Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 64183 (KAR)
POOJA v. BINNI ASHWIN
RPFC/200052/2023 · 2025-12-05
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64183 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64183 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #
$#%!#!#
&#"
'
!"!##
$ %
&#
!"!&'"
$ % %
(
(
#)* ( (
# ( #++'#)( (
+'+' (
( #! ,
(
(
(
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
(
-
-
./0123/3/45/0673.2123/3/4528 9/:262/5;<;;8/2=2> 67 3.2 48>28 ><32> +'+' 1<002> /5 8/?/5<@ /0A2@@<524B0 4#++'#) 45 3.2 :/@2 4: 8/5A/1<@ B>;2 (<?/@74B83<@<6B8<;/:480.483C3.2(<?/@74B83,67 9./A. .28 123/3/45 :/@2> B5>28 2A3/45 #! 4: 8 022D/5;?</5325<5A2.<0622582E2A32>
.2 ?<88/<;2 6239225 3.2 123/3/4528 <5> 820145>253 .<=/5; 6225 04@2?5/F2> <3 <8<><;/ %/@@<;2 /5 328?0 4: .8/03/<5 8/3B<@ .<0 543 6225 >25/2> .282 <112<80 34 62 A283</5 ?<8/3<@ >/0A48> 6239225 3.2 1<83/20<5>9/3./5?453.04:3.2?<88/<;21<83/20.<=2 622503<7/5;021<8<32@7.2123/3/4528.<0<@@2;2>?253<@ <5> 1.70/A<@ 3483B82 0B::282> 67 .28 <3 3.2 .<5>0 4: 3.2 820145>253 .B06<5>
3/0A4532532>3.<30.234@28<32>3.2
- 3 -
.<8>0./145@79/3.3.2.4124:82=/=<@/53.262.<=/4B84:
3.2820145>253 .B06<5>492=28123/3/4528 9<0 3.8495 4B3 4: 3.2 ?<38/?45/<@ .4?2 67 3.2 820145>253 <5> .28 :<?/@7 ?2?6280 <5> 3.<3 0.2 .<0 6225 820/>/5; /5 3.2 1<8253<@.4B02 & .2 820145>253 .<0 :/@2> 3.2 123/3/45 :48 203/3B3/45 4: 45EB;<@ /;.30 /5 4#+'#) /5A2 0.2 >/> 543 .<=2 <57 04B8A2 4: /5A4?2 :48 .28 0B8=/=<@ /5A@B>/5;34A4532033.2123/3/450.2:/@2>3.2123/3/45:48 ?</5325<5A2 * 23/3/4528 2G<?/52> .2802@: <0
# <5> 2G./6/32> ! >4AB?2530 20145>253 2G<?/52> ./?02@: <0
# <5> 2G./6/32> ! >4AB?2530 .2 (<?/@7 4B83 .<0 82E2A32>3.2123/3/45 ! 2<852>A4B502@:483.2123/3/45280B6?/303.<3 (<?/@7 4B83 .<0 :</@2> 34 <1182A/<32 3.2 :<A30 3.<3 123/3/4528.<0622503<7/5;021<8<32@79/3./5?453.04:
?<88/<;2 9/3.4B3<57 :/5<5A/<@ .2@1 :84? 3.2820145>253 282@7 62A<B02 3.2 820145>253 .<0 :/@2> 123/3/45 :48
- 4 -
8203/3B3/45 4: A45EB;<@ 8/;.30 3.2 <012A3 4: 52;@/;25A2 A<554362/;5482>.282:482.20B6?/303.<33.248>28/0 :<A3B<@@7 <5> @2;<@@7 /5A4882A3 9<88<53/5; /5328:2825A2 <3 3.2.<5>04:3.24B83
2<852> A4B502@ :48 3.2 820145>253 .B06<5> =2.2?253@7 0B6?/30 3.<3 3.2 123/3/4528 .<0 ?/028<6@7 :</@2>34184=23.<30.2.<0622552;@2A32>53.243.28 .<5> 820145>253 .<0 0.495 ./0 645<:/>2 67 :/@/5; 3.2 123/3/45 022D/5; 8203/3B3/45 4: A45EB;<@ 8/;.30 9./A. /0 0B::/A/253 254B;. 34 184=2 3.<3 .2 /0 <@9<70 82<>7 <5> 9/@@/5;343<D2A<824:.2825A2.20B6?/303.282/054 28848/53.248>28 + 2<8>128B02>3.282A48>0
" 2A3/45 #! 4: 8 0B??<87 184A22>/5;0 03<32?253 ?<>245 4<3.
82;<8>/5; 52;@/;25A2 34 184=/>2 ?</5325<5A2 .<0 34 62 0A8B3/5/F2> A8/3/A<@@7 A450/>28/5;
3.2 :<A30 <5> A/8AB?03<5A20 0B884B5>/5; 3.2 1<83/20 /5 9./A. 3.27 @/=2 /5 >?/332>@7 123/3/4528 /0 52/3.28
- 5 -
2?1@472> 548 0.2 .<0 <57 04B8A2 4: /5A4?2
5=<8/<6@7 0.2 9/@@ .<=2 34 >2125> B145 3.2 .2@1 <5> <00/03<5A2 34 62 825>282> 67 3.2 820145>253 .B06<5> .282 /0 54 >/01B324:3.2:<A33.<39/3./5?453.04:3.2?<88/<;2 0.29<003<7/5;021<8<32@7 ) .2(<?/@74B83.<041/52>3.<334EB03/:73.2 <@@2;<3/45 4:
.B06<5> 123/3/4528 .<0 543 :/@2> <57 A4?1@</53
3.<0:B83.28.2@>3.<3H I .25820145>253/082<>7343<D2.286<AD549 2=25 549 6B3 0.2 /0 543 82<>7
3 0.490 3.<3 3.282 /0 54 52;@/;25A2 45 3.2 1<83 4: 3.2 820145>253 34 3<D2 A<82 4: .28 .282:482 0.2 .<0 :</@2> 34 184=2 3.2 <@@2;<3/45 ?<>2 <;</503 3.2820145>253J
#' (B83.28 ?282@7 62A<B02 0.2 >/> 543 :/@2 <57 A4?1@</534:.<8<00?253<5>3483B823.20<?294B@>543 46@/=<32 3.28201450/6/@/37 45 3.2 1<83 4: 3.2 820145>253 .B06<5> 34 184=/>2 3.2 ?</5325<5A2 .4B;. 3.2 820145>253 .B06<5>A@</?3.<3.2.<0:/@2>3.2123/3/45:48 8203/3B3/454:A45EB;<@8/;.303.2?<3328/0125>/5;0/5A2
- 6 -
'#) >?/332>@73.282/0543./5;4582A48>340.493.2 645< :/>204:820145>2534:.262/5;82<>734184=/>2.28 ?</5325<5A2 B::/A/253 254B;. 34 .4@> 3.<3 .2 /0 543 /5325>/5;9.<3.2/00<7/5; ## 53.2=/294:3.2?<33283.2:4@@49/5;H
< .2123/3/45/0<@@492> 6 .2 48>28 ><32> +'+' 1<002> /5 8/?/5<@ /0A2@@<524B0 4#++'#) 45 3.2 :/@2 4:
8/5A/1<@ B>;2 (<?/@7 4B83 <@<6B8<;/ /0 .28267023<0/>2 A <3328 /0 82?/332> 34 3.2 (<?/@7 4B83 :48 :820. A450/>28<3/45 > 0 <5 /5328/? <88<5;2?253 3.2 820145>253 .B06<5> 0.<@@ 1<7 0''' 128 ?453. 34 3.2 123/3/4528 9/:2 .2 0</> <?4B53 0.<@@ 62 1</> :84?3.2><324:3./0123/3/4562:4823./04B83
- 7 -
2 .2 (<?/@7 4B83 0.<@@ >/01402 4: 3.2 ?<3328 9/3./5 394 ?453.0 /5A2 3.2 1<83/20 <82 8218202532> 67 3.2/8 A4B502@ 3.27 0.<@@ <112<8 62:482 3.2 (<?/@7 4B83 45 #'#' 9/3.4B3 <57:B83.28543/A2
!() *#!#+ %
/034#@4#'