Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 64205 (KAR)
BASAVARAJ S/O SHANKAREPPA KUMBAR v. CHANDRASHEKAR S/O SANGAPPA TALIKOTI
RSA/200001/2021 · 2025-11-14
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64205 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64205 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#"$"" %%
&%'
(
! " #$$ "
$##$$ %$#& ' "
(
"
""
"
) $#
$&#$$#&
"
! " ! "
"
! "
! Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
" "
! *
$"
*
+, -..,//-012./-301344 35 6,478, 1+35 7981 6,30: -::83,;,<6=1+,>9<:?,01-0<<,@8,,<-1,<$##$$ .-55,<307%$#&701+,43/,74,03783;3/9<:, '"9<<,63+-/4785+781A1+,"3851..,//-1,7981* 6= B+3@+ 1+, "3851 ..,//-1, 7981 B+3/, -//7B30: 1+, -..,-/43/,<6=1+,<,4,0<-0128,5.70<,01+,8,305,1-53<, 1+, >9<:?,01 -0< <,@8,, <-1,< $&#$$#& .-55,< 30 7) $# 70 1+, 43/, 74 3;3/ 9<:, ' " 9<<,63+-/4785+781A1+,83-/7981C-0<@705,D9,01/= <35?355,<1+,5931
+, -67;, 5931 35 43/,< 6= 1+, ./-301344 5,,E30: 8,/3,474<,@/-8-1370.755,55370-0<@705,D9,013-/8,/3,474 30>90@1370 -:-3051 1+, <,4,0<-01 @701,0<30: 1+-1 70, -0:-..- 57 3;-/30:-..- -/3E713 +-< 1B7 B3;,5
- 3 -
0-?,/= -0:96-3 -0< 95+3/-6-3 "87? +35 43851 B34,2 -0:96-3-5706=0-?,+0<8-5+,E+-82<,4,0<-01+,8,30 B-5 6780 -0:96-32#51 B34, <3,< 30 1+, =,-8 #&F% /,-;30:6,+30<<,4,0<-012+-0<8-5,E+-841,81+,<,?35, 74 +35 43851 B34, -0:-..- ?-883,< 95+3/-6-3 "87? +35 5,@70< B34,295+3/-6+-3 - 570 6= 0-?, -5-;-8-> B-5 6780 B+7 -/57 .-55,< -B-= 30 1+, =,-8 #&& B31+791 /,-;30:6,+30<-0=+,385
# -0:-..- B-5 B78E30: -5 -0 11,0<,8 30 -:-/E71 7981 -0< +, <3,< 70 $&$F#&% 41,8 +35 <,-1+ <,4,0<-012+-0<8-5,E+-8 B-5 -..7301,< -5 11,0<,8 70 - @7?.-55370-1,8= :8790< 30 #&& 95+3/-6+-321+, 5,@70< B34, 74 -0:-..- B-5 8,@,3;30: 1+, .,05370 -?7901 95+3/-6+-3 .-55,< -B-= 70 $#$$$&-19@+-6-/;3//-:,
9830: +,8 /34,13?, 5+, +-< .98@+-5,< /-0< 6,-830: =7## ?,-59830: -@8,5 478 - 59?
74 5#G$$$2301,8?574-8,:351,8,<,,<74-/,<-1,<
- 4 -
#&$$$F -0< 5+, -/57 7B0,< - +795, 6,-830: 7)$ -1 9@+-6-/ ;3//-:, -0< 5+, -/57 +-< <,.7531,< @,81-30 -?79015 30 1+, -80-1-E- -0E -/3E713 30 "3H,< ,.75315
) +-1 1+, ./-301344 35 1+, 570 74 ,/<,8 5351,8 74 95+3/-6-3/-301344+-<1-E,0@-8,74<,@,-5,<295+3/-6-3 <9830: +,8 /34,13?, -0< -/57 30@988,< +9:, ?,<3@-/ ,H.,05,5 74 95+3/-6-3 +-1 30 @7053<,8-1370 74 +35 5,8;3@,5-0<-/57/7;,-0<-44,@137017B-8<5+3?5+,+-< ,H,@91,<-!3//<-1,<#&$$$&6,D9,-1+30:+,8,0138, .87.,813,5 30 +35 4-;798 +, B3// B-5 ,H,@91,< 30 1+, .8,5,0@, 74 B310,55,5 +-1 !3// B-5 B8311,0 6= 70,
38,?-1+743>-=-.98-01,8?5741+,/-51!3//5931 5@+,<9/, .87.,813,5 B,8, 6,D9,-1+,< 30 1+, 0-?, 74 1+, ./-301344 -657/91,/= +-1 1+, 5-3< 95+3/-6+-3 +-< <,.7531,<1+, 783:30-/!3// B31+70, +3;-5+-8-0- -13/74 703;3//-:,0<31-/9E
- 5 -
+, <,4,0<-01 B31+791 +-;30: -0= 83:+1 131/, -0<301,8,517;,81+,5931.87.,81=+-<761-30,<+350-?, ,01,8,<301+,8,;,09,8,@78<5-0<B-518=30:17,0@-5+ 1+, "3H,< ,.7531 -?79015 70 1+, 6-535 74 @,81-30 <7@9?,015 @/-3?30: 17 6, 1+, 51,.2570 74 <,@,-5,<2 95+3/-6-3+,./-301344<9830:1+,?701+74-09-8=$# /,-801-6791,H,@9137074!3//30+354-;7986=95+3/-6-3 +-1-41,88,@,3.1741+,5-3<<7@9?,01487?3;-5+-8-0- -13/ 74 703 ;3//-:, +, 43/,< 1+, 5931 478 <,@/-8-1370 .755,55370-0<@705,D9,013-/8,/3,47430>90@1370
) ,4,0<-01 30 +35 B8311,0 51-1,?,01 <,03,< 1+, ./-301-;,8?,0155.,@343@-//=-//,:30:1+-11+,./-301344+-< 43/,< - 5931 70 1+, 6-535 74 - 4-/5, 4-683@-1,< -0< @70@7@1,< !3// +-1 1+, <,4,0<-01 +-< .98@+-5,< 1+, .87.,81= 30 1+, 0-?, 74 <,@,-5,<295+3/-6-3 -5 +, B-5 1+,7;,80?,01,8;-01559@+1+-11+,?71+,8741+, <,4,0<-01 +-< 071 30;,51,< -0= ?70,= -0< 5+, B-5 071 1+, -657/91, 7B0,8 74 1+, .87.,81= ,0@, 579:+1 478 <35?355-/741+,5931
- 6 -
+,83-/79816-5,<701+,./,-<30:548-?,<1+, 47//7B30:3559,5
!
"
#
$ %&&&% '
" (
$ %&&&%
#
"
)
*
" +"
G /-301344 ,H-?30,< +3?5,/4 -5 !# -0< ,H+3631,< $ <7@9?,015 -5
H# 17
H$ B7 B310,55,5 +-;, 6,,0 ,H-?30,< -5 !2 -0< !2) ,4,0<-01 ,H-?30,< +3?5,/4 -5 !2# -0< ?-8E,< <7@9?,015 -5
H# 17
H 0 -..8,@3-1370 74 ,;3<,0@,1+,183-/7981<,@8,,<1+,5931-5.8-=,<478
- 7 -
,30: -::83,;,< <,4,0<-01 .8,4,88,< 1+, 8,:9/-8-..,-/307%$#&6,478,1+,43851-..,//-1, 7981"3851-..,//-1,798148-?,<1+,47//7B30:.73015478 315@7053<,8-1370
'
%&&%"
'
' %&&&%
" ( *#
"
"
-0< 70 8,2-..8,@3-1370 -05B,8,< 1+, .7301 7# 30 1+, 0,:-13;, -0< .7301 75 -0< ) 30 1+, -4438?-13;, 705,D9,01/=-//7B,<1+,-..,-/5,1-53<,1+,>9<:?,01 -0< <,@8,, .-55,< 6= 183-/ 7981 -0< <35?355,< 1+,5931 ,30:-::83,;,<1+,./-301344356,478,1+357981 F +35 7981 6= 78<,8 <-1,< $#$# 48-?,< 1+,47//7B30:59651-013-/D9,5137074/-B
- 8 -
,
-* #
#
)
'# . /( 0
)%+
/1 0
2
)13"
% 83 9:95130 /,-80,< @7905,/ -..,-830: 478 1+, ./-301344-..,//-01 1-E30: 1+35 7981 1+879:+ 1+, 8,@78<5596?311+-11+,<,@,-5,<95+3/-6-3B-51+,51,.2 ?71+,8 74 <,4,0<-01 +-1 1+,8, B-5 @,81-30 -03?7531= 6,1B,,0<,@,-5,<95+3/-6-3-0<1+,<,4,0<-015770-41,8 1+, <,?35, 74 -0:-..- +-1 -1 -0 90<35.91,< .7301 74 13?, 95+3/-6-3 -0< <,4,0<-01 +-< -883;,< -1 @,81-30 90<,851-0<30: 30 1,8?5 74 B+3@+ - <7@9?,01 E07B0 -5 A<,@/-8-1370C@-?,176,,H,@91,<6=<,4,0<-01:3;30:9. -// -0< -0= 74 +35 @/-3?
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
-..,-/ -0< <35?35530: 1+, 5931 ,0@, 596?315 1+-1 1+, 59651-013-/ D9,5137074/-B6,-05B,8,<30-4438?-13;,-0<<35?3551+, -..,-/ #) ,-8<,895,<1+,8,@78<5 # 83 -0:-..- -/3E71, B-5 30313-//= ?-883,< 17 70, -0:96-3 ,4,0<-01 B-5 6780 791 74 1+, 5-3< ?-883-:,-0:96-3.-55,<-B-=301+,=,-8#&F%.70 +,8<,?35,-0:-..-?-883,<95+3/-6-35706=0-?, -5-;-8-> B-5 6780 17 -0:-..- 791 74 1+, 5,@70< ?-883-:,B31+95+3/-6-3-0:-..--/3E71,.-55,<-B-= 70$&$F#&% 355,@70<570-5-;-8->487?1+,5,@70< ?-883-:, .-55,< -B-= 70 $G#&& 7 1+,8,478, 70/= 598;3;30: +,385 74 -0:-..- -/3E71, -8, 95+3/-6-3 -0< <,4,0<-012+-0<8-5,E+-8 - 13 - #G H$35+,-;3/=8,/3,<9.706=1+,@7905,/478 1+,./-301344-..,//-01 17.73017911+, -03?7531=6,1B,,0 95+3/-6-3 -0< +-0<8-5,E+-8 ,895-/ 74 1+, 5-3< <7@9?,01 30<3@-1, 1+-1 <,4,0<-012+-0<8-5+,E+-8 +-< <,@/-8,< 1+-1 9.70 1+, <,?35, 74 +35 4-1+,8 1+, 5,8;3@, 6,0,4315 +-;, 6,,0 ,D9-//= 5+-8,< 6,1B,,0 95+3/-6-3 +3?5,/4-0<-5-;-8-> ,+-54981+,8<,@/-8,<1+-1+,+-5 07 @/-3? 478 1+, .,05370 -?7901 1+-1 35 .-=-6/, 17 95+3/-6-3-0<1+-1+,+-5-/57305189@1,<1+-11+,,0138, .,05370-?79016,.-3<1795+3/-6-3135-/57708,@78< 1+-1 <,4,0<-01 B-5 :3;,0 -..7301?,01 70 @7?.-55370-1, :8790< 70 1+, <,?35, 74 -0:-..- -/3E71, 5 83:+1/= 1-E,0 071, 74 6= 1+, "3851 ..,//-1, 7981 -1 1+, 13?, B+,0 1+, 5-3< <7@9?,01 B-5 ,H,@91,< <,4,0<-01 B-5 -:,< #& =,-85 1 35 071 90@7??70 1+-1 B+,0 1+,8, -8, @/-3?54781+,<,-1+2@9?28,138,?,016,0,4315-?70:511+, +,38574-0,?./7=,,.-813@9/-85B+7+-..,0,<176,51,. ?71+,8 -0< 51,. 570 @,81-30 -88-0:,?,015 B79/< <,43031,/=6,?-<,-0<301+,3051-01@-5,530@,<,4,0<-01
- 14 -
B-5:3;,0@7?.-55370-1,-..7301?,0131B-50-198-/1+-1 +, +-< :3;,0 1+, <,@/-8-1370 74 +, 071 @/-3?30: -0= .,05370-8= 6,0,4315 +, 5-3< <7@9?,01 @-0071 1+,8,478, 6, 1-E,0 3017 @7053<,8-1370 -5 1+,8, 6,30: - 518-30,< 8,/-13705+3. 6,1B,,0 <,@,-5,< 95+3/-6-3 -0< 1+, <,4,0<-01 # 7?30:171+,!3//.87.790<,<6=1+,./-301344 @-5,741+,./-301344351+-1+,/,-801-67911+,,H,@9137074 !3//<-1,<#&$$$&70/=301+,?701+74-09-8=$# -8-:8-.+F741+,./-3018,-<5-590<,8 I3
# 5
&#
' ,
6
4 7 89!:
) #
#
)
.
6
#F H@,.1 1+, -67;, 1+, ./-301344 +-5 071 :3;,0 -0= <,1-3/ B+-157,;,8 -5 17 1+, 5798@, 74 30478?-1370
- 15 -
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
- 16 -
6,,0 ,H-?30,< 70 $)$F$# -0< #$%$# 8,5.,@13;,/= +95 B+,0 1+, ./-301344 ,H-?30,< +3?5,/4 -0< 1B7 71+,8 B310,55,5 1+, 5@836, B-5 -/57 -/3;, +, 1B7 B310,55,5 !2 -0< !2) +-;, -<?311,< 1+-1 95+3/-6-3+-<078,/-13;,5303>-=-.98+-170/=1+,5-3< B310,55,5 -@@7?.-03,< 95+3/-6-3 17 3>-=-.98 478 ,H,@91370 74 !3// +, B310,55,5 +-;, -/57 -<?311,< 1+-1 8,:3518-1370 74 -0= <7@9?,01 B-5 17 6, <70, 30 9<<,63+-/ -0< 071 3>-=-.98 +, "3851 ..,//-1, 7981 +-5/3:+1/=1-E,0071,741+,4-@11+-11+,8,B-5078+=?, 788,-57047895+3/-6-317:7-//1+,B-=173>-=-.98- 518-0:, ./-@, 17 ,H,@91, 1+, !3// -/70: B31+ 518-0:, .,85705 $
"981+,8 !2 -0< !2) +-;, -<?311,< 1+-1 1+,= -8, 1+, @/75, 483,0<5 74 1+, ./-301344 -0< +-< 071 <35@/75,<-67911+,!3 $#171+,./-301344+3535=,1 -071+,8 @38@9?51-0@, B+3@+ 35 ;,8= 900-198-/ 0 1+-1 34 !2-0<!2)-8,1+,@/75,483,0<5741+,./-301344B+-1 .8,;,01,< 1+,? 487? 8,;,-/30: 1+, ,H,@91370 74 !3//
- 17 -
-1/,-51-41,81+,<,?35,7495+3/-6-3301+,=,-8$$&-0< 1+,=E,,.30:D931,13//1+,=,-8$# # ,1 -071+,8 -5.,@1 74 1+, ?-11,8 35 1+-1 671+ !2-0<!2)-8,-88-=,<-5-@@95,<.,8570530.,@3-/ -5,7)$#+-1301+,5-3<@-5,1+,=+-;,43/,<- ;-EE-/-1+ ?-8E,< -5
H# !) -/57 ,H,@91,< - 6-3/ 670<B+3@+-8,?-8E,<-5
H+,3853:0-198,5701+, ;-E-/-1+ 35 ?-8E,< -1 *+&,' &,' -0< 1+, 53:0-198, 4790< 70 5-3< ;-EE-/-1+ 35 30
0:/35+ B+3/, 1+, 53:0-198,4790<701+,-//,:,<!3//3530-00-<-
+95 1+, 53:0-198,5 74 !2 -0< !2) 4790< 70 1+,
H# 35 <344,8,01 -0< <35130@1 487?
1+-1 74 1+, 53:0-198, @/-3?,< 17 +-;, 6,,0 ?-<, 70 1+, 5-3< !3// 7053<,830:1+,6-@E:8790<741+,5-3<B310,55,5B+7-8, 30;7/;,< 30 1+, 5.,@3-/ @-5, -0< 1+,= +-;30: -443H,< <344,8,0153:0-198,301+,;-EE-/-1+-5B,//-5301+,670< 1+-0 1+-1 74 1+, 53:0-198, 4790< 70 1+, !3// 1+, 43851 -..,//-1, 7981 +-5 <,@/30,< 17 -@@,.1 1+, @38@9?51-0@,5 74,H,@9137074!3//176,6,=70<8,-570-6/,<7961
- 18 -
) +, 43851 -..,//-1, 7981 +-5 -/57 4790< 1+-1 1+,8, 35 07 >951343-6/, 8,-5705 478 95+3/-6-3 17 <3530+,831 1+,<,4,0<-01+357981@-0071430<-0=8,-57017<344,8 B31+1+,8,-5705-553:0,<-0<1+,@70@/95370-883;,<-16= 1+,43851-..,//-1,7981
5 83:+1/= .7301,< 791 6= /,-80,< @7905,/ 478 1+, <,4,0<-01 1+, 183-/ 7981 B31+791 -;,8130: 17 1+35 .830@3./, 8,D938,?,01 74 .87;30: 1+, !3// +-5 ?,8,/= :/755,< 7;,8 1+, ,;3<,0@, -0< +-5 7.30,< 1+-1 ?,8, ,H-?30-137074!2-0<!2)B-559443@3,0117.87;,1+, !3// G +, ;,8= >9<:?,01 74 1+, .,H 7981 8,/3,< 9.706=1+,@7905,/4781+,-..,//-01 @-5, 1+, .,H 7981 -1 .-8- #% +-5 8,31,8-1,<1+, .87.7531370 /-3<<7B06=1+,.,H7981301+,@-5,74 ;5 ! " J -- ) -8-:8-.+#%741+,5-3<>9<:?,0135,H18-@1,<+,8,90<,8 ,#$
; 0
8 :
- 19 -
' *# 5
# 5
! ; # # !)
0<%33-3)
=>;-
58 :)
? ,&
. *# -
<; 0
9 #*##
@A%+%B-< /? 8% #&'& ( )*&: -) C*
5)
? )
#
)
# # #
)
) ##
/(
. )
). /(2
)
'
)
* -
(D #
)
# #
#
# ' #
#
. #
#
#
)
#
- 20 -
-
'
# ) #
) *
) #
#
# '
##
#
## #
#)
#
# ' # #
#
)
#
'
'
)
# #
# #
+ 0
) ' #
*
# #
. #
-
)-
#
.
#
-
'
/ 0
) ) '
)
#)
)# '
#
- 21 -
#
#6
+,.87.753137075-0<G35-../3@-6/,171+, 4-@1-0<@38@9?51-0@,5741+,@-5,0-88-1,<-67;,30@, 1+, ./-301344 +-5 071 6,,0 -6/, 17 <,495, 1+, 595.3@3795 @38@9?51-0@,5 30 1+, ?-00,8 E07B0 17 /-B 31 @-0071 6, +,/<1+-1+,+-5.87;,<1+,!3//-58,D938,<90<,8/-B F +-1 -.-81 30 1+, 078?-/ @38@9?51-0@,5 <,4,0<-016,30:1+,0-198-/+,3874-0:-..-1+79:++, B-5 6780 17 +35 43851 B34, B79/< +-;, 6,,0 1+, 83:+149/ 7B0,8741+,596>,@1.87.,81=301+,-65,0@,7495+3/-6-3 /,-;30: 6,+30< -0= 71+,8 +,38 ./-301344 @-0071 90<,8 1+, :-86 74 5-3< !3// @/-3? 1+, 5931 5@+,<9/, .87.,813,5 +, 59651-013-/ D9,51370 74 /-B 35 1+,8,478, -05B,8,< -4438?-13;,/=3,1+,43851-..,-/7981>951343,<305,1130: -53<, 1+,>9<:?,01 -0<<,@8,,<-1,< $&#$$#& .-55,< 30 7) $# 6= 1+, 7981 74 1+, 3;3/ 9<:, -0<
"9<<,63+-/-0<<35?355,<1+,5931
- 22 -
% @@78<30:/= 8,:9/-8 5,@70< -..,-/ 35
"" +, >9<:?,01 -0< <,@8,, <-1,< $##$$ .-55,<307%$#&6=1+,7981741+,,03783;3/ 9<:,-0<"9<<,63+-/35@70438?,< & 01,83?-../3@-1370534-0=51-0<<35.75,<74 )$ ,4,0<-01 35 ,0131/,< 17 5,,E 8,/,-5, 74 1+, -?7901 B+3@+ B-5 <,.7531,< 30 1+, @8,<31 74 <,@,-5,< 95+3/-6-3
./ &""' $
3517#/7%