Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 64459 (KAR)
SUBHAS @ SUBHASHCHANDRA v. NAMADEV AND ANR
MFA/203642/2024 · 2025-10-09
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64459 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64459 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #$ "
#$ !$%! ""
&%' (
! "
#
$%&%''& !((( )*+))&,,"
Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
'
(
#(
$%&'# !((( )*+))&,,"
! ('-
#"
( ( #.*!#" (
(**&
)
,/
(
0 ( 0 0(
)
'.)')'' &+
'''(0
( ( 0
10
10 0
- 3 -
$ !10
"
234 566758 9:;7< 7=>3?: #.*!#" ?@ ?>?< 723=874 => #,&& !27<73:5@>7< <7@7<<7; >? 54 A>27 =>B" 254 C77: @387;CD>27=853E5:>C73:F5FF<37G7;CD>27H9;FE7:>5:; 5I5<;;5>7;'.'''65447;CD>277:3?< 3G3809;F7 J 0( 5:; ;;3>3?:58 ) 252569< 3:
?&+
'''5:;477K3:F7:25:=7E7:>?@=?E67:45>3?: ' (5=>4 F3G3:F <347 >? >27 @383:F ?@ >27 566758 C<37@8D 4>5>7; 5<7 >25> ?: '#''' 5> 5C?9> +* 6E >27 =853E5:> 5:; 234 @<37:; 5883K5<H9: I7<7 6<?=77;3:F ?: E?>?<=D=87 C75<3:F <7F34><5>3?: ?)**) )'+%'?:5>>3F9;9<>?7G5;9<F=<?44E53:<?5;:75< 5<7EE5 >7E687 27 =853E5:> I54 <3;3:F >27 E?>?<=D=87>>25>>3E75523:;<5?87<?H776C75<3:F <7F34><5>3?: ?)*+))&,, =5E7 @<?E C5=K 43;7 3: 5 <5425:;:7F83F7:>E5::7<5:;;5427;>27E?>?<=D=87?@ >27 =853E5:> 4 5 <7498> ?@ >27 5@?<7453; 5==3;7:> >27 =853E5:>494>53:7;F<37G?943:H9<3745:;I542?463>583L7;
- 4 -
* 27=853E5:>@387;567>3>3?:9:;7<7=>3?:#++ ?@>27=>477K3:F=?E67:45>3?:>I546875;7;>25>27 467:> 29F7 5E?9:> >?I5<;4 E7;3=58 7M67:474 =?:G7D5:=7=25<F747>=>I54@9<>27<6875;7;>25>>27 5==3;7:> ?==9<<7; 69<78D ?: 5==?9:> ?@ >27 <542 5:; :7F83F7:>;<3G3:F?@>27?@@7:;3:FG723=87CD3>4;<3G7<
: 47<G3=7 ?@ :?>3=7 <746?:;7:> ?# ;3; :?> 56675< 5:; 27:=7 >27D 5<7 685=7; 746?:;7:> ?' 56675<7; >2<?9F2 =?9:478 5:; @387; I<3>>7:
4>5>7E7:> ;7:D3:F >27 5G7<E7:>4 E5;7 3: >27 =853E 67>3>3?:
% :>27C5434?@>276875;3:F4?@>2765<>374>27
853E4<3C9:58@<5E7;>273449745:;>27<75@>7<<7=?<;7;
>27 7G3;7:=7 27 =853E5:> 3: ?<;7< >? 6<?G7 >27 =547 7M5E3:7; 23E478@ 54 )# 5883K5<H9: I54 7M5E3:7; 54 )' 5:; <23G5C545:5F?9;5 65>38 I54 7M5E3:7; 54 )* 5:; F?> 7M23C3>7; ;?=9E7:>4 :5E78D M# >? M#, : C7258@ ?@ <746?:;7:>4 3:463>7 ?@ F3G3:F 49@@3=37:>?66?<>9:3>374>27D25G7:?>87;5:D7G3;7:=7
- 5 -
+ 27
853E4 <3C9:58 CD >27 3E69F:7; H9;FE7:> 278;>25>>275==3;7:>>??K685=7?:
5==?9:> ?@ <542 5:; :7F83F7:> ;<3G3:F ?@ >27 ?@@7:;3:F G723=87 CD 3>4 ;<3G7< 54 5 <7498> ?@ I23=2 >27 =853E5:> 494>53:7;F<37G?943:H9<37427<3C9:5896?:=?:43;7<3:F >27?<585:;;?=9E7:>5<D7G3;7:=7685=7;C7@?<73>278; >25> >27 =853E5:> 34 7:>3>87;
>? =?E67:45>3?: ?@ 4+#,%+
) 58?:F I3>2 3:>7<74> 5> >27 <5>7 ?@ +/ 65 5:; ;3<7=>7; >27 :49<5:=7 ?E65:D >? ;76?43> >27 =?E67:45>3?: 5E?9:> 58?:F I3>2 3:>7<74> 73:F 5FF<37G7;>234566758254C77:@387;
. <3 3;<5E<7;;D 7:K5::5 5<5;;D 875<:7;
=?9:478 @?< >27 =853E5:> 254 <5347; >27 @?88?I3:F =?:>7:>3?:4
5" (3<4>8D >27 =853E5:> 254 7M5E3:7; < 23G5C545:5F?9;5 5>38 54 * 27 ;?=>?< 3: 234 7G3;7:=7 254 4>5>7; >25> >27 =853E5:> 254 49@@7<7; 62D43=58;345C383>D?@'./>?I2?87C?;D9>>27<3C9:58
- 6 -
254>5K7:>27I2?87C?;D;345C383>D5>%/I23=234?:>27 8?I7<43;7
C" 7=?:;8D 27 254 =?:>7:;7; >25> 5> >27 >3E7 ?@>275==3;7:>>27=853E5:>I5475<:3:F4*
)67< E?:>2545;<3G7<7254584?7M5E3:7;')7E68?D7< >?
74>5C8342 >25> E?:>28D 3:=?E7 ?@ >27 =853E5:> 34 4*
)27<3C9:582545447447;:?>3?:583:=?E7?@ >27 =853E5:> 54 4#.%
) 6E I23=2 34 ?: >27 8?I7< 43;7
=" 54>8D ;97 >? >27 5==3;7:> >27 =853E5:> 254 494>53:7; F<37G?94 3:H9<374 7 I54 ><75>7; 54 3:)65>37:> @?< 5 67<3?; ?@ :3:7 ;5D4 7 254 49@@7<7; 8?> ?@ 653:
;9<3:F >27 ><75>E7:> 5:; 254 >? 49@@7< >27 ;345C383>D >2<?9F2?9> 234 83@7 27 =?E67:45>3?: 5I5<;7; CD >27 <3C9:589:;7<>27275;4?@A653:5:;49@@7<3:F4BA8?44?@ 5E7:3>374B5:;?>27<3:=3;7:>587M67:4745<7?:>278?I7< 43;7 7:=7 27 254 4?9F2> @?< 7:25:=7E7:> ?@ =?E67:45>3?:CD588?I3:F>27566758
- 7 -
& : >27 ?>27< 25:; <3 9C542 588569< 875<:7;=?9:47856675<3:F@?<>27:49<5:=7 ?E65:D254 <5347;@?88?I3:F=?9:>7<=?:>7:>3?:4
5" (3<4>8D 7G7: >2?9F2 ;?=>?< 254 ;76?47; >25> =853E5:> 254 49@@7<7; './ ;345C383>D >? >27 I2?87 C?;D 43:=7 @<5=>9<74 5<7 <79:3>7; =?:43;7<3:F >27 5F7 5G?=5>3?: 5:; 3:H9<374 49@@7<7; CD >27 =853E5:> <3C9:58 254<3F2>8D5447447;I2?87C?;D;345C383>D54%/
C"7=?:;8D>27=853E5:>=853E4>25>27I5475<:3:F 4*
) 67< E?:>2 54 5 ;<3G7< 7M=76> 7M5E3:3:F ' 27 254 :?> 6<?;9=7; 5:D ;?=9E7:>4 >? 74>5C8342 2343:=?E7
=" 23<;8D =?:43;7<3:F >27 3:H9<374 494>53:7; CD >27 =853E5:> 5:; =?:43;7<3:F >27 5F7 5G?=5>3?: 5:;
3:H9<374 49@@7<7; CD >27 =853E5:> >27 =?E67:45>3?:
5I5<;7; CD >27 <3C9:58 9:;7< >27 275;4 ?@ A653: 5:;
49@@7<3:FB A8?44 ?@ 5E7:3>374B 5:; ?>27< 3:=3;7:>58 275;4 5<7H94>5:;<754?:5C877:=7274?9F2>@?<;34E34458?@ >27566758
- 8 -
, 75<; >27 875<:7; =?9:478 @?< >27 65<>374 5:; 67<947;>27H9;FE7:>5:;5I5<;?@>27<3C9:58
# > 34 :?> 3: ;3469>7 >25> >27 =853E5:> 254 49@@7<7; 3:H9<D 3: 5 <?5; ><5@@3= 5==3;7:> ?==9<<7; ?: '#''';97>?<5425:;:7F83F7:>;<3G3:F?@;<3G7<?@ >27 523:;<5 ?87<? H776 C75<3:F <7F34><5>3?: ?)*+) )&,, 97 >? >27 5C?G7 5==3;7:> >27 =853E5:> 254 49@@7<7;>27@?88?I3:F3:H9<374)
## 27=853E5:>2547M5E3:7;>27;?=>?<54* I2?><75>7;23E27;?=>?<3:2347G3;7:=7;76?47;>25> >27=853E5:>25449@@7<7;'./62D43=58;345C383>D>?I2?87 C?;D ?:43;7<3:F >27 7G3;7:=7 ?@ ;?=>?< 5:; 3:H9<374 49@@7<7;CD>27=853E5:>I75<7?@>27?63:3?:>25>I2?87 C?;D;345C383>D=5:C75447447;5>#/
- 9 -
#' G7:>2?9F2=853E5:>254=853E7;>25>27I54 75<:3:F 4*
) 67< E?:>2 54 5 ;<3G7< 27 254 7M5E3:7; ' >? 74>5C8342 >25> 27 I54 65D3:F 4*
)67<E?:>25454585<D7254:?>6<?;9=7;
5:D ;?=9E7:>4 ?< C5:K 4>5>7E7:> >?
42?I >25> 27 I54 F7>>3:F E?:>28D 4585<D ?@ 4*
) 27 5==3;7:> ?==9<<7; 3: >27 =547 ?: 25:; 34 ?@ >27 D75< ''' 27<7@?<7 <3C9:58 254 <3F2>8D 5447447; >27 :?>3?:58 3:=?E7 ?@ >27 =853E5:> 5> 4#.%
) 54 67< >27 =25<> 6<765<7; CD >27 ?:BC87 5<:5>5K5 >5>7 7F58 7<G3=7 9>2?<3>D ==?<;3:F8D E?:>28D 3:=?E7 ?@ >27 =853E5:> 254 C77:=?:43;7<7;27 E98>36837< 56683=5C87>? 234 5F7 F<?96 34 #% ==?<;3:F8D 8?44 ?@ @9>9<7 3:=?E7 254 C77: <75447447;54@?88?I4) 4#.%
)M#'M#%M#
#N4'+%%
)
#* 97>? >27 5==3;7:> >27=853E5:>254 49@@7<7;
>27 5C?G7 453; 3:H9<374 5:; C7=5947 ?@ I23=2 27 I54 5;E3>>7; >? 2?463>5854 5: 3:)65>37:> @?<567<3?;?@ :3:7 ;5D4 27 254 49@@7<7; >2<77 @<5=>9<74 ?:43;7<3:F >27
- 10 -
7G3;7:=7?@;?=>?<3:H9<37449@@7<7;CD>27=853E5:>5:; E7;3=58<7=?<;4I75<7?@>27=?:43;7<7;?63:3?:>25>>27 =?E67:45>3?: 5I5<;7; CD >27 <3C9:58 9:;7< >27 275;
A653:5:;49@@7<3:FB254>?C77:25:=7;@<?E4%
) >?4. )?44?@5E7:3>374254>?C77:25:=7;@<?E 4*
)>?4
)
# 27 =?E67:45>3?: 5I5<;7; CD >27 <3C9:58 9:;7<?>27<275;45<7H94>5:;<754?:5C87
#% 27 =?E69>5>3?:?@ =?E67:45>3?: 34 54 9:;7<
53:5:;49@@7<3:F 4%
)
4. ) ?44?@5E7:3>374?@83@7 4*
) 4
) >>7:;5:>4=25<F74 4'%
) 4'%
) 67=358@??; 4#%
) 4#%
) 7;3=587M67:474 4#',%+
) 4#',%+
) ?44?@@9>9<73:=?E7 4#*'.%
) 4'+%%
) ?44?@3:=?E7;9<3:F ><75>E7:>67<3?; 4'%
) 4'%
)
?:G7D5:=7588?I5:=7 4#%
) 4#%
) (9>9<7E7;3=587M67:474 4'%
) 4'%
) )*+ ,-
. , /. 01*023430) ,- /. - 11 -
#+ :>27<7498>I76544>27@?88?I3:F
5" 2756675834
C" 27 H9;FE7:> 5:; 5I5<; 65447; CD >27
853E4<3C9:5834E?;3@37;
=" 27 =853E5:> 34 7:>3>87; >? 5 >?>58 =?E67:45>3?: ?@ 4+'.+
) 54 5F53:4> 4+#,%+
)5I5<;7;CD>27<3C9:585:;
7:25:=7; =?E67:45>3?: ?@ 4#+'.%
) 58?:F I3>2 3:>7<74> 5> >27 <5>7 ?@ +/ 67< 5::9E ;" 27746?:;7:>?'):49<5:=7 ?E65:D 34 ;3<7=>7; >? ;76?43> >27 7:25:=7;
=?E67:45>3?: 5E?9:> 58?:F I3>2 3:>7<74> @<?E>27;5>7?@@383:F?@>27=853E67>3>3?: >388>27;5>7?@<7583L5>3?:I3>23:567<3?;?@ 43MI77K4@<?E>27;5>7?@<7=736>?@5=?6D ?@>234H9;FE7:>
- 12 -
7" 27 ;76?43> 5:; <787547 ?@ 7:25:=7;
=?E67:45>3?: 42588 C7 54 67< >27 ?<;7< ?@ >27<3C9:58
5. &" ' $
5. &!$%!' $
34>?#8?#'