- 1 - !"# $ %& $ %& "&#" $$ '#( ) ! " # $ % &' % ()* ( ! % (!* Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % + + , % ( ( -* % %-!+( (. " # ! , / )!!!!0, $ *, #$ - $ )%! $ *,!! )%! + ( ( 1 1 - 3 - & #( 1 $ 23' 455647 89:6; 6<=3>9 *,#$ >? =26 >=>; 623<76'<=-#26;6394?=6;;6?6;;6:=>4'@=26<=&?>; '2>;=$ 24' A669 ?376: AB =26 9'8;49<6 >C549B <247769D39D =26 E8:DC69= 49: 4F4;: :4=6: *,!! 54''6: AB =26 693>; 3G37 8:D6 0 23==458; #?>;'2>;==26@;3A8947&$39 >)%! ! 4<=' D3G39D ;3'6 => =26 ?3739D >? =26 455647 A;36?7B '=4=6: 4;6 =24= >9 !-!) F269 =26 :6<64'6: F4' 5;><66:39DABF47H>95;>56;'3:6>?=26;>4:964;>;;B 4;:7><4=6:F3=239=2673C3='>?6:4C>F9>96:4C 474A8;4D3'=4=623D2F4B4=4A>8=)(4C44=49:3<4 4;A64;39D >% -*F4':;3G69AB3=':;3G6;39 ;4'249:96D73D69=C4996;3923D2'566:49:7>'=<>9=;>7 >G6;3=49:G3>769=7B:4'26:=>=26:6<64'6: 4D4554E6 '8'=4396:D;36G>8'39E8;36'49:'8<<8CA6:=>=2639E8;36' >9=26'5>= - 4 - , 26 <743C49=' ?376: 4 56=3=3>9 89:6; 6<=3>9 )) >? =26 <= '66H39D <>C569'4=3>9 ?>; =26 :64=2 >? =26 :6<64'6:47>9DF3=239=6;6'= / 5>9 '6;G3<6 >? 9>=3<6 ;6'5>9:69= >! 45564;6: =2;>8D2 <>89'67 49: ?376: F;3==69 '=4=6C69= :69B39D =26 4G6;C69='C4:6 39 =26 <743C 56=3=3>99'53=6>? '6;G3<6 >? 9>=3<6 =26 ;6'5>9:69= > ;6C4396: 4A'69= 4' '8<2 26F4'574<6:6I54;=6 9 =26A4'3' >? 5764:39D' >?=26 54;=36' =26 743C' ;3A8947 ?;4C6: =26 3''86' 49: =26;64?=6; ;6<>;:6: =26 6G3:69<626;3A8947AB3C58D96:E8:DC69=49:4F4;: 24' 54;=7B 477>F6: =26 <743C 56=3=3>9 49: 267: =24= =26 <743C49='4;669=3=76:=>4<>C569'4=3>9>?')% 47>9D F3=2 39=6;6'= 4= =26 ;4=6 >? )J 54 49: :3;6<=6: ;6'5>9:69= >!9'8;49<6 >C549B => :65>'3= =26 <>C569'4=3>9 4C>89= 47>9D F3=2 39=6;6'= 639D 4DD;36G6: =26 5;6'69= 455647 24' A669 ?376: AB =26 9'8;49<6>C549B - 5 - ) 26764;96:<>89'67?>;=269'8;49<6>C549B24' ;43'6:=26?>77>F39D<>9=69=3>9'( 4$ 3;'=7B 47=2>8D2 =26 <743C49=' <743C =24= =26 :6<64'6: F4' 64;939D '!% 56; C>9=2 =26B 24G6 ?4376: => '8A'=49=34=6 =263; <743C F3=2 '855>;=39D :><8C69=' 26 4<<3:69= ><<8;;6: 39 =26 B64; !) 9 =264A'69<6>?:><8C69=4;B6G3:69<6=26;3A8947>8D2= => 24G6 <>9'3:6;6: =26 9>=3>947 39<>C6 >? =26 :6<64'6: 4''6''6:AB=26;3A89474='%56;C>9=23'>9 =2623D26;'3:6 A$ 4'=7B 26 24' <>9=69:6: =24= :6<64'6: F4' 49 4D;3<87=8;4774A>8;26;3A894724'4::6:J>?39<>C6 >?=26:6<64'6:=>F4;:'?8=8;65;>'56<='39'=64:>?/J <>9=;4;B => =26 74F 743: :>F9 AB =26 56I >8;= 39 =26 <4'6>? 3=2 =26 4A>G6 <>9=69=3>9' =26 764;96: <>89'67 '>8D2==>477>F=26455647 - 6 - * 26764;96:<>89'67?>;=26<743C49='24';43'6:=26 ?>77>F39D<>9=69=3>9'( 4$ 3;'=7B =26 <743C49=' 4''6;= =24= =26 :6<64'6: F4' 4D6:4A>8=!/B64;'4==26=3C6>?=264<<3:69=49:24:4 C>9=27B39<>C6>?'%ABF>;H39D4'D;3<87=8;6 74A>8; >F6G6; =26 4''6''C69= >? C>9=27B 39<>C6 >? =26 :6<64'6: 4= '% AB =26 ;3A8947 3' E8'= 49: ;64'>94A76 A$ 4'=7B <>9'3:6;39D =26 4D6 49: 4G><4=3>9 >? =26 :6<64'6: =26 >G6;477 <>C569'4=3>9 4F4;:6: AB =26 ;3A89473'E8'=49:;64'>94A76 64;: =26 764;96: <>89'67 ?>; =26 54;=36' 49: 56;8'6:=26E8:DC69=49:4F4;:>?=26;3A8947 - = 3' 9>= 39 :3'58=6 =24= 4D4554 4==3C493 :36: 39 =26 ;>4: =;4??3< 4<<3:69= ><<8;;6: >9 !-!) :86 => ;4'2 49: 96D73D69= :;3G39D >? :;3G6; >? =26 4; A64;39D 6D3'=;4=3>9 >% -*G69=2>8D2<743C49=24' <743C6:=24=:6<64'6:F4'64;939D'!%56;C>9=2 4' 4 4D;3<87=8;6 74A>8; 26B 24G6 9>= 5;>:8<6 49B - 7 - :><8C69= => 6'=4A73'2 =26 '4C6 <<>;:39D => =26 D83:67396' 3''86: AB =26 4;94=4H4 =4=6 6D47 6;G3<6' 8=2>;3=B ?>; 4<<3:69=' ><<8;;6: 39 =26 B64; !) =26 9>=3>947 39<>C6 >? =26 :6<64'6: '2477 A6 =4H69 4= '*%56;C>9=2>=264?>;6'43:39<>C6/J24' =>A64::6:>94<<>89=>??8=8;65;>'56<='39G36F>?=26 74F 743: :>F9 AB =26 >9'=3=8=3>9 69<2 >? =26 85;6C6 >8;= 39 * !"# #'85;4$ 28' =26 C>9=27B 39<>C6 <>C6' => '!!% 26 :6<64'6: F4' 4D6: 4A>8=!/B64;'4==26=3C6>?=264<<3:69=49:C87=35736; 45573<4A76 => 23' 4D6 D;>85 3' @& 39<6 26 F4' 4 A4<267>; J 24' => A6 :6:8<=6: =>F4;:' 56;'>947 6I569'6' 28' =26 <743C49=' 4;6 69=3=76: => <>C569'4=3>9>?+, -#'!!K!KKJ$ >94<<>89=>?@7>''>?:6569:69<B& 9 4::3=3>9 =26 <743C49=' 4;6 69=3=76: => <>C569'4=3>9>?'%>94<<>89=>?@7>''>?6'=4=6& 49: <>C569'4=3>9 >? '% >9 4<<>89= >? @?896;47 6I569'6'& - 8 - 9G36F>?=2674F743::>F9AB=2685;6C6>8;=39 =26 <4'6 >? @$%$ % &' $ ( ) (* 64<2 >? =26 <743C49=' 4;6 69=3=76: ?>; <>C569'4=3>9 >? '/% 89:6; =26 264: >? @7>'' >? 7>G6 49: 4??6<=3>9 49: <>9'>;=38C& ! 28' =26 <743C49=' 4;6 69=3=76: => =26 ?>77>F39D <>C569'4=3>9( >C569'4=3>989:6; :3??6;69=64:' C>89=39 #'$ >''>?:6569:69<B ,!, 896;476I569'6' >''>?6'=4=6 >''>?7>G649:4??6<=3>9 ! ./0 ,! , 9=26;6'87==26?>77>F39D>;:6;3'54''6:( 4$ 264556473'/00123456/7. A$ 26 E8:DC69= >? =26 743C' ;3A8947 3' C>:3?36: - 9 - <$ 26 <743C49=' 4;6 69=3=76: => 4 =>=47 <>C569'4=3>9 >? ',!- 4' 4D439'= ')%4F4;:6:AB=26;3A8947 :$ 269'8;49<6>C549B3':3;6<=6:=>:65>'3= =26<>C569'4=3>94C>89=47>9DF3=239=6;6'= 4=)J54?;>C=26:4=6>??3739D>?=26<743C 56=3=3>9 =377 =26 :4=6 >? ;6473L4=3>9 F3=239 4 56;3>:>?'3IF66H'?;>C=26:4=6>?;6<635=>? 4<>5B>?=23'E8:DC69= 6$ 26 455>;=3>9C69= :65>'3= 49: ;6764'6 >? 4C>89='2477A6C4:6394<<>;:49<6F3=2=26 =6;C'>?=264F4;:>?=26;3A8947 3- '$ ( & 3- '"&#"( & 3'= >(7 >(/- (