- 1 - ! "#! "##$ !! %$& ' !" #$ # %" &' ( " &) #( Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " *& " + ,*$-& * " (& .#'" .&" % + .*$(& - " (- .#'" .&"* % + .*$-& */ #( "/""#&)#&#* ( * 01 / - ) )( '$$ % &&$#&# (*"#&## % % % - 3 - 2 % 2 % % # 2 % 341 566758 9:;7< 7=>4?: )( ?@ >37 ?>?< 734=871=>'$$37<74:5@>7<<7@7<<7;>?51A>37=>0@?< 13?<> 351 B77: @487; BC >37 =854D5:>1 =35887:E4:E >37 F9;ED7:> 5:; 5G5<; ;5>7; &&$#&# 65117; BC >37 7:4?< 4H48 %9;E7 I % 4:;35:9< 4: ?(*"#&## # 5=>1 E4H4:E <417 >? >37 @484:E ?@ >37 566758 B<47@8C 1>5>7; 5<7 >35> ?: &-&#&#& 5> 5B?9> #&& ;7=7517; 985E5665 G51 6<?=77;4:E 4: 341 D?>?<=C=87 B75<4:E<7E41><5>4?:? .(-".('''?:87@>14;7?@>37 <?5; @?88?G4:E ><5@@4= =?:;4>4?:1 3487 37 G51 >5J4:E 5 >9<:>?G5<;1G74E3 B<4;E7 18?G8C 4: 4:;35:9<.5:E5H5>4 <?5; 5> >35> >4D7 >37 8?<<C B75<4:E <7E41><5>4?: ? . #$" .&=5D7@<?D?66?14>7;4<7=>4?:G4>334E31677;4: - 4 - 5 <513 5:; :7E84E7:> D5::7< ;5137; 5E54:1> >37 D?>?<=C=87 97 >? 4D65=> ;7=7517; @788 ;?G: 5:; 19@@7<7;5:4:F9<C5:;19==9DB7;>?>374:F9<C ( 37 =854D5:>1 @487; 5 67>4>4?: 9:;7< 7=>4?: -- ?@ >37 => 177J4:E =?D67:15>4?: @?< >37 ;75>3 ?@ >37 ;7=7517;58?:EG4>34:>7<71> 6?: 17<H4=7 ?@ :?>4=7 >37 <716?:;7:> ? 5:; # 56675<7; >3<?9E3 =?9:178 5:; ;4; :?> @487 G<4>>7: 1>5>7D7:> 37 <716?:;7:> ?( 351 56675<7; >3<?9E3 341 =?9:178 5:; @487; 5 G<4>>7: 1>5>7D7:> ;7:C4:E >37 5H7<D7:>1D5;74:>37=854D67>4>4?: * : >37 B5141 ?@ >37 6875;4:E1 ?@ >37 65<>471 >37 854D1<4B9:58@<5D7;>374119715:;>37<75@>7<<7=?<;7; >37 7H4;7:=7 37 <4B9:58 BC 4D69E:7; F9;ED7:> 5:; 5G5<;35165<>8C588?G7;>37=854D67>4>4?:5:;378;>35> >37 =854D5:>1 5<7 7:>4>87; >? 5 =?D67:15>4?: ?@ 1(#**#&".58?:EG4>34:>7<71>5>>37<5>7?@'K65 5:; ;4<7=>7; >37 <716?:;7:> ?(.7845:=7 7:7<58 - 5 - :19<5:=7 ?D65:C >; >? ;76?14> >37 =?D67:15>4?: 5D?9:>58?:EG4>34:>7<71>74:E5EE<47H7;>376<717:> 566758351B77:@487; - 37 875<:7; =?9:178 @?< >37 4:19<5:=7 =?D65:C 351 <5417;>37@?88?G4:E=?:>7:>4?:1 5 4<1>8C 37 351 =?:>7:;7; >35> >37 5==4;7:> 351 ?==9<<7;;97>?>37:7E84E7:=7?@;7=7517;G3?G51<4;4:E D?>?<=C=87B75<4:E7E? .(-".('''37<4B9:58 7<<7;4:3?8;4:E>35>>37;<4H7<?@ ?<<C58?:741:7E84E7:> 4: =5914:E >37 5==4;7:> 7 @9<>37< =?:>7:;7; >35> >37 6?84=75@>7<>3<?9E34:H71>4E5>4?:351@487;5=35<E71377> 5E54:1> >37 ;7=7517; 51 G788 51 >37 ;<4H7< ?@ >37 ?<<C 37;7=7517;G51<4;4:E>37D?>?<=C=874:34E31677;5:; <5135:;:7E84E7:>D5::7<;5137; ?<<C37<4B9:58351 378; >35> ;<4H7< ?@ >37 ?<<C 351 =?:><4B9>7; '*K >? >37 5==4;7:>G34=341?:34E37<14;7 B 7=?:;8C37351=?:>7:;7;>35>=?:14;7<4:E>375E7 5:; 5H?=5>4?: ?@ >37 ;7=7517; >37 ?H7<588 =?D67:15>4?: 5G5<;7;BC>37<4B9:5841?:34E37<14;7 - 6 - = 51>8C37351=?:>7:;7;>35>4:H47G?@F9;ED7:>?@ >341 ?9<>4:>37=517?@(#)**+,(*,-.+/*0(1 2 $*-3,+*(/,-$ ,-. +/*0( % 4567 4 ,-. 8--*8+*. 9,++*0( .:(;(*. - 4 & >37 4:>7<71>5G5<;7;BC>37<4B9:58'K6541?:34E37<14;7 7:=71?9E3>@?<588?G4:E>37566758 ) >37 875<:7; =?9:178 56675<4:E @?< >37 =854D5:>1351=?:>7:;7;>35>>375==4;7:>?==9<<7;;97>? 1?87:7E84E7:=7?@;<4H7<?@>37 ?<<CG3?=5D74:5<513 5:;:7E84E7:>D5::7<5:;;5137;5E54:1>>37D?>?<=C=87 :>37=35<E71377>@487;BC>376?84=7>375B5>7;=35<E7 1377>351B77:@487;?:8C@?<>37?@@7:=769:4135B879:;7< 7=>4?:(5:;7=>4?:$?@ ?>?<734=871=>37<741 :? :7E84E7:=7 ?: >37 65<> ?@ >37 ;7=7517; 37<7@?<7 <4B9:58 351 <4E3>8C 378; >35> ;<4H7< ?@ >37 ?<<C 351 =?:><4B9>7; '*K >? >37 5==4;7:> : <7167=> ?@ L95:>9D 37 351=?:>7:>7; >35>=?:14;7<4:E>37 5E7 5:;5H?=5>4?: ?@>37;7=7517;>37?H7<588=?D67:15>4?:5G5<;7;BC>37 - 7 - <4B9:5841F91>5:;<751?:5B87?9E3>@?<;41D41158?@>37 566758 $ 75<; >37 875<:7; =?9:178 @?< >37 65<>471 7<917; F9;ED7:>5:;5G5<; ' 37 =517 ?@ >37 =854D5:> 41 >35> ?: &-&#&#& 5> 5B?9> #&& ;7=7517; 985E5665 G51 6<?=77;4:E 4: 341 D?>?<=C=87B75<4:E<7E41><5>4?:? .(-".('''?: 87@> 14;7 ?@ >37 <?5; @?88?G4:E ><5@@4= =?:;4>4?:1 3487 37 G51 >5J4:E 5 >9<: >?G5<;1 G74E3B<4;E7 4: 4:;35:9< 5:E5H5>4<?5;5>>35>>4D7>378?<<CB75<4:E<7E41><5>4?: ? .#$" .& =5D7 @<?D ?66?14>7 ;4<7=>4?: G4>3 34E3 1677;5:;<5135:;:7E84E7:>D5::7<;5137;5E54:1>>37 D?>?<=C=87 97 >? 4D65=> ;7=7517; @788 ;?G: 5:; 19@@7<7;5:4:F9<C5:;19==9DB7;>?>374:F9<C & ? 6<?H7 >37 =517 =854D5:>1 35H7 7M5D4:7; >G? G4>:71171 # 5:; 6<?;9=7; M >? M 37 <716?:;7:>1 35H7 :?> 7M5D4:7; 5:C G4>:71171 :?< 6<?;9=7;5:C;?=9D7:>15:;#35H7=5>7E?<4=588C - 8 - 1>5>7; >35> 5==4;7:> ?==9<<7; ;97 >? >37 :7E84E7:=7 ?@ ;<4H7< ?@ >37 ?<<C H7: >37 =35<E7 1377> @487; BC >37 6?84=7 4: <7167=> ?@ ;7=7517; 41 =?:=7<:7; >37 5B5>7; =35<E71377>41@487;?:8C@?<>37?@@7:=769:4135B879:;7< 7=>4?:(5:;$?@ ?>?<734=871=> ?:14;7<4:E>341 7H4;7:=7 ?@ =854D5:>1 5:; =35<E7 1377> <76?<> >37 <4B9:58 351 <4E3>8C =?D7 >? >37 =?:=8914?: >35> >37 ;7=7517;351=?:><4B9>7;*K>?>377M>7:>5:;;<4H7<?@ >37 ?<<C351=?:><4B9>7;'*K>?>377M>7:>37<741:? 7<<?<4:@4:;4:EE4H7:BC>37<4B9:58 :<7167=>?@L95:>9D41=?:=7<:7;=?:14;7<4:E>37 5E7 5:; 5H?=5>4?: ?@ >37 ;7=7517; >37 ?H7<588 =?D67:15>4?: 5G5<;7; BC >37 <4B9:58 41 F91> 5:; <751?:5B87 # : <7167=> ?@ 4:>7<71> 41 =?:=7<:7; 4: 84E3> ?@ >37 4H414?: 7:=3 ;7=414?: ?@ >341 ?9<> 4: >37 =517 ?@ (#)**+,(*,-.+/*0(12$*-3,+*(/,-$,-. +/*0( % 4567 4 ,-. 8--*8+*. 9,++*0( - 9 - .:(;(*.- 4 & >37<5>7?@4:>7<71>5G5<;7; BC >37 <4B9:58 5> 'K 65 ?: >37 =?D67:15>4?: 5D?9:> 56675<17M=7114H715D7351>?B7<7;9=7>?-K65 ( :>37<7198>>37@?88?G4:E?<;7<4165117; 37 566758 41 ,<<=*. :- ;,0+ ?:8C 4: <7167=>?@4:>7<71>41=?:=7<:7;37?>37<65<> ?@ >37 F9;ED7:> 5:; 5G5<; 65117; BC >37 <4B9:5841=?:@4<D7; 37 4:19<5:=7 =?D65:C 41 ;4<7=>7; >? ;76?14> 7:>4<7 =?D67:15>4?: 5D?9:> G4>3 -K 65 4:>7<71> G4>34: - G77J1 @<?D >37 ;5>7 ?@ <7=746>?@>37=?6C?@>341?<;7<G4>384B7<>C>? <7=?H7<@<?D?G:7<?@>37?@@7:;4:EH734=87 .7 %!& # .7 %#$& # 41>?8?(&