Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 64449 (KAR)
FARIZUDDIN @ FARIDDUDDIN v. GANESH AND ORS
MFA/201337/2023 · 2025-10-30
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64449 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64449 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$
$$
%& '( $$ )
%&
'
(
! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
"
#$% &
'"
' #()*&
%
%* #
*'" #()*&
*
% #
+'" #()*&
(
' %% #
*'" #()*&
+
* #
+'" #()*&
$
% ,
- 3 -
"'' #()*&
)
! , ' #()*&
! , ' #()*&
&
' #()*&
' #()*&
- #&$& & ( "
%&
& &
. & &+
- 4 -
)'
(
! '
"
'"
' #()*&
%( #
*'" #()*&
%
% #
- 5 -
+'" #()*&
*
' %* #
* '" #()*&
(
* #
+'" #()*&
+
% ,
"'' #()*&
$
! , ' #()*&
)
, ' #()*&
! - 6 -
' #()*&
&
' #()*&
'
#()(&
- # (&% & ( "
%&
"
& & & &+
"
/
/ 0
- 7 -
#
12 3 &(* & % 45 64728 9: ;12 <7=4>=?; =?8 ;12 3 &%%$ & % 45 64728 9: ;12 ?5@A=?<2 3>B=?: =C=4?5; ;12 D@8C>2?; =?8 =E=A8 8=;28 & & B=5528 4? 3 &+ 9: ;12 3>>45543?2A 63A >B73:22.5 3>B2?5=;43? =?8 2?43A 4F47@8C2=8C4A463A513A;G 3>>45543?2A. A4266=<;536;12<=52=A2=5@?82A/
12 4?D@A28<7=4>=?; =C28 % :2=A5 924?C = 5H47728 7=93@A 834?C 272<;A4<=7 E3AH 1=5 6=772? 6A3> ;12 124C1; 3? && & =?8 5@5;=4?28 CA42F3@5 4?D@A4253?14512=86A=<;@A236726;1=?86A=<;@A236 A4C1; 72C 4?D@A425 ;3 93;1 2:25 =?8 >=D3A 5B4?=7 4?D@A: 2?<2 12 64728 <7=4> B2;4;43? 9263A2 ;12 3>>45543?2A 522H4?C <3>B2?5=;43? 36 5 &&&&&#E4;14?;2A25;=; *IB2A=??@>6A3> ;12 A25B3?82?;5
12 3>>45543?2A =6;2A <3?5482A4?C ;12 2?;4A2 >=;2A4=7 =F=47=972 3? A2<3A8
- 8 -
=E=A828 5(&$)*# E4;1 4?;2A25; =; ;12 A=;2 36 I B2A =??@> 6A3> ;12 8=;2 36 B2;4;43? ;477 4;5 2?;4A2A2=74J=;43? % CCA42F289:;125=48D@8C>2?;=?8=E=A8;12 ?5@A=?<2 3>B=?: BA262AA28 ;12 =BB2=7 >=4?7:
<3?;2?84?C;1=;=<<482?;E=53<<@AA283? && &=?8 ;1245=9474;: 2A;464<=;2E=5 455@283?+& & ;1@5 ;12A2 45 827=: 36 :2=A5 =?8 ;12 5=48 827=: E=5 ?3;
<3?5482A289:;12 3>>45543?2A;456@A;12A<3?;2?828 ;1=; ;12 3>>45543?2A <3>>4;;28 =? 2AA3A 4? =552554?C ;12845=9474;:=;+&IE4;13@;=?:A2=53?2F2?;13@C1;12 3<;3A1=5=5525528*&I845=9474;:12A263A2A2K@25;28 63A>38464<=;43?36;124>B@C?28D@8C>2?;9:<3?5482A4?C ;1263773E4?C5@95;=?;4=7K@25;43?5367=E/
- 9 -
! " #
$
#%
* 24?C=CCA42F285=>2D@8C>2?;=?8=E=A8;12 <7=4>=?;4?D@A28 1=5 BA262AA28 ;12 =BB2=7 4? 3 &%%$ & % <3?;2?84?C ;1=; 12 5@5;=4?28 &&I 845=9474;: 8@2 ;3 ;12 4?D@A425 5@5;=4?28 =?8 12 <=??3; =;;2?8145E3AH=?:>3A212A263A25@9>4;5;1=;&&I 845=9474;:;392<3?5482A2826@A;12A5;=;28;1=;12E=5 2=A?4?C 5&&&&# B2A >3?;1 =?8 ;1@5 A2K@25;28 63A >38464<=;43? 36 ;12 3A82A 3? ;12 63773E4?C 5@95;=?;4=7 K@25;43?5367=E/
&
'( )* ' ( )*
#
!
#
- 10 -
$
&
+ ! !#%
( 2=A8 ;12 72=A?28 <3@?5275 3? 93;1 ;12 54825 =?8B2A@528;12>=;2A4=75=F=47=9723?A2<3A8
+ 12A2 45 ?3 845B@;2 ;1=; ;12 <7=4>=?; E=5 = 5H47728 7=93@A 14A28 9: 2?52A 72<;A4<=7 3>B=?:
7=4>=?; 5;=;25 ;1=; 12 E=5 2=A?4?C 5&&&&# B2A >3?;1 9@; 12 1=5 ?3; 64728 =?: 83<@>2?; ;3 BA3F2 ;12 5=>22>2;E4;1=?=<<482?;3? && &L(M
"3@?8 2A;464<=;2E=539;=4?283? *&$ &=?8L+ M 45=9474;: 2A;464<=;2 E=5 39;=4?28 3? +& & =?8 ;12A2=53?563A827=:4?39;=4?4?C;1245=9474;: 2A;464<=;2 45?3;>2?;43?28=?:E12A25B2A"3@?8 2A;464<=;212 5@5;=4?28;1263773E4?CCA42F3@54?D@A425/ , -
. , /
- 11 -
0 1 '
, 1 '
$ , 2 & 2
1 ' 3 + 0 4
& %
$ ?5@BB3A;36145<3?;2?;43?<7=4>=?;2L=>4?28 ;12 3<;3A =5 " 3? +& & E13 =6;2A 2L=>4?4?C ;12 <7=4>=?; 455@28 45=9474;: 2A;464<=;2 =5 B2A L+ =552554?C *&I ;3 ;12 E1372 938: " 5;=;28 ;1=; ;12 <7=4>=?; A2K@4A25 =?3;12A 5@AC2A: 63A A2>3F=7 36 ;12 4>B7=?; 63A6A=<;@A236 726;1@>2A@5=?8 ;12 =BBA3L4>=;2 <35; 36 ;12 5@AC2A: 4?<7@84?C ;12 >284<=7 <35; E3@78 92 =A3@?85 &&&&#;35 (&&&#
- 12 -
) 12 ?5@A=?<2 3>B=?: 845B@;28 L( M
"3@?8 2A;464<=;2=?8=753L+M45=9474;: 2A;464<=;2=5 ;12: E2A2 ?3; 4? ;4>2 5 ;12 8=;2 36 4?<482?; 45 && &;124?<3>236;12<7=4>=?;45;392;=H2?=;
5)&&&#B2A>3?;1=5B2A;128=;28%&( && 4?5;2=8365+&&&#;=H2?9:;12 3>>45543?2A+&I36 5)&&&#<3>25;35+)&&#=?8;12A272F=?;6=<;3A45 %$ ! 2=A?28 <3@?527 63A ;12 <7=4>=?; 5;=;28 &&I 6@?<;43?=7 845=9474;: 45 ;3 92 ;=H2? "12A2=5 72=A?28 <3@?52763A;12?5@A=?<2 3>B=?:845B@;28;12845=9474;:
=5525528 9: ;12 3<;3A 63A ;12 A2=53? ;1=; 3<;3A E=5 2L=>4?28=6;2A=82<=8236;124?<482?;
& 123<;3A>284<=77:2L=>4?28;12<7=4>=?;3? +& & F2A46428 ;12 4?D@A425 5@5;=4?28 9: 14> 4? ;12 :2=A &=?8=5525528;12845=9474;:=;*&I
33H4?C;3 ;12 ?=;@A2 36 4?D@A425 =?8 B2A438 36 135B4;=74J=;43? ;145 3@A; 64?85 4; A2=53?=972 ;3 ;=H2 845=9474;: =; *&I =5
- 13 -
=55255289:;123<;3A1@5;12<3>B2?5=;43?;3E=A85 845=9474;:<3>25=5@?82A/ 5*)&&#L*&IL %$N5* (&%&#
12 3>>45543?2A =E=A828 5!& $# ;3E=A85 >284<=7 2LB2?525 =?8 =753 5 &&&&# 63A A2>3F=7 36 4>B7=?;59=54?C3?;122F482?<236" 1@5;12;3;=7 <3>B2?5=;43?<3>25;35*(*&($#
12 <3>B2?5=;43? =E=A828 9: ;12 3>>45543?2A 45 5(&$)*# =?8 4; 45 A28@<28 ;3 5*(*&($# % ?;12A25@7;;1263773E4?C3A82A45B=5528/ 4 3;1 ;12 =BB2=75 =A2
44 12 <7=4>=?; 45 2?;4;728 63A ;3;=7 <3>B2?5=;43?365*(*&($#E4;14?;2A25;=;
I B2A =??@> 6A3> ;12 8=;2 36 =<<482?; ;477 ;128=;236A2=74J=;43?
- 14 -
444 12 ?5@A=?<2 3>B=?: 45 84A2<;28 ;3 82B354; ;12 =63A25=48 <3>B2?5=;43? =>3@?;
=73?C E4;1 4?;2A25; E4;14? 3?2 >3?;1 6A3> ;12 8=;236;145D@8C>2?;
4F >3@?;
4? 82B354; 45 ;3 92 ;A=?5>4;;28;3;12<3?<2A?28 3@A; F ? 5@<1 82B354; ;12 <7=4>=?; 45 B2A>4;;28;3E4;18A=E;122?;4A2=>3@?;=73?C E4;14?;2A25;=<<A@283?4;
*+' %$& #
45;3/73/!! /