Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 64178 (KAR)
RAMANNA v. KHADIRSAB AND ANR
MFA/201153/2025 · 2025-12-15
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64178 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64178 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#
$
! "
""
%&' #$
""
%&'
"" (
%&'
""
)
%&'
""
)
%&'
""
*+
%&'
"" ( (
%&'
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
#
$
%&'(
$ %&'(
! $
(( )"
$ $
!" $ ) *&+' %!, )
"
) $)$ % ((*$('
#
$ )))
*
! "
#
$
- 3 -
%&'(
$ %&'(
! $
( )"
$ $
!" $ ) &+&+ %!, )
"
) $)$ % ((**($('
)#
$ ) ) *
#) )
! "
#
$
%&'(
- 4 -
$ %&'(
! $
((( )"
$ $
!" $ ) ' %!, )
"
) $)$ % ((*&$('
)#
$
) +
#))
! "
#
$
%&'(
$ %&'(
! $
- 5 -
((( )"
$ $
!" $ ) + %!, )
"
) $)$ % ((**$('
*+#
$
#
! "
#
$
%&'(
$ %&'(
! $
( )"
$ $
!" $ ) &((( %!,
- 6 -
)
"
) $)$ % ((*+$('
( (#
$ #
+
#
# )
! "
#
$
%&'(
$ %&'(
! $
((( )"
$ $
!" $ ) (+& %!, )
"
) $)$ % ((**$('
- 7 -
$ )
-
! ./01.2.3435622374.6839/530:;/76<5=44=/>?=2. 9/>43>2 /; @367>3< 9/0>43@ ;/7 :672=34 2.3A 673 26B3> 0: ;/7 .367=>1
/55/> 6?67< <623< ((* =4 :6443< CA 2.3 /072 /; 3>=/7 =8=@ 0<13 D % 62 0<<3C=.6@ => / (' 9/>>3923< ?=2. /4& (' 2/ * ('
$/((/;(=4;=@3<616=>422.36?67< :6443< => / (' >3 6>656??6 ?=;3 /; 0@@6::66<67613<6C/02*&A3674532?=2.6>699=<3>2/> (( 6>< <=3< 37 4/>4 ;=@3< 9@6=5 :32=2=/> 9@6=5=>1 9/5:3>462=/>/;4(((( %.37=C0>6@9/>4=<37=>12.3 38=<3>93/>739/7<176>23<9/5:3>462=/>/;4+((* %?=2. =>237342 62 +E :37 6>>05 ;7/5 2.3 <623 /; :32=2=/> 2=@@ 736@=F62=/>.37=C0>6@;072.37/C43783<734:/><3>2/=4
- 8 -
@=6C@3 2/ =><35>=;A 734:/><3>2 / 64 734:/><3>2 / .64 =>4073<2.3/;;3><=>183.=9@3
*117=383<CA2.346=</7<372.=46::36@=4;=@3<CA2.3 9@6=56>24=>?.=9.=2=49/>23><3<2.62<393643<?64613<*& A3674622.32=53/;699=<3>2.373;/73E=42/C36<<3< 2/?67<4;02073:7/4:3924
/?3765/0>24?373176>23<;/7@/44 /;9/>4/72=05@/44/;@/836><6;;392=/>6><@/44/;3426236>< 6@4/ ;/7 53>26@ 61/>A .373;/73 73G03423< ;/7 3>.6>9353>2 /;9/5:3>462=/>
367<2.3671053>24/;C/2.4=<34
' .3 <393643< 6>656??6 532 ?=2. 699=<3>2 /> (( .3 9@6=56>24 .683 >/2 ;=@3< 6>A </9053>24 2/ :7/83.37=>9/5344.3532?=2.699=<3>2=>2.3A367( >/2=/>6@=>9/53/;4&((( %:375/>2.=42/C326B3>64:37 2.310=<3@=>34/;2.3#67>626B62623
316@378=93402./7=2A .3?64613<*&A36746><2.373;/73E/;=>9/53=42/C3 6<<3< 2/?67<4 ;02073 :7/4:3924 64 :37 2.3 H0<153>2 /; 2.3 />-C@3 0:7353 /072 => 2.3 9643 /; !
- 9 -
"#$%"!&' ($)!*6></>32.=7<=42/C3 <3<0923< 2/?67<4 :374/>6@ 3I:3>434 64 :37 2.3 10=<3@=>34 /;
2.3 />-C@3 0:7353 /072 => 2.3 9643 /; ) '!" '
+!*,# # .350@2=:@=376::@=96C@3=4 .042.3@/44/;<3:3><3>9A9/5342/4(*(((( %!&(((J E% 7<II"
.3699=<3>2=4/;2.3A367(6><2.373;/7364:37 2.3 10=<3@=>34 /; 2.3 />KC@3 0:7353 /072 => 2.3 9643 /; -" .!! ! "#$ %"!& /
0"**0" *!6><=>2.39643/;1!& & ! "#$ %"!& / )&! 2 3 )4&! 2 & *! 2.3 9@6=56>24 673 3>2=2@3< ;/7 4*&((( % 369. ;/7 @/44 /; 9/>4/72=05 4'((( % =4 6?67<3< 0><37 9/>83>2=/>6@ .36<4 64 :37 2.3 10=<3@=>34 /;
/>-C@3 0:7353 /072 => 2.3 9643 /; ! "#$%"!&' ($)!*
1 (2017) 16 SCC 680 2 (2009) 6 SCC 121 3 (2018) 18 SCC 130 4 (2020) 9 SCC 644 5 (2017) 16 SCC 680
- 10 -
&>6@@2.39@6=56>246733>2=2@3<;/72.39/5:3>462=/> /; 4((( % ?=2. =>237342 62 'E :37 6>>05 64 616=>42 4+((* %6?67<3<CA2.37=C0>6@
+.36?67</;9/5:3>462=/>:6443<CA2.37=C0>6@=4 5/<=;=3<640><37 36<4 5/0>2=>4 /44/;3:3><3>9A (*(((( % /44/;/>4/72=05 +'((( % /?67<49/>83>2=/>6@.36<4 '((( % /26@
#
(.373;/732.3;/@@/?=>1/7<37=4:6443< !=" ::36@=46@@/?3<=>:672 !==" .3 @6=56>24 673 3>2=2@3< ;/7 2.3 2/26@ 9/5:3>462=/> /; 4((( % ?=2. =>237342 62 'E :6 ;7/5 2.3 <623 /; :32=2=/> 2=@@ 2.3 <623 /; 736@=F62=/>
- 11 -
!=8" .3 734:/><3>2%>4076>93 9/5:6>A =4 <=73923< 2/ <3:/4=2 2.3 6;/7346=< 9/5:3>462=/> 65/0>2 ?=2.=> />35/>2.;7/52.3<623/;2.=4/7<37 !8" > 409. <3:/4=2 2.3 @6=56>24 673 :375=223< 2/ ?=2.<76?2.365/0>26@/>1?=2.6;/7346=<=>237342 3G06@@A
$ /( /; ( $ /(' /; ( $ /(' /; ( $/(+*/;(6><$/(/;(.683 C33> ;=@3< CA 2.3 734:392=83 9@6=56>24 616=>42 2.3 H0<153>2 6><6?67<:6443<=>/4& ('2/* ('
.3 =>H073< 9@6=56>24 => 2.3 6;/7346=< 734:392=83 6::36@4532?=2.6>699=<3>2/>((6><;=@3<9@6=5 6::@=962=/>49@6=5=>19/5:3>462=/>?=2.=>237342.37=C0>6@ 9/>4=<37=>1 2.3 3>2=73 38=<3>93 /> 739/7< 176>23< 9/5:3>462=/>64;/@@/?4 >/& (' 4''* % >/+ (' 4((( % >/*( (' 4&( % >/* (' 4+(+ % >/* (' 4&(& % >/* (' 4'&&' %
- 12 -
.3 6;/7346=< 9/5:3>462=/> ?64 176>23< CA 2.3 7=C0>6@ ?=2. =>237342 62 2.3 7623 /; +E :37 6>>05 ;7/5 2.3 <623/;:32=2=/>2=@@736@=462=/>
* =>93 2.3 =>H07=34 40;;373< CA 2.3 9@6=56>24 673 4=5:@3 => >62073 2.=4 /072 ;=><4 =2 7364/>6C@3 2/ 176>2 4((( % 2/ 369.
/; 2.3 9@6=56>24 => 2.3 6C/83 6::36@4 => 6<<=2=/> 2/ 2.3 9/5:3>462=/> 6?67<3< CA 2.3 7=C0>6@ 64 :37 2.3C3@/?26C@3 >/& (' 4''* % >/+ (' 4(((( % >/*( (' 4( % >/* (' 4'*(+ % >/* (' 4'(& % >/* (' 4+&' %
>2.37340@22.3;/@@/?=>1/7<37=4:6443< !=" $ /((( /; ( $ /( /; ( $ /(' /; ( $ /(' /; ( $/(+*/;(6><$/(/;(673 6@@/?3<=>:672 !==" .3@6=56>24 =>2.36C/83734:392=836::36@4673 3>2=2@3<;/72.3,-./-012345/674/;4((( %369.=> 6<<=2=/> 2/ 2.3 9/5:3>462=/> 2.62 .64 C33> 6?67<3< CA 2.3
- 13 -
7=C0>6@ ?=2. =>237342 62 'E :37 6>>05 ;7/5 2.3 <623 /; :32=2=/>2=@@2.3<623/;736@=F62=/> !===" 34:/><3>2%>4076>93 9/5:6>A =4 <=73923< 2/ <3:/4=22.36;/7346=<9/5:3>462=/>?=2.=>/>35/>2.;7/52.3 <623/;2.=4/7<37 !=8" > 409. <3:/4=2 2.3 9@6=56>24 673 :375=223< 2/ ?=2.<76?2.33>2=7365/0>26@/>1?=2.=>237342699703</>=2
!8">8=3?/;2.3/7<37<623<(:6443</> / ( 2.3 9@6=56>24 673 >/2 3>2=2@3< ;/7 =>237342 ;/7 2.3 <3@6A3<:37=/</;'(<6A4=>;=@=>12.36::36@4
58# %"' ! =42/@/'