- 1 - !"# $! %&!'!&& &(! ))*+, #)!!++ - ! " !! !! # $%&% '% $%&% '% $%&% ' ! ! ( Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! )*+' ! +& ++! '','% ! '+ $ '% ! ! ! '','% )',', ! $ ! " ! -. -. /0 102323(405 36 7/89904:34: 2/0 (5;05 ;820; '','%18660;<=5061(4;042 ( >4;05 0723(4%% (?2/0854828@8(937072 ),(5;0534:/360A2054B042 ?5(B 2/0 C>536;3723(4 (? 32= (9370 898<>58:3 2( 2/0 C>536;3723(4 (? ><$5<84 (9370 2823(4 /85D8; ?(5 8 1053(;(?(40=08530?5(B'','%2399 )',', 085; 53 8/84206/ 0683 908540; 7(>4609 ?(52/0102323(40584;53(189536/488;8E 908540; - 3 - ?(52/05061(4;0426$282005>60;2/0B82053896(4 507(5; 4 E30D (? 2/0 53E89 7(420423(46 >5:0; <= 2/0 908540;7(>4609?(5<(2/2/018523062/01(3422/82D(>9; 85360?(5B=7(463;05823(436 ! "#"$% + =846D052(2/08<(E01(3423634 ?(52/0?(99(D34: !! % 061(4;042 ( 18660; 2/0 (5;05 ;820; '','% (5;0534: 0A2054B042 (? 2/0 102323(405 86 62820;8<(E061052/0(5;053B1>:40;2/0102323(40536 34E(9E0;34B>923190753B34897860686>4;05 53B0 ( %* ' (?/(D@(93702823(4?(5 2/0 (??0470 1>436/8<90 >4;05 0723(4 ) (? F - 4 - 53B0 ( )* ' +(?/(D@(93702823(4?(5 2/0 (??04706 1>436/8<90 >4;05 0723(46 + +* +&+ '*%'+'508;D32/0723(4 +)(? F 53B0 ( ') '+ (? 2823(4 8G85 (9370 2823(4 ?(5 2/0 (??04706 1>436/8<90 >4;05 0723(46 + +* *,4 %+ 0 + + %+ 0 %', ') &+ + * ' 508; D32/ 0723(4 +) (? 84; 0723(4,*(? 72F + 53B0 ( % '+ (? 2823(4 8G85 (9370 2823(4 ?(5 2/0 (??04706 1>436/8<90 >4;05 0723(46 + +* +& ,% + '* &+%'+%',508;D32/0723(4 +)(? 84; 0723(46,,,*(? 72F % 53B0 ( ' &(?/(D@(93702823(4?(5 2/0(??04701>436/8<90>4;050723(4&*(? 72F , 53B0 ( ' (? /(D@ (9370 2823(4 ?(5 2/0 (??0470 1>436/8<90 >4;05 0723(4 '* (? 5F84; * 53B0 ( & '+ (? /(D@ (9370 2823(4 ?(5 2/0 (??0470 1>436/8<90 >4;05 0723(4 '* (? 5 - 5 - , 47(463;05823(4(?2/0753B3489842070;0426(? 2/0 102323(405 34 087/ (? 2/060 78606 84; 896( 60E0589 753B3489 78606 2/82 850 50:362050; 8:83462 /36 79(60 866(7382068650?0550;2(342/03B1>:40;(5;0584;896( 28@34: 342( 7(463;05823(42/0?872 2/82 2/0102323(40536 34 2/0/8<32(?B(E34:89(4:D32/+2(%(2/051056(4684;36 34E(9E0; 34 E853(>6 753B3489 (??04706 /36 0A2054B042 >4;050723(4%%(?2/072D86?09240706685= * 061(4;042 ( /8; 366>0; 2/0 6/(D$78>60 4(2370;820;'*'%'%2(2/0102323(405862(D/=6>7/ 15(700;34:6>4;050723(4%%(?2/0726/8994(2<0 34323820; 8:83462 /3B ;B3220;9= 2/0 102323(405 /86 6><B3220;/36(<C0723(46(4''%'%86605234:2/82/0 /864(27(BB3220;84=(??047084;4(7860/8604;0;34 /36 7(4E3723(4 2399 ;820 84; /0 36 508;= 2( ?870 04H>35= /0 3B1>:40; (5;05 ;3679(606 2/82 2/0 102323(405 D86 5015060420; <= 84 ;E(7820 84; 8?205 /08534: 2/0 102323(4052/5(>://36;E(78202/03B1>:40;(5;0578B0 2(<018660; - 6 - & 0:3625823(4(?2/08<(E0683;786068:834622/0 102323(405364(234;361>20582/0532368;B3220;/07860 50:362050;8:834622/0102323(405>4;0572/8604;0; 342/0102323(40518=34:?3400:3625823(4(?2D(753B3489 78606>4;050723(4 '*(?504;0;340A07>234:2/0 <(4;6<=2/0102323(405 42/0753B348978606 D/37/850 50:362050; >4;05 0723(46 *, 84; '* (? 2/0 102323(40536?8734:25389<0?(502/05389(>52 23662820; 2/82342/0753B34897860?(52/0(??04701>436/8<90>4;05 0723(4 ' 84; ) (? 50?0550; 2( 8<(E0 36 683; 2( /8E0 04;0; 34 87H>32289 2 36 62820; 2/82 2/0 D32406606 /8E04(26>11(520;2/07860(?2/015(607>23(484;63470 2/0=/8E02>540;/(623902/0877>60;D8687H>3220; ) /03B1>:40;(5;053686108@34:(5;05D/050 2/050 36 50?050470 2( 087/ 84; 0E05= 753B3489 7860 50:362050; 8:83462 2/0 102323(405 84; /36 7(4;>72 34 2/0 6(7302= D/37/ 68236?30; 5061(4;042 ( 34 186634: 2/0 0A2054B042 (5;05 /0 7(4;>72 (? /36 - 7 - 866(738206D86896(28@04342(7(463;05823(4D/390186634: 2/03B1>:40;(5;05 ' 0723(4%%(?2/0727(>9;<034E(@0;<= 2/0 5061(4;0426 3? 32 8110856 2/82 2/0 B(E0B042 (5 2/0 872 (? 2/0 102323(405 850 78>634: 8985B (5 ;84:05 2( 8 1056(4(515(1052=84;3?2/0508505086(48<90:5(>4;6?(5 <0930E34: 2/82 6>7/ 1056(4 36 04:8:0; (5 36 8<(>2 2( <0 04:8:0; 34 7(BB3663(4 (? 2/0 (??0470 34E(9E34: ?(570 (5 E3(90470(5(??04701>436/8<90>4;05/812056 ,84; *(? (52/822/0102323(405/868<0220;6>7/(??0470 84;896(3?2/0D324066068504(2D39934:2(7(B0?(5D85;2( :3E0 0E3;0470 34 1><937 8:83462 6>7/ 1056(4 <= 583634: 81150/0463(4 (4 2/035 1852 86 50:85;6 2/0 68?02= (? 2/035 1056(4 (5 15(1052= 4 :(34: 2/5(>:/ 2/0 3B1>:40; (5;05 ?34; B82053896?(55061(4;042 (2( 18666>7/(5;05 08540; 7(>4609 ?(5 2/0 102323(405 198706 50938470 (4 2/0 ;07363(4 (? 2/36 (>52 34 - 8 - 2( 7(4204;2/824(5086(48<90(11(52>432=D86:3E042(2/0 102323(40584;2/82/0D864(2:3E047(1=(?2/0501(52(? 2/01(93702( 34E(@00723(4%%(? 2/072 0/86 896( 19870; 50938470 (4 2/0 ;07363(4 (? 2/0 ($(5;34820 047/ (? 2/36 (>52 34 84; ! "# !$ % 2( 7(4204; 2/82 4( 5086(48<90(11(52>432=D86:3E042(2/0102323(4052(1>2 ?(52//36;0?0470 /0 ?8726 34 2/(60 78606 850 0423509= ;3??05042 ?5(B2/015060427860 42/3678602/0B82053896;3679(60 2/82 2/0 6/(D$78>60 4(2370 D86 366>0; (4 '*'%'% /0 102323(405 /86 6><B3220; /36 (<C0723(46 86 62820; 8<(E0 (4 ''%'% /0 3B1>:40; (5;05 78B0 2( <0 18660; (4 '','% /0 B82053896 (4 507(5; 896( ;3679(60 2/82 2/0 102323(405 D86 5015060420; <= 84 &' ( ) *"###+,-"#"#"+*&&*"#"# "'*()* *&###.,-"#"/ &.*#0*"#" '*()* *&##&+-"#&"&*#*"#" - 9 - ;E(7820 2( 1>2 ?(52/ /36 7(420423(4 <0?(50 5061(4;042 ( 061(4;042 ( /86 18660; 2/0 (5;05 34 ;02839 50?05534: 2( 087/ (? 2/0 753B3489 78606 50:362050; 8:83462 2/0 102323(405 84; 2/0 5086(46 ?(5 ?(5B34: 84 (1343(4 2( 34E(@0 0723(4 %% (? 2/0 72 4;05 6>7/ 7357>B6284706 4(40 (? 2/0 8<(E0 ;07363(46 D399 8119= 2( 2/0?8726(?2/078602(7/89904:02/03B1>:40;(5;05 8B 68236?30; 2/82 5061(4;042 ( /86 811930; /36 B34; 84; /86 15(E3;0; 84 (11(52>432= (? <034: /085; 2( 2/0 102323(405 84; 2/050 850 4( 5086(46 2( 34205?050 D32/ 2/0 68B00470 846D052/08<(E01(342342/0I40:823E0J 84;15(700;2(18662/0?(99(D34: /00E363(402323(436& !., )&&+ ' 362 ( 9 (+&