- 1 - ! " # $ $$ %&' ( ! " # $ % & % ' ( (( "" ) % ! % % (( ! # Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ % %( * % & ( ("$& (% & ( & ( ' " % ! ( ( ( %' ( + ( ' , ( ' % - - .' # /012 34/ 01567/839 :; </018/2 =:689/< ;:1 >:34 34/ ?013@/9 4@90??/0<@9;@</2050@89334/0A012:;34/1@>680< @8 % :!! 203/2 " ?099/2 >B 34/ 22@3@:80</8@:1@C@<'625/082/7>/1 0<0>6105@ " 4/ ;0=39 :; 34/ =09/ 01/ 3403 :8 ) 03 0>:63 A4/8 34/ ?/3@3@:8/1 >/@85 34/ ?@<<@:8 1@2/1 0<:85A@344@9;1@/82 @D4@<>/@8534/1@2/1A09?1:=//2@85:8 7:3:1=B=</ >/01@85 1/5@93103@:8 : "%"! 3: 5: 3: :38::1$2&%@<<05/:86<>0150'/A015@1:028/0107082@1 - 3 - @3B 69 93082 0 0163@ 9A@;3 01 >/01@85 1/5@93103@:8 : "" =07/ ;1:7 :??:9@3/ 2@1/=3@:8 @8 1094 082 8/5<@5/83 7088/1 A@34 4@54 9?//2 082 2094/2 3: 34/ 7:3:1=B=</ :; @D4@< 26/ 3: A4@=4 4/ 96930@8/2 51@/C:69 @8E61@/94/1/0;3/14/A0994@;3/23:10701/22B:9?@30< 0<0>6105@ A4/1/@8 4/ A09 @8?03@/83 ;:1 7:1/ 3408 20B9 082@8==61/293:A012931/037/83 8E61/2=<0@7083 ;@</2 0 =<0@7 0??<@=03@:8 =<0@7@85 =:7?/8903@:8:;94/1@>680<=:89@2/1@8534/ /83@1/ 703/1@0< :8 1/=:12 51083/2 9 ! 0<:85 A@34 @83/1/930334/103/:;)F?/108867;1:734/203/:;?/3@3@:8 3@<<34/203/:;1/0<@G03@:8 551@/C/2>B 34/ 90@2 E6257/83 4/ ?1/;/11/2 34@9 0??/0<A4/1/@8@3@9=:83/82/2340334/0??/<<083A09A:1D@85 @80/2@=0<3:1/082/018@859?/17:834>634@9 @8=:7/ A09 8:3 =:89@2/1/2 082 4/ ;6134/1 9303/2 3403 8: 07:683 A09 51083/2 3:A0129 0@8 082 6;;/1@85 (::2 082 =:8C/B08=/ =4015/9 :99 :; 8=:7/ 261@85 1/037/83 /1@:2 082 :99 :; 7/8@3@/9 63 :8<B 0 5<:>0< =:7?/8903@:8 :; - 4 - 9 ! @9 51083/2 A4@=4 1/H6@1/9 @83/1;/1/8=/ 082 1/H6/93/2;:1/8408=/7/830823:0<<:A34/0??/0< ) 27@33/2<B 09 ?/1 I) J :682 /13@;@=03/ 34/ ?/3@3@:8/196930@8/2682@9?<0=/2;10=361/:;;1:830<>:8/A4@=4 @951@/C:69@880361/0824/96930@8/276<3@?</0>109@:89:C/1 ;0=/8/=D94:6<2/134@54082:34/1?0139:;4@9>:2B3A09 7/83@:8/2 3403 34/1/ A09?0@8 08296;;/1@85 26/ 3: A4@=44/ A09 680></ 3: 7:C/ 1@543 </5 >63 4/ 409 8:3 /I07@8/2 34/ :=3:1:18:2@90>@<@3BA09099/99/294:A@8551@/C:69@8E61@/9 4/1/;:1/ =:89@2/1@85 34/ 80361/ :; 34/ @8E61@/9 34/ 1@>680< 409 51083/2 9" 09 0 5<:>0< =:7?/8903@:8 082 9)!! 3:A0129 7/2@=0< /I?/89/9 :8 34/ >09@9 :; 34/ /2@=0<@<<903I!0829:0<9:93:A0129033/82083 =4015/9/A094:9?@30<@G/2;:10?/1@:2:;341//20B9 ==:12@85<B =:89@2/1@85 34/ =:83/83@:89 :; 34/ =<0@70830??/<<083 34@9 :613 ;@829 C0<@2 1/09:89 @8 34/ 01567/839082;//<93:1/099/9934/=:7?/8903@:8 ! 8 C@/A :; 34/ 907/ 34@9 :613 510839 9 3:A0129 ?0@8 082 96;;/1@85 9 3:A0129 <:99 :; 07/8@3@/9 082 9 3:A0129 1089?:13 082 I310 - 5 - :61@947/83 =4015/9 8 3:30< 34/ =<0@7083 @9 /83@3</2 ;:1 /8408=/2 =:7?/8903@:8 :; )*+ A4@=4 A:6<2 =:7/9 3:3:30<=:7?/8903@:8:;), -+$9" K"!K )& 8 0<< 34/ 3:30< =:7?/8903@:8 A:6<2 =:7/9 3: 9! A@34 @83/1/93 03 )F ?/1 08867 ;1:7 34/ 203/ :; ?/3@3@:83@<<34/203/:;1/0<@G03@:8 834/1/96<334/;:<<:A@85:12/1@9?099/2- @& 4/0??/0<@9 @@& 4/ =<0@7083 @9 /83@3</2 ;:1 34/ 3:30< =:7?/8903@:8 :; 9! A@34 @83/1/93 03 )F ?/1 08867 ;1:7 34/ 203/ :; ?/3@3@:8 3@<< 1/0<@G03@:8 @@@& 4/ 1/9?:82/83 : J 896108=/ :7?08B 0<1/02B 2/?:9@3/2 34/ =:7?/8903@:8 0A012/2 >B 34/ 1@>680< 4/1/;:1/ 1/9?:82/83 : @92@1/=3/23:9 A@34@83/1/930334/ 103/:;)F?/108867A@34@8:8/7:834;1:7 34/203/:;:12/1 - 6 - @C& 896=42/?:9@334/0??/<<083@9?/17@33/23: A@34210A 34/ /83@1/ 07:683 0<:85 A@34 @83/1/930==16/2:8@3 .+ %$ ' # @93 :-< :-! -'