- 1 - !!" !#$ % "&"'""! ""'' ($!) *+ ""'' ($) ""'' ($!) * + ! "" " "#"$ %$$" " ! " &&" $" '((( " " Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ") )" $'*&!( %$" ") "(+(+""$" " )) ) " $" " $" " $ " " $$" " ) " " "'(((+ $ " " ) " " " " , " $ !!( * + " " "#$ %$$" " ! " &&" $" '((( " " ") )" $'*&!( - 3 - %$" ") "(*((""$" " )) ) " $" " $" " $ " " $$" " ) " " "'(((+ $ " " ) " " " " , " $ !( * + " " ") )" $'*&!( $" %$$" " ! "" " "#"$'*&!( " &&" $" - 4 - '((( %$" )- " )) ) " $" " $" " $ " ) " " ) " " "'(((+ $ " " " " " , " $ !!( " " " " ) (( (((' " "")+.) "") $"""" ") " $$ ) " "" / "$ &! "0123040565784459608:5;1752<=198>7?66?1@ A?40 ;1@65@4 1= B589@5> ;12@65B =19 <894?56 405C 895 48D5@ 2< =19 0589?@3 "05658<<58B689?651241=405;1771@8A89>>845> (((+<8665>EC405>>?4?1@8B5@?19?:?B2>358@> 1419 ;;?>5@4 B8?76 "9?E2@8B 1, $ ?@ 16!! 1= ( ! 1= ( 8@> !& 1= ( >845> (((+ - 5 - @ (*++ 1@5 >5;5865> 0860?D8B8 26055BD2789 8@> 5578 A595 498:5BB?@3 ?@ 8 ;89 E589?@3 1 '('F'!&"05>9?:591=405;8908>>9?:5@?4?@89860 8@> @53B?35@4 78@@59 A?40 0?30 6<55> B164 ;1@491B 1:59 405 :50?;B5 >8605> 405 918>6?>5 >?4;0 8@> ?4 429@5> 4294B5 6 8 9562B4 0860?D8B8 >?5> 1@ 405 6<14 8@> 140596 62648?@5> ?@G29?56 1!! 1= ( ?6 =?B5> EC 405 61@ 8@> >8230459 1= 405 >5;5865> 0860?D8B8 "05 ?@G295> ;B8?78@4 ' 260?BD2789 =?B5> 1! 1= ( 8@> 405 ?@G295> ;B8?78@4'5578=?B5> 1!&1=(=19405?@G29?56 62648?@5> EC 4057 ?@ 405 8;;?>5@4 838?@64 405 1A@59 8@> ?@629591=405;8956<1@>5@419578?@5>E5=195 405 "9?E2@8B ?@ 8BB 14059 ;8656 "05 "9?E2@8B 398@45> 6 (( (((' 8@> 6( (((' ?@ 16!! 1= ( 8@> ! 1= ( 956<5;4?:5BC A?40 ?@459564 84 405 9845 1= +. <59 8@@27 =917 >845 1= <54?4?1@ 4?BB 958B?684?1@ 1A5:59 1!&1=(A86>?67?665>EC405"9?E2@8B *339?5:5>EC40568?>19>59 )1(* &1=(+ ?6 =?B5> EC 405 B538B 95<9565@484?:56 1= >5;5865> 0860?D8B8 - 6 - "05C 64845> 4084 405 >5;5865> A86 835> ( C5896 >1?@3 48?B19?@3 A19D 05 A86 589@?@3 6! (((' <59 71@40 24 405 "9?E2@8B 086 48D5@ 405 ?@;175 86 6 *((' 8@> *(. 41A89>6B1661==24295<916<5;46?6@148>>5>EC405"9?E2@8B 61 8B61 758359 8712@46 A595 398@45> =19 498@6<19484?1@ 5H<5@656 B166 1= B1:5 8@> 8==5;4?1@ 8@> 4026 95I25645> =19 5@08@;575@4 !@14059;865?@ )1(* +1=(+?6=?B5>EC405 ?@G295>;B8?78@4260?BD2789508664845>408405A86835> C5896844054?751=4058;;?>5@41;;2995>1@(*++ 5 62648?@5> 40955 ?@G29?56 "05 "9?E2@8B 086 @14 398@45> 405 8712@462@>59405058>B1661=589@?@3>29?@34054958475@4 <59?1> B166 1= =24295 589@?@36 B166 1= 875@?4?56 8@> 405 8712@4=198445@>8@4;089356 =11>8@>@129?6075@4 ) 1(!!* 1= (+ ?6 =?B5> EC 405 ?@6298@;5 ;17<8@C 838?@64 405 8A89> <8665> ?@ 1!! 1= ( 78?@BC ;1@45@>?@3 4084 956<1@>5@4 1 9578?@5> 5H <8945 E5=195 405 "9?E2@8B 4 ?6 =294059 64845> 4084 40595 ?6 5H49819>?@89C>5B8C1=(C5896?@=?B?@3405;B8?7<54?4?1@24 40595?6@15H<B8@84?1@3?:5@=19405>5B8C=917405C589++ - 7 - 41 ( 4 ?6 =294059 ;1@45@>5> 4084 405 ?@6298@;5;17<8@C 5H87?@5>1@405?9E508B=8@>?4?664845>4084>2541405 >5B8C 405C ;12B> @14 <91>2;5 405 ;1<C 1= 405 <1B?;C "05?9 1==?;5A8660?=45>4A?;5>29?@3B864(C5896"05C8B61612304 =19 E8@D 6484575@4 =917 8@898 8@D =917 &( ++ 41 ( ++41=?@>1248641A0540598@C8712@4A86;95>?45> =19 405 68?> <1B?;C 24 405 E8@D 64845> 4084 405 95;19>6 <5948?@?@341405C5896++ 8@>++A595>56491C5>"0595?6 @1 <1B?;C 8@> 40595=195 405C ;8@@14 E5 05B> B?8EB5 "0595 ?6 ?@19>?@845 >5B8C 1@ 405 <894 1= 405 <54?4?1@596 "05 "9?E2@8B 398@45>405?@45956484+.<598@@27 E24B8459 ?4A8695>2;5> 41!. & 4 ?6 =294059 ;1@45@>5> EC 405 B589@5> ;12@65B =19 ?@6298@;5 ;17<8@C 4084 ?@ 405 ;1@@5;45> 784459 86 40595 ?6 B538B E89 41 =?B5 8@ 8<<58B 2@>59 405 ;4 +&& =19 405 8A89>5>;17<5@684?1@1=6( ((('19B566408@6( (((' 4058<<58B?6@14=?B5>24@1@'=?B?@31=4058<<58B;8@@14;175 ?@ 405 A8C 1= 405 8<<5BB8@4 41 ;1@4564 40?6 784459 "05 ;B8?78@46 ;8@@14 48D5 8>:8@4835 1= 405 6875 "05 ?@;175 48D5@8440598451=6*('<59>8C?6E865B566"05@14?1@8B - 8 - ?@;175 ?@ 405 C589 ++ ?6 6*' 41 6(' <59 >8C 8@> 4026 95I25645>4195>2;5405;17<5@684?1@ +589>405893275@461=E1406?>56 ("058;;?>5@4?@I2564?1@?61;;2995>1@(*++ 24 405 ;8656 A595 =?B5> ?@ 405 C589 ( ?5 8=459 ( C5896640595A86@1B?7?484?1@=19=?B?@3405 6 844084 4?75 405 68?> ;8656 A595 @27E595> 8@> 405 8712@46 A595 398@45>EC405"9?E2@8B?@8;;19>8@;5A?40B8A "05 B589@5> ;12@65B =19 405 ?@6298@;5 ;17<8@C ;1@45@>5>4084405>9?:591=405956<1@>5@41086@1:8B?> >9?:?@3B?;5@;524405;1<C1=405>9?:?@3B?;5@;5A86=?B5>EC 405<54?4?1@596"05"9?E2@8B?@ 1!!1=(08648D5@ 405 ?@;175 1= 405 >5;5865> 86 6*(' <59 >8C 8@> @14?1@8B ?@;175866 *(('<5971@4018B61 86<59405$ 95<194 ' H$! 405 835 A86 48D5@ 86 ( C5896 8@> 405 72B4?<B?59 8<<B?;8EB5 A86 * ;;19>?@3BC 8=459 >5>2;4?@3 1@5 40?9> 41A89>6<5961@8B5H<5@656 405B1661=>5<5@>5@;CA86899?:5> 866 &( ((('18B6195861@8EB58712@46A595398@45>=19 B1661=B1:58@>8==5;4?1@ 498@6<19484?1@8@>=2@598B5H<5@656 - 9 - 64058;;?>5@4?61=405C589++ 40?61294=?@>6@195861@ 41 ?@459=595 A?40 405 5@4?95 ;17<5@684?1@ 1= 6 (( (((' 398@45> EC 405 "9?E2@8B 8@> 405 ?@6298@;5 ;17<8@C A86 >?95;45>41<8C40568?>8712@4 @ 1! 1= ( 405 <54?4?1@59 ;1@45@>5> 40840562648?@5>40955?@G29?5686<59H0?E?4$8@>405C895 6?7<B5 ?@ @84295 5 086 @14 <91>2;5> 8@C 75>?;8B E?BB6 6 62;0 3B1E8B ;17<5@684?1@ 1= 6( (((' A86 398@45>EC 405 "9?E2@8B8@>?4@55>6@1?@459=595@;5 "05 B589@5> ;12@65B =19 405 ?@6298@;5 ;17<8@C ;1@45@>5> 4084 40595 A86 >5B8C 1= ( C5896 ?@ =?B?@3 405 8<<B?;84?1@ "05 "9?E2@8B 8B61 1E659:5> 4084 40595 A86 @1 B?7?484?1@?@=?B?@3662;0 40568?>;1@45@4?1@1=405B589@5> ;12@65B ;8@@14 E5 8;;5<45> 4 ?6 =294059 ;1@45@>5> 4084 405 ?@6298@;5 ;17<8@C 086 @14 ;1@45645> ?@ 8@14059 ;1@@5;45> 784459864058A89>8712@4?61@BC6( ((('1A5:59 405 B589@5> ;12@65B =19 405 ;B8?78@46 ;1@45@>5> A05@ 405 ?@6298@;5;17<8@C8;;5<45>405?9B?8E?B?4C?@1@51=405784459 405C ;8@@14 >?6<?45 405 6875 ?@ 8@14059 784459 A05@ 8BB 405 784459689?651241=40568758;;?>5@4 - 10 - "0595=195 ) 1(!!* 1= (+ =?B5> EC 405 ?@6298@;5;17<8@C086@1759?468@>?6>?67?665> 8@>618B61 )1(* &1=(+8@> )1(* +1=(+=?B5>EC 405 ;B8?78@46 =19 5@08@;575@4 895 >?67?665> ;1@=?97?@3 405 8A89>1=405"9?E2@8B ,-* ('""!) &! ?641B1