- 1 - !"#$ %#&## # '( ')*+ '** , ! " #$%$& ' ( ) & #$%& !( * '" Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - %' !" $'% ! " '%&+'&' , # &&)'&' , # -) ( ! " ( . ( ! . ( " /01 23404056 01 70839 :; <573115< 06 32=<4>364 57 1;?/0=4<; /=<@=9 61404A43 7 364=8 3=84/ =69 3A<51?036?31! "/=<@=9@/501=<<=;39=1= 1583 =??A139 06 <0>3 5)'&' 57 =<B34 =<9 580?3 4=4056=0?/A<75<4/357736?32A601/=:83A693<3?4056 -)57690=636=8593%+&236906C564/3708357<8 0D08(A9C3!<6"=69(5A<4=0?/A< ' 06?3 4/3 @<04436 ?5>28=064 859C39 :; 13?569 <312569364 /=1 ?A8>06=439 06 <3C014<=4056 57 ?<0>3 06 - 3 - <0>3 5)'&' 4/01 5A<4 933>1 04 704 45 3E4<=?4 4/3 ?5>28=064=694/31=>3<3=91=1A693< !"#$ % & '#() % * +,- ./0123$ 456789:;<& 3=>?*>@A6 B$ C $D 9$ $ E< (F*BG <HIJ K$LM (7 K4 N <I $OP 20+QRSR $:!8< ;$ $ $ < TU VW3V% 20 2 " 3 X 8Y (Z=8 [$O (\ %]= (^; /0_J ( P*$: ;$& 30; )$Y(#`$ $ , $(F*BG<HI (Z=24 $aU &<3 $''&'' $ ,-b B$ @S $c4 $D @:!8< OL dS4$ P 8e T 2@U :U8)$ 48e,-b B$ K$ T0fg ;$3 D 2 $ P 8e T 2@U ;I 20 $O &<3 &+&-'&% S 48e,-b B$ ($2&* Ch$=4DN203[(#1I < TU iQ :*)c3 :8 $ j8 0 - 4 - < k;%$UC%$48e,-b B$i(@$ P 8e T 2@U :U8l m $O 3% 4 K2038Y :U8)$O )k6 4 9$K 3I$20 $O(Vn= Kmae Q +a:@9$HK$; $CI(%o(Vn= $ 48e,-b i(@$ P 8e T 2@U :U8)$O VW3V% 20p $ ($ iR9$ K30; q 2 $ S m: K iQ r( 4D ! VW3V% 20 2 " ( q* s4($ c*! 3I-+ C4 5 , 56 sk= .It D" N 3V%J *? Hu* v- w[ 8bU )$Y $D ( @ L8Y 48e,-b B$$Lx S( L8Yc;y wx $c9I$c*z 20<$C $wxS # $ c4$aU<F 3=<639?5A613875<4/3234040563<=9D3<406C45 4/3 =883C=40561 06 4/3 ?5>28=064 /=1 28=?39 <380=6?3 56 13D3<=8 95?A>3641 45 93>5614<=43 4/=4 4/3 13?569 <312569364 @=1 4<=6173<<39 45 /=<@=9 2A<1A=6445=4=435D3<6>3645<93<9=439'+&-'&) /01 4<=6173< =??5<906C 45 /0> 2<3?0204=439 = 13<031 57 8040C=40561 :34@336 /=<@=9 @/3<3 4/3 234040563< 01 13<D06C =1 <573115< 06 4/3 32=<4>364 57 - 5 - 1;?/0=4<; =69 4/3 13?569 <312569364 38;06C 56 4@5 93?010561 57 4/01 5A<4 563 <3693<39 06 ?<0>06=8 GA<0190?4056 =69 =654/3< A693< @<04 GA<0190?4056 83=<639 ?5A6138 1A:>041 4/=4 4/3 13?569 <312569364 /=D06C D0<4A=88; 8514 =88 1A?/ 2<5?33906C1 01 65@ >01A106C 4/3 2580?3 >=?/063<; /3 2<31364 ?5>28=064 <31A8406C 06 <3C014<=4056 57 4/3 0>2AC639 ?<0>3 /3 ?5643691 01 =?4A=439:;>=8=70931=690643693915838;45/=<=114/3 234040563< 654@04/14=6906C 4/3 @04/9<=@=8 57 5&'''%'&' :; 4/3 13?569 <312569364 3 /=1 7A<4/3< 28=?39 <380=6?3 56 4/3 GA9C>364 57 4/3 5# 5<906=4336?/06<8 5&$'&''?5663?439@04/ <8 5&&&'&'' 373<<06C 45 4/3 <383D=64 7=?4A=8 >=4<0E ?5A6138 =<CA31 4/=4 4/3 234040563<H1 A608=43<=8 4<=6173< @=1 @04/9<=@6 :; 4/3 4=43 5D3<6>364 =743< 4=B06C 6543 57 4/3 654070?=4056 011A39 :; 4/3 390?=8 5A6?0857690=4/<5AC/04111014=643?<34=<;D09383443< 9=439 '&+'&% =99<31139 45 4/3 32A4; A23<064369364 57 580?3 =0?/A< A:#0D01056 @/5 @=1 - 6 - 4/3606D3140C=406C 5'&-??5<906C45/0>4/3 @04/9<=@=8 57 4/3 5&'''%'&' :; 4/3 13?569 <312569364 ?83=<8; 2<31A225131 =??324=6?3 57 4/3 4=43 5D3<6>364H193?0105645<31?0694/34<=6173<654070?=4056 /=D06C <3=80I39 4/=4 6304/3< 4/3 2=<364 932=<4>364 65< 4/3 :5<<5@06C 061404A4056 6=>38; /=<@=9 /=9 :336 ?561A8439 4 01 06 4/01 ?5643E4 ?5A6138 ?5643691 4/=4 4/3 ?56406A=4056 57 ?<0>06=8 2<5?33906C1 =>5A64145=6=:A13572<5?311578=@=690180=:8345:3 JA=1/39 3< ?564<= 83=<639 ?5A6138 75< <312569364 5' 1A:>041 4/=4 4/3 KF <325<4 70839 06 5'&- 75< 4/3 57736?3 A693< 3?4056 57 4/3 ?/39A839 =1431 =69?/39A839<0:31!<3D364056574<5?04031"?4)%) 01 65@ 236906C ?561093<=4056 :375<3 4/3 56H:83 23E 5A<437A<4/3<1A:>0414/=44/3234040563</=1>01A139 ?3<4=06 ?<A?0=895?A>364145 4/3 13<05A12<3GA90?3574/3 13?569<312569364@/0?/<3JA0<314/5<5AC/06D3140C=4056 06<0>3 5)'&';9<=@06C=44364056454/3934=0839 - 7 - 14=43>364 57 5:G3?40561 /3 ?5643691 4/=4 4/3 234040563< /=1 7<=A9A83648; =69 0883C=88; ?<3=439 95?A>3641 2A<25<4398;011A39:;563(=0611014=643?<34=<; 390?=8 5A6?08 57 690= =69 4/=4 2<0>= 7=?03 >=43<0=81 =44<=?406C 3?4056 -) 57 4/3 =<3 =815 75<4/?5>06C 36?3/31A:>0414/=465069A8C36?3A693<3?4056%' 57<01@=<<=6439 $ 3=<639 0C/ 5A<4 5D3<6>364 83=93< 1A225<41 4/3 1A:>0110561 57 <312569364 5' =69 ?5643691 4/=4 4/01 01 = 704 ?=13 75< 06D3140C=4056 45 2<5?339 + =D06C /3=<9 4/3 83=<639 ?5A6138 =69 56 23<A1=8 57 4/3 23404056 2=23<1 4/01 5A<4 /=1 C0D36 =6E05A1?561093<=4056454/395?A>364128=?3956<3?5<9 =69 /=1 =815 3E=>0639 4/3 14=43>364 57 5:G3?40561 70839 :;4/313?569<312569364 - /3 ?=13 56 /=69 /=1 = 856C =69 ?/3JA3<39 /0145<; /3 13?569 <312569364 2<313648; 13<D06C =1 - 8 - <573115<571;?/0=4<;=44/3=0?/A<61404A4357390?=8 ?036?31 /=1 :336 3>:<50839 06 >A840283 8040C=40561 @04/ /=<@=94/3061404A405606@/0?/4/3234040563< 013>285;39/370<14<5A69578040C=4056@=14<0CC3<39:; = A608=43<=8 4<=6173< 654070?=4056 011A39 :; 4/3 4=43 5D3<6>364 56 +''&) 4<=6173<<06C 4/3 13?569 <312569364 23<>=63648; 45 /=<@=9 @04/5A4 4/3 ?561364 57 4/3 061404A4056 :306C 4/3 :5<<5@06C =A4/5<04; ?/=8836C39 4/3 5<93< :375<3 4/01 5A<4/3@<0423404056@=1=885@39=694/3>=443<@=1 <3>04439454/34=435D3<6>364256<3#3E=>06=4056 4/3 4=43 5D3<6>364 75A69 4/=4 6304/3< 4/3 2=<364 932=<4>364 65< 4/3 :5<<5@06C 061404A4056 /=9 :336 ?561A8439 2<05< 45 5<93<06C 4/3 23<>=6364 4<=6173< 5613JA3648; 4/3 4<=6173< 654070?=4056 @=1 @04/9<=@6 /3 13?569 <312569364 JA31405639 4/01 93?01056 06 5&'''%'&' :A4 1A:13JA3648; @04/9<3@ 4/3 @<04 2340405656'&''&'' - 9 - % 6?34/3@04/9<=@=8574/34<=6173<654070?=4056 =44=0639 706=804; 56 =??5A64 57 4/3 13?569 <312569364 @04/9<=@06C 4/3 @<04 23404056 4/01 5A<4 01 65@ <3JA0<39 45 3E=>063 @/34/3< 4/3 06040=4056 57 >A840283 ?<0>06=8 2<5?33906C1 :; @=; 57 2<0D=43 ?5>28=0641 =69 2580?3 ?5>28=0641 01 GA1407039 /3 ?569A?4 57 4/3 13?569 <312569364 06 =22<5=?/06C 4/3 =4056=8 5>>011056 75< ?/39A839 =1431 =69 06 13?A<06C = <3?5>>369=4056 90<3?406C 4/3 4=43 5D3<6>364 45 4<=6173< /0> 45 /=<@=9=815@=<<=641?561093<=4056 ) /3 <3?5>>369=4056 57 4/3 =4056=8 5>>011056 75< ?/39A839 =14319=439 &&%'&' @=1 ?/=8836C39 :375<3 4/01 5A<4 06 5&&)'&' ; 5<93<9=439'-&+'&'4/31=09<3?5>>369=40561@3<3 JA=1/39 & 1<3C=<914/3?<0>06=82<5?33906C106040=43906 <0>3 5'&''&''75<57736?31A693<3?4056!000"574/3 <543?4056 57 0D08 0C/41 ?4 )$$ 3?40561 !"!2" !"!J" !"!<" !"!I="! " !"!I?" !'"!D=" =69 - 10 - !'"!D00" 57 4/3 ?/39A839 =1431 =69 ?/39A839 <0:31 !<3D364056 57 4<5?04031" >369>364 ?4 '&$ =69 3?4056 '- <3=9 @04/ 3?4056 57 236906C :375<3 4/3 9904056=8 014<0?4 =69 3110561 5A<4 /=<@=9 4/3 1=>3 @=1 ?/=8836C39 :; 4/3 2<31364 234040563< 06 <8 5&$'&'' ?5663?439 @04/ <8 5&&&'&'' /3 0<3?45< 57 /=<@=9 /=9 =815 70839 = ?5663?439 23404056 6 4/3 <325<439 GA9C>364 <3693<39 06 4/3 1=09 >=443<1 4/01 5A<4 455B 14<56C3E?324056454/3?569A?4574/313?569<312569364 =<=C<=2/1 45 + 57 4/3 1=09 GA9C>364 @/0?/ =<3 <383D=64=<33E4<=?439:385@ !" # $ %" # # & '(%)*" % * - 11 - * +# $ , " ) # " + )" -./0-0- $ *1 2 * 3 454 3 454 " + *1 * )"6/0-0 " + ' 7 * " + $ * 2 * )"0-0/0-00# " 8" $ %# % , 9(2:%' '2*+%% ;*" *+%+< = >%)%+%>% %) %)=+(< 0-06 * = * ?-6 $@ ! ! " #" $ % ! ! ! " #" $ % ! ! - 12 - A # # / # $# " B< C # = $ $ $ " + = $ $ $ % , " % % , $# " ?" + $ % , " % $ $ " +# # $ $# "D - 13 - 6=?=<37A823<A1=8574/35:13<D=40561>=93 :;4/35#5<906=4336?/574/015A<4@/083JA=1/06C4/3 2<5?33906C106<0>3 5'&''&''04013D093644/=44/3 36?//=914<56C8;932<3?=4394/3?569A?4574/313?569 <312569364312043/=D06C1A773<39=9D3<135<93<1=44/3 /=691574/015A<456'&''&'4/313?569<312569364 /=1 56?3 =C=06 06040=439 ?<0>06=8 2<513?A4056 4/<5AC/ <0>3 5)'&' =<0106C 5A4 57 /01 @<04436 ?5>28=064 9=439 '%&+'&' @/0?/ 01 65@ 15AC/4 45 :3 JA=1/39 =D06C?561093<39 4/3 706906C1<3?5<939:; 4/01 5A<4 06 5&&)'&' =69 4/3 5:13<D=40561 3E4<=?439 /3<306=:5D37<5>4/3GA9C>364574/35#5<906=4336?/ 04 01 A675<4A6=43 4/=4 4/3 13?569 <312569364 2<313648; 13<D06C=1=<573115<=44/3=0?/A<61404A4357390?=8 ?036?31/=1<323=4398;>01A1394/32580?3>=?/063<;:; 859C06C>A840283106?8A906C=2<0D=43?5>28=064A693< 3?4056 '&& < 1 <0C/48; 65439 :; 4/3 5#5<906=43 36?/ 4/3 9012A43 :34@336 4/3 2=<4031 01 2A<38; @04/06 4/3 <3=8> 57 13<D0?3 GA<012<A936?3 743< @04/9<=@06C - 14 - 5&'''%'&' =69 4/3<3:; =885@06C 4/3 011A3 <38=406C45/01?8=0>75<4<=6173<45 /=<@=945 =44=06 706=804; 4/3 13?569 <312569364 ?=6654 65@ :3 23<>04439 45 <31A<<3?4 4/3 9012A43 4/<5AC/ ?<0>06=8 2<5?33906C1 56 = D=CA3 =883C=4056 4/=4 4/3 234040563< ?5>>044394/37457?3<4=0695?A>3641 ' D36 56 >3<041 = >340?A85A1 3E=>06=4056 57 4/3 ?5>28=064 <3D3=81 4/=4 4/3 011A3 57 @/34/3< 4/3 13?569 <312569364 ?5A89 /=D3 :336 4<=6173<<39 45 /=<@=9@=10413874/31A:G3?457JA3<031>=93 :; 4/3 <06?02=8 3?<34=<; 32=<4>364 57 390?=8 9A?=4056 =69 4/3 6D3140C=406C 770?3<L4/3 32A4; A23<064369364 57 580?3 =0?/A< A:#0D01056 45 4/3 390?=85A6?0857690=6<31256134/3390?=85A6?08 57 690= 4/<5AC/ 041 11014=64 3?<34=<; < (=06 011A39=?8=<070?=4056 9=439 '&+'&% 454/3 3773?44/=4 4/3 3E23<036?3 ?8=0>39 :; 4/3 13?569 <312569364 =1 3605< 5A13 770?3< 7<5> &&'&& 45 &''&&- =4 /3A885<B390?=8?/5585<B?5A89654:3<3?B5639 - 15 - 75< 4/32A<2513 579343<>0606C /01380C0:0804; =1 11014=64 <573115< 06 1;?/0=4<; /01 D3<; ?8=<070?=4056 /=1 :336 3E43610D38; <373<<39 45 :; 4/3 83=<639 =C014<=43 @/083 ?561093<06C 4/3 MH <325<4 70839 06 5'&- =<=C<=2/ $ 57 4/3 =C014<=43H1 5<93< 123?070?=88; 93=81 @04/4/01?5>>A60?=4056 1?5<<3?48;25064395A4:;83=<639?5A613875< 4/3 234040563< 4/3 =883C=4056 57 4/374 =223=<1 @/588; >01?56?30D392=<40?A8=<8;@/364/395?A>36406JA314056 = ?8=<070?=4056 011A39:; 4/3 390?=85A6?08 57 690= 01 = 2A:80? 95?A>364 /01 D3<; 95?A>364 /=9 :336 <38039 A256 :; 4/3 6D3140C=406C 770?3< 06 5'&- =69 4/3 234040563< /=9 65 <583 06 041 011A=6?3 4 01 3JA=88; ?A<05A14/=44/313?569<312569364/=163D3<JA31405639 4/3 D=80904; 57 4/3 1=09 ?8=<070?=4056 06 =6; 83C=88; <3?5C60139 >=663< /36 4/313 ?0<?A>14=6?31 =<3 ?A>A8=40D38;?561093<39@/=43>3<C31014/=44/313?569 <312569364 9<0D36 :; 23<156=8 =60>5104; /=1 :336 088# =9D0139 =69 /=1 3>:=<B39 A256 1A14=0639 ?<0>06=8 - 16 - 8040C=4056 =C=0614 4/3 234040563< @/0?/ 01 3E4<3>38; A675<4A6=43 D36 07 4/3 =883C=40561 06 4/3 2<31364 ?5>28=064=<3=??32439=47=?3D=8A34/3;95654=44<=?4 4/3 06C<3903641 57 3?4056 -) /3 13?569 <312569364 >A14 <37<=06 7<5> A663?311=<08; 06D5B06C 4/3 ?<0>06=8 2<5?311 =69 >01A106C 2580?3 >=?/063<; =C=0614 4/3 234040563< =69 54/3< 14=77 >3>:3<1 57 /=<@=9 /3 234040563< =6 =?=93>0?0=6 13<D06C =1 <573115<571;?/0=4<;/=1:3369<=CC3906452<5856C39 =69 A6@=<<=6439 8040C=4056 6040=4056 57 ?<0>06=8 2<5?33906C1 =C=0614 =?=93>0?0=61 ?=A131 /A>080=4056 >364=8 4<=A>= =69 4/3 855>06C 4/<3=4 57 =<<314 =>5A6406C 45 /=<=11>364 /3 2<31364 ?=13 3E3>2807031 >01A13 57 2580?3 >=?/063<; :; 4/3 13?569 <312569364 9312043 /58906C = <3125610:83 25104056 =4 4/3 =0?/A< 61404A43 57 390?=8 ?036?31 /01 01 ?83=<8; =6 =:A13 57 2<5?311 57 8=@ @=<<=6406C 3E3<?013 57 06/3<364 25@3<1 - 17 - A693< 3?4056 %' < 45 2<3D364 >01?=<<0=C3 57 GA140?3 $ 5< 4/3 75<3C506C <3=1561 4/3 75885@06C 5<93< 012=1139 /32340405601 /3?5>28=0649=439'%&+'&' =4 663EA<3# =69 4/3<3C014<=4056 57<0>3 5)'&' :;4/3 =<B34=<9 580?3 4=4056 =0?/A< 75< 4/3 57736?3 2A601/=:83 A693< 3?4056 -)57 65@236906C:375<3 4/35A<4 57 4/3 <06?02=80D08(A9C3!3605<0D01056"=69(=0?/A<=4 663EA<3# 45C34/3< @04/ =88 7A<4/3< 2<5?33906C1 2A<1A=64 4/3<345 =<3 /3<3:; JA=1/39 06157=< =1 4/3 234040563<01?56?3<639 -+ '##* & ( 014 5'8 5'