Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 64462 (KAR)
FAIJAHAMAD BASHIRALI SHAIK AND ORS v. GULAB NABILAL SHAIK AND ANR
MFA/203823/2023 · 2025-10-10
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64462 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64462 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"# $% & '!"#
() (
%$ (& ( %
%$ ( ( %
' $ ( (
' $ $
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$
" )
* ! #
( ( $
"' ! % $ &#
%
" ) * ! + $ ) %#
$&!#
%
%))
"
$
- 3 -
%
" )
%
""& %
"
* ! #
() (
%$ ( ( %
%$ ( ( %
' $ (' ( ' $ $ $
" )'
- 4 -
( ( $
"' ! % "$" &#
* ! '+ %#
&!#
, $ -
))
%
))
$ -
%
% (
(
- 5 -
!"# !( #
. $ /0 1/234 56 783 92:/;:<70 =83>3:0 .& $' /0 1/234 56 783 <0?>:<93 .;@:<6?<43>397/.<&!#.1783.7.>38/923097 !1.>08.>7A78397-#53/<B:BB>/3C3456783D?4B;3<7:<4 :=:>44:734))@:0034/<. $56 783 44/7/.<:2 3</.> /C/2 ?4B3 :<4 " /D:6:@?>:!1.>08.>7A783>/5?<:2-#/<9378398:223<B3 /0 7. 783 0:;3 D?4B;3<7 5.78 783 :@@3:20 :>3 92?5534 7.B3783>83:>4:<49.;;.<D?4B;3<7/053/<B@:0034
:970 B/C/<B >/03 7. 783 1/2/<B .1 783 :@@3:20 5>/312607:734:>378:7.< :7:5.?7&)@;
.< :2/4:< 8.=E 7. 3CB:.< >.:4 /< 537=33< ..@: 8:C:</8.=E7.:44/:07/8.=E:7.2:@?>=83<783 4393:034 :C34 =:0 7>:C32/<B :0 : @/22/.< >/43> .< 783 ;.7.>96923 53:>/<B >3B/07>:7/.< ."$" & 7 78:77/;3>/43>.1783;.7.>96923>.43/7/<8/B80@334:<4
- 6 -
/< >:08 :<4 <3B2/B3<7 ;:<<3> :<4 4:0834 7. 783 >.:4 4/C/43> >30?27/<B /< 783 :99/43<7 0 : >30?27 .1 783 :1.>30:/4 :99/43<7 783 4393:034 0?07:/<34 B>/3C.?0 /<D?>/30 :<4 0?99?;534 :<4 4/34 .< 783 =:6 7. 783 8.0@/7:2
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
- 7 -
G?:<7?; .1 9.;@3<0:7/.< 92:/;34 56 783 92:/;:<70 /0 3F.>5/7:<73<93830.?B871.>4/0;/00:2.1783@37/7/.<
<7835:0/0.1783@23:4/<B0.1783@:>7/30783 >/5?<:2 1>:;34 783 /00?30 :<4 783>3:173> >39.>434 783 3C/43<93 83 92:/;:<70 /< .>43> 7. @>.C3 783/> 9:03 3F:;/<34 92:/;:<7 . 3F:;/<34 :0 %" :<4 B.7 3F8/5/7344.9?;3<70<:;326F7.F, <538:21.1 >30@.<43<7.4/4<.7234:<63C/43<93<.>B.7;:>E34 4.9?;3<70 83 >/5?<:2 56 783 /;@?B<34 D?4B;3<7 /<73>:2/:832478:7783:99/43<77..E@2:93.<:99.?<7.1 >:08 :<4 <3B2/B3<7 >/4/<B .1 783 .113<4/<B C38/923 56 /70 >/43>:0:>30?27.1=8/987834393:0340?07:/<34/<D?>/30 :<40?99?;5347.783/<D?>/3083>/5?<:21?>783>8324 78:7 783 92:/;:<70 :>3 3<7/7234 7.
: 9.;@3<0:7/.< .1 0'$":2.<B=/78/<73>307:7783>:73.1)H@: :<4 4/>39734 783 /<0?>:<93 9.;@:<6 7. 43@.0/7 783 9.;@3<0:7/.<:;.?<7:2.<B=/78/<73>3073/<B:BB>/3C34 567830:;378303:@@3:208:C3533<1/234
- 8 -
) >/ 4:6.<B?<7/E:>78323:><349.?<0321.> 783 <0?>:<93 .;@:<6 8:0 >:/034 783 1.22.=/<B 9.<73<7/.<0( :# />07263C3<78.?B878392:/;:<708:C392:/;34 783/<9.;3.17834393:034:70$"@3>;.<7856 4./<B :B>/9?27?>:2 :<4 9.<7>:97 =.>E 836 8:C3 <.7 @>.4?934 :<6 4.9?;3<70 7. 307:52/08 783 0:;3 83 >/5?<:2:0030034783<.7/.<:2/<9.;3.<7835:0/0.1783 98:>7 @>3@:>34 56 783
:><:7:E: 7:73 3B:2 3>C/93 ?78.>/76 783 :99/43<7 8:0 .99?>>34 /< 783 63:> /<073:4 .1 9.<0/43>/<B 783 /<9.;3 :7 0'$" 8:0 =>.<B269.<0/43>34:70&$" 5# 39.<426838:09.<73<73478:79.<0/43>/<B783 :B3 :<4 :C.9:7/.< .1 783 4393:034 783 .C3>:22 9.;@3<0:7/.< :=:>434 56 783 >/5?<:2 /0 .< 8/B83> 0/43 3<93 83 0.?B87 1.> >34?97/.< .1 9.;@3<0:7/.< 56 :22.=/<B783:@@3:21/23456783<0?>:<93.;@:<6
- 9 -
& 3> 9.<7>: 23:><34 9.?<032 :@@3:>/<B 1.> 783 92:/;:<708:09.<73<73478:7:77837/;3.1:99/43<7783 4393:034=:03:></<B.10$"@3>;.<781>.;783 9.<7>:97=.>E :# 39.<426/7/0923:>1>.;7833C/43<93.1% 78:783>8?05:<4=:0=.>E/<B:0:.<7>:97.>:77837/;3 .1 :99/43<7 .<0/43>/<B 78/0 :0@397 .1 783 ;:773> 783 ;.<7826/<9.;3:003003456783>/5?<:2:70$"/0 .<7832.=3>0/43 5# 8/>426 83 8:0 9.<73<734 78:7 /< C/3= .1 783 D?4B;3<7 .1 .<-523 @3F .?>7 /< 9:03 .1
!" 783 92:/;:<70 :>3 3<7/7234 7.=:>40 783 2.00 .1 9.<0.>7/?; :7 0'$" :<4 0$" 3:98 7.=:>40 783 2.00 .1 307:73 :<4 1?<3>:2 3F@3<030 :<4 7836 :20. 3<7/7234 1.> H 309:2:7/.< .< 783 9.<C3<7/.<:2 83:40 3<93 783 92:/;:<70 :>3 3<7/7234 1.> 0''$" 3:98 ?<43> 783 83:4 .1 A2.00 .1 9.<0.>7/?;- :<4 0)$" ?<43> 783 83:4 .1 A2.00 .1 307:73- :<4 0)$" 1.>
- 10 -
1?<3>:2 3F@3<030 3<93 83 0.?B87 1.> 3<8:<93;3<7 .1 9.;@3<0:7/.<
3:>4 783 23:><34 9.?<032 :@@3:>/<B 1.> 783 @:>7/303>?034783:@@3:2@:@3>0 , 7 /0 <.7 /< 4/0@?73 78:7 783 4393:034 :C34 :/D:8:;:4 8:/E 4/34 /< >.:4 7>:11/9 :99/43<7 =8/98 .99?>>34 .< 4?3 7. >:08 :<4 <3B2/B3<7 >/4/<B 56783>/43>.1783;.7.>9692353:>/<B>3B/07>:7/.<." $" &C3<78.?B892:/;:<708:C392:/;3478:7783 4393:034 =:0 3:></<B 0$" @3> ;.<78 :0 :
9.<7>:97=.>E3F93@7783>3/0:>313>3<93/<F!:#<. .783> 4.9?;3<70 8:C3 533< @>.4?934 7. @>.C3 78:7 783 4393:034 =:0 3:></<B 0$" @3> ;.<78 <43> 78303 9/>9?;07:<930 <.7/.<:2 /<9.;3 8:0 7. 53 :0030034 :0 @3> 783 B?/432/<30 /00?34 56
:><:7:E: 7:73 3B:2 3>C/93 ?78.>/76 1.> 783 :99/43<7 .99?>>34 /< 783 63:> 783 <.7/.<:2 /<9.;3 8:0 7. 53 9.<0/43>34 :0 0'$"@;/<073:4.10$"@;83>/5?<:2 8:0>/B8726:4434'H.1783/<9.;3.17834393:0341.>
- 11 -
7.=:>40 783 A1?7?>3 @>.0@3970- :<4 >/B8726 434?9734 I78 /<9.;3 .1 783 4393:034 1.> 8/0 @3>0.<:2 :<4 2/C/<B 3F@3<030 83 >/5?<:2 8:0 >/B8726 :@@2/34 783 ;?27/@2/3> A)-
99.>4/<B26 2.00 .1 43@3<43<96 8:0 533< >3:0030034:01.22.=0
8?0 783 92:/;:<70 :>3 3<7/7234
7.
9.;@3<0:7/.< .1 0 & $" !0' J 'H# K ,,LL)L$'.<:99.?<7.1A2.00.143@3<43<96-
< :44/7/.< 783 92:/;:<70 :>3 3<7/7234 7. 9.;@3<0:7/.<.10)$".<:99.?<7.1A2.00.1307:73- :<4 9.;@3<0:7/.< .1 0)$" .< :99.?<7 .1 A1?<3>:2 3F@3<030-
< C/3= .1 783 2:= 2:/4 4.=< 56 783 ?@>3;3 .?>7 /< 783 9:03 .1 # $ !0?@>:# 92:/;:<7 .0 :<4 :>3 @:>3<70 .1 783 4393:034 :>3 3<7/7234 1.> 9.;@3<0:7/.< .1 0''$" 3:98?<43>78383:4.12.00.11/2/:29.<0.>7/?;92:/;:<7
- 12 -
.=/13.17834393:034/03<7/72341.>9.;@3<0:7/.<.1 0''$"?<43>78383:4.1A2.00.10@.?0:29.<0.>7/?;- :<492:/;:<7.'4:?B873>.17834393:034/03<7/72341.> 9.;@3<0:7/.< .1 0''$" ?<43> 783 83:4 .1 A2.00 .1 @:>3<7:29.<0.>7/?;- ' 8?078392:/;:<70:>33<7/72347.7831.22.=/<B 9.;@3<0:7/.<( $%&'()*+','-&. -+&.&'*&)-( $,'*+' /(0 .00.143@3<43<96 & $" ?<3>:23F@3<030 )$" .00.1307:73 )$" .00.10@.?0:2 9.<0.>7/?; ''$" .00.1:>3<7:2 9.<0.>7/?; ''$" .00.1/2/:29.<0.>7/?; !''F# $" *)1 22
<783>30?27=3@:007831.22.=/<B+
- 13 -
!/# .78783:@@3:20:>3%&& '()*+,%-. !//# 83 D?4B;3<70 .1 783 2:/;0 >/5?<:2 /0 ;.4/1/34 !///# 83 92:/;:<70 :>3 3<7/7234 7. : 7.7:2 9.;@3<0:7/.< .1 0 $" :0 :B:/<07 0'$":=:>43456783>/5?<:2 !/C# 83 <0?>:<93 .;@:<6 /0 4/>39734 7. 43@.0/7 783 3<7/>3 9.;@3<0:7/.< :2.<B =/78 /<73>307:7)H@:1>.;7834:73.11/2/<B.1 78392:/;@37/7/.<7/227834:73.1>3:2/M:7/.< =/78/<:@3>/.4.10/F=33E01>.;7834:73.1 >393/@7.19.@6.178/0D?4B;3<7
3- /430 !"#
3- /5#!6 50 !"#
/07.(2.((