- 1 - ! "#$## #%% &' &(%)* &)) + ! " " # $ % $&'" ($$ ) $ %* Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - + #$ $$$ %,++ &' ($ ) $* $$+ -)*+$ $ +% + && $ . % $ " ! $$ + + ++ $$ + + % . $# )$ . * /01220331456708491::;60<=65="14<5= 84 =" =4 5/0 >830 => 301?40< <<858=413 865?8:5 14< 0668=46 ;<90 %8@1A12;? )>=? 6/=?5 B?813 =;?5,* 1?0 8C2;94849 5/0 @;<9C045 => :=4D8:58=4 14< - 3 - =?<0? => 604504:0 <150< :=4D8:5849 5/0C >=? 5/0 =>>04:06 2;486/1730 ;4<0? 0:58=46 - - - 14< " => 5/0 4<814 $0413 =<0 '")>=?6/=?5B$,*14<604504:8495/0C5=;4<0?9= )8* 8C230 8C2?86=4C045 >=? C=45/ 14< 5= 21A >840 => 6 & >=? 5/0 =>>04:0 2;486/1730 ;4<0? 60:58=4 => $ 84 <0>1;35 => 21AC045 => >840 >;?5/0? 5/0A 6/=;3<;4<0?9=68C2308C2?86=4C045>=?-<1A6E )88* 8C2308C2?86=4C045>=?A01?14<5=21A>840 =>6 &>=?5/0=>>04:02;486/1730;4<0?60:58=4- => $ 84 <0>1;35 => 21AC045 => >840 >;?5/0? 5/0A 6/=;3< ;4<0?9=>=?>=?C=45/6E )888* 8C230 8C2?86=4C045 >=? " C=45/6 14< 5= 21A >840 => 6 & >=? 5/0 =>>04:0 2;486/1730 ;4<0? 60:58=4 => $ 84 <0>1;35 => 21AC045 => >840 >;?5/0? 5/0A 6/=;3<;4<0?9=68C2308C2?86=4C045>=?C=45/E - 4 - )8D* 8C2308C2?86=4C045>=?A01?14<5=21A>840 =>6 &>=?5/0=>>04:02;486/1730;4<0?60:58=4 => $ 84 <0>1;35 => 21AC045 => >840 >;?5/0? 5/0A 6/=;3< ;4<0?9=68C2308C2?86=4C045>=?C=45/6E )D*8C2308C2?86=4C045>=?"C=45/14<5=21A>840 =>6 &>=?5/0=>>04:02;486/1730;4<0?60:58=4-=> $ 84 <0>1;35 => 21AC045 => >840 >;?5/0? 5/0A 6/=;3< ;4<0?9=68C2308C2?86=4C045>=?C=45/E )D8* 8C230 8C2?86=4C045 >=? C=45/ 14< 5= 21A >840 => 6 & >=? 5/0 =>>04:0 2;486/1730 ;4<0? 60:58=4 - => $ 84 <0>1;35 => 21AC045 => >840 >;?5/0? 5/0A 6/=;3<;4<0?9=68C2308C2?86=4C045>=?-<1A6E )D88* 8C230 8C2?86=4C045 >=? C=45/ 14< 5= 21A >840 => 6 & >=? 5/0 =>>04:0 2;486/1730 ;4<0? 60:58=4 => $ 84 <0>1;35 => 21AC045 => >840 >;?5/0? 5/0A 6/=;3<;4<0?9=68C2308C2?86=4C045>=?<1A614< - 5 - )D888*8C230 8C2?86=4C045 >=? " C=45/ 14< 5= 21A >840 => 6 & >=? 5/0 =>>04:0 2;486/1730 ;4<0? 60:58=4 " => $ 84 <0>1;35 => 21AC045 => >840 >;?5/0? 5/0A 6/=;3<;4<0?9=68C2308C2?86=4C045>=?<1A6 01?< ?8 1C1<12;? 301?40< :=;4603 >=? 5/0122033145614<?8 1C1<1?/1/17;<<84301?40< 89/ =;?5 =D0?4C045 $301<0? >=? 5/0 ?062=4<045 & 5150 $0?;60<5/0C150?8136=4?0:=?< 4 D80F => 5/0 ?8D13 :=450458=46 ;?90< 7A 301?40<:=;4603>=?5/021?58065/02=8455/15F=;3<1?860 >=?CA:=468<0?158=486 A 146F0? 5= 5/0 17=D0 2=845 86 B ,>=?5/0>=33=F849 - 6 - /01220331456/1D0?1860<60D0?139?=;4<6>=? 8C2;94849 5/0 @;<9C045 => :=4D8:58=4 14< =?<0? => 604504:0 21660< 7A 5/0 ?813 =;?5 01?40< :=;4603 >=? 5/0 1220331456 15 5/0 58C0 => 1<<?066849 5/0 1?9;C0456 :=4>840</861?9;C045=43A5=600G304804:A84604504:849 5/01::;60</0301?40<:=;4603/164=51<<?0660<14A 1?9;C045 5= :/1330490 5/0 8C2;940< @;<9C045 => :=4D8:58=4 =F0D0?/0:=4504<0<5/15$865/0=43A 84@;?0< F/= 6;651840< =40 9?80D=;6 84@;?A 7;5 4= H&?1A F16 2?=<;:0< 5= 6/=F 5/15 /0 /16 6;>>0?0< >?1:5;?0 H$"865/0F=;4<:0?58>8:15020?51848495=$H$-86 20?51848495=$"14<H$'8620?51848495=$H$ 865/0F=;4<:0?58>8:15020?51848495=5/084@;?0<F/=F16 4=5 0H1C840< 70>=?0 5/0 =;?5 6 20? 5/060 F=;4< :0?58>8:15065/084@;?0</1D06;651840<=43A68C23084@;?806 =4 5/0 <150 => 5/0 84:8<045 5/15 =::;??0< =4 14<5/0?0>=?0/02?1A6>=?6/=F849304804:A84604504:849 5/01::;60< - 7 - 5 86 5/0 :=450458=4 => 5/0 2?=60:;58=4 5/15 1::;60< /1D0 :=CC8550< 5/0 =>>04:06 2;486/1730 ;4<0? 0:58=46-'---14< " => $ 4 133 1::;60< F0?0 :/1?90 6/0050< 14< 5/0AF0?05?80<::;60<=6-14</1D0<80<14< 5/0:16019184655/0C8617150< " /0 2?=60:;58=4 /16 0H1C840< $ 5= $ 14<9=5C1?G0<H6$5=$14<8<0458>80<65= /084>=?C145&$865/00A0F854066$$14< $" 1?0 5/0 84@;?0< 0A0F85406606 14< 5/0A /1D0 6;22=?50< 5/0 :160 => 5/0 2?=60:;58=4 $- 86 5/0 =:5=? F/= 5?0150< 5/0 84@;?0< 0A0F85406606 14< 866;0< F=;4<:0?58>8:15061620?H6$"5=$ - =468<0?8495/0=?1314<<=:;C0451?A0D8<04:0 231:0<=4?0:=?<7A5/02?=60:;58=41C=>5/0=2848=4 5/15 5/0 2?=60:;58=4 86 6;::066>;3 84 2?=D849 5/0 9;835 => 1::;60< =6 5= " 14< 5= >=? 5/0 =>>04:06 2;486/1730;4<0?0:58=46-- - 8 - - 14< " => $ 70A=4< ?016=41730 <=;75 14< 5/0?0>=?05/0A1?03817305=70:=4D8:50< ' /1D09=405/?=;9/5/08C2;940<@;<9C045=> :=4D8:58=4 21660< 7A 5/0 ?813 =;?5 5 /16 :=4D8:50< 5/060 1220331456 >=? 5/0 17=D0 618< =>>04:06 14< 604504:0< 16 65150< 17=D0 <= 4=5 >84< 14A ?016=4 5= 8450?>0?0 F85/ 5/0 @;<9C045 => :=4D8:58=4 21660< 7A 5/0 ?813 =;?5 /830 604504:849 5/0 1220331456 1::;60< >=? 5/0 =>>04:06 2;486/1730 ;4<0? 0:58=46 14< - => $5/0A 1?0 604504:0< 5= ;4<0?9= 68C230 8C2?86=4C045 >=?120?8=<=>=40A01?01:/F85/<0>1;35604504:0+=? 5/0 =>>04:0 2;486/1730 ;4<0? 0:58=46 - " => $5/0AF0?0604504:0<5=;4<0?9=68C2308C2?86=4C045 >=?120?8=<=>68HC=45/601:/F85/<0>1;35604504:0+=? 5/0 =>>04:0 2;486/1730 ;4<0? 0:58=46 => $ 5/0A F0?0 604504:0< 5= ;4<0?9= 68C230 8C2?86=4C045 >=? 1 20?8=< => 5/?00 C=45/6 F85/ <0>1;35 604504:0 +=? 5/0 =>>04:06 2;486/1730 ;4<0? 0:58=46 14< - => $ - 9 - 5/0AF0?0604504:0<5=;4<0?9=68C2308C2?86=4C045>=? 120?8=<=>=40C=45/01:/ =40 => 5/060 =>>04:06 1?0 2;486/1730 :=C2;36=?83A F85/ 6;7651458D0 604504:0 =468<0?849 5/0 >1:5 5/15 0D04 5/=;9/ 5/0 :/1?90 6/005 :1C0 5= 70 >830< 1918465 1::;60< =6 5= 14< 5/060 1220331456 F0?0 :=4D8:50< >=? :1;6849 84@;?806 5= $ $ 14< $" 304804:A C1A 70 6/=F4 F/830 604504:849 5/0 5/0 1220331456 1::;60<=65="14<5=::=?<8493A 146F0?5/0 17=D0 2=845 14< 2?=:00<5=21665/0>=33=F849 )8* /0:?8C841312201386 )88* /0 @;<9C045 => :=4D8:58=4 <150< 21660< 84 0668=46 160 =" 7A 5/0 301?40< <<858=413 865?8:514<0668=46 ;<90%8@1A12;?>=?5/0 =>>04:062;486/1730;4<0?0:58=46- - 10 - - - 14< " => $ 86 /0?07A:=4>8?C0< )888* /0 =?<0? => 604504:0 21660< 7A 5/0 ?813 =;?586C=<8>80<16;4<0? )1* /0 1220331456 ::;60< =6 5= " 14<5=1?0604504:0<5=21A >840 => 6 & 01:/ >=? 5/0 =>>04:0 2;486/1730 ;4<0? 0:58=4 => $ 14< 84 <0>1;35 5= 21A >840 5/0A 6/133 ;4<0?9= 68C230 8C2?86=4C045 >=? 1 20?8=< => C=45/6 )7* +=? 5/0 =>>04:06 2;486/1730 ;4<0? 0:58=46 - - - 14< " 5/0 1220331456 1::;60< =6 5= " 14< 5=1?0604504:0<5=21A>840 => 6 & 01:/ >=? 01:/ => 5/0 =>>04:0614<84<0>1;35=>21AC045 => >840 5/0A 6/133 ;4<0?9= 68C230 8C2?86=4C045 >=? 1 20?8=< => <1A6 - 11 - ;5 => 5/0 >840 1C=;45 5= 70 <02=6850< 7A 5/0 1::;60<16;C=>6 &5=70218<5=5/084@;?0<I $14<16;C =>6 &01:/5=70218<5=$ 14<$" 09865?A 5= 604< 71:G 5/0 ?813 =;?5 ?0:=?<6 13=49 F85/ :=2A => 5/86 @;<9C045 >=? 84>=?C158=4 14< 400<>;3 1:58=4 ,* &##) $ 865=3=' $