- 1 - !"# $ % & && '#( ) ! " #$ % &'## '$#"(" Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % ) '$"(" % (*(# " ! %%"+* "! % % &#( (("$ % , % , ! -./ 011203 ./ 4.325 67 8-2 011233098:30.;098 <952= 2:8.>9"+* "!>4>8>=2-.:32/:8"?$$:-03329@.9@8-2 A<5@;2980950B0=510//2550825&#(10//25678-2 29.>= .C.3 <5@2 095 553 0/0C0D03709 08 0/0C0D03709.9>(("$8>;>5.478-2/0.5 A<5@;29809529-09:28-2:>;129/08.>9 - 3 - 20=58-20=@<;298/>48-2320=925:><9/234>= 8-2 011233098 095 320=925 :><9/23 4>= =2/1>95298 > >8.:28>=2/1>95298>"./5./129/25B.8- * 9A<=25 :30.;098 0@25 ( 720=/ B>=D.9@ 0/ 306><=;28B.8-090::.5298>9(#(("$0954.325:30.; 128.8.>9 :30.;.9@ :>;129/08.>9 >4 /""(((((' B.8- .982=2/8 -2 8=.6<903 :>9/.52=.9@ 298.=2 2C.529:2 >9 =2:>=5 @=09825 /##+(' B.8- .982=2/8 08 8-2 =082 >4 &E4=>;8-25082>40B0=58.33=203.F08.>9 # @@=.2C25 67 8-2 /0.5 >=52= -2 1=242==25 09 011203 095 ;0.937 :>9829525 8-08128.8.>92= B0/ 20=9.9@ /((' 12= 507 -2 5>:8>= 0 25 8-2 5./06.3.87 0/ #(E6<88=.6<903-0/80D29>937"*E2B0/05;.8825 8> ->/1.803 >9 (#(*("$ 095 5./:-0=@25 >9 (?*("$ -2 0;><98 0B0=525 <952= C0=.></ -205/ 0=2 ;20@2= -2 :30.;098 /</80.925 4>33>B.9@ .9A<=.2/ "! %=0:8<=2 >4 =05.</<390/-0483248 !./130:254=0:8<=2:>;;<825>4 /-048>4=05.</095<390095 *!B./8>432484>=20=; 095>8-2=;<38.132@=.2C></.9A<=.2/>C2=-./298.=26>57 - 4 - -2 128.8.>92= 8-><@- /80825 8-08 -2 B0/ 20=9.9@ /((' 12= 507 -2 -0/ 9>8 4.325 097 .9:>;2 1=>>42;28B.8-090::.5298>9(#(*("$0950/12= 8-2@<.523.92/>40=9080D080822@032=C.:2/<8->=.87 -./9>8.>903.9:>;28>6280D290/ /""+('12=;>98- G# ./ 8-2 B><95 :2=8.4.:082 >:8>= .//<25 5./06.3.87:2=8.4.:08208G""20 258-25./06.3.87 0/#(E-2128.8.>92=B0/0@25"?720=/095;<38.13.2= 8> 62 80D29 0/ "$ >:8>= /80825 8-08 -2 B0/ 05;.8825 >9 (#(*("$ 095 -2 B0/ >12=0825 095 5./:-0=@25 >9 (?(*("$ -2 :30.;098 ./ -0C.9@ 52/8=<:8.>9>412=;09298.;10.=.9@>41>B2=>4;2;62=>4 A>.98095B20D92//095/8.4492//>4A>.980442:8.9@0:8.C.8.2/ >4 50.37 3.C.9@ 2 :099>8 5> 097 B>=D 095 :099>8 3.48 -20C7>6A2:8//<:-8-25./06.3.87>48-232483.;6B0/ 0 250/#(E-2=24>=2"*=5>4#(E:>;2/8>"*E -2 8=.6<903 -0/ =.@-837 80D29 5./06.3.87 095 .8 9225/ 9> .982=42=29:2-23>//>44<8<=220=9.9@:010:.87:>;2/8> /""+( ) " ) "$ ) "*E H * !!+, -2 - 5 - 8=.6<903 @=09825 *, 30D- 8>B0=5/ ;25.:03 2G129/2/ 095 .8 9225/ 9> .982=42=29:2 2 B0/ ->/1.803.F254>=06><8507/0953082=-28>>D8=208;298 0/09><8108.298-2=24>=2:>9/.52=.9@8-2>::<108.>9 908<=2 >4 .9A<=.2/ 12=.>5 >4 ->/1.803./08.>9 095 >8-2= =232C09840:8>=/8-./:><=84.95/.8=20/>906328>@=09809 0;><98 >4 *, 4>= 10.9 095 /<442=.9@ * , 4>= 3>// >4 0;29.8.2/ *, 4>= 8=09/1>=808.>92G8=09><=./-;298095088295098:-0=@2/ &-28=.6<90303/>@=09825*,4>=4<8<=2 ;25.:03 2G129/2/ 095 .8 9225/ 9> .982=42=29:2 -2 128.8.>92=;.@-89>8-0C208829525097>8-2=B>=D08320/8 4>= 0 12=.>5 >4 # ;>98-/ 29:2 3>// >4 .9:>;2 5<=.9@ 30.5<112=.>5@=09825./*+ , + -</ .9 033 :>;1>9298/ 0B0=525 67 8-./ :><=8 0=20/623>B - 6 - 29:2 8-2 011233098':30.;098 ./ 298.8325 4>= 8>803 :>;129/08.>9>4*-!+,03>9@B.8-.982=2/8088-2 =082 >4 &E 10 .9/8205 >4 /##+(' 0/ @=09825 67 8-28=.6<903 $ 98-2=2/<388-24>33>B.9@>=52=./10//25 . 11203./.910=8 0=8.:<30=/ ;><98 .9 / >//>44<8<=220=9.9@:010:.87 *??#( 25.:032G129/2/ "((((( 0.9095/<442=.9@ (((( >//>40;29.8.2/ ((( =09/1>=808.>9 ;25.:03 2G129/2/ 095 088295098 :-0=@2/ *(((( %<8<=2;25.:032G129/2/ (((( >// >4 .9:>;2 5<=.9@ 30.5 <1 12=.>5 #+((( ./0 -!+ - 7 - .. -2 A<5@;298 095 0B0=5 10//25 50825 (&(#( 10//25 67 8-2 29.>= .C.3 <5@2 095 553 0/0C0D03709 08 0/0C0D03709 .9 > (("$ ./ ;>5.4.25 ... -2 :30.;098 ./ 298.8325 8> 0 /<; >4 *-!+ 03>9@ B.8- .982=2/8 08 &E 104=>;8-25082>4128.8.>98.338-25082 >4 =203.F08.>9 .9/8205 >4 /##+(' @=09825678-28=.6<903 .C 2/1>95298 >9/<=09:2 >;1097 03=2057 521>/.825 8-2 0B0=525 0;><98 624>=28-28=.6<903 8-2=24>=2 ./5.=2:825 8> 521>/.8 8-2 29-09:25 :>;129/08.>9 >4 *! , 03>9@ B.8- .982=2/8 08 8-2 =082>4&E10B.8-.9>92;>98-4=>;8-2 5082>48-./>=52= - 8 - C 9 /<:- 521>/.8 :30.;098 ./ 12=;.8825 8> B.8-5=0B 8-2 298.=2 0;><98 03>9@ B.8- .982=2/80::=<25>98-2/0;2 *1, '& ( % ./8>"3>$