- 1 - ! " #$ %#&!#!# '() ! " #$# % &%& '% %% " ( % % #$# % %% % % Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - #)( '% & (* & +,-% ) % %%% . % # ( ( % ( " "( % % - #())#()/ % " " " %%" ((( # ( - (()(/ % " %%"# ( * %%% % ( % % % %% " ((( (* % % % % % % " % %( %%" % % %% " % %(* % % %*% 0 %%% % % - 3 - % % 10 % ! ! 2 & %34,4,5637 ,- 839573 4+,- 5:74 -33;,6< 95==5>,6< 73=,39-! ? --:359?>7,459@374,57?7,57?6A54+37?BB75B7,?43>7,4 57C3757C,73@4,56D:?-+,6<4+3,EB:<63CC3E?6C654,@3- C?43C # ( ?6C ( ,--:3C 8A 73-B56C364 5 (F,C3663G:73??6C663G:73(C3E?6C,6<975E 4+3B34,4,56374+3B?AE36459- #())#()/:B33- ,94A,63 7573 ,G4336 ?;+ ,G4A >5 +5:-?6C ,F3 :6C73C 6C ,G4336 6=A 45>?7C- ?773?7- 59 B75B374A 4?G9574+39,6?6@,?=A3?7-(((45F,C3 654,@3 C?43C # ( ?6C - (()(/ :B33- +,743367573>364A63?;+,G4A,63+5:-?6C>5 :6C73C6C5:743366=A45>?7C-B75B374A4?G957 #F,C3654,@3C?43C( * 8 --:3?>7,459E?6C?E:-57?6A54+37?BB75B7,?43>7,4 57C37 57 C,73@4,56 C,73@4,6< 73-B56C364 65 ( 45 9574+>,4+ ,--:365C:3-@374,9,@?43,673-B3@4594+3B?AE364-E?C3 8A4+3B34,4,563745>?7C-4+3B75B374A4?G9574+39,6?6@,?= A3?7-(((45(* @ C,73@44+373-B56C364-45B75C:@3?==73@57C-C5@:E364- 73-5=:4,56- ?--3--E364 57C37- F?=:?4,56 73B574- ?6C @5EE:6,@?4,56 73=,3C :B56 957 ,--:,6< 4+3 ,EB:<63C C3E?6C 654,@3-B374?,6,6<3G@=:-,F3=A454+3B37,5CB5-4 9,6?6@,?= A3?7 ( ,6@=:C,6< 8:4 654 =,E,43C 45 73-5=:4,56- 957 ?--3--E364 ?6C B75B374A 4?G @?=@:=?4,56 957 4+3 -?,C B37,5C >,4+5:4 735B36,6< 73F,-,6< 57 ,6 ?6A E?6637 C,-4:78,6< 4+3 B75B374A 4?G ?--3--E364- ?6C B?AE364-?=73?CA@56@=:C3C:B459,6?6@,?=A3?7(* C ,73@44+373-B56C364-45B?A4+3@5-4594+3B34,4,56* - 4 - 3 %?-- ?6A 54+37 57C37- ?- 4+,- 5608=3 5:74 E?A C33E ?BB75B7,?43?6C9574+,-?@459;,6C63--4+3B34,4,5637?- ,6C:4A85:6C-+?==3F37B7?A A ,EB:<63C 654,@3- C?43C (# ( # ?6C ( B75C:@3C ?4 663G:73- ?6C ( 4+3 73-B56C364 :6,@,B?= 57B57?4,56 +?- @?==3C :B56 4+3 B34,4,5637 45 B?A ? -:E 59 - #())#()/ ?6C - (()(/ 45>?7C- B75B374A 4?G >,4+ ? 9:74+37 C,73@4,56 59 >+,@+ ?@4,56 >5:=C 83 ,6,4,?43C ,6 437E- 59 3@4,56(??6C(#@594+3 :6,@,B?=,4,3-@4() 3?763C 36,57 5:6-3= 7, ?7,-+ ?7?-?BB? ?BB3?7,6<957B34,4,56374+75:<+F,C35@5693736@3739377,6< 45 4+3 C5@:E364- 9,=3C ?=56< >,4+ ? E3E5 C?43C ($ ( # 87,6<- 45 4+3 ?44364,56 59 4+,- 5:74 4+?4 ?- ?<?,6-4 4+3 C3E?6C 7?,-3C 8A 4+3 73-B56C364 5 ( :B45 4+3 A3?7- ((( 45 ( F,C3 654,@3 C?43C () (( 4+3B34,4,5637+?-9:==AB?,C?6C-?4,-9,3C4+3 C3E?6C 3-:8E,4-4+?4654>,4+-4?6C,6<4+3B?AE364?- ?85F3 4+3 73-B56C364?:4+57,4,3- +?F3 8336 ,--:,6< E:=4,B=3654,@3->,4+5:4C,F:=<,6<4+3C34?,=-36?8=,6<4+3 - 5 - B34,4,5637 45 :6C37-4?6C ?6C ?--3-- 4+3 8?-,- 59 4+3 C3E?6C- -5 E?C3 3 ?=-5 73937- 45 ?76?4?;? :6,@,B?=,4,3- ?6C 374?,6 4+37 ?> E36CE364 @4 -B3@,9,@?==A >,4+ 7393736@3 45 ?E36CE364 45 3@4,56(#594+3 :6,@,B?=,4,3-@4()>+,@+B75F,C3- 957,6-374,56,6-:8-3@4,56593@4,56(#>+,@+73?C- ?-:6C37! !" 39377,6<454+3-?E3+3-:8E,4-4+?44+3-?,C -4?4:457AB75F,-,565B37?43-?-?8?7454+373-B56C364-45 -4?;3 ?6A @=?,E 83A56C 4+3 B37,5C @5643EB=?43C 4+373:6C37 +3739573 +3 -:8E,4- 4+?4 4+3 ,EB:<63C 654,@3-?4663G:73-?6C(@?==,6<:B564+3B34,4,5637 45B?A-:@+?+:<3-:E59E563A>,4+5:4B75F,C,6<4+3 C34?,=-?-454+3B37,5C45>+,@+4+3AB374?,6,-?78,47?7A ?6C:6-:-4?,6?8=3 - 6 - # 6 73-B56-3 7, E?73-+ 5H? =3?763C @5:6-3= 957 73-B56C36457B57?4,56 -:8E,4- 4+?4 4+3 C5@:E364-65>9:76,-+3C8A4+3B34,4,5637?=56<>,4+4+3 E3E5 >5:=C 83 473?43C ?- ?6 ?--3--E364 :6C37 3@4,56 (# 59 4+3 :6,@,B?=,4,3- @4 () ?6C ?9437 ?9957C,6< -:99,@,364 5BB574:6,4A 45 4+3 B34,4,5637 ?BB75B7,?4357C37->,==83B?--3C,6?@@57C?6@3>,4+=?> ) 3?7C %37:-3C4+373@57C- I +3 ,EB:<63C 654,@3 ?4 663G:73 @?==,6< :B56 4+3 B34,4,5637 45 B?A ? -:E 59 - #())#()/ B:7B5743C=A B374?,6- 45 4+3 A3?7- ((( 45 +,=3 ,EB:<63C 654,@3 ?4 663G:73( @?==,6< :B56 4+3 B34,4,5637 45 B?A - (()(/ B374?,6- 45 4+3 A3?7 # $ 6 4+3 =,<+4 59 -:8E,--,56 E?C3 ?6C 4+3 C5@:E364-9:76,-+3C5683+?=9594+3B34,4,563745,6C,@?43 4+?44+3C3E?6CE?C38A4+373-B56C364?:4+57,4,3-?-59 4+3 A3?7 ( B:7B5743C=A +?F,6< 8336 B?,C 8A 4+3 - 7 - B34,4,5637 4+3 C3E?6C 65> E?C3 ,6 663G:73 957 4+3 B37,5CB7,57454+3-?,CB?AE36473D:,73-73@56-,C37?4,56 - 9?,7=A -:8E,443C 8A =3?763C @5:6-3= 7, E?73-+ 5H? ?BB3?7,6< 957 73-B56C364 5 ( ?6C ?=-5 ;33B,6< ,6 E,6C 4+3 -:8E,--,56 E?C3 8A =3?763C 36,57 @5:6-3= ?BB3?7,6< 957 4+3 B34,4,5637 B?74,@:=?7=A >,4+7393736@3454+3?E36CE3643993@43C453@4,56(# 594+3 :6,@,B?=,4,3-@44+,-5:74C33E-,4?BB75B7,?4345 73E?6C 4+3 E?4437 45 4+3 @56@3763C +,39 99,@37 59 73-B56C3645 (>,4+95==5>,6<C,73@4,56-! , 7,4B34,4,56,- ,, +3 +,39 99,@37 -+?== 9,7-4 9:76,-+ 4+3 C34?,=- 8?-3C 56 >+,@+ 4+3 ,EB:<63C 654,@3- +?F3 8336 ,--:3C ?4 663G:73- ?6C ( 45 4+3 B34,4,5637 >,4+,6 (# C?A- 975E 4+3 C?43 59 73@3,B4 59 4+3 @374,9,3C @5BA594+357C37 +373:B564+3B34,4,5637 -+?== 9,=3 ,4- 73-B56-3 ?=56< >,4+ 4+3 C5@:E364- -:BB574,6< 4+3,7 @=?,E 59 4+3A +?F,6< 8336 B?,C 4+3 4?G3- :B45 ( - 8 - ,,, 5@?= ,6-B3@4,56 ,9 ?6A 73D:,73C 957 4+3 B:7B5-3 59 ?--3--E364 ?6C C3437E,6?4,56 594+3B75B374A4?G-+?==83@56C:@43C>,4+ 4+3 B7,57 654,@3 ?6C ,6 B73-36@3 59 ?:4+57,J3C73B73-364?4,F3-59B34,4,5637 ,F :@+ 3G37@,-3 -+?== 83 :6C374?;36 ?6C ?BB75B7,?43 57C37- -47,@4=A ,6 ?@@57C?6@3 >,4+=?>-+?==83B?--3C8A4+3@56@3763C +,39 99,@37 >,4+,6 ?6 5:437 =,E,4 59 E564+- ?9437 B34,4,5637 -:8E,44,6< ,4- 73-B56-3?-C,73@43C?85F3 F == @564364,56- ,6@=:C,6< 4+3 D:3-4,56 59 =,E,4?4,569574+3B:7B5-359?--3--E36459 B75B374A 4?G ?73 ;3B4 5B36 45 83 :7<3C 8395734+3@56@3763C+,3999,@37 F, 4 ,- E?C3 @=3?7 4,== -:@+ 57C37 ,- B?--3C 4+3 73-B56C364 5 (4>56 E:6,@,B?= -+?== 654 4?;3 ?6A B73@,B,4?4,F3 ?@4,56 B:7-:?64 454+3C3E?6C654,@3-?4663G:73-?6C (-:8H3@4E?4437594+,-B34,4,56 F,, 4 ,- 9:74+37 E?C3 @=3?7 4+?4 65 5B,6,56 ,- 3GB73--3C ,6 4+,- 57C37 56 E37,4- 59 4+3 E?4437 +3 +,39 99,@37 -+?== ?--3-- ?6C B?-- ?BB75B7,?43 57C37- 56 4+3 E37,4- 59 - 9 - 4+3 @?-3 >,4+5:4 83,6< ,69=:36@3C ,6 ?6A E?6637>+?4-53F378AC,-B5-?=594+,->7,4 B34,4,56 !*+ '#!#) & ,-45 !(=5 !()