Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 64452 (KAR)

SMT. SEETABAI W/O DEELIP WANKODE v. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER

WP/201132/2022 · 2025-09-12

Jyoti Mulimani

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !" #!$$ !! %& ! "#$ % ! & '( ) Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - *++*,-./0 12345,6 24 7,0.68 28 -/./4. 0+9.:2;+-./0 82* /0, <,/+/+24,* .4= *+0,50.=*+ %.+50.4>.* 82* /0, *,5<24=,4/ 0.9, .<<,.*,= +4 <,*524 0,7*+,88.1/5.*,/0,5,) / +5 5/./,= /0./ /0, <,/+/+24,* +5 /0, 2?4,* 28 /0, 6.4= 7,.*+4; :2& -,.53*+4; /2 .4 ,@/,4/ 28 $A 1*,5 34/.5 5+/3./,= ./ 0.+> 2B. +66.;, .63> .4= +5/*+1/ .6.73*.;+ /+55/./,=/0.//0,<,/+/+24,*7,+4;/0,2?4,*+4 <255,55+24.4=+4136/+9./+2428/0,6.4=-.=,.4.<<6+1./+24 7,82*, /0, ,<3/: 2--+55+24,* .6.73*.;+ +5/*+1/ 82* 1249,*5+24 28 0+5 6.4= 8*2- .;*+136/3*.6 /2 424".;*+136/3*.6 *,5+=,4/+.6<3*<25,24$$$0, ,<3/: 2--+55+24,* .6.73*.;+ .8/,* . 6.<5, 28 /+-, <*,51*+7,= 34=,* /0, .*4./.>..4=,9,43,1/24$$A$0.5*,C,1/,=/0, .<<6+1./+24 /+5/0+5*,C,1/+242*=,*/0./+51.66,=+4/2D3,5/+24 +4 /0+5 *+/ ,/+/+24 24 5,9,*.6 ;*234=5 .5 5,/ 23/ +4 /0, -,-2*.4=3-28 *+/,/+/+24 - 3 - E 2345,6 82* /0, <,/+/+24,* .4= 82* /0, *,5<24=,4/0.9,3*;,=5,9,*.6124/,4/+245 2345,6 82* /0, <,/+/+24,* +4 <*,5,4/+4; 0+5 .*;3-,4/5 5/*,432356:3*;,=/0.//0, ,<3/: 2--+55+24,*+5*,D3+*,=/2 1245+=,* /0, .<<6+1./+24 ?+/0+4 /0+*/: =.:5 8*2- /0, =./, 28 *,1,+</ 28 /0, .<<6+1./+24 , .*;3,= 7: 5.:+4; /0./ +4 /0, <*,5,4/ 1.5, /0, ,<3/: 2--+55+24,* 0.5 42/ /.>,4 .4: =,1+5+24*,;.*=+4;/0,.<<6+1./+24?+/0+4.<,*+2=28/0+*/:=.:5 : ?.: 28 *,<6: /2 /0+5 124/,4/+24 C35/+8+,= /0, .1/+2428/0, ,<3/: 2--+55+24,*,.*;3,=7:5.:+4;/0./ /0,*,+5.4.6/,*4./+9,.4=,88+1.1+235*,-,=:.9.+6.76,/2/0, <,/+/+24,* , 9,0,-,4/6: 124/,4=,= /0./ /0,*, +5 42 7.* 82* /0, ,<3/: 2--+55+24,*/2*,C,1//0,<*.:,*7,:24=/0,/+-, 8+@,=34=,*/0,*,6,9.4/<*29+5+24528/0,1/112*=+4;6:0, 537-+/5/0.//0,<,/+/+24+5=,92+=28-,*+/5.4=/0,5.-,-.: 7,=+5-+55,= A ,.*=/0,.*;3-,4/5.4=<,*35,=/0, *+/<.<,*5 ?+/03/-25/1.*, - 4 - 0,+553,*,9269,5.*234=/0,.<<6+1./+24537-+//,= 7:/0,<,/+/+24,*82*1249,*5+2428/0,6.4= /+542/+4=+5<3/, /0./ /0, <,/+/+24,* -29,= .4 .<<6+1./+24 82* 1249,*5+24 24 $$$ 5 <,* /0, .*4./.>. .4= ,9,43, ,124= -,4=-,4/! 1/ $ ,1/+24 F 28 /0, .*4./.>. .4= ,9,43,1/+5.-,4=,=5<,*/0,.-,4=-,4/.=3/:1.5/5 24/0, ,<3/: 2--+55+24,*/2;+9,0+5=,1+5+24.4=+553,/0, 2*=,*?+/0+4.<,*+2=28/0+*/:=.:58*2-/0,=./,28*,1,+</28 /0, .<<6+1./+24 4 /0, <*,5,4/ 1.5, .4 ,4=2*5,-,4/ 2*=,* +5 +553,= 24 $$A$ +, 7,:24= /0, <,*+2= 28 /0+*/: =.:5 8*2-/0,=./,28*,1,+</28/0,.<<6+1./+24 /+5<+92/.6/242/,/0./+8/0, ,<3/: 2--+55+24,*8.+65 /2;+9,0+5=,1+5+24.4=+553,/0,2*=,*?+/0+4/0+*/:=.:58*2- /0,=./,28*,1,+</28/0,.<<6+1./+24/0,.<<*29.682*=+9,*5+24 82* 35, 50.66 =,,-,= /2 0.9, 7,,4 ;*.4/,= 7: /0, ,<3/: 2--+55+24,*.4=/0,5.-,50.667,1,*/+8+,=.4=+553,=+4/0, -.//,* .5 -.: 7, <*,51*+7,= 537C,1/ /2 <.:-,4/ 28 8,, <*,51*+7,= 34=,* 537"5,1/+24 ! 0,*,82*, /0, <,/+/+24,* +5 0,6= /2 7, ,4/+/6,= /2 /0, 7,4,8+/ 28 =,,-,= 1249,*5+24 +4 *,5<,1/ 28 /0, 537C,1/ 6.4= 7,.*+4; :2& 5+/3./,= ./ 0.+>2B.+66.;,.63>.4= +5/*+1/.6.73*.;+ - 5 - 2*/0,*,.52455/./,=.729,/0,,4=2*5,-,4/+553,=7: /0, *,5<24=,4/ +5 6+.76, /2 7, D3.50,= 112*=+4;6: +/ +5 D3.50,= & 0, *+/28 ,*/+2*.*++52*=,*,=0,,4=2*5,-,4/ =./,= $$A$ +553,= 7: /0, *,5<24=,4/" ,<3/: 2--+55+24,*.6.73*.;+9+=,44,@3*,"+5D3.50,= 0, 3/02*+/: 1241,*4,= +5 =+*,1/,= /2 ,88,1/ 1249,*5+24 .4=+553,1249,*5+241,*/+8+1./,+48.92*28/0,<,/+/+24,*.8/,* *,1,+</284,1,55.*:10.*;,582*53101249,*5+24+4.112*=.41, ?+/0/0,6.??+/0+4.<,*+2=28/0*,,-24/058*2-/0,=./,28 *,1,+</28/0,1,*/+8+,=12<:28/0+52*=,* ,536/.4/6:/0, *+/,/+/+24+5 '( %$ !!& $ +5/2)62)