- 1 - ! "#$ $$ %&' ( ! "#$% "$&' ( ! $)'%%)& ! $)&*% " + $ % % ! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " " ( " ! ,!% % *(% %( , # " " ,! - , # ./0123./0456.7289:;9238<1.8 3<8 /==./> <8 :<>.1 ;? 23. =.2<2<97.0$@>/<6/72 /4/<78223.A5146.72/71/B/011/2.1% %=/88.1 ;? 23. 0<7@<=/> <820<@2 /71 .88<978 ,514. /71 9290 @@<1.72>/<680<;57/> /<@350 C:9083902D0<;57/>EF<7 9*(% %(8..G<74.73/7@.6.729:@96=.78/2<97 3.:/@289:23.@/8./0.23/297*%* %( 23. @>/<6/72 6.2 B<23 /7 /@@<1.72 B3.7 3. B/8 =09@..1<74 />974 B<23 3<8 :0<.718 <7 / @/0 ;./0<74 9#$' $%() 15. 29 0/83 /71 7.4><4.72 10<H<74 ;? 0.8=971.72 9 $ 10<H.0 9: 779H/ /0 7 23. 8/<1 /@@<1.72 3. 8582/<7.1 - 3 - 40<.H958<7A50<.8/712/G.720./26.72<7/>/7G598=<2/> /<@350 .7@. 3. :<>.1 / @>/<6 =.2<2<97 ;.:90. 23. 0<;57/> @>/<6<74 @96=.78/2<97 :096 23. 0.8=971.728 @972.71<74 23/2 3. B/8 /4.1 & ?./08 /2 23. 2<6. 9: /@@<1.72 /71 ;? B90G<74 /8 <H<> 9720/@290 3. B/8 ./07<74 8&% %%% $ =.0 69723 /71 15. 29 /@@<1.72/> <7A50<.8 3. 85::.0.1 1<8/;<><2? 3. 0<;57/> @978<1.0<74 23. .72<0. 6/2.0</>8 /H/<>/;>. 97 0.@901 3/1 /B/01.1 / 8569:8* * *%% $B<23<72.0.82/223.0/2.9:'I=.0 /7756 :096 23. 1/2. 9: =.2<2<97 2<>> <28 0./><J/2<97 :096 0.8=971.729 K7850/7@.96=/7? * 440<.H.1;?23.8/<1A5146.729:23.0<;57/> 23.<7A50.1$@>/<6/723/8=0.:.00.123<8/==./> ) 8 =.0 !9571 .02<:<@/2. 23. @>/<6/72 3/8 85::.0.1 :0/@250. 9: 83/:2 9: >.:2 :.650 6<11>. 01 /71 923.0 <7A50<.8 . B/8 398=<2/><J.1 :90 % 1/?8 /8 =.0 <8@3/04. 566/0?L..L/6<7.123.9@290/8 ! B39 /88.88.1 23. 1<8/;<><2? /2 )I 29 23. B39>. ;91?3.0<;57/>@978<1.0.13<8:57@2<97/>1<8/;<><2?/2 - 4 - %I /7123<89502 :<71879 0./897 29 <72.0:.0. B<23 23. 8/<1901.039543<2<8@972.71.1;?23.@>/<6/7223/23. B/8./07<748&% %%% $=.069723 3.3/8792=0915@.1 /7?=099:9:<7@96.;.:90.23.0<;57/>723./;8.7@.9: =099:9:<7@96.23.0<;57/>3/82/G.723.<7@96.9:23. @>/<6/72 /2 8& %%% $ =.0 69723 B3<@3 <8 97 23. >9B.0 8<1..7@. 23<89502:<718<20./897/;>.292/G.792<97/> <7@96. 9: 23. @>/<6/72 /2 8% )% $ =.0 69723 /8 =.0 23.@3/02<885.1;?23.#/07/2/G/.4/> .0H<@.852390<2? :9023./@@<1.729:23.?./0 %(3.0<;57/>3/80<432>? /==><.1 23. 65>2<=><.0 9: D)E @978<1.0<74 23. /4. 9: 23. @>/<6/72 @@901<74>? 3. <8 .72<2>.1 :90 >988 9: :5250. ./07<74@/=/@<2?/8571.0 8% )% $L L)L%IM8 &* )%% $ ' 3. 0<;57/> 3/8 0<432>? /B/01.1 / 856 9: 8 &( *%% $ 29B/018 6.1<@/> .L=.78.8 /8 =.0 23. =0.8@0<=2<978 =0915@.1 ;? 23. @>/<6/72 B3<@3 7..18 79 <72.0:.0.7@.;?23<89502 - 5 - ( 16<22.1>? 23.@>/<6/72B/8398=<2/><J.1:90% 1/?8/71571.0497.8504.0<.83.0.:90. 23<89502:<718 <20./897/;>.29/B/01/7/695729:8)% %%% $:90=/<7 /7185::.0<74+29/B/01/7/695729:8)% %%% $:90>988 9: /6.7<2<.8 /71 29 /B/01 /7 /69572 9: 8% %%% $ 29B/018 20/78=902/2<97 /22.71/72 /71 .L20/ 7950<836.72 @3/04.8 99G<74 29 23. 7/250. 9: <7A50<.8 8582/<7.1 3. 6<432 3/H. 792 /22.71.1 3<8 B90G /2>./82 :90 230.. 697238 3.7@. 3. <8 .72<2>.1 :90 8% ()% $ :90 >988 9: <7@96.150<74>/<15==.0<913.@96=.78/2<97/B/01.1 ;?23.0<;57/>:90:5250.6.1<@/>.L=.78.8/28 % %%% $ 7..1879<72.0:.0.7@. & 7 />> 23. 292/> @96=.78/2<97 @96.8 29 8) ) ')% $ B<23 <72.0.82 /2 'I =.0 /7756 :096 23. 1/2.9:=.2<2<972<>>23.1/2.9:0./><8/2<97 3. /B/01 9: @96=.78/2<97 =/88.1 ;? 23. 0<;57/><8691<:<.1/8571.0 - 6 - ./18 B/01;?23. 0<;57/> B/01;?23<8 9502 /<7/7185::.0<74 8% %%% $ 8)% %%% $ .1<@/>.L=.78.8 8 &( *%% $ 8 &( *%% $ 988 9: :5250. ./07<74 @/=/@<2? 8 ** %%% $ 8 &* )%% $ * 0/78=902/2<97 .L20/ 7950<836.72 /71 /22.71/72@3/04.8 8 %%% $ 8) %%% $ )9889:/6.7<2<.8 8% %%% $ 8)% %%% $ '9889:./07<74150<74 20./26.72=.0<91 8 * %%% $ 8% ()% $ ( "5250. 6.1<@/> .L=.78.8 8 % %%% $ 8 % %%% $ 92/> 8* * *%% $ )! !* 3.0.B<>>;..73/7@.6.729:8 & )% $ % 723.0.85>2 23.:9>>9B<74901.0<8=/88.1 < ==./><8 << 3. @>/<6/72 <8 .72<2>.1 :90 23. 292/> @96=.78/2<979:8) ) '*% $B<23<72.0.82/2 'I=.0/7756:09623.1/2.9:=.2<2<972<>>23. 1/2.9:0./><J/2<97/8/4/<7828* * *%% $ - 7 - <<< .8=971.72 9 K 7850/7@. 96=/7? <8 1<0.@2.1 29 1.=98<2 23. /:90.8/<1 @96=.78/2<97 /69572 B<23<7 97. 69723 :096 23.1/2.9:23<8A5146.72 <H 7 85@3 1.=98<2 23. @>/<6/72 <8 =.06<22.129B<2310/B23..72<0./69572/>974 B<23<72.0.82/@@05.197<2 +* %$' # <829 >9** #