- 1 - ! " #$%!$!$ &!' ! "# $ % & # & ! & ' & # ! "# $ # '( & !% Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # !!) # * &+ ! ! # & # ,# # # # * # !& ! ! ,* # # -. $#-. % #/010123/4 15 6/724/ 0815 2940 5//:13; 72<<2=13; 4/<1/75 1% 559/>=41027?/40124>41@9>5813;08/24A/4A>0/A &+ ! ! B>55/A 6C 08/ &50 4/5B23A/30 13 2 D1A/ 33/E94/# 527>4>508/B/010123/415?23?/43/A 11% 559/>=41027F>3A>F9524>3C5910>6</A14/?01235 A14/?013; 08/ 4/5B23A/305 >90824101/5 02 ?2351A/4 08/ B/010123/45 4/@9/50 >3A 4/B4/5/30>0123 A>0/A !& ! ! D1A/ 33/E94/* =108 A9/ B42?/55 27 <>= - 3 - ! #/010123/4 =82 =>5 =24:13; >5 08/ >4F >3>;/4 >0 4/5B23A/30 2';41?9<094>< ?1/3?/ 31D/4510C >1?894 =>5/>4<1/404>357/44/A02>AA/D>A>;1 6C >3 24A/4 A>0/A &+ ! !' ;;41/D/A 6C =81?8 B/010123/48>A>BB42>?8/A081529406C71<13;=410B/010123 13 #2! !'! !' C 24A/4 A>0/A !! &! ! 0815 29408>AA15B25/A2708/5>1A=410B/010123#>4>&&2708/ 5>1A24A/44/>A5>593A/4 ! "#"$$"$% & ' 8>0 13 79408/4>3?/ 02 08/ >724/5>1A 24A/4 B/010123/4 F>A/ > 4/B4/5/30>0123 A>0/A !+ !! ! - 4 - 5//:13; ?>3?/<<>0123 27 08/ 5>1A 04>357/4 24A/4 >3A 4/@9/50/A02B/4F108/402?230139/1308/B4/5/30B25013; ??24A13;<C 5>1A 24A/4 =>5 ?>3?/<</A >3A 58/ =>5 B/4F100/A02?230139/>01A>4 965/@9/30<C 6C 08/ 1FB9;3/A 24A/4 A>0/A &+ ! ! 08/ 4/5B23A/30 2&31D/4510C 8>5 04>357/44/A 08/ B/010123/4 742F 8/4 B4/5/30 B25013; >0 1A>402>=>A1F>001;41?9<094></5/>4?8/30/4>5 >4F >3>;/4 8/ 4/5B23A/30 2&31D/4510C ><52 1559/A4/</>5/24A/42308/D/4C5>F/A>C 3 4/5B235/ 08/4/27 08/ B/010123/4 8>A ;1D/3 > 4/B4/5/30>0123 23?/ >;>13 4/@9/5013; 02 ?>3?/< 08/ 04>357/4 24A/4 >3A 02 B/4F10 8/4 02 ?230139/ 23 08/ B4/F15/ 08>0 08/4/ =/4/ ?/40>13 B2<1?/ ?>5/5 4/;150/4/A >3A>4/B/3A13;?2351A/4>01236/724/08/2940>3A08>010 =29<A6/A1771?9<07248/402B425/?90/08/5>1AF>00/4517 8/4 4/@9/50 =>5 320 ?2351A/4/A /3?/ 529;80 724 B/4F155123 02 ?230139/ 13 08/ B4/5/30 B25013; ;;41/D/A 6C 08/ 1FB9;3/A 24A/4 A>0/A &+ ! ! >3A 8/4 - 5 - 4/B4/5/30>0123 320 6/13; ?2351A/4/A 6C 08/ 4/5B23A/30 2&G31D/4510C B/010123/4 8>5 >BB42>?8/A 0815 2940 6C 08/B4/5/30=410B/010123 ) 815 2940 6C 24A/4 A>0/A ! ! 8>A ;4>30/A>3130/41F24A/42750>C50>C13;08/2B/4>012327 08/1FB9;3/A24A/4A>0/A&+ ! ! />43/A ?2935/< >BB/>413; 724 08/ B/010123/4 4/10/4>013; 08/ ;4293A5 94;/A 13 08/ F/F24>3A9F 27 B/010123 596F10 08>0 08/ 4/5B23A/3031D/4510C 6C 24A/4 A>0/A&! ! !B42A9?/A>033/E94/8>A04>357/44/A ?/40>13/FB<2C//5308>0 08/3>F/2708/B/010123/4=>5 3204/7</?0/A 8/ 5>1A 04>357/4 24A/4 >0 33/E94/ =>5 08/ ;/3/4>< 04>357/4 895 23?/ 08/ ;/3/4>< 04>357/4 15 /77/?0/A =108290 >3C 4/@9/50 24 ?821?/ 08/ 4/5B23A/30 2&31D/4510C ?29<A 320 8>D/ 1559/A 08/ 1FB9;3/A 04>357/4 24A/4 A>0/A &+ ! ! 04>357/4413; 08/ B/010123/4 ><23/ =81?8 15 1FB/4F15516</ / 596F105 08>0 08/4/>4/3249</5;2D/4313;08/04>357/42708//FB<2C//5 27 4/5B23A/30 2&31D/4510C 2=/D/4 /D/3 93A/4 08/ - 6 - 04>357/4;91A/<13/51559/A6C08/2D/43F/3027>43>0>:> 72408/C/>4! !! !) F24/08>3)H2708/020><?>A4/5 504/3;08 ?>3320 6/ 04>357/44/A / 596F105 513?/ 08/ 4/5B23A/30 2&31D/4510C 13 0/4F5 27 33/E94/ 8>5 ><4/>AC 04>357/44/A H 27 /FB<2C//5 =81?8 ?23501090/ F24/ 08>3 H 27 08/ ?>A4/ 504/3;08 08/ 1FB9;3/A 04>357/424A/415935950>13>6</ 8>0 13 0/4F5 27 91A/<13/ 2)$'% >3C 5B/?1>< 04>357/4 208/4 08>3 08/ ;/3/4>< 04>357/4 ?>3 6/ /77/?0/A 23<C >70/4 260>1313; 08/ B4124 B/4F155123 27 08/ 81/7 13150/4 /7/4413; 02 91A/<13/ 2$'% 8/ 596F105 08>0 08/B/010123/415/3010</A024/F>13138/4B4/5/30B25013; 724& C/>45>558/=>5B250/A0208/B4/5/30B25013;13 08/ C/>4 ! & / 79408/4 596F105 08>0 B/010123/4 6/13; 93F>441/A8>5>32B012302?8225/8/4B<>?/27?821?/>5 B/4 91A/<13/ 2$% 895 8/ 596F105 08>0 08/ 1FB9;3/A04>357/424A/46/5/0>51A/ + 34/5B235/ </>43/A?2935/<>BB/>413;72408/ 4/5B23A/30 2&31D/4510C 4/7/4413; 02 08/ A2?9F/305 - 7 - /3?<25/A 02 08/ >BB<1?>0123 71</A 5//:13; D>?>013; 27 08/ 130/41F 24A/4 596F105 08>0 08/ B/010123/4 6/13; 429B /FB<2C// 15 /3010</A 02 50>C 13 8/4 B25013; 23<C 724 > B/412A270=2C/>45308/1350>30?>5/ B/010123/48>D13; 6//3 B250/A 02 08/ ?944/30 B25013; /77/?01D/ 742F !! '! & 8>5 50>C/A 724 2D/4 /1;80 C/>45 8>0 B/010123/4A/5B10/08/24A/452704>357/4>3A08/4/<1/D13; 24A/45 ?2F13; 1302 /77/?0 23 >3A 742F &+ ! ! 8>5 93>9082415/A<C 6>4;13; 1302 08/ 2771?/ >3A 8>5 6//3 ?4/>013;49?:95/D/4CA>C1308/2771?/4>=13;>00/30123 27 0815 2940 02 08/ F/F2 A>0/A & +! ! >3A 08/ A2?9F/30 /3?<25/A 08/4/=108 =81?8 15 >AA4/55/A 6C 08/ /3124 ?1/30150 >3A />A 27 08/ 31D/4510C 02 08/ AF131504>01D/ 771?/4 27 31D/4510C 27 ;41?9<094>< ?1/3?/5 >1?894 8/ 596F105 08>0 13 08/ 5>1A </00/4 08/ /3124 ?1/30150 >3A />A 27 08/ 4/5B23A/30 2' 8>5 3>44>0/A 08/ 1FB/A1F/30 894A</5 >3A A1771?9<01/5 6/13; ?4/>0/A 6C 08/ B/010123/4 13 08/ A>C 02 A>C 2771?1>< >?01D101/5 / ><52 596F105 08>0 08/ B/010123/4 >70/4 71<13; - 8 - 08/ B4/5/30 =410 B/010123 8>5 724?16<C 53>0?8/A 08/ >00/3A>3?/4/;150/4>3A8>52D/4=4100/308//3041/51308/ >00/3A>3?/4/;150/4 & 5 4/;>4A5 08/ ?230/30123 27 B/010123/4 6/13; /3010</A0250>C138/4?944/30B250724>F131F9FB/412A 27 & C/>45 >5 B/4 ;91A/<13/ 2$'% </>43/A ?2935/< 596F10508>008/5>1A49</15>BB<1?>6</23<C020825/=82 =/4/241;13><<CB250/A1308/CA/4>6>A>43>0>:>4/;123 308/1350>30?>5/ B/010123/4=>5>AF100/A<C>BB2130/A13 08/ C/>4 ! + >3A 08/ B/412A 27 & C/>45 ?230/FB<>0/A 08/4/138>55022A/EB14/A559?8 58/15320/3010</A02 5//:6/3/71008/4/93A/4 && /79408/4596F10508>008/<1F1027)H4/7/44/A 02 6C 08/ </>43/A ?2935/< 724 08/ B/010123/4 15 320 >BB<1?>6</0208/1350>30?>5/>508/B25027>4F>3>;/4 1523<C23/>3A23<CB/010123/4152??9BC13;08/5>1AB250 >3A08/5>1A;91A/<13/515320>BB<1?>6</ - 9 - &! 5 4/;>4A5 08/ ?230/30123 27 4/@914/F/30 27 260>1313; B4124 B/4F155123 27 08/ 81/7 13150/4 >5 B/4 91A/<13/ 2)$'% </>43/A ?2935/< 596F105 08>0 08/ 04>357/4 27 08/ B/010123/4 A2/5 320 7><< =10813 08/ ?410/41> ?230/FB<>0/A 93A/4 08/ 5>1A 49</ >5 /D1A/30 742F 08/ 1FB9;3/A04>357/424A/4 &' / 596F105 08>0 08/ ?14?9F50>3?/5 ?230/FB<>0/A93A/491A/<13/215320>BB<1?>6</1308/ 1350>30 ?>5/ 13>5F9?8 >5 08/ B/010123/4 8>5 290<1D/A 08/ F131F9F B/412A 27 0=2 C/>45 B4/5?416/A 724 429B /FB<2C///3?/ 5//:5724A15F155><2708/B/010123 & />4A#/495/A08/4/?24A5 & 0 15 5/00</A B2510123 27 <>= 08>0 04>357/4 15 >3 13?1A/30 27 /FB<2CF/30 >3A 93</55 24 1<</;><10C 2308/B>402708/>90824101/515F>A/290 130/47/4/3?/6C 08/29405>4/026/?14?9F5B/?0AF100/A<C08/4/>4/32 ;91A/<13/51308/4/5B23A/302&31D/4510C;2D/4313;08/ 04>357/4 B42?/55 2=/D/4 724 08/ B94B25/ 27 - 10 - ?23D/31/3?/ 08/2D/43F/30 24A/45 1559/A 742F01F/ 02 01F/8>56//34/<1/A9B2372408/B94B25/2704>357/4 815 >5B/?02708/F>00/41532013A15B90/ &) 0 15 ><52 320 13 A15B90/ 08/ B/010123/4 15 429B /FB<2C// =82 =>5 >BB2130/A 13 08/ C/>4 ! + >3A 04>357/44/A 02 08/ B4/5/30 B250 /77/?01D/ 742F !! '! & >3A 8>5 6//3 2??9BC13; 08/ ?944/30 B250 724 2D/4 /1;80 C/>45 5 B/4 08/ ;91A/<13/5 08/ F131F9F A94>0123 =81?8 > 429B /FB<2C// ?>3 50>C 13 > B>401?9<>4B25013;150=2C/>453C4/A9?012324/E0/35123 08/4/27 15 724 /E?/B0123>< 4/>5235 >3A ?14?9F50>3?/5 F/30123/A1391A/<13/2#/010123/4A2/53207><<13>3C 2708/?14?9F50>3?/5?230/FB<>0/A93A/491A/<13/52 & 8/ ?230/30123 94;/A 6C 08/ ?2935/< 724 08/ B/010123/408>0B/010123/4=29<A7><<6/C23A08/<1F1027)H 27 08/ 020>< ?>A4/ 504/3;08 >5 ?230/FB<>0/A 93A/4 91A/<13/2><52320>BB<1?>6</13>5F9?8>5>AF100/A<C 08/ B/010123/4 =82 15 08/ 52</ ?>3A1A>0/ 2??9BC13; 08/ ?944/30 B250 724 2D/4 /1;80 C/>45 8/4/724/ 08/ <1F10 - 11 - B4/5?416/A 724 )H ?>3320 6/ 0>:/3 58/<0/4 6C 08/ B/010123/4 & 0153/?/55>4C><5202:32=08>008/B/010123/4 8>A >BB42>?8/A 0815 2940 23 />4<1/4 2??>5123 =8/3 58/ =>5 04>357/44/A 13 08/ C/>4 ! ! ! 815 2940 =81</ A/?<1313; 02 @9>58 24 02 5/0>51A/ 5>1A 04>357/4 24A/4 1FB9;3/A 08/4/93A/4 8>A A15B25/A 27 08/ =410 B/010123 F/4/<C A14/?013; 08/ B/010123/4 8/4/13 02 F>:/ > 4/B4/5/30>01235//:13;><0/43>0/B25013;3A/408/;915/ 27 08/ 5>1A 24A/4 B/010123/4 1350/>A 27 5//:13; ><0/43>0/ B<>?/B25013; 8>A 529;80 724 ?>3?/<<>0123 27 08/ 04>357/4 24A/4 >3A F>3>;/A 02 50>C 13 08/ 5>F/ B2510123 01<< 08/ 1FB9;3/A 04>357/4 24A/4 15 B>55/A D/3 >70/4 08/ 1FB9;3/A 04>357/4 24A/4 >3A 08/ 4/<1/D13; 24A/4 >5 4/D/></A 742F 08/ 4/?24A5 B/010123/4 8>5 ?230139/A 02 2??9BC 08/ ?944/30 B250 724?16<C /?24A ><52 582=08>008/B/010123/415?4/>013;D149</30>0F25B8/4/13 08/ =24:B<>?/ 13 08/ 3>094/ 27 724?16<C 2D/4 =41013; >3A /30/413;8/4>00/3A>3?/1308/4/;150/4A/5B10/58/8>D13; - 12 - 6//3 4/<1/D/A 815 >00109A/ >B>40 742F 08/ >62D/ A15/3010</ 08/ B/010123/4 724 >3C /@910>6</ 4/<1/7 20=10850>3A13;08/5>F/ 08/49</54/7/44/A02>62D/A2 320 F>:/ 290 >3C B42D15123 724 08/ ?2351A/4>0123 27 B/010123/4-5?>5/ &+ 2 ;4293A5 F>A/ 290 #/010123 <>?:5 F/410 ??24A13;<C08/5>F/15 3 D1/= 27 A15B25>< 27 F>13 B/010123 B/3A13; 130/4<2?9024C >BB<1?>01235 17 >3C A2 320 594D1D/ 724 ?2351A/4>0123??24A13;<C 08/C>4/A15F155/A !() &$!$' % 1502&<2! #