B< B5 0!& 1@1A63678 9.3A/7?<145BA;36/:143K23<030<3360<B/<93A53A3<:3 .3 :B;23<019/B< 1@1A636 78 9.3 A/7?<14 /0 ;B6/5/3610?<63A, 4 B 3160 @1A6789.3 A/7?<14 @1A6789./0 B?A9 #1/< 1<6 0?553A/<= 0(((( 0((( 36/:14 K23<030 0!& 0!& B00 B5 5?9?A3 31A</<=:121:/98 0! 0 ((( & A1<02BA919/B< 3K9A1 <B?A/0.;3<9 1<6 1993<61<9 :.1A=30 0&((( 0(((( B00 B5 1;3</9/30 0(((( 0((( - 7 - ! B00 B5 /<:B;3 6?A/<= 41/6 ?2 23A/B6 0(( 0&((( '?9?A3 ;36/:14 3K23<030 B914 0&! ! 0 (& .3A3@/44733<.1<:3;3<9B5 0&( ( 302B<63<9 B M <0?A1<:3 B;21<8 .10 14A3168 632B0/936 9.3 :B;23<019/B< 1;B?<9 1@1A636 78 9.3A/7?<14 <9.3A30?499.35B44B@/<=BA63A/0210036, $/% 22314/0 $//% .3 :41/;1<9 /0 3<9/9436 5BA 9.3 3<.1<:36 :B;23<019/B< B5 0&( @/9. /<93A309 19 !I 23A 1<<?; 5AB; 9.3 6193 B5 239/9/B<9/449.36193B5A314/J19/B< $///% 302B<63<9 B M <0?A1<:3 B;21<8 /0 6/A3:936 9B 632B0/9 9.3 15BA301/6 - 8 - :B;23<019/B<1;B?<914B<=@/9./<93A309@/9./< B<3;B<9.5AB;9.36193B59./0>?6=;3<9 $/C% < 0?:. 632B0/9 9.3 :41/;1<9 /0 23A;/99369B@/9.6A1@9.33<9/A31;B?<914B<= @/9./<93A3091::A?36B</9 *+, '& ( % /09B,4B,! , )