Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 64473 (KAR)
SURESH S/O KASHINATH v. KASHINATH S/O SIDRAM KANNALE AND ORS
RFA/200064/2015 · 2025-11-06
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64473 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64473 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "!#!! $$
%$&$' (
! "#"
$
%
&#
"
&! % "
#
' #&()*&
"
****#
&!%
"
( #&()*&
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
"
****#
&!% "
#$
#+(
+*&#
&!% "
#
#)&)
"
"'
"
***&#
#
"
# #
&) '" $
" ,
***&#
# $
"
# # #
#
&) '" $
" ,
***&#
- 3 -
+#
$
"
"
+(
# #
# #
&) '" $
" ,
***&#
#
"
"
(+
# #
# #
!#
#
' +-
$
'&! %
&!%-
"
"
'- ''
%
' '+&&
)'
$"
+##*& . $ / $"'
###**&&
' ''
#
" ' '
$"
" ."#$
"###
"
- 4 -
#! !."#$
"###
" %
01234453612789054631:91;;751:<3<<=15>5?78905 @A?<B5:9 3:? ?5C=55 ?395? +#*#*& 43225? 1: # D#**&& D: 905 ;165 D; 5:1D= 1>16 $A?<5 3:? $"' 036E1!;D=20D=9F905
=136DA=9G%78H01C0905
=136DA=9 032?12B1225?9052A19D;9054631:91;;# #
05C325D;9054631:91;;129039 #& BBD>3765 4=D45=9152 753=1:< 8#D2#)(& 9D )( 9D93668 B532A=1:< * 3C=52 + <A:932 219A395? 39 D:<34A= 1663<5 I 036E1 ?52C=175? 32 4631:9 F G 2C05?A65 4=D45=98 3:? 3 0DA25 4=D45=98 B532A=1:< *J* ;559 219A395? 39 D:<34A= 1663<5 036E1 936AE ?52C=175? 32 2C05?A65FG4=D45=98D=1<1:3668756D:<5?9DD:5 1?=3B 3::365# # 31? 1?=3B 3::365 905 4=D4D219A2 43225? 3H38 653>1:< 7501:? 012 H1;5 =3BB3
- 5 -
!?5;5:?3:9D#%3:?+2D:2:3B568 3201:390 !?5;5:?3:9D#&%120H3:390!?5;5:?3:9D#% $3<3::390 !?5;5:?3:9 D#% 3:? 3@EAB3= !?5;5:?3:9 D#+%# 631:91;; 12 905 2D: D; 3201:390!?5;5:?3:9D#&%# #
039 905=5 032 755: :D 43=9191D: D; 905 2A19 2C05?A65 4=D45=9152# 5;5:?3:9 D# H32 B3:3<1:< 905 3;;31=2 D; 905 @D1:9 ;3B168 4=D45=91521:C6A?1:<9053<=1CA69A=363C91>1915232 05H32=521?1:<1:D:<34A=1663<53:?32905 D905= ?5;5:?3:92 03? <D:5 9D 8?5=373? ;D= 9051= 61>5610DD?#
039 905 ;3905= D; 905 4631:91;;
343=9 ;=DB 751:< 166195=395 03? 2A2931:5? 7A=: 1:@A=1521:905853=&(3:?H32:D91:012 <DD?053690# #+
039 ?5;5:?3:9 D# 93E1:< 3?>3:93<5 D; 905 219A391D: 1: 905 3725:C5 D; 3:8 43=9191D:
D7931:5? C5=931: ?55?2 D; CD:>583:C5 1: 012
- 6 -
:3B5 3:? 1: 905 :3B5 D; ?5;5:?3:9 D#)
"303?5>3443 H0D 12 3 29=3:<5= 9D 905 ;3B168# 039905231?9=3:23C91D:23=5CD66A21>53:?:D9 71:?1:<D:9054631:91;;# #
0394631:91;;03?=5IA5295??5;5:?3:9D2#&9D ;D=43=9191D:3:?366D9B5:9D;01265<191B395K 203=5 DA9 D; &90 203=5 366DC3765 9D ?5;5:?3:9 D#& 1: 905 2A19 3:? 4=D45=9152# 5;A236 D; H01C0CD:29=31:5?01B9D;1659054=525:92A19;D= 43=9191D:# # 5;5:?3:9 D# 03? ;165? H=1995: 29395B5:9 CD:95:?1:<9039 #&
05 2A19 F G 3:? FG2C05?A65 4=D45=91523=5:D9905 3:C529=364=D45=9152D;905;3B168D;4631:91;;3:?905 ?5;5:?3:9 D2#& 9D #
039 1?=3B 3::365 905 ;3905=D;905?5;5:?3:9D2#&9D3:?<=3:?;3905= D;9054631:91;;?A=1:<01261;591B503?2D6?9055:91=5 2A19 2C05?A65? 4=D45=9152 3:?
39 905 91B5 D; 012
- 7 -
?5390:D4D=91D:D;2A192C05?A654=D45=9152H3265;9 1:90503:?2D;?5;5:?3:9D2#&9D# #
039 905 <5:536D<8 ;A=:1205? 78 905 4631:91;; H32 1:CD==5C9 3:? 1:CDB46595 32 1?=3B 3::365 905 4=D4D219A2 03? 9HD H1>52 :3B568 =3BB3 3:? A<3BB3# 1?=3B 3::365 03? ;DA= ?3A<095=2 :3B568 3B363731 3=32H391 =1?5>1 A6DC03:3 3:? ;1>5 2D:2 :3B568 31@1:390 $3<3::390 120H3:390 3201:3903:?3@EAB3=7D=:DA9D;012 ;1=29 B3==13<5 H190 =3BB3 H0165 3 ?3A<095= 3:? 9HD 2D:2 :3B568 05563 A=A:390 3:? 3:<3443 7D=:DA9D;01225CD:?B3==13<5H190A<3BB3#
05 231? C016?=5: D; 1?=3B 3::365 03>5 :D9 755:
7=DA<09 D: =5CD=? 32 2AC0 905 2A19 12 :D9 B31:931:3765;D=:D:@D1:?5=D;:5C5223=843=9152# # 9 12 ;A=905= CD:95:95? 9039 63:? 1: 8#D#)( B532A=1:<&3C=5<A:932032<D:5;D=9054A=4D25 D;;D=B391D:D;4A761C=D3?#3:?1:8#D#)(/)
- 8 -
H32 3CIA1=5? ;D= 3=3:@3 =D@5C9# 05=532 63:? 1:
8#D#)(9D93668B532A=1:<)3C=52032755:2D6? 78 1?=3B 3::365 1: ;3>DA= D; ?5;5:?3:9 D#) 1: 905 853= &# 05=53;95= ?5;5:?3:9 D# 4A=C0325? 3: 5J95:9 D; 3C=52 D; 63:? ;=DB ?5;5:?3:9 D#)# 039 5;5:?3:9 D# 362D 4A=C0325?3:D905=5J95:9D;&3C=5)<A:9323:? 3C=52*<A:932;=DBA<3BB33:?=3BB3# #+
039 BA9391D: 032 755: 5;;5C95? 1: =5245C9 D; 905 3;D=5231?9=3:23C91D:2#
0A2905?5;5:?3:9D#032 755:1:4D225221D:3:?5:@D8B5:9D;905231?5J95:9 D; 63:? 32 372D6A95 DH:5= 905=5D; 3:? 905 4631:91;; 032:D=1<09919653:?1:95=529D>5=90523B5# +# 5;5:?3:9 D#) 1: 012 H=1995: 29395B5:9 ?5:81:< 905C325 D;905 4631:91;; 032 CD:95:95?9039054A=C0325? 3: 5J95:9 D; 3C=52 D; 63:? 1: 8#D#)( 1: 95=B2 D;
?55? D; 2365 ?395? *&#*#& ;=DB A<3BB3 3:? 1?=3B34435>5:75;D=590571=90D;9054631:91;;#
03905
- 9 -
362D4A=C0325?3:D905=5J95:9D;3C=5&(<A:932;=DB D:5 55=3 1:<0 1: 95=B2 D; ?55? D; 2365 ?395? *#*#&#
03905 12 362D905DH:5= D; 0DA254=D45=98 905 4631:9 FG 2C05?A65 4=D45=98 32 2AC0 05 032 755: 1:
4D225221D:3:?5:@D8B5:99D905231?5J95:9D;63:?3:? 4631:9 FG 2C05?A65 4=D45=98#
039 1?=3B 03? 2D6? 231? C5=931:5J95:9D;63:?1:;3>DA=D;D:5"303?5> ?5443 3<205998 03=3:3443 3:? 55=321:<0 3@4A9 H0D 3=5 362D :5C5223=8 43=9152 9D 905 2A19# 5:C5 2DA<09 ;D= ?12B12236D;2A19# #
05
=136DA=97325?D:9054653?1:<2;=3B5?905 ;D66DH1:<122A52 &%05905=4631:91;;4=D>5290392A192C05?A654=D45=9152 3=53:C529=363:?@D1:9;3B1684=D45=9152D;01B256;3:? ?5;5:?3:9D#&9DL % 05905= 905 4631:91;; 4=D>52 9039 05 12 03>1:< &&*90 203=51:9052A194=D45=9152L %05905=905?5;5:?3:9D#4=D>5290392A191273?;D= :D:@D1:?5=D;:5C5223=843=9152L +% 05905= 905 ?5;5:?3:9 D# 4=D>52 9039 012 ;3905= 3:? BD905= 2D6? 28# :D# )( B532A=1:< 3C=52 1:
;3>DA=D;?5;5:?3:9D#)A:?5==5<1295=5?2365?55? 1:905853=&L
- 10 -
% 05905= 905 ?5;5:?3:9 D# 4=D>52 9039 05 032 4A=C0325? 3C=52 D; 63:?
1: 28# :D# )( ;=DB ?5;5:?3:9D#)DA9D;012256;53=:1:<L )%05905=905?5;5:?3:9D#4=D>52903963:?753=1:< 28#:D#)(3:?+120124A=C0325?4=D45=98L (% 05905= 905 4631:91;; 12 5:91965? ;D= 43=9191D: 3:? 2543=3954D225221D:324=385?;D=L %039D=?5=D=?5C=55L
)# 631:91;; 5J3B1:5? 01B256; 32 & 3:? 5J017195? && ?DCAB5:92 32 J2#& 9D && H0165 ?5;5:?3:9 D# 5J3B1:5? 01B256; 32 & ?5;5:?3:9 D#+ 5J3B1:5? 01B256;32?5;5:?3:9D#)5J3B1:5?01B256;32 3:?D:5H19:522H325J3B1:5?32#+3:?5J017195?&+ ?DCAB5:92 32 J2#& 9D &+# : 344=5C1391D: D; 905 5>1?5:C5905
=136DA=93:2H5=5?122A5D2#&3:?(1: 905:5<391>53:?122A5D2#+)3:?3??191D:36122A5 D2#&9D + 1: 9053;;1=B391>5 3:?CD:25IA5:968 ?12B1225? 9052A19#51:<3<<=15>5?9054631:91;;1275;D=59012DA=9# (# =13C01:"303@3:653=:5?CDA:25634453=1:<;D= 905 4631:91;;3445663:9 93E1:< 9012 DA=9 90=DA<0 905
- 11 -
4653?1:<2 3:? 905 B395=136 5>1?5:C5 463C5? D: =5CD=? 39 905DA92592A7B192 (#& 039905
=136DA=9032;3165?9D3?>5=99D905 4653?1:<2 3:? 905 B395=136 5>1?5:C5 463C5? D: =5CD=? 1:CDB1:<9D9055==D:5DA2CD:C6A21D:D;:D:5J1295:C5 D;905;3B1684=D45=9152;D=9054A=4D25D;43=9191D:# (# 039 3?B1995?68 8#D#)( CD:21295? D; * 3C=52 + <A:932 D; 63:?# A9 D; 905 231? 5J95:9 A<3BB390525CD:?H1;5D;1?=3B4A=4D=95?9D03>5 2D6?3:5J95:9D;3C=52D;63:?1:;3>DA=D;?5;5:?3:9 D#) 1: 95=B2 D; ?55? D; 2365 ?395? *&#*#& 4=D?AC5?39 J#)#
0A205 2A7B1925>5:1; 905231? 5J95:9 D; 63:? 12 5JC6A?5? 905=5 =5B31:2 & 3C=52 D; 63:?H190905;3B168# (# 039 ?5;5:?3:9 D#12H3:390 C631B2 9D 03>5 4A=C0325?3C=52D;63:?;=DB905231?"303?5>3443 ?5;5:?3:9 D#) 1: 95=B2 D; ?55? D; 2365 ?395? &#*(#&4=D?AC5?39J#H01C0D:683??2A49D
- 12 -
905 & 3C=52 D; 63:? B3E1:< 19 &+ 3C=52 D; 63:? =5B31:1:<H190905;3B168#
039905
=136DA=9032:D9 3?>5=95?9D90123245C9D;905B3995=# (#+
2 =5<3=?2 905 4=D45=98 B532A=1:< 3C=52 &( <A:932 905 2A7@5C9 B3995= D; 2365 ?55? ?395? *#*#&4=D?AC5?39J#052A7B1929039905=5 3=5 :D ?593162 32 9D ;=DB H0DB 55=3 1:<0 03? 4A=C0325?9054=D45=98#
05=5;D=5052A7B1929039905 CD:>583:C5 1; 3:8 B3?5 78 01B 1: ;3>DA= D; ?5;5:?3:9D#)12:D971:?1:<D:9054631:91;;# (#
2 =5<3=?2 ?55?2 D; 2365 ?395? &&#*#**) 32 45= J# 5J5CA95? 78 A<3BB3 1: ;3>DA= D; 120H3:390?5;5:?3:9D#3:?3:D905=?55?D;2365 ?395? *#*+#**( 32 45= J#+ 5J5CA95? 78 =3BB3 1: ;3>DA= D; 120H3:390?5;5:?3:9 D# CD:>581:< 3??191D:36 3C=52 * <A:932 D; 63:? 12 CD:C5=:5?05 2A7B192 9039 905 23B5 12 3 C65>5= =A25 3?D495? 78 ?5;5:?3:9 D# 9D <59 905 ;3B168 4=D45=98 1: 012
- 13 -
5JC6A21>5 :3B5 ?5:81:< 905 65<191B395 203=5 =1<09 919651:95=529D;905D905=;3B168B5B75=21:C6A?1:<905 4631:91;;# 5 2A7B192 9039 905
=136 DA=9 032 :D9 3?>5=95? 9D 90525 3245C92 D; 905 B3995= H01C0 0D61291C3668 =53? <1>5 3 41C9A=5 D; 5J1295:C5 D;
2A7293:9136 5J95:9 D; 63:? 3>3163765 ;D= 43=9191D: 3:?
?129=17A91D: D; 203=52 3BD:<29 905 ?52C5:?3:92 D;
1?=3B 3::365# 5:C5 255E2 ;D= 366DH1:< D; 905 344536# # =1#03=3:37323443 # 37205998 6H53=:5? CDA:256 34453=1:< ;D= ?5;5:?3:9 D# H0D 12 905 D:68 CD:95291:<=524D:?5:91:9012344536>505B5:9682A7B192 9039 #& 039 32 D: 905 ?395 H05: 1?=3B 3::365 43225? 3H38 905=5 H32 :D 63:? 3>3163765 ;D= 905 4A=4D25D;43=9191D:#
039A<3BB33:?=3BB3H5=5 <1>5: 905 63:? 1: 8#D#)( 78 1?=3B ?A=1:< 012 61;591B5 9DH3=?2 9051= B31:95:3:C5 3:? 1: 5J5=C125 D;
- 14 -
9051= 372D6A95 =1<09 D>5= 905 231? 4=D45=98 905 231? A<3BB33:?=3BB303?2D6?4D=91D:2D;90563:?1: 95=B2D;J#)1:;3>DA=D;"303?5>3443M?5;5:?3:9 D#) 3:? 1: 95=B2 D; J2# 3:? + 1: ;3>DA= D; ?5;5:?3:9 D#12H3:390#
43=9 ;=DB 9039 120H3:390 ?5;5:?3:9 D# 03? 362D 4A=C0325? 905 63:? ;=DB "303?5>3443?5;5:?3:9 D#)#
0A2 905 4=D45=98 4A=C0325? 78 120H3:390 ?5;5:?3:9 D# A:?5=J2#3:?+3=5012372D6A954=D45=9152# #
2=5<3=?29D905=5B31:1:<5J95:9D;90563:? 05 2A7B192 9039 19 12 ;D= 905 4631:91;; 9D 529376120 905 3>3163716198D;905231?4=D45=983:?:DB12CD:?AC9C3:
75 399=17A95? 9D 120H3:390 ?5;5:?3:9 D## 5:C5 2A7B192 9039 :D 1665<36198 D= 5==D= C3: 75 ;DA:? 1: 905 @A?<B5:9 3:? ?5C=55 43225? 78 905
=136 DA=9 H3==3:91:<1:95=;5=5:C5# # 9 12 2A7B1995? 9039 905 ?5;5:?3:9 D#& ;3905= D;
905 4631:91;; 43225? 3H38 ?A=1:< 905 45:?5:C8 D; 905
- 15 -
4=525:9 344536# CCD=?1:<68 78 D=?5= ?395? #*#*+ D905= 65<36 =54=525:9391>52 D; ?5;5:?3:9 D#& 03>5 755: 7=DA<09D:=5CD=?# &*# 53=?#5=A25?905=5CD=?2# &&# : CD:21?5=391D: D; 905 4653?1:< 3:? 905 =1>36 CD:95:91D:2 :D95? 37D>5 905 4D1:92 9039 3=125 ;D= CD:21?5=391D:3=5- !3% 05905=905
=136DA=912@A291;15?1:CDB1:< 9D 905 CD:C6A21D: 9039 905 4631:91;; 032 ;3165? 9D 4=D>5 905 2A19 4=D45=9152 9D 75 905 3:C529=36@D1:9;3B1684=D45=9152D;01B256;3:? ?5;5:?3:9D2#&9DL !7% 05905=905
=136DA=912@A291;15?1:0D6?1:< 9039 905 2A19 12 73? ;D= :D:@D1:?5= D; :5C5223=843=9152L !C% 05905= B3995= =5IA1=52 =5CD:21?5=391D: 78 905
=136DA=9L D1:9D#& &# 05 D:G765 45J DA=9 1: 905 C325 D;
- 16 -
=54D=95?1: 3943=3* 032 =5195=395?9054=1:C14652D;63H=5IA1=5?9D757D=:1:B1:? 1:32A19;D=43=9191D:H01C0=53?232A:?5= N*#5B38CD:21?5=19344D21959D29395751:< 3H566259965?4=1:C1465D;63H90391:32A19;165? 78 3 CD203=5= CD43=C5:5= CDDH:5= D= @D1:9 DH:5= 32 905 C325 B38 75 ;D= 43=9191D: 3:? 2543=3954D225221D:D;01205=203=5IA3D905=2 19 12 :5C5223=8 ;D= 905 DA=99D 5J3B1:5 1: 905 ;1=29 1:293:C5 905 :39A=5 3:?
C03=3C95= D; 905 4=D45=9152 1: 2A19 2AC0 32 H0D H32 905 D=1<1:36 DH:5=D; 905 2A19 4=D45=91520DH 3:? 78 H01C0 2DA=C5052053CIA1=5?2AC04=D45=9152H05905= 19H3201205=256;3CIA1=5?4=D45=98D=3:C529=36 4=D45=98 D= @D1:9 4=D45=98 D= CD43=C5:5=8 4=D45=981:01205=03:?3:?1;2DH0D3=5H5=5 905CD43=C5:5=2D=@D1:9DH:5=2H19001B05=32 905 C325 B38 75# 5CD:?68 0DH 905 ?5>D6A91D:
D; 01205= 1:95=529 1: 905 4=D45=98 9DDE 463C5 CD:25IA5:9 A4D: 01205= ?5390 D: 2A=>1>1:< B5B75=2 D; 905 ;3B168 3:? 1: H039 4=D4D=91D: H05905=05205?15?1:9529395D=65;97501:?3:8 95293B5:93=82ACC5221D:1:;3>DA=D;3:8;3B168 B5B75= D= DA921?5= 9D 1:05=19 01205= 203=5 1:
4=D45=9152 3:? 1; 2D 192 5;;5C9#
01=?68 H05905= 905 4=D45=9152 1: 2A19 3=5 C343765 D; 751:< 43=9191D:5?5;;5C91>5683:?1;2D1:H039B3::5=L 32968H05905=3664=D45=91523=51:C6A?5?1:905 2A19 3:? 366 CD203=5=2 CD43=C5:5=2 CDDH:5=2 D= @D1:9DH:5=2 32 905 C325 B38 75 3=5 B3?5 43=91529D9052A19L
0525122A52751:<B395=136 ;D=4=D45=?124D236D;90543=9191D:2A1903>59D 753:2H5=5?78905DA=9D:90573212D;;3B168 9=55 1:95= 25 =56391D:2 D; ;3B168 B5B75=2
- 17 -
5>1?5:C5 3??AC5? 3:? 905 4=1:C14652 D; 63H 34461C37659D905C325#O
&# 0A2 565B5:93=8 =5IA1=5B5:9 1: 3 2A19 ;D= 43=9191D:129D;1=291?5:91;89055J1295:C53:?3>3163716198D;
9054=D45=983:?192:39A=532C631B5?7890543=91523:? 905=53;95=9D32C5=931:9051=5:91965B5:9A:?5=90563H;D= 366D9B5:9D;203=532C631B5?# &+# : 905 1:293:9 C325 905 4631:91;; C631B1:< 01B256; 9D 75 905 ?52C5:?3:9 D; 1?=3B 3::365 032 CD:95:?5?90392A192C05?A654=D45=9152D=1<1:3668756D:<5? 9D 1?=3B 3::365# 631:91;; 032 4=D?AC5? J##&& =5CD=?2D;=1<0945=931:1:<963:?1:8#D#)(1:H01C0 905:3B52D;1?=3B 3::3653:?012H1>52=3BB33:? A<3BB303>5755:20DH:9166905853=&((M&(# &# 0A2;=DB9053;D=5231?J##&&1912C653=9039 32D:905853=&((&(3:5J95:9D;&3C=52*<A:932 D;63:?1:8#D#)(1220DH:9D753>31637651:905;3B168 D;1?=3B 3::365#
- 18 -
&)# 'D66DH1:< 3=5 905 9=3:23C91D: 9039 03>5 93E5: 463C51:=5245C9D;9053;D=5231?63:?A:?5=?55?2D;2365 32?593165?05=51:- !3% J#)12905?55?D;2365?395?*&#*#&A:?5= H01C0A<3B33:?1?=3B344303>5CD:>585?3:
5J95:9 D; * 3C=52 DA9 D; 63:? 1: 8#D#)( 1: ;3>DA=D;"303?5>3443M?5;5:?3:9D#)# !7% J##12905?55?D;2365?55??395?&#*(#& A:?5= H01C0 "303?5>3443 M ?5;5:?3:9 D#) 032 2D6?3:5J95:9D;*3C=521:8#D#)(1:;3>DA= D; 120H3:390 M ?5;5:?3:9 D##
<5 D; 120H3:390?5;5:?3:9D#1220DH:32&853=2# !C% J##12905?55?D;2365?395?*#*#&A:?5= H01C0 D:5 55=3 1:<0 032 2D6? 3: 5J95:9 D; * 3C=52&(K<A:932D;63:?1:8#D#)(1:;3>DA= D;"303?5>3443M?5;5:?3:9D#)# !?% J##12905?55?D;2365?395?&&#*#**)A:?5= H01C0 A<3B3 032 2D6? 3: 5J95:9 D; *& 3C=5 ) <A:932 D; 63:? 1: 8#D#)( 1: ;3>DA= D; 120H3:390M?5;5:?3:9D## !5% J##+12905?55?D;2365?395?*#*+#**(A:?5= H01C0=3BB30322D6?3:5J95:9D;*3C=52*
- 19 -
<A:932 D; 63:? 1: 8#D#)( 1: ;3>DA= D; 120H3:390M?5;5:?3:9D## &(# 0A2 A:?5= 905 3;D=5231? ?55?2 D; 2365 39 J##J##3:?J##+120H3:390M?5;5:?3:9D# 032 3CIA1=5? 37DA9 *) 3C=52 *) <A:932 D; 63:? 1: 8#D#)( 1: 012 :3B5# 0165 A:?5= J#& 3:? "303?5>3443 M ?5;5:?3:9 D#) 032 3CIA1=5? * 3C=52 &(K<A:932D;63:?# &#
CCD=?1:<9D5;5:?3:9D#C5=931:4D=91D:2D;
63:?1:8#D#)(1229395?9D03>5755:A9161P5?;D=D3? 3:?;D= 3=3:@34=D@5C9# &# 0DA<0?5;5:?3:9D#)1:012H=1995:29395B5:9 032 C631B5? 9039 1?=3B 3::365 03? 362D 2D6? C5=931:
5J95:9 D; 63:?
1: ;3>DA= D; D:5 "303?5>3 ?5443 3<3205998 03=3:3443 3:? 55=321:<0 3@4A9 :D 43=91CA63=?5931623=5B3?53>3163765# *# 039 90DA<0 ?A=1:< 905 9=136 19 12 CD:95:?5? 9039 905 3;D=5231? 63:?2 1: 8#D#)( H32 <1>5: 9D
- 20 -
A<3B3 3:? =3BB3 1: 615A D; B31:95:3:C5 3:? 1:
;A=905=3:C5 9D 9051= =1<092 9058 03? 2D6? 905 4D=91D:2 D;
63:? 9D "303?5>443 ?5;5:?3:9 D#) 3:? 120H3:390 ?5;5:?3:9 D# 905=5 12 :D 4653?1:< 1: 905 H=1995: 29395B5:99D905231?5;;5C9# &# : 905 1B4A<:5? $A?<B5:9 3:? ?5C=55 D; 905 =136DA=9905=512:D32C5=931:B5:9D;9053C9A365J95:9 D; 63:? 2D6? 3:? =5931:5? 1: 905 ;3B168#
05=5 12 362D :D 32C5=931:B5:9 3:? 344=5C1391D: 32 9D 73212 D: H01C0 A<3B3 3:? =3BB3 2D6? 905 4=D45=98 245C1;1C3668 1:
;3>DA= D; 120H3:390 M ?5;5:?3:9 D##
05=5 12 :D ?12CA221D: D= ;1:?1:<32 9D 3:8 4=1D=43=9191D:#
039343=9 905=512362D:D5>1?5:C565?1:=5245C9D;H05=537DA923=5 =5B31:1:<5J95:9D;63:?# # 0DA<0 120H3:390?5;5:?3:9 D# C631B2 3: 5J95:9 D; ) 3C=52 ) <A:932 D; 63:? 32 012 256; 3CIA1=5? 4=D45=98 1: 95=B2 D; J2# 3:? + 905=5 12 :D ?12CA221D: 78 905
=136 DA=9 =5<3=?1:< 905 73212 D; 2AC0
- 21 -
C631B78905?5;5:?3:9D#5>5:H016519056?01B9D75 905 372D6A95 DH:5= 905=5 D;# : 905 3725:C5 D; B395=136 5>1?5:C53:?3:8?12CA221D:2905=51:905
=136DA=9CDA6? :D9 03>5 CDB5 9D 905 CD:C6A21D: 9039 ?5;5:?3:9 D# 751:<905DH:5=D;63:?2A7@5C9B3995=D;J2##3:? +# # 05:9054631:91;; 0324=1B3;3C15 4=D>5? 63:? 753=1:< 8#D#)( B532A=1:< & 3C=52 * <A:932 756D:<1:< 9D 1?=3B 3::365 3:? H05: D:68 C5=931: 4D=91D:2D;905231?63:?H5=53615:395?3:?1:9053725:C5 3C9A3632C5=931:B5:9D;63:?2D6?3:?=5931:5?9012DA=9 12D;905>15H9039905
=136DA=912:D9@A291;15?1:CDB1:< 9D905CD:C6A21D:D;2A194=D45=9152:D9751:<9053:C529=36 @D1:9;3B1684=D45=98D;4631:91;;3:??5;5:?3:92D#&9D# D1:9D# +#
2=5<3=?2;1:?1:<D;905
=136DA=9;D=32A19 751:<73?;D=:D:@D1:?5=D;:5C5223=843=9812=565>3:99D :D959039?5;5:?3:9D#032:D9?124A95?905=56391D:2014
- 22 -
D; 4631:91;; 5JC549 CD:95:?1:< 9039 905 4631:91;; 032 :D9 <1>5:905?593162D;D905=B5B75=2?52C5:?3:92D;1?=3B 3::365#5;5:?3:9D#01B256;1:905H=1995:29395B5:9 <1>5: 905 ?593162 D; D905= ;3B168 B5B75=2#
05 259965? 4D2191D:D;63H1290391:32A19;D=43=9191D:905=512:D73= ;D=7=1:<1:<3:?=5CD=?905B5B75=2D;905@D1:9;3B16839 3:8 293<5 D; 4=DC55?1:< 75;D=5 192 CD:C6A21D:# : 3:8 5>5:9 19 12 259965? 4D2191D: D; 63H 9039 =?5= & A65 &* D?5D;1>16=DC5?A=5N
#
05?12B12236D;9052A1978 905
=136DA=9D:9012<=DA:?C3::D9752A2931:5?#
D1:9# # 05905==5B3:?12:5C5223=8- )# 05 D:G765 A4=5B5 DA=9 1: 905 C325 D;
=54D=95? 1:
- 23 -
!!H0165?5361:<H190122A5D;=5B3:?393=3 D#)#+032056?32A:?5= )#+# CD:@D1:9=53?1:<D;A652 3:?+ D; =?5= +& 7=1:<2 ;D=90 905 2CD45 32 362D CD:9DA=2D;9054DH5=2D;=5B3:?9039H05:905 3>31637655>1?5:C5122A;;1C15:99D?124D25D;905 B3995=9054=D45=CDA=25;D=3:344566395DA=9 129D;D66DH905B3:?395D;A65+D;=?5=+& 3:?9D?595=B1:59052A19;1:3668#912D:681:
2AC0 C3252 H05=5 905 ?5C=55 1: C03665:<5 12 =5>5=25? 1: 344536 3:?
3 =59=136 12 CD:21?5=5? :5C5223=8 9039 905 344566395 DA=9 20366 3?D49 905 CDA=25 D; =5B3:?1:< 905 C325# 9 =5B31:2 9=1959039D=?5=D;=5B3:?12:D99D7543225?1: 3=DA91:5B3::5=75C3A253:A:H3==3:95?D=?5= D; =5B3:? B5=568 56D:<3952 905 61;5 D; 905 6191<391D:H190DA925=>1:<905C3A25D;@A291C5# :
D=?5= D; =5B3:? D:68 D: 905 <=DA:? 9039 905 4D1:92 9DAC01:< 905 344=5C1391D: D; 5>1?5:C5 H5=5:D9?5369H190789059=136DA=9B38:D975 CD:21?5=5? 4=D45= 1: 3 <1>5: C325 75C3A25 905 ;1=29 344566395 DA=9 19256; 12 4D225225? D; @A=12?1C91D:9D5:95=1:9D;3C923:?344=5C1395905 5>1?5:C5#
05=5 CDA6? D; CDA=25 75 25>5=36 5>5:9A3619152 H01C0 B38 @A291;8 3: D=?5= D;
=5B3:? D= H05=5 =5B3:? HDA6? 75 =3905= :5C5223=8?545:?1:<D:905;3C923:?905<1>5: 259D;C1=CAB293:C52D;3C325#
(#
2:D95?37D>5905
=136DA=9H016593E1:<A4 366905122A52;=3B5?7819;D=CDBBD:CD:21?5=391D:032
- 24 -
6D2921<09D;905=5IA1=5B5:9D;3?@A?1C391:<905=536122A5 1:CD:9=D>5=28#:903932:D95?37D>5- &# 9 ;3165? 9D 3?>5=9 9D 905 CD=5 122A5 D;
5J1295:C53>3163716198 D; 905 63:? ;D= 905 4A=4D25 D; 43=9191D:# # 9 362D ;3165? 9D 344=5C1395 =5<3=?1:< 905 73212 D: H01C0A<3B33:?=3BB303?2D6?9054=D45=981:
;3>DA= D; "303?5>3443 M ?5;5:?3:9 D#) 3:? 120H3:390M?5;5:?3:9D## # 9 032 362D :D9 344=5C1395? 9039 5>5: 3;95= 905 4A=4D=95? 23652 1: ;3>DA= D; 120H3:390?5;5:?3:9 D# 3:? "303?5>3443 ?5;5:?3:9 D#) 905=5 =5B31:5?63:?1:8#D#)(# +#
05=5 12 :51905= 3:8 5>1?5:C5 :D= 3:8 ?12CA221D: =5<3=?1:< 120H3:390?5;5:?3:9 D# 75CDB1:< 372D6A95DH:5=D;90563:?1:95=B2D;J2#9D+#
- 25 -
# 9DA<099D03>53??5?905D905=;3B168B5B75=232 CD:95:?5? 78 ?5;5:?3:9 D# ;D= CDB46595 3?@A?1C391D:D;905# # 0A2 1: 905 CD:21?5=5? >15H D; 9012 DA=9 B3995= =5IA1=52 =5344=5C1391D: 78 905
=136 DA=9 3;95= 45=B1991:< 905 43=9152 9D 653? ;A=905= 5>1?5:C5 1: 905 B3995=# '3161:< H01C0 905 CD:C549 D; CDB46595 3:? 5;;5C91>5 3?@A?1C391D: D; 905 B3995= =5B31:2 1:CDB46595# 05=5;D=59012DA=9?55B219344=D4=13959D259321?5905 @A?<B5:9 3:? ?5C=55 3:? =5B3:? 905 B3995= ;D= ;=520 CD:21?5=391D:1:90561<09D;905D725=>391D:2B3?537D>5# # 5:C5905;D66DH1:<-
!3% 0534453612366DH5?# !7% 05@A?<B5:93:??5C=5543225?78905
=136 DA=91205=578259321?5# !C% 05 B3995= 12 =5B1995? 9D 905
=136 DA=9 ;D= ;=520 CD:21?5=391D:#
05
=136 20366 3;;D=? D44D=9A:1989D9054631:91;;3:??5;5:?3:929D 653? 3??191D:36;A=905= 5>1?5:C5 1; 3:8
- 26 -
3?>5=91:< 9D 905 4D1:92 =3125? 05=51:37D>5 3:? 905=5D; 4322 @A?<B5:9 3:? ?5C=55 3CCD=?1:<68# !?% 1:C59052A191245:?1:<21:C5*&&905
=136 DA=9203665:?53>D=9D?124D25D;9052A1932 5J45?191DA2324D221765H1901:3:DA95=61B19D;
D:5853=;=DB905?395D;=5C5149D;C5=91;15? CD48D;9012D=?5=# !5% 1:C5 905 43=9152 3=5 =54=525:95? 90=DA<0 9051= CDA:256 9058 20366 34453= 75;D=5 905 9=136DA=9D:&#&#*H190DA93:8;A=905= :D91C5#
)& %!!' #
" 129D#&6D#