Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 64426 (KAR)
RAMESH REKULGIKAR S/O MARUTI v. PRABHAKAR REDDY AND ANR
MFA/202267/2019 · 2025-10-09
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64426 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64426 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$
$$
%&'
(
! "
"#$% & #'()""(
)
&
**# **! "* *
""' +
#'((((
*),
"#
"()()-+! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
* *
"$"! *
+ * + ()"")(" *
.$$
)(" *
* *
+
/
# / ! " 012345012678094:;<=;45:>30: ) 5>:1??01@>:<>@03=A450B@1>8194161>9:4450 C7368094 193 1D123 31403 ()"")(" ?1::03 =A 450 2>9B>?1@ 09>;2 >E>@ 7360 193 >312 F<;2 :5;24 G2>=791@HI >9
;.$$ ;< )(" :00J>96 <;2 09519B08094;<450B;8?09:14>;9 50<1B4:;<450B1:01204514;9(%(%)("14 1=;74$(?8D509450B@1>8194D1:?2;B003>96;95>:
8;4;2BAB@0 =012>96 206>:4214>;9 ;#
#'- <2;8
- 3 -
&150021=134;D123:1C6002150804D>45191BB>30941:
50 31:503 161>9:4 1 @;22A =012>96 06>:4214>;9 ;# )
#)."D5>B5D1:?12J03906@>6094@A>94508>33@0;< 450 2;13 D>45;74 19A >93>B14>;9 ;< 450 ?12J>96 70 4;
D5>B5 B@1>8194 :7:41>903 >9C72>0: 1@@ ;E02 =;3A 5013 >9C72A 193 @;:4 40045 193 :7<<0203 <21B4720 ;< 81K>@@1 =;90:0D1:42014031:>9?14>094<;2:0E021@31A:193 1@:;4;;J4201480941:;74?14>094<;2:;804>801931@:; 4;;J420148094<2;87279191J0941@;:?>41@>312<;2 <21B4720;<81K>@@1193@;::;<40045193=0B17:0;<5013 >9C72A50>::4>@@:7<<02>96<2;86>33>90::193>8=1@19B0;< =;3A 0 =0B;80: 3>:1=@03 193 791=@0 4; 0129 5>:
@>E0@>5;;3 09B0 50 <>@03 1 B@1>8 ?04>4>;9 =0<;20 450 2>=791@ :00J>96 B;8?09:14>;9 ;< :'(((((
# 50 2>=791@ B;9:>302>96 450 094>20 81402>1@ ;9 20B;23 1D12303 19 18;794 ;< :)'((
# =74 50@3 4514 B@1>8194 B;942>=7403 '(L ;< 906@>609B0 4; 450 1BB>3094 509B0 1D12303 '(L ;< :)'((
# D5>B5 B;80: 4;
:"..)'(
#4;604502D>45>94020:4144502140;<.L?02
- 4 -
19978<2;84503140;<?04>4>;94>@@4503140;<201@>M14>;9 1933>20B403450)9320:?;930944;30?;:>4450:180D>45>9 4D;8;945<2;84503140;<450;2302 -
012903 B;79:0@ <;2 450 B@1>8194 B;9409303 451445032>E02;<450@;22A?12J03450@;22A>94508>33@0 ;< 450 2;13 >9 450 9>654 5;72: D>45;74 19A >93>B14>;9 ;2 @>654:509B04502>=791@02203>9<>K>96'(LB;942>=74;2A 906@>609B0 ;9 450 ?124 ;< 450 B@1>8194 0 <724502 B;94093034514450B@1>8194D1:138>4403>94505;:?>41@ 1: 19 >9?14>094 <;2 :0E021@ 31A: 193 1<402 3>:B51260 B;94>9703450420148094<;2:0E021@8;945:1:;74?14>094 193 >9B72203 5760 803>B1@ 0K?09:0: 0 :7=8>4403 4514 450B@1>8194D1:0129>96:"'(((
#?028;945=A3;>96 =7:>90:: =74 450 2>=791@ 51: 41J09 ;9@A :(((
# ?02 8;945D5>B5>:;9450@;D02:>300<724502:7=8>4403 4514 450 B@1>8194 :7:41>903 <21B4720 ;< 81K>@@1 <2;941@ 30?20::03 <21B4720 ;<:J7@@ <21B4720 ;<@14021@ >9B>:;2 193 450 2>=791@ D>45;74 B;9:>302>96 :1>3 81402>1@ 1D12303 801620B;8?09:14>;9509B0?21A:<;21@@;D>964501??01@
- 5 -
' 020@>037?;9067@14>;9"';<4507@0:;<450 ;13067@14>;9:"%%206123>96B;942>=74;2A906@>609B0 D5>B52013:1:<;@@;D:
! ! ! " #
$
! ! ! %
%
%
! %
%
! %
! ! &
- 6 -
.
012903B;79:0@<;220:?;93094;)#9:7219B0 ;8?19A B;9409303 4514 450 B@1>8194 D1: 51E>96 :7<<>B>094?@1B04;B2;::4502;13=745031:503450@;22A ;9 450 @0<4 2012 093 :>30 193 457: 450 2>=791@ 2>654@A 1::0::03450B;942>=74;2A906@>609B014'(L;9=;45450 E05>B@0: 193 >4 9003: 9; >9402<0209B0 0 <724502 :41403 4514 450 B@1>8194 513 9;4 :7<<0203 19A 3>:1=>@>4A 1:
1::0::03 =A +)#;B4;2 193 50 51: 9;4 41J09 19A 420148094 193 457: 450 2>=791@ 2>654@A 9;4 B;9:>30203 19A3>:1=>@>4A509B050?21A:<;23>:8>::1@;<4501??01@ $ 1E>9650123450@012903B;79:0@:<;2=;45450 ?124>0: 193 ;9 ?027:1@ ;< 450 81402>1@: ;9 20B;23 450 1BB>3094>:9;4>93>:?7404>:1@:;9;4>93>:?7404514450 ;<<093>96 @;22A D1: 37@A >9:7203 D>45 450 )93 20:?;93094 193?;@>BAD1:>9<;2B01:;94503140;<4501BB>3094:
?02 450 81402>1@ ;9 20B;23 450 B@1>8194 D1: ?2;B003>96 ;9 5>: 8;4;2BAB@0 ;9 450 3140 ;< >9B>3094 14 1=;74 $( ?81939012450;74:J>24:;<14D12 >@@1605031:503 161>9:41@;22AD5>B5D1:?12J03;94508>33@0;<4502;13
- 7 -
D>45;743>:?@1A>96450?12J>96@>654:51260#:5004>:<>@03 161>9:445032>E02;<450@;22A5020D1:30@1A;<%31A:
>9 <>@>96 450 B;8?@1>94 50 B;8?@1>9194 >: 9;4 19 0A0D>490:: 4; 450 1BB>3094 : ?02 450 >9E0:4>614>;9 ;<<093>96@;22AD1:?12J03>91906@>6094819902D>45;74 41J>96 ?20B174>;9: : ?02 450 2;765 :J04B5 1990K03 4; 450?;419B591814501BB>3094:?;4>:#.'D5>B5>: 78=1>4;A3021=1314>;91@>65D1A:?02450:1>3 3;B78094:45020120*;;3:@1M102E;042;@78?193 B;8802B>1@ =7>@3>96: 9012 450 :?;4 193 450 D>345 ;< 450 2;13>:9;48094>;903>9450?19B59181
: ?02 450 >:1=>@>4A 024><>B140 450 B@1>8194 51: :7:41>903 <21B4720 ;< @0<4 81K>@@1 0K<;@>14>;9 ;< 40045 >94507??02C1DD5>B512062>0E;7:>9914720@1>8194 :41403451450D1:1603)A012:144504>80;<1BB>3094 =74 9; 3;B78094 >: ?2;37B03 4; ?2;E0 5>: 160 9 450 1=:09B0 ;< ?2;;< ;< >9B;80 450 2>=791@ 51: B;9:>30203 450 160 ;< 450 B@1>8194 =04D009 . 4; -( A012: 193 1??@>03 450 87@4>?@>02 ;< G"'H D5>B5 >: C7:4 193 ?2;?02
- 8 -
*72450245;765>4>::414034514450B@1>8194D1:0129>96 :"'(((
#?028;9455051:9;4?2;37B0319A>9B;80 ?2;;< 5>: ;724 <>93: >4 201:;91=@0 4; B;9:>302 450 9;4>;91@ >9B;80 ;< 450 B@1>8194 14 :$(((
# ?02 8;945 1: ?02 450 67>30@>90: >::703 =A 450 129141J1 4140
061@02E>B0:745;2>4A !<;24501BB>3094;<450 A012)(" % +) >9 5>: 0E>309B0 :41403 4514 50 >: 450 3;B4;2D5;42014034501??0@@1941934503>:1=>@>4A12>:>96 <2;8450<21B4720:1208094>;9031:<;@@;D:
>! 70 4; B;8?@040 @;:: <2;8 81K>@@12A 40045 ?14>094 >: 51E>96 3><<>B7@4A 4;
81:4>B140 450 <;;3 ?2;?02@A 370 4; D5>B550>:;9:;<43>04 >>! *21B4720 ;< 450 @;D02 B09421@ 193>=7@12 9B>:;2 20:7@4>96 >94; 3>:472=19B0>94509;281@;BB@7:>;9 >>>! *21B4720 ;< 19402>;2 40045 B17:>96 3><<>B7@4A>9450:?00B5 >E! *21B4720B17:>96<1B>1@1:A88042A E! *21B4720 ;< 450 81K>@@12A 1@E0;@12 =;90193@;::<1B>1@3>:<>67208094
- 9 -
E>!
;=>@>4A ;< 7??02 193 @;D02 40045 :?1B>96 ;< 2081>9>96 19402>;2 40045 370 4; <21B4720 193 0K<;@>14>;9
193<>91@@A:4140345144501??0@@194:7:41>903?02819094 4;41@ ?124>1@ 3>:1=>@>4A ;< )(L D5>B5 B;220:?;9309B0 4;
"(L;<3>:1=>@>4A4;450D5;@0=;3A
"( 012903 B;79:0@ <;2 450 20:?;93094:
E0508094@A B;9409303 4514 1: 450 1??0@@194 :7:41>903 <21B4720:;<81K>@@1193@;::;<400454503>:1=>@>4AB;7@3 9;4 =0 B;9:>30203, 45020<;20 450 2>=791@ 2>654@A 3>3 9;4 B;9:>3024503>:1=>@>4ABB;23>96@A50:;76544;3>:8>:: 4501??01@
"" 04>4>;902:7:41>903<21B4720:
>9C72>0:D5>B5120 62>0E;7:>9914720193504;;J4201480941:>9?14>094193 1@:; 1: 19 ;74 ?14>094 <;2 :0E021@ 31A: 0 :7:41>903 3>:1=>@>4A1934503;B4;21::0::03450:18014"(L4;450 D5;@0=;3A704;450>9C72A:7:41>903>94501BB>3094 45020>:3>:472=19B04;4509;281@;BB@7:>;919345020>:1 3><<>B7@4A >9 450 :?00B5 193 45020 >: 1 <1B>1@ 1:A88042A
- 10 -
5020<;2045>:;724<>93:201:;91=@04;41J04503>:1=>@>4A 14"(L
") *724502 >4 D1: :41403 4514 50 D1: 1603 ) A012: D;2J>96 >9 1 =1J02A 193 0129>96 :"'(((
# ?02 8;945745051:9;4<>@0319>9B;80B024><>B1404;?2;E0 5>:>9B;800804D>45191BB>3094;9(%(%)("5>:
>9B;80 4; =0 41J09 1: :$(((
# ?02 8;945 1: ?02 450 67>30@>90: ;< 129141J1 061@ 02E>B0: 745;2>4A 193 450 87@4>?@>02>:". " ;9:>302>964501@@<1B4:193B>2B78:419B0:450 @;::;<<74720>9B;80B;80:4;:"--((
#$(((K") K".K"(L!19345018;7946219403793024505013?1>9 193:7<<02>964;4500K4094;<:'((((
#1D12303=A450 2>=791@9003:9;>9402<0209B019318;794;<:$'(((
# 79302 450 5013 @;:: ;< 809>4>0: >: 4; =0 2037B03 4;
:'((((
#5>:;7249;4>9B@>9034;>9402<020D>45450 18;794 ;< :'((((
# 1@2013A 6219403 =A 450 2>=791@ 793024505013@;::;<@><0K?0B419BA
- 11 -
"- :?02450B;94094>;9;<450@012903B;79:0@<;2 4501??0@@194206123>96B;942>=74;2A906@>609B045>:;724 <00@: 4514 450 32>E02 ;< 450 @;22A :5;7@3 9;4 ?12J 450 E05>B@0 ;9 450 81>9 2;13 B122A>96 <1:4 41B4>B 193 >4 >: 1 B@012E>;@14>;9;<7@0"')!>E!193509B09;906@>609B0 >: 1442>=7403 4; 450 ?04>4>;902
1??0@@194 5020>9 74 450 2>=791@02203>9<>K>96;<'(L;<906@>609B0;95>:?124 38>4403@A?04>4>;9D1:<>@03161>9:445032>E02;<450@;22A 193 >4 >: <;2 450 9:7219B0 ;8?19A 4; ?2;E0 450 B;942>=74;2A 906@>609B0 =74 450A <1>@03 4; 3; :;
45020<;2045032>E02;<450@;22A=012>96;#)
#)." >:1@;90906@>6094>9?12J>96450@;22A>94508>33@0;<450 2;13 D>45;7441J>96 19A ?20B174>;9: 193 457: 450 ;2302 ;<4502>=791@>9<>K>96'(L;<450906@>609B0;9450?124 ;<4501??0@@194>:022;90;7:193>:8;3><>031:"(L
"' BB;23>96@A>9E>0D;<4501=;E03>:B7::>;9:>9 1@@ 450 4;41@ B;8?09:14>;9 D;7@3 B;80: 4;
)*!*! + 50 B;8?09:14>;9 >: 09519B03 <2;8 :)'((4;'() ) *++, ' *Corrected vide court order dated 13.11.2025. - 12 -
". 50 1D123 ;< B;8?09:14>;9 ?1::03 =A 450 2>=791@>:8;3><>031: ,-.)/01,2)-342
0523
;:: ;< <74720 0129>96 B1?1B>4A :
"--((
#
;::;<809>4>0: : '((((
# ;D123:>:<>67208094 : $'(((
# ;D123:
;:: ;<
><0 K?0B419BA : '((((
# 1>9193:7<<02>96 : '((((
# 03>B1@0K?09:0: : '((
#
;::;<>9B;80372>96@1>37? ?02>;3 : )-(((
# *>K14>;9;<24><>B>1@0045 : '(((
# ;D123: >:B0@@190;7:51260: : )((((
# ) *!*! +
"$ 945020:7@4450<;@@;D>96;2302>:?1::03 >! ??01@>:
>>! 50 B@1>8194 >: 094>4@03 <;2 4;41@ B;8?09:14>;9;<:--"%((
#D>45>94020:4
- 13 -
14.L?0219978<2;84503140;<?04>4>;9 4>@@4503140;<201@>M14>;9 >>>!
50 20:?;93094 # 9:7219B0 ;8?19A 1@2013A 30?;:>403 '(L ;< '(- -" ++, D>45 >94020:4 14 450 2140 ;< .L =74 450 @>1=>@>4A;<4509:7219B0;8?19A>:<>K0314 %(L >9:4013 '(L
5020<;20 450 9:7219B0 ;8?19A >: 3>20B403 4; 30?;:>4 %(L;<'() ) *++,
./0
0KB@73>96 450 18;794 1@2013A 30?;:>403 =0<;20 450 2>=791@! D>45>9 1 ?02>;3 ;< ;90 8;945 <2;8 450 3140 ;< 45>: ;2302 >E! 9:7B530?;:>44501??0@@194>:?028>4403 4;D>45321D45018;7941@;96D>45>94020:4 1BB2703;9>4
.+ %$' #
>:4;"@;$$ *Corrected vide court order dated 13.11.2025.