- 1 - ! "#$ %$&!$!$ '$( ! "#$ !!% ! &$'''#( #( (# &#''' ) $ &#*' Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( $* %'' ! &#$''' ")') ! ))% ! !+ ! , -& *')'" -& '%)')' **)'$ ! ! ! %'")'"-& )*'))')'-& %'()')' ! ! ! . ! ! !! - 3 - / / 012134345617 &819168+63 5 4: ;19571304: 5<73 ;146=+==741>18;?301578178+318*')'"2+::1846 5**)'$;?@04A0301+22B4A+3456593012134345617 94B18 <6817 7817 <B1 59 5( :11C46= 217D4::4563594B1@743316:3+31D1630+:;11671E1A318+: @1BB +: 57817 8+318 '%)')' 71E1A346= 04: +22B4A+3456 94B18<68177817%<B159 ') 1+7618A5<6:1B9573012134345617:<;D43:30+3 3012B+46349971:256816350171460+:94B18301+;5>1 :<43 46 5**)'$ 957 301 71B419 59 81AB+7+3456 46E<6A3456 +68 957 A+6A1BB+3456 59 301 :+B1 8118 8+318 )*'$)''* 1F1A<318 ;? 819168+63 5) 46 9+>5<7 59 819168+6352134345617017146+:653;46846=56301 2B+463499 G 71:2568163 5 0+3 301 819168+63 5 & 21343456170+894B18+22B4A+3456<68175(<68177817 - 4 - <B1 59 :11C46= A56856+3456 59 81B+? 46 94B46= 301 @743316 :3+31D163 @04A0 +22B4A+3456 A+D1 35 ;1 71E1A318;?301 74+B 5<73@481 57817 8+318*')'" +:217661F<71& '( 1+7618A5<6:1B9573012134345617:<;D43:30+3 46 301 D1+6@04B1 819168+63 5( G 71:2568163 5) 017146 @05 0+8 2<7A0+:18 301 :<;E1A3 2752173? 975D 819168+635&213434561701714646301?1+7)''*:5<=03 04D:1B935;14D2B1+818+:+73B?G819168+635(@04A0 +22B4A+3456@+:+BB5@1856*')'"19168+635(G 71:25681635)@+:217D433183594B1@743316:3+31D163 ' 3 4: +3 304: E<6A3<71 819168+63 5 & 2134345617 017146 0+8 94B18 +6 +22B4A+3456 <6817 7817 - :11C46=71>41@593015781771E1A346=04:71H<1:359 94B46=@743316:3+31D163@04A0+B:5A+D135;171E1A318 '# 1+7618A5<6:1B9573012134345617:<;D43:30+3 301 @016 301 819168+63 5 & 2134345617 :5<=03 217D4::456 35 94B1 @743316 :3+31D163 6143017 4::<1: @171 - 5 - 97+D18+680+:+6?1>4816A10+8;116B180171957101 :<;D43:30+3301+22B4A+34565<=03350+>1;116+BB5@18+: 301 :+D1 @+: 94B18 ;19571 A5DD16A1D163 59 374+B 01 74+B5<73@4305<3A56:481746=301:+D10+:D1A0+64A+BB? 71E1A318301+22B4A+3456 1:<;D43:30+330174=03:59301 2+7341: 46 71:21A3 59 301 4DD5>+;B1 275217341: 46>5B>18 +68 46 301 +;:16A1 59 +6? :1745<: >45B+3456 59 301 275>4:456: 59 B+@ 301 74+B 5<73 5<=03 653 35 0+>1 71E1A318301+22B4A+3456 '$ 1+7618 A5<6:1B 957 301 819168+63 5 G 2134345617 9<73017 :<;D43: 30+3 D+3317 4: D571 57 B1:: :133B18 ;13@116 301 2+7341: :46A1 301 819168+63 5 G 2134345617 35 5@1: + 8<3? 35 27531A3 301 463171:3 59 819168+635(@050+:;11665@217D43318;?30174+B 5<733594B1@743316:3+31D163+68A5631:3301D+331765 271E<84A1 @4BB ;1 A+<:18 49 301 2134345617 4: 217D43318 35 94B1301@743316:3+31D163 '% 1+7817<:1830171A578: - 6 - '* 05<=0 6534A1 4: :17>18 56 301 53017 :481 01714:6571271:163+3456 '" 01 :<43 4: 94B18 ;? 301 2B+463499 71:2568163 501714695781AB+7+345646E<6A3456+68A+6A1BB+345659 8118 +: 65318 +;5>1 B1+7B? 301 :<43 4: 46 71:21A3 59 4DD5>+;B12752173?@04A0301819168+6352134345617 017146AB+4D18350+>12<7A0+:1846317D:59811859:+B1 975D 819168+63 5) !<73017 301 819168+63 5 2134345617 017146 AB+4D: 35 0+>1 +B416+318 301 :+48 2752173? 46 9+>5<7 59 819168+63 5( G 71:2568163 5) 22+7163B? @016 301 +22B4A+3456 @+: 94B18 ;? 301 819168+635&2134345617:11C46=217D4::4563594B1301 @743316 :3+31D163 +: 217 5( 374+B 0+8 653 A5DD16A18 +68 4::<1: @171 653 97+D18 0+3 +2+73 819168+635(0+8=5304D:1B94D2B1+81856*')'" +68 01 @+: 217D43318 35 94B1 301 @743316 :3+31D163 01 74+B5<735<=03350+>13+C16304:+:21A359301D+3317 4635A56:4817+3456@04B171E1A346=30171H<1:395794B46=301 @743316:3+31D163 - 7 - ' 1+7618 A5<6:1B 957 301 819168+63 5 G 21343456170+::<;D4331830+32+7341:0+>1+BD5:3+D4A+;B? 71:5B>18 301 D+3317 56:481746= 301:1 21A<B4+7 9+A3: 59 301 D+3317 +68 301 74=03: 59 301 2+7341: 46>5B>18 304: 5<73811D:43+2275274+3135+BB5@301+22B4A+345694B18;? 301 2134345617 :11C46= 217D4::456 35 94B1 301 @743316 :3+31D163 AA57846=B?301@743213434564: ) 014D2<=618578174::13+:481 ( 01 +22B4A+3456 94B18 ;? 301 819168+63 5 5 G 2134345617 :11C46= 217D4::456 35 94B1 @743316 :3+31D1634:+BB5@18 56:1H<163B? 819168+63 5 G 2134345617 4: 217D433183594B1@743316:3+31D163 !)* '$!$( & 4:35B5)'