- 1 - !" # $% # $% !%&! ## '&( ) ! ! ! " # $ % & #'& (&& ) ## * Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & ! ' +!! & & & & & , % & &+!$$$ ' # ' -' +!! (& )&# % # $$$ & #* % % )* % # & && & & % ' $$$& % # ' .# #'& # $, $! % ' - - 3 - % % ' # /' & /' ' # % )& /' &* 012 344536 7895: 5;<1=8 )* => <05 =<=: #501;652;<,)05:5183><5::5>5::59<=32?<05;<@>=: 20=:<*032A558>1659AB<05;631C38<2A518D3DD:15E59AB <05F79DC58<3893G3:993<59$$$432259AB<05 991<1=836581=:1E16'79D53895CA5: .#3< #1F3B347:318# =$, $! %3;<2 D1E18D :125 <= <05 >1618D => <05 344536 A:15>6B2<3<593:5<03<=8$,$!3<3A=7<$"4C G058 <05 95;53259 0:1C38< = 3C7 3D38C361 G32 4:=;55918D =8 012 C=<=:;B;65 A53:18D :5D12<:3<1=8 =. . >:=C 1H=<3 <= 1F347: 3< <03< <1C5 3 :3;<=: 389 <G= :3165:2 G5:5 G:=8D6B 43:H59 18 <05 C19965=> <05:=39 05:5 G5:58= 1891;3<=:2<= <05 632< - 4 - <:3165:A53:18D:5D12<:3<1=8 =.$ .$3895E588= >58;18D => 2<=852 =: 8= 61D0< G32 25< 18 <= 1891;3<5 <05 43:H59 E501;65 05 95;53259 932059 012 C=<=:;B;65 <= <05 2319 <:3165: 32 3 :5276< => G01;0 <05 95;53259 272<31859D:15E=7218F7:15238927;;7CA59<=<0518F7:152 05;631C38<2>1659345<1<1=87895:5;<1=8 => <05 ;< 255H18D ;=C45823<1=8 >=: <05 953<0 => <05 95;5325936=8DG1<018<5:52< ! 825:E1;5=>27CC=82:524=8958< =2389 34453:59 <0:=7D0 ;=78256 389 >1659 <051: G:1<<58 2<3<5C58<2 958B18D <05 3E5:C58<2 C395 18 <05 ;631C 45<1<1=8 05:524=8958< =9198=<34453:A5>=:5<05 :1A7836389058;5G32463;595I.43:<5 " 8<05A3212=><054653918D2=><0543:<152<05 631C2 :1A7836>:3C59<05122752389<05:53><5::5;=:959 <055E1958;5 05;631C38<218=:95:<=4:=E5<05;325 5I3C1859;631C38< =32&.38938=<05:G1<852232 &. 389 D=< 5I01A1<59 9=;7C58<2 83C56B I& <= I& 8 A5036> => :524=8958< = =85 G1<8522 G32 - 5 - 5I3C1859 32 . 389 D=< 5I01A1<59 9=;7C58<2 83C56B I <= I" 05 631C2 :1A7836 AB <05 1C47D859 F79DC58<0569<03<<053;;1958<<==H463;5=8 3;;=78<=>:32038985D61D58<3;<=>A=<0<059:1E5:=><05 :3;<=: 389 <:3165: 389 <05 :195: => <05 C=<=:;B;65 2 3 :5276< => G01;0 <05 95;53259 272<31859 18F7:152 389 27;;7CA59<=<0518F7:152 05 :1A7836>7:<05:0569<03< <05 ;631C38<2 3:5 58<1<659 <= 3 ;=C45823<1=8 => 2$$$$ .36=8DG1<018<5:52<3<<05:3<5=>J43 38991:5;<59:524=8958< =<=43B=86B<=<055I<58<=> "$J => <05 58<1:5 ;=C45823<1=8 3C=78< 36=8D G1<0 18<5:52<518D3DD:15E59<012344536032A558>1659 05 653:859 ;=78256 >=: <05 34456638<2 ;631C38<2032:31259<05>=66=G18D;=8<58<1=82 3* 53:859 ;=78256 34453:18D >=: <05 ;631C38<2 032 ;=8<58959 <03< <05 3;;1958< =;;7::59 975 <= <05 85D61D58;5 => 9:1E5: => <05 <:3;<=: 389 <:3165: A53:18D :5D12<:3<1=8 =.$ .$ 3<<3;059 <= <05 <:3;<=: 053;;1958<=;;7::593<3A=7<$"4C 05<:3;<=:389 - 6 - <G=<:3165:2G5:5G:=8D6B43:H5918<05C19965=><05:=39 05:5 G5:5 8= 1891;3<=:2 <= <05 632< <:3165: A53:18D :5D12<:3<1=8 =.$. $ 18;5 1< G32 93:H <05 95;53259.:195: => <05 C=<=:;B;65 G32 783A65 <= 255 <05 43:H59<:3165:18<05C19965=><05:=3975<=85D61D58;5 => 43:H18D <:3165: 18 <05 C19965 => <05 :=39 <05 3;;1958< 032 =;;7::59 389 :1C38<0 9159 5 >7:<05: ;=8<58959 <03< :1A7836 032 G:=8D6B 0569 <03< 95;53259 032 ;=8<:1A7<59<=<053;;1958<=86B=8<05D:=789<03<05G32 8=<0=6918D9:1E18D 61;58;5 05:5 12 8=C3<5:136<=4:=E5 <03<95;53259032;=8<:1A7<59<=<053;;1958<82744=:< => 012 ;=8<58<1=8 05 :56159 =8 <05 F79DC58< => =8@A65 45I =7:< 18 <05 ;325 => 05:5>=:5 05 032 ;=8<58959 <03< <05 >18918D => <05 :1A7836 <03< 95;53259 032 ;=8<:1A7<59 "$J <= <05 3;;1958<1278272<3183A65 A* 8 :5245;< => K738<7C 05 032 ;=8<58959 <03< 3<<05<1C5=><053;;1958<95;53259G323D593A=7<!" - 7 - B53:2 5 G32 53:818D => 2"$$$ . 45: C=8<0 05 :1A7836032322522598=<1=83618;=C5=><0595;532593< 2$$$$ .45:C=8<0G01;012=8<056=G5:2195 ;* 5;=896B 32 45: <05 63G 6319 9=G8 AB <05 =8@A6574:5C5=7:<18<05;325=>! " #$ % " & ' ( $ ) **) + 18 ;325 <05 95;53259 G32 256>.5C46=B59 =: =8 3 >1I592363:B383991<1=8=>"J=><0552<3A61205918;=C5 <=G3:92 ?>7<7:5 4:=245;<2@ 20=769 A5 <05 G3::38< G05:5 <05 95;53259 G32 A56=G <05 3D5 => "$ B53:2 05 23C5 20366A5;=82195:59 9* 01:96B3245:<0563G63199=G8AB<05=8@A65 74:5C5 =7:< 18 <05 ;325 => ' ( )274:3* <05 ;631C38<2 3:5 58<1<659 >=: 2"$$$ . <=G3:92 ?6=22 => 52<3<5@3892"$$$ .<=G3:92?>785:365I458252@ 5* %=7:<06B 32 45: <05 F79DC58< => <05 =8@A65 74:5C5=7:<18<05;325=>, - #$ % " & ! . ) + 53;0 => <05 ;631C38<2 3:5 58<1<659 >=: ;=C45823<1=8 => 2!$$$$ . - 8 - 7895: <05 0539 => ?6=22 => 6=E5 389 3>>5;<1=8 389 ;=82=:<17C@ >* 32<6B;=82195:18D<053D53893E=;3<1=8=><05 95;53259 <05 =E5:366 ;=C45823<1=8 3G3:959 AB <05 :1A783612=8<056=G5:219558;5054:3B2>=:366=G18D <05344536 :1 7A0320 366347: 653:859 ;=78256 34453:18D >=: <05 827:38;5 =C438B ;=8<58959 <03<<053;;1958<032=;;7::59975<=<0585D61D58;5=><05 95;53259 32 G566 32 <05 9:1E5: => <05 <:3;<=: 05 ;631C38<203E58=<1C4653959<059:1E5:3891827:5:=><05 <:3;<=: 32 3 43:<B 05 25;=89 :524=8958< 1827:5: 12 1827:59 G1<0 =86B 25;=89 <:3165: A53:18D :5D12<:3<1=8 =.$ .$ 05:5>=:505;=8<58959<03<=G85:=> <05<:3;<=:32G56632<051827:5:=><05<:3;<=:03E5<=A5 C395613A65>=:85D61D58;5 3* 5>7:<05:;=8<58959<03<<05 :1A7836>31659<= ;=82195: <03< <05 9:1E5: => <05 <:3;<=: 12 85D61D58< 18 ;37218D <05 3;;1958< E58 1> 1< 12 0569 <03< 1< 12 3 - 9 - ;=C4=21<5 85D61D58;5 61A5:<B C3B A5 :525:E59 <= <05 1827:5: => <05 <:3165: A53:18D :5D12<:3<1=8 =.$ . $<=181<13<52543:3<54:=;55918D23D3182<<059:1E5:=> <05 <:3;<=: 389 1827:5: 8 2744=:< => 012 ;=8<58<1=8 05 032:56159=8F79DC58<=>=8@A6545I=7:<18<05;325 => ( !/ $ % " 0 ( &" *1) A* 8 :5245;< => K738<7C => ;=C45823<1=8 05 ;=8<58959<03<5E58<0=7D0;631C38<203E5;631C59<03< <05 95;53259 G32 53:818D 2"$$$ . 45: C=8<0 <05B 03E58=<4:=97;5938B9=;7C58<<=52<3A6120<0523C5 05:5>=:5 :1A7836 032 5::59 18 32252218D <05 8=<1=836 18;=C5=><0595;532593<2$$$$ .45:C=8<0G01;0 12=8<0501D05:2195 ;* 32<6B 05 ;=8<58959 <03< ;=82195:18D <05 C3<5:136 3E3163A65 =8 :5;=:9 <05 =E5:366 ;=C45823<1=8 3G3:959 AB <05 :1A7836 12 =8 <05 01D05: 2195 389 <05:5>=:5054:3B59>=:912C12236=><05344536 - 10 - 53:9 <05 653:859 ;=78256 >=: <05 43:<152 389 45:7259<05F79DC58<3893G3:9=><05 :1A7836 , 05;325=><05;631C38<212<03<=8$,$! 3< 3A=7< $" 4C <05 95;53259 G32 9:1E18D 3 C=<=:;B;65A53:18D:5D12<:3<1=8 =. .<=G3:92 1F347: >:=C 1H=<3 2195 3< <03< <1C5 3 <:3;<=: 389 <G= <:3165:2 G5:5 G:=8D6B 43:H59 18 <05 C19965 => <05 :=39 05:5 G5:5 8= 1891;3<=:2 <= <05 632< <:3165: A53:18D :5D12<:3<1=8 =.$ .$18;5 1< G32 5E5818D <05 43:H18D=><05<:3;<=:389<:3165:G328=<E121A65389<05:5 G5:5 8= 2<=85 >58;18D 389 8= 1891;3<=:2 1891;3<18D <05 43:H18D=><05E501;65 05:195:=><05C=<=:;B;6501<<05 632< <:3165: 75 <= <05 1C43;< 05 27>>5:59 18F7:152 389 27;;7CA59<=<0518F7:152 05 :1A7836=8344:5;13<1=8=> 9=;7C58<3:B389=:365E1958;5=><0543:<152032D1E583 ;653: >18918D <03< <05 3;;1958< 032 =;;7::59 975 <= 85D61D58;5=><05<:3165:A53:18D:5D12<:3<1=8 =.$ . $ 18;5 <:3165: G32 G:=8D6B 43:H59 18 <05 C19965 => <05:=3918<0581D0<<05:5G5:58=1891;3<=:2<=<05632< - 11 - <:3165:3898=61D0<25<18389<05:5G328=2<=85>58;18D <= 1891;3<5 <05 43:H59 E501;65 8 241<5 => D1E18D 27;0 3 >18918D =86B A5;3725 ;03:D5 2055< 032 A558 >1659 3D3182< <0595;53259>=:8=<0=6918D39:1E18D61;58;5"$J=><05 ;=8<:1A7<=:B 85D61D58;5 032 A558 >32<5859 =8 <05 95;53259 $ 05 =8@A65 45I =7:< 18 ;325 => 0569 <03< <0=7D0 9:1E18D E501;65 G1<0=7<61;58;512 38=>>58;5A7<23C5AB1<256>C3B8=< 6539 <= 3 >18918D => 85D61D58;5 32 :5D3:92 <05 3;;1958< 05 :565E38< 43:3D:3402 3:5 43:3D:340 =2 389 , 389 <0523C53:55I<:3;<5905:57895:>=:532B:5>5:58;5 L 8 !!"#$1<G320569<03< %& '!( )) ' * )) *+( , -. * )) * + ( +). . + -. * ( )) * +). / +). -. 0 -.*(*.() . -. * .) - 12 - ) *(/ -. . 0 1 * 0 * +). * .( 1 * 0 * +). .+ ** -.)) * . * + )) )) *-.+ 0. . *. 0 )) , -. ) * ( )) ( * .() .*. ( 0 * )) 0 .() 0 0 ( * - .. . 0 )) "*++ . . . * . ( ( *( . )) )) . . . )) ( -. ( ( * + )) 0 ( . + -. ( + )) . * + + 0* . .1* 0 0 )) * + -. ( *0 * ' ( )) ' + 0 ( * )) + 232 0 (. 0)1(. 1 * 0 )) * . 0 .. * 0+ ( )) . 0 - 13 - )) 4)! *. .% 5/* . + (( ** ( 0 * ( . *.) * )) ). ./ 0.0 0+ + . * ( 6 + + .) .))/ ) + ) 0*.)** 0.+ .)+7+ .))/* + .) . )) + 0. .+* + 0 + ) +. 0.0)* 0)) 8 E58 <05 =8@A65 45I =7:< 18 ;325 => ," 2 ! " # $ % " 0 ( & "+ *) + 0569 <03< <05 >3;< <03< 3 45:2=8 G32 3 41661=8 :195: =8 3 C=<=:;B;6536=8DG1<0<059:1E5:389=85C=:545:2=8=8 <05 41661=8 C3B A5 3 E1=63<1=8 => <05 63G 7< 27;0 E1=63<1=8AB1<256>G1<0=7<38B<018DC=:5;388=<6539<=3 >18918D => ;=8<:1A7<=:B 85D61D58;5 786522 1< 12 52<3A612059 - 14 - <03< 012 E5:B 3;< => :1918D 36=8D G1<0 <G= =<05:2 ;=8<:1A7<5951<05:<=<053;;1958<=:<=<051C43;<=><05 3;;1958<74=8<05E1;<1C 05:5128=>18918DAB<05 :1A7836<=4:=E5<03< <05 95;53259 032 ;=8<:1A7<59 <= <05 3;;1958< 05:5>=:5 >18918D => <05 :1A7836 <= <05 5I<58< <03< 95;53259 032 ;=8<:1A7<59"$J<=<053;;1958<12613A65<=A525<32195 ;;=:918D6B1<1225<32195 0=7D0<05;631C38<2 ;631C <03<95;53259 G32 53:818D 2"$$$ . 45: C=8<0 <05B 03E5 8=< 4:=97;59 38B 9=;7C58< <= 4:=E5 <05 18;=C5 => <05 95;53259 8 <053A258;5=>4:==>=>18;=C5<058=<1=83618;=C5032<= A5 32252259 2 45: <05 D719561852 122759 AB <05 3:83<3H3<3<55D365:E1;527<0=:1<B>=:<053;;1958< <3H58463;5 18<05 B53: $! <058=<1=836 18;=C5 => <05 95;53259 032 <= A5 <3H58 3< 2$$$$ . 4C = <05 3>=:52319 18;=C5 "J 032 <= A5 39959 =8 3;;=78< => >7<7:5 4:=245;<2 18 E15G => <05 63G 6319 9=G8 AB <05 =82<1<7<1=858;0=><0574:5C5=7:<183' (4 - 15 - )274:3* 072<05C=8<06B18;=C5;=C52<=2"$$ . 18;5<05:53:521I95458958<21<12344:=4:13<5<=9597;< !<0 => <05 18;=C5 => <05 95;53259 <=G3:92 45:2=836 5I458252 389 :5C31818D 3C=78< 032 <= A5 <3H58 32 012 ;=8<:1A7<1=8<=<05>3C16B 0595;53259G323D593A=7< !" B53:2 3< <05 <1C5 => <05 3;;1958< 389 C76<14615: 34461;3A65<=0123D5D:=7412?!@ 072<05;631C38<23:5 58<1<659 <= ;=C45823<1=8 => 2""$$$ . )2,"MM!*=83;;=78<=>?6=22=>95458958;B@ ! 8 3991<1=8 <05 ;631C38<2 3:5 58<1<659 <= ;=C45823<1=8=>2"$$$ .=83;;=78<=>?6=22=>52<3<5@ 389 ;=C45823<1=8 => 2"$$$ . =8 3;;=78< => ?>785:36 5I458252@ " 8 E15G => <05 63G 6319 9=G8 AB <05 74:5C5 =7:<18<05;325=>3, - #$ %4)274:3* ;631C38< =2 389 3:5 43:58<2 => <05 95;53259 3:5 58<1<659 <= ;=C45823<1=8 => 2!$$$$ . 53;0 7895: <05 0539 => /6=22 => >16136 ;=82=:<17C/ ;631C38< = G1>5 => <05 95;53259 12 58<1<659 <= ;=C45823<1=8 => 2!$$$$ . - 16 - 7895: <05 0539 => ?6=22 => 24=7236 ;=82=:<17C@ 389 ;631C38< =2!<=;0169:58=><0595;532593:558<1<659 <= ;=C45823<1=8 => 2!$$$$ . 53;0 7895: <05 0539 => ?6=22=>43:58<36;=82=:<17C@ 072<05;631C38<23:558<1<659<=<05>=66=G18D ;=C45823<1=8 *+,-./01-2-3,4 31,4,-0,/3. *2-01- '.( =22=>95458958;B )"$$INII!* ""$$$ . %785:365I458252 "$$$ . =22=>52<3<5 "$$$ . =22=>24=7236;=82=:<17C !$$$$ . =22=>&3:58<36;=82=:<17C $$$$ . =22=>%16136;=82=:<17C $$$$ . 0/5 " "6 8<05:5276<<05>=66=G18D=:95:12432259 3* 0534453612/557,31-+/40 A* 05 F79DC58< => <05 631C2 :1A7836 12C=91>159 - 17 - ;* 05 ;631C38<2 3:5 58<1<659 <= 3 <=<36 ;=C45823<1=8 => ." "6 32 3D3182< 2$$$$ .3G3:959AB<05 :1A7836 9* 05827:38;5=C438B1291:5;<59<= 954=21< <05 58<1:5 ;=C45823<1=8 3C=78< 36=8D G1<018<5:52<3<J43>:=C<0593<5=>>1618D=> <05 ;631C 45<1<1=8 <166 <05 93<5 => :5361O3<1=8 G1<018 3 45:1=9 => 21I G55H2 >:=C <05 93<5 => :5;514<=>;=4B=><012F79DC58< 5* 8:5245;<=>;=8<58<1=8:31259AB<05 827:38;5 =C438B <03< 1827:5: => <05 :3165: A53:18D :5D12<:3<1=8 =.$ .$ <05:5 12 ;=C4=21<5 85D61D58;5 A5<G558 <05 <:3;<=: 389 <:3165:261A5:<BC3BA5:525:E59<=<051827:5:=> <05 :3165: A53:18D :5D12<:3<1=8 =.$ . $ <= >165 3 2543:3<5 ;325 >=: :5;=E5:B >:=C <05=G85:=>=<05:E501;65G01;0G3218E=6E5918 <05 3;;1958< 15 <05 =G85: => 8D185 =. $ .$ 389 :3165: 03212 =$ > 27;0 3 45<1<1=8 12 >1659 <05 :136 =7:< 12 91:5;<59 <= 95;195 <05 C3<<5: 1895458958<6B G1<0=7< A518D 18>6758;59AB<05>18918DD1E58AB<05 :1A783618 :5245;<=>85D61D58;512275 - 18 - >* 8 E15G => <05 F79DC58< => <05 45I =7:< 18 <05 ;325 => ( )274:3* 27;0 61A5:<B 12 :525:E59 <= <05 :524=8958< = <= 181<13<5 2543:3<5 4:=;55918D2 >=: :5;=E5:B >:=C <05=G85:=>=<05:E501;65G01;0G3218E=6E5918 <05 3;;1958< 15 <05 =G85: => 8D185 =. $ .$ 389 :3165: 03212 =$ 18 3;;=:938;5G1<063G1>63G45:C1<2 36 '# ( % 36 '!%&!( % # 12< =6 =