Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 64478 (KAR)
SHRIMANT v. RUKKAVVA AND ORS
RPFC/200047/2024 · 2025-10-24
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64478 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64478 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$ # #
%#! &
! " #$
%
&
%% '
() '%
! *
( %
)
! ( $
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! "
#$%
+ , ! ( $ -. &
+ +
)#& + + ) ' ' !! ( !! + +
+ $
+
+ '
/$ %
#/$ %&
0. 12.3.45 1.5-5-64 -3 78 50. 0937:4; 7.-4< :<<2-.=.; 78 50. 62;.2 ;:5.; !! 1:33.; -4 2>-3?6( !! 64 50. @->. 6@ 50. 2-4?-1:> 9;<. +:A->8 6925 -B:8192 -4 5.2A3 6@ C0-?0 :>>6C-4< 50. 1.5-5-64 @->.; 78 2.3164;.453 C-@. :4; ?0->;2.4 94;.2 .?5-64 ! 2 50. +:A->8 6925 0:3 ;-2.?5.; 50. 2.3164;.45 1.5-5-64.20.2.-4561:8 1.2A6450:3
- 3 -
A:-45.4:4?. 56 50. C-@. 2.3164;.45 6 :4; (
.:?0 56 2.3164;.45 63! :4; ( C06 :2. 50. ?0->;2.4 6@ 1.5-5-64.2:4;2.3164;.456 ! 0. A:22-:<. 7.5C..4 50. 1.5-5-64.2 :4;
2.3164;.45 6 0:=-4< 7..4 36>.A4-D.; 64 ! :4;2.3164;.4563!:4;(0:=-4<7..476246956@50. 3:-;A:22-:<.-3465-4;-3195. ( 5-3:>>.<.;50:5;9.56?.25:-4A:2-5:>;-3?62;
50. 2.3164;.45 6 C-@. C:3 @62?.; 56 >-=. C-50 0.2 1:2.453:>64<C-5050.A-462?0->;2.4:4;50.1.5-5-64.2
0937:4; ;.31-5. 0:=-4< 39@@-?-.45 -4?6A. :4; 3692?. 6@ -4?6A. 0:3 4.<>.?5.; 56 126=-;. A:-45.4:4?. 56 50. 2.3164;.45 6 C-@. :4; ?0->;2.4 .4?. : 1.5-5-64 94;.2 .?5-64 ! 6@ 2 C:3 @->.; 3..E-4< A6450>8 A:-45.4:4?.6@ @62.:?06@50.2.3164;.453
42.31643.1.5-5-64.20937:4;@->.;35:5.A.45 6@67B.?5-64:;A-55-4<50.A:22-:<.:4;2.3164;.4563! :4; ( 0:=-4< 7624 695 6@ 50. A:22-:<. 5 -3 06C.=.2
- 4 -
?645.45.;50:52.3164;.456 C-@.C:3464?661.2:5-=. -4 ;-3?0:2<-4< 50. A:2-5:> 67>-<:5-64 :4; 50:5 2.3164;.45 6 C-@. C:3 .:24-4< ! 1.2 A6450 @26A 0.2 ?66>-.C62E:339?030.C:3.?646A-?:>>83694;:4;:7>. 56A:-45:-40.23.>@:4;50.?0->;2.4
5-3@9250.2?645.45.;50:50-3A650.20:;@->.; :4:11>-?:5-647.@62.50.33-35:456AA-33-64.2-B:8192 97
-=-3-64-42.31.?56@>:4;-486!!) A.:392-4< ( :?2.3 <945:3 :4; 0-3 A650.2 0:; :>36 @->.; : 2>-3?6 !! 7.@62. 50. ;;-5-64:> + -B:8192C0-?0.4;.;-4?6A126A-3.45.2A36@C0-?0
50. :@62.3:-; >:4; 0:3 7..4 <-=.4 56 0-3 A650.2 0:5 2.3164;.45 6 C-@. ;.3.25.; 50. ?6A1:48 6@ 50. 1.5-5-64.2 0.2.-4 64 :??6945 6@ 50. 1261.258 0:=-4< 7..4 5:E.46=.2780-3A650.2:4;50:50.0:34.=.24.<>.?5.;
622.@93.;56A:-45:-450.A 0.;.A:4;7.-4<A:;.78 50.2.3164;.453:2.942.:364:7>. 0:50.-3:>C:832.:;8 :4;C->>-4<565:E.?:2.6@50.A
- 5 -
0.52-:>692564:112.?-:5-646@50..=-;.4?. :4; 50. A:5.2-:> 1>:?.; 64 2.?62; 1:33.; 50. -A19<4.; 62;.2 ;-2.?5-4< 50. 1.5-5-64.2 0937:4; 0.2.-4 56 1:8 50. A6450>8 A:-45.4:4?. :A6945 :3 465.; :76=. $.-4< :<<2-.=.;7850.3:A.50.1.5-5-64.2-37.@62.50-36925 * .:24.;?6943.>2-:30:3
-E30-55:E-4<50-3 69255069<050.2.?62;3A62.1:25-?9>:2>850.;.163-5-64 6@ 2.3164;.45 C-@. =.0.A.45>8 397A-53 50:5 50.2. -3 46 208A. 62 2.:364 @62 50. 2.3164;.45 C-@. 56 35:8 :C:8 @26A50.?6A1:486@1.5-5-64.2 0937:4;.397A-5350:5
30. 0:3 ?:5.<62-?:>>8 :4; 94:A7-<9693>8 :;A-55.; -4 0.2 ;.163-5-64 :3 C.>> -4 50. ?2633.F:A-4:5-64 50:5 30. >.@5
50. ?6A1:48 6@ 1.5-5-64.2 36>.>8 64 :??6945 6@ ;-3195. 2:-3.; 78 A650.2 6@ 50. 1.5-5-64.2 0937:4; -4 2.31.?5 56
50.
1261.258 7.:2-4< 86!!) . -43-353 50:5 50. ;.163-5-646@2.3164;.45 C-@.C69>;-4;-?:5.50:530.0:; :<2..;562.59245650.A:52-A64-:>06A.-@50.A650.26@
50. 1.5-5-64.2 0:; 2.5924.; 50. 1261.258 7:?E 56 50. 1.5-5-64.2 . @9250.2 397A-53 1.5-5-64.2 :4; 2.3164;.45
- 6 -
6 :2. 2.>:5.; .=.4 650.2C-3. :3 50. 1.5-5-64.2 -3 A:5.24:> 94?>. 6@ 2.3164;.45 6 . 397A-53 ?643-;.2-4< 50. 7:?E<2694;6@ 50. ;-3195. :3 C.>> :3 50. 2.>:5-6430-17.5C..450.1:25-.350.62;.21:33.;7850. 52-:>69257.3.5:3-;. .:2;.293.;50.2.?62;3 )
0. @:?5 2.A:-43 50:5 50. 2.3164;.45 6 :>64<C-500.2A-462?0->;2.4-32.3-;-4<C-500.21:2.453 ;A-55.;>8 30. 0:3 46 3692?. 6@ -4?6A. .F?.15 50. 1921625.; ?66>-. C62E 0. 52-:> 6925 5:E-4< -456 ?643-;.2:5-64 6@ 50. @:?59:> :31.?5 6@ 50. A:55.2 0:3 :C:2;.; A:-45.4:4?. 6@ 56 50. 2.3164;.45 C-@. :4; ( .:?0 56 2.3164;.45 63! :4; ( 5 :48 35:4;:2; 50. 3:-; :A6945 ?:4 4.-50.2 7. ?643-;.2.; :3 .F627-5:4562>9F92-693
3 2.<:2;3 50.2.:3643@622.3164;.45 6 56 35:8 :C:8 @26A 50. 1.5-5-64.2 0937:4; :>64< C-50 0.2 ?0->;2.4 -3 ?64?.24.; :;A-55.;>8 50.2. C:3 : @:A->8
- 7 -
;-3?62; 5069<0 -5 A:8 0:=. 35.AA.; @26A 50. 1261.258 ;-3195.2:-3.;7850.A650.26@50.1.5-5-64.26264650.2 ?69453 :3 :>>.<.; -4 50. 1.5-5-64 0. 64>8 G9.35-64 2.G9-2.3 ?643-;.2:5-64 -3 50:5 -@ 2.3164;.45C-@. :4;
?0->;2.4?:4@-4;50.A3.>=.36250.2.-34.<>-<.4?.:350. 1:256@1.5-5-64.20937:4;56126=-;.A:-45.4:4?. 0.3. :31.?530:=.7..45:E.4465.6@7850.+:A->86925
450:5=-.C6@50.A:55.250-36925;6.3465 3..:482.:36456-45.2@.2.C-5050.62;.21:33.;7850. 2-4?-1:> 9;<. +:A->8 6925 -B:8192 -4 2>-3? 6( !! ;:5.; !!6<2694;3:2.A:;.695 @62-45.2@.2.4?..4?.1.5-5-64-3
'( )# #* $
-356 >6! %