- 1 - !" #$%$$ $&& ' '(&)* ')) + !" # $ %% & " % % %% %% ' % "( (( # $ %% %' ") & Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % ' *+$& ' % % ",(*(" % $ & ("* % % ' ' % % % % - %$ $% - & ./ 011/22034 5/637 0889:/; <" 63 1/8602 0:/ = >< ("*<34./?62/<?4./2/0@3/;;;646<302 /::6<3:9;7/'= >6A0B019@0$?<@:.<@4 C@602<9@4D&6:6E19736374./A9;7E/34<?8<3F6846<303; <@;/@ <? :/34/38/ ;04/; ",(*(" 8<3F684637 .6E ?<@ 4./<??/38/:1936:.052/93;/@/846<3:!!03;++<?4./ 3;603/302<;/$?<@:.<@4-4./-&03;/846<3:$"& 03; ! <? @<4/846<3 <? .62;@/3 ?@<E /G902 ??/38/ 84 $?<@ :.<@4 C D& 03; :/34/38637 4< 93;/@7< 6E1@6:<3E/34?<@"(B/0@:03;10B0?63/<?:((( - 3 - ?<@ 4./ <??/38/ 1936:.052/ 93;/@ /846<3 !! <? ) 4< 93;/@7< 6E1@6:<3E/34 ?<@ B/0@: 03; 10B 0 ?63/ <? :"(((( ?<@4./<??/38/1936:.052/93;/@/846<3++ <?)4<93;/@7<@67<@<9:6E1@6:<3E/34?<@(B/0@:?<@ 4./<??/38/93;/@/846<3$"&1936:.052/93;/@/846<3! <? 8403;10B0?63/<?:(((( H64.;/?0924 :/34/38/:H.62/08I96446370889:/;<:4<+ @6/??084:<?4./80:/0@/4.045/6374./ ?04./@ <? 4./ F6846E 76@2 2<;7/; ?6@:4 63?<@E046<3 0: 1/@ G"07063:40889:/;<"4<+?<@.0F6378<EE644/;4./ <??/38/: 1936:.052/ 93;/@ /846<3 ! *!$&$6& J $A& +,*<?03;/846<3:+03;!<? 8403;/846<3 ,$8&<?@/F/346<3<?.62;0@@607/84./@/:1<3;/34 <268/0?4/@@/76:4/@6374./80:/63@6E/< (".0F/ 93;/@40K/3 63F/:467046<3 03; ?62/; 8.0@7/:.//4 07063:4 0889:/;<:"4<+?<@4./05<F/:06;<??/38/: 46:4./8<34/346<3<?4./1@<:/8946<34.04<3 (,(!(" 0889:/; <" ?<@8652B K6;3011/; 4./ F6846E - 4 - ?@<E 4./ 89:4<;B <? ./@ 790@;603 <3 .6: E<4<@8B82/ 5/0@637 @/76:4@046<3 < (,! 03; 4.9: 8<EE644/; 4./ <??/38/ 1936:.052/ 93;/@ /846<3 !! <? 889:/;<"H@<37?922B8<3?63/;./@5BK//1637./@ 630@/34/;1@/E6:/:03;4./@/5B8<EE644/;<??/38/93;/@ /846<3 ++ <? ?4/@ K6;3011637 03; H@<37?922B 8<3?63637 4./ F6846E H.< 6: E63<@ 76@2 H64. 4./ ./21 <? 0889:/; < 0889:/; <" 8<EE644/; 077@0F04/; 1/3/4@046F/ :/G902 0::0924 @/1/04/;2B ?<@ 0 1/@6<; <? E<34.:03;4./@/5B8<EE644/;<??/38/1936:.052/93;/@ /846<303;!<? 8446:02:<4./8<34/346<3<? 4./1@<:/8946<34.040889:/;<".0;?<@8652BK6;3011/; 4./ F6846E <3(,(!("H64.4././21 <? 0889:/; <: 4<+K3<H637?922BH/224.04:./6:0E63<@07/;"*B/0@: ./@/5B ./.0:8<EE644/; 4./<??/38/1936:.052/ 93;/@ /846<3:"!03;"*<?4./ 84 + < 1@<F/ 4.6: 8<34/346<3 4./ 1@<:/8946<3 /G0E63/; :" 4< " 7<4 E0@K/; G:" 4< " ./ 0889:/;.0:;/36/;022638@6E6304637E04/@6020F062052/<3 - 5 - @/8<@;63.6::404/E/3493;/@/846<3"<?@594 .0:3<42/;03B/F6;/38/63:911<@4<?4./6@;/?/38/ ./ @602 <9@4 0?4/@ 40K637 634< 8<3:6;/@046<3 022 4./:/ E04/@602<3@/8<@; 80E/ 4< 4./8<3829:6<3 4.04 4./ 1@<:/8946<3 6: :988/::?92 63 1@<F637 4./ 79624 <? 4./ 0889:/; ?<@ 4./ <??/38/: 93;/@ /846<3: !! 03; ++ <? 03;/846<3!<? 8407063:40889:/;<"03; 088<@;6372B8<3F684/;03;:/34/38/;.6E0::404/;05<F/ H.62/08I96446370889:/;<:4<+ /637077@6/F/;5B 4./:0E/0889:/;<"6:5/?<@/4.6:<9@4 ! %/0@; @6 .6F0303; 04403:./446 2/0@3/; 8<93:/2 ?<@ 4./ 011/22034 03; @6 0E0;0@ .0.059;;63 2/0@3/; %67. <9@4 <F/@3E/34 2/0;/@ ?<@ @/:1<3;/34 <"404/ 3?<@49304/2B 4./ 2/0@3/; 8<93:/2 ?<@ 4./ 011/2203403;2/0@3/;%67.<9@4<F/@3E/342/0;/@0@/ 3<46301<:646<34<0::6:44./<9@405<944./?084:<?4./ 80:/ - 6 - * /@9:/;4./E04/@602:63829;6374./@602<9@4 @/8<@;: 3F6/H<?4./8<34/346<3:@06:/;634./1/4646<3 4./1<6344.04H<92;0@6:/?<@EB8<3:6;/@046<36: B03:H/@4<4./05<F/1<6346:634./ ?<@4./?<22<H637 , 3646022B H.< 6: 4./ ?04./@ <? 4./ F6846E 2<;7/; 4./ ?6@:4 63?<@E046<3 0: 1/@ G" :1/86?68022B :404637 4.04 64 H0: 011/22034 <" 03; "( H.< .0F/ K6;3011/;.6:E63<@;097.4/@03;8<EE644/;4./<??/38/ %<H/F/@ H.62/ ?62637 4./ 8.0@7/:.//4 "( 6: 864/; 0: 1@<:/8946<3 H643/:: G ;04/; "(+(" 6: 4./ E6::6378<E1206342<;7/;5B"(H.<6::06;4<5/4./ - 7 - .9:503; <? 4./ F6846E 3 4./ 50:6: <? G 80:/ 63 @6E/ <( (" 80E/ 4< 5/ @/76:4/@/; 04/@ 4./ 1@/:/34 8<E120634 63 @6E/ < (" 80E/ 4< 5/ 2<;7/;G+6:4./:404/E/34<?4./F6846E@/8<@;/;5B 4./ 2/0@3/; 076:4@04/ 93;/@ /846<3 "!+ <? @ H./@/4./F6846E022/7/;8<EE6::6<3<?<??/38/5B"( ./@ .9:503; 03; :1/86?68022B :404/; 4.04 4./ 011/22034 0889:/; <" .0; 3<4 8<EE644/; 03B <??/38/ 07063:4 ./@ ./3 4./ F6846E 6: /G0E63/; 0: " :./ .0:76F/307<5B/4<4./:404/E/3493;/@/846<3"!+<? @ 4< :404/ 4.04 "( .0; 3<4 8<EE644/; 03B <??/38/ 594 64 H0: 0889:/; <" H.< 8<EE644/; 4./ <??/38/706363./@?9@4./@8.6/?/G0E63046<3:./:404/: 4.04 64 H0: "( H.< K6;3011/; ./@ 03; 8<EE644/; 077@0F04/; 1/3/4@046F/ :/G902 0::0924 ?4/@ :98. 6386;/34:./E0@@6/;4<"(03;:./H0:@/:6;637H64. .6E "( "* 6: 4./ <84<@ H.< /G0E63/; 4./ F6846E 03;6::9/;/;6802/@46?6804/0:1/@G"+:1/@4.6: - 8 - ;<89E/34 4./@/ 0@/ :673: <? :/G902 634/@8<9@:/ 0: 4./ .BE/3H0:@9149@/;4H0:1/@463/344<3<4/4.040:1/@ 4.//;6802/@46?6804/07/<?4./F6846EH0:E<@/4.03" B/0@:5942/::4.03(B/0@:./1@<:/8946<36:1208637 @/26038/ <3 4./ /F6;/38/ <? "* 03; 4./ /;6802 /@46?6804/G"+088<@;6374<H.68.4./F6846E6:E<@/ 4.03 " B/0@: ;< 3<4 ?63; 03B @/0:<3 ?<@ 4./ 1@<:/8946<34<63F<K/4./1@<F6:6<3:<? 84 "" " 63 ./@ /F6;/38/ .0: :404/; 4.04 0889:/; <"H0::9112B637:03;?<@8<3:4@9846<3<?4./.<9:/5B ./@ ?04./@ .9: :./ ;/F/2<1/; 6346E08B H64. 0889:/; <" %/ 4<<K ./@ <3 E<4<@8B82/ 03; 0889:/; <+ 0@@037/;0@/34/;.<9:/H./@/:./:40B/;H64.0889:/; <" ?<@ 4H< E<34.: 9@637 4.6: 1/@6<; ./ 8<EE644/; 077@0F04/;1/3/4@046F/:/G9020::0924<3./@./:404/: 4.04 0889:/; <: 03; .0F/ 3<4 8<EE644/; 03B <??/38/ ./ 02:< :404/: 4.04 H./3 :./ E0@@6/; "( 5/?<@/4.6:6386;/34:./H0:07/;"*4<" B/0@:?022 4./:/E04/@602:5<4.<@0203;;<89E/340@B/F6;/38/0@/ - 9 - 40K/3634<8<3:6;/@046<34./@/0@/:/@6<9:638<3:6:4/386/: 634./:404/E/34<?4./F6846E@/8<@;/;93;/@/846<3"!+ <?@E0@K/;0:G+03;./@/F6;/38/2/;0:" 2:< 4./@/ 6: :/@6<9: 638<3:6:4/38B 5/4H//3 G"+ L /;6802 /@46?6804/ 03; G, L 8.<<2 /@46?6804/ @/70@;637 ;04/ <? 56@4. 6::9/; 5B "" 88<@;637 4< H.68.:./H0:<32B"*B/0@:<?07/044./46E/<?022/7/; <??/38/./3:98.638<3:6:4/38B6:?<93;634.//F6;/38/ 2/; 5B 4./ 1@<:/8946<3 03; H./3 " .0: 8.037/; ./@ F/@:6<3@/70@;6378<EE6::6<3<?4./<??/38/:5B"(<@ 5B0889:/;<"03;.0:07063;/36/;8<EE6::6<3<?4./ <??/38/ 5B /64./@ <? 4./E 0E <? 4./ <1636<3 4.04 64 6: 3<4:0?/4<@/2B<3:98.638<3:6:4/34/F6;/38/<?4./F6846E 63<@;/@4<8<3F6840889:/;<" " 4 6: 1/@463/34 4< 3<4/ 4.04 4./ ?04./@ <? 4./ F6846E H.< 6: 4./ 63?<@E034 .0: 3<4 :911<@4/; 4./ 80:/<?4./1@<:/8946<3L:/6M9@/E0.0M0@H643/:: :+ 03; L :1<4 E0.0M0@ H643/::/: :! 03; * L E0.0M0@H643/::/:4<G!.0F/3<4:911<@4/;4./80:/ - 10 - <? 4./ 1@<:/8946<3 %/38/ 40K637 3<4/ <? 022 4./:/ ?084: 03; 86@89E:4038/: <? 4./ 80:/ 0E <? 4./ <1636<3 4.04 4./011/220346:/34642/;?<@4./5/3/?64<?;<95403;./6: /34642/;4<5/08I9644/; " .0F/7<3/4.@<97.4./6E1973/;A9;7E/34<? 8<3F6846<303;<@;/@<?:/34/38/10::/;5B4./@602<9@4 4 .0: 673<@/; G+ 4./ 404/E/34 <? F6846E @/8<@;/; 93;/@ :/846<3 "!+ <? @ H./@/ :./ .0: 76F/3 82/03 8.644<0889:/;<"4.0:02:<673<@/;4./638<3:6:4/38B 63 4.//F6;/38/ <? F6846E " @/70@;637 8<EE6::6<3 <? 4./ <??/38/ /64./@ 5B 0889:/; <" <@ 5B "( 4 .0: 02:<673<@/;G"+/;6802/@46?6804/6::9/;5B"* 088<@;637 4< H.68. 4./ F6846E H0: 07/; E<@/ 4.03 " B/0@:044./46E/<?022/7/;6386;/344.0:02:<673<@/; 4./ /F6;/38/ <? " 4.04 :./ H0: 07/; "* 4< " B/0@: H./3 :./ H0: E0@@6/; 4< "( 73<@637 :98. E04/@602 8<34@0;6846<3: 03; 638<3:6:4/386/: 4./ @602 <9@4 1@<8//;/;4<8<3F6844./0889:/;H.68.6:26052/4<5/:/4 - 11 - 0:6;/88<@;6372B03:H/@4./1<634?<@8<3:6;/@046<363 4./0??6@E046F/03;1@<8//;4<10::4./?<22<H637 $6& ./@6E630211/026: $66& ./ 6E1973/; A9;7E/34 <? 8<3F6846<3 03; <@;/@ <? /34/38/ ;04/; ",(*(" 10::/; 63 1/8602 0:/ $ & < ("* <3 4./ ?62/ <? 2/0@3/; ;;646<302 /::6<3: 9;7/ ' = > 6A0B019@06:./@/5B:/40:6;/ $666& <3:/I9/342B 011/220340889:/; <" 6: 08I9644/; <? 4./ <??/38/: 1936:.052/ 93;/@ /846<3: !! ++ <? 03; /846<3 $"&1936:.052/93;/@/846<3!<? 84 $6F& 0625<3;<?4./0889:/;03;4.04<? .6::9@/46/::.022:403;8038/22/; - 12 - $F& '63/ 0E<934 6? 03B ;/1<:64/; 5B 011/220340889:/; <" 6: <@;/@/; 4< 5/ @/?93;/;4<.6E0?4/@011/021/@6<;6:<F/@ /76:4@B4<:/3;508K4./02<37H64.8<1B<?4.6: A9;7E/34?<@63?<@E046<303;?<@3//;?920846<3 ,* '$$) % 6:4<"2<