Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 64174 (KAR)

MOULALI v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

CRL.RP/200082/2022 · 2025-09-08

M G Uma

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " #$%&#'()*$#(( + ! " #$ %& % %% ! ' ! !! % % & %( ! " ! %% !$ % ! & )("$& !! % # & & (*) ! ) * % # #& # *** ! Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - +* *) % # ' % !%! & % && !% *() & ! (& ! % % & %%%, & % & % ! & & % % '% %- # "! %- # $ ./ 0/123245 6/727245/0 8/259 7./ :;;<3/= 25 4) * 457./ >2?/ 4> 7./ ?/:05/= ==27245:? 212?#<=9/:5=#&:?:8<0:92">403.407@02:?4<07,$23 2A6<95259 7./ B<=9A/57 4> ;4512;7245 :5= 40=/0 4> 3/57/5;/=:7/=(*);4512;72597./:;;<3/=>407./ 4>>/5;/36<523.:8?/<5=/0/;72453*():5="$4>7./ 5=2:5 !/5:? 4=/ + ">40 3.407 @!,$ :5= <5=/0 /;7245 ( 4> 7./ 5=2:5 4740 /.2;?/3 ;7 ) ">40 3.407 @;7,$ :5= 3/57/5;259 74 6:C >25/ 4> 3 >40 7./ 4>>/5;/ 6<523.:8?/ <5=/0 /;7245 *() 4> !D 74 <5=/09432A6?/2A602345A/57>40:6/024=4>45/C/:0>40 - 3 - 7./4>>/5;/6<523.:8?/<5=/0/;72454>!:5=74 6:C >25/ 4> 3 >40 7./ 4>>/5;/ 6<523.:8?/ <5=/0 /;7245(4>;7E27.=/>:<?73/57/5;/3E.2;.E:3 ;45>20A/= 25 02A25:? 66/:? 4+* *) 6:33/= 8C 7./ ?/:05/= ==27245:? 23702;7 :5= /332453 #<=9/ :?:8<0:92">403.407@&203766/??:7/4<07,$12=/B<=9A/57 =:7/=*** * ./>:;734>7./;:3/25802/>:0/7.:7!'.:3 >2?/= 7./ >2037 25>40A:7245 E27. :.:9:45 64?2;/ :3 6/0 F!57./8:3234>7./3:A/& :36/0F!+;:A/ 74 8/ 0/9237/0/= >40 7./ :841/ 3:2= 4>>/5;/3 :9:2537 7./ :;;<3/= 8/259 7./ 02=/0 4> 7./ A4740;C;?/ 8/:0259 0/92370:72454* +<02597./251/3729:7245 6/727245/0E:3:660/./5=/=:5=;.:09/3.//7;:A/748/ >2?/= :9:2537 .2A >40 7./ 4>>/5;/3 6<523.:8?/ <5=/0 /;72453 *() :5= 4> ! :5= <5=/0 /;7245 ( 4> ;7 ./02:?4<07744G;4952H:5;/4>7./4>>/5;/3 :5= 0/9237/0/= 7./ ;02A25:? ;:3/ ./ :;;<3/= .:= - 4 - :66/:0/= 8/>40/ 7./ 02:? 4<07 6?/:=/= 547 9<2?7C :5= ;?:2A/= 74 8/ 702/= ./ 6043/;<7245 /F:A25/= !' 74 !' :5= 947 A:0G/= F3! 74 ! 25 3<66407 4> 273 ;457/57245./:;;<3/=.:3=/52/=:??7./25;02A25:740C A:7/02:?3:1:2?:8?/450/;40=8<7.:3547?/=:5C/12=/5;/ 253<664074>.23=/>/5;/ ./ 02:? 4<07 :>7/0 7:G259 2574 ;4532=/0:7245 :?? 7./3/ A:7/02:?3 45 0/;40= 604;//=/= 74 6:33 7./ 2A6<95/= B<=9A/57 4> ;4512;7245;4512;7259 7./ :;;<3/= >40 7./ :841/ 3:2= 4>>/5;/3 :5= 3/57/5;/= :3 37:7/= :841/ /259 :9902/1/= 8C 7./ 3:A/ 7./ :;;<3/= .:= 60/>/00/=02A25:?66/:?4+* *)./&203766/??:7/ 4<07 45 0/:660/;2:7245 4> 7./ A:7/02:?3 45 0/;40= =23A233/= 7./ :66/:? 12=/ B<=9A/57 =:7/= *** 7./0/8C;45>20A2597./B<=9A/574>7./02:?4<07/259 :9902/1/=8C7./3:A/7./:;;<3/=238/>40/7.234<07 %/:0= 02 #:G: ?/:05/= ;4<53/? >40 7./ 0/1232456/727245/0:5=02 46:?G023.5::=:1?/:05/= - 5 - %29. 4<07 41/05A/57 !?/:=/0 >40 7./ 0/3645=/57 7:7/!/0<3/=7./A:7/02:?3450/;40= + 5 12/E 4> 7./ 021:? ;457/572453 <09/= 8C 7./ ?/:05/=;4<53/?>40847.7./6:072/37./642577.:7E4<?= :023/>40AC;4532=/0:724523 C :53E/0 74 7./ :841/ 64257 23 >407./>4??4E259 ( 7237./;457/572454>7./6043/;<72457.:77./ :;;<3/= E:3 7./ 02=/0 4> 7./ A4740;C;?/ 8/:0259 0/92370:7245 4* + :5= 45 7./ =:7/ 4> 7./ 25;2=/57./.:302==/57./3:A/25:0:3.:5=5/9?29/57 A:55/0 34 :3 74 /5=:59/0 7./ .<A:5 ?2>/ :5= =:3./= :9:2537 45/ :??2G:0B<5 :9/= >4<0 C/:03 :3 : 0/3<?7 4> - 6 - E.2;. ./ =2/= ./ 6/727245/0 8/259 7./ 02=/0 4> 7./ 4>>/5=259 1/.2;?/ ?/>7 7./ A4740;C;?/ :7 7./ 3647 :5= 0:5 :E:CE27.4<725>40A2597.23>:;7747./64?2;/:5=E27.4<7 3.2>7259 7./ 25B<0/= 74 7./ .43627:? ./0/8C ./ .:3 ;4AA277/= 7./ 4>>/5;/3 6<523.:8?/ <5=/0 /;72453 *() :5=4>!:5=<5=/0/;7245(4>;7 4 6041/ 273 ;457/57245 7./ 6043/;<7245 /F:A25/= !' !' !' !'( :5= !' 8/259 7./ /C/E275/33/3747./25;2=/57!'8/2597.//C/E275/33 .:3 >2?/= 7./ >2037 25>40A:7245 2AA/=2:7/?C :>7/0 7./ :;;2=/57 0/>/00259 74 7./ :;;<3/= :3 7./ 02=/0 4> 7./ 4>>/5=259A4740;C;?/ ) /:05/= ;4<53/? >40 7./ 6/727245/0 36/;2>2;:??C ;457/5=/=7.:77./:;;<3/=23547=236<72597.:7./E:3 7./ 02=/0 4> 7./ A4740;C;?/ E.2;. A/7 E27. 7./ :;;2=/57 E.2;.0/3<?7/=257./=/:7.4>7./=/;/:3/=<77./45?C ;457/572457:G/58C7./?/:05/=;4<53/?>407./6/727245/0 237.:7545/4>7.//C/E275/33/3.:1/364G/5:84<702=259 4>7./A4740;C;?/25:0:3.:5=5/9?29/57A:55/08C7./ - 7 - 6/727245/0 :5= 7./0/>40/ :;;<3/= 23 /5727?/= >40 :;I<277:? 7 23 :?34 .23 ;457/57245 7.:7 7./ /C/E275/33/3 .:1/ :=A277/=7.:77./=/;/:3/=8/2597./;.2?=:9/=>4<0C/:03 3<==/5?C ;:A/ 45 74 7./ 04:= E.2;. 0/3<?7/= 25 7./ :;;2=/57 :5= 7./0/>40/ 7./ :;;<3/= 23 /5727?/= >40 :;I<277:? /:05/= ;4<53/? >40 7./ 6/727245/0 6?:;/3 0/?2:5;/457./=/;2324525 57./;:3/8/>40/7./%45,8?/ 6/F 4<07 7./4<07 483/01/= 7.:7 7./ 6043/;<7245 .:3 547?/=:5C/12=/5;/743.4E:374.4E7./:;;2=/57744G 6?:;/ ./0/ E:3 /12=/5;/ 8/>40/ 7./ 4<07 7.:7 7./ =/;/:3/= .2A3/?> ;:A/ <5=/0 7./ ?/>7 >0457 E.//? E.2;. 0/3<?7/= 25 .23 =/:7. ./ 1/.2;?/ 2514?1/= 25 7.:7 ;:3/ E:3 7./ 8<3 E.2;. E:3 =021/5 8C 7./ :;;<3/= 7./0/25 <7257./60/3/57;:3/7./1/.2;?/23:A4740;C;?/02==/5 45 : .29.E:C E.2;. =:3./= :9:2537 7./ =/;/:3/= :5= 0/3<?7/=25.23=/:7.1/57.4<9.7.//C/E275/33/3.:1/ 1 (1972) 4 SCC 758 - 8 - 37:7/=7.:77./=/;/:3/=;:A/457./04:=7./6/727245/0 ;4<?=.:1/:142=/=.2A834?<7/?C54=/>/5;/E:37:G/5 8C 7./ :;;<3/= =<0259 7./20 ;0433/F:A25:7245 :3 74 E.C ./ ;4<?= 547 :142= 7./ :;;2=/57 ./0/ 23 547 /1/5 : 3<99/37245 74 :5C 4> 7./ /C/E275/33/3 0/9:0=259 7./ =/>/5;/ E.2;. 7./ :;;<3/= E:3 E2??259 74 7:G/ %/ .:3 :?3454737/66/=25747./E275/3384F7436/:G:84<7.23 =/>/5;/ :5= 32A6?C 37:7259 7.:7 7./ ;.2?= 3<==/5?C ;:A/ 4574;04337./04:=:5=./=:3./=:9:2537.2A7E:3 5/1/0 7./ ;457/57245 4> 7./ 6/727245/0 8/>40/ 7./ 02:? 4<077.:7./.:3A:=//>>407374:142=7./:;;2=/578<725 3627/ 4> 7.:7 7./ ;.2?= 273/?> ;:A/ 25 ;457:;7 E27. 7./ A4740;C;?/ E.2;. 0/3<?7/= 25 .23 =/:7. 5=/0 3<;. ;20;<A37:5;/37./:;;<3/=23?2:8?/>40;4512;7245 77.2337:9/?/:05/=;4<53/?>407./6/727245/0 3<8A277/= 7.:7 7./ :;;2=/57 .:= 4;;<00/= 45 *+* :5= /?/1/5 C/:03 .:1/ 8//5 ?:63/= >04A 7./ =:7/ 4> 7./ :;;2=/57 7 7./ 72A/ 4> 7./ 4> 7./ :;;2=/57 7./ 6/727245/0 :;;<3/=E:3:9/=*C/:034E./23.:1259 - 9 - >:A2?C 74 3<66407 :5= 7./0/>40/ 60:C3 >40 3.4E259 ?/52/5;CE.2?/3/57/5;259.2A * 7 23 5472;/= 7.:77./ 02:? 4<07 .:3 ;4512;7/= 7./ :;;<3/= 847. >40 7./ 4>>/5;/3 6<523.:8?/ <5=/0 /;72453*():5=4>!./%45,8?/6/F4<0725 ! " ## $ 2%.:3;:7/9402;:??C./?=7.:77./4>>/5;/<5=/0 /;7245 4> ! 8/259 7./ A:B40 4>>/5;/ 4>>/5;/ <5=/0 /;7245 *() 4> ! A/09/3 E27. 7./ 3:A/ ./0/>40/543/6:0:7/3/57/5;/5//=3748/2A643/=>40 7./ 4>>/5;/ 6<523.:8?/ <5=/0 /;7245 *() 4> ! ./0/>40/:A4>7./46252457.:77./02:?4<07:3E/?? :3 7./ &2037 66/??:7/ 4<07 .:1/ ;4AA277/= :5 /0040 25 3/57/5;259 7./ 6/727245/0 >40 847. 7./ 4>>/5;/3 %/5;/ 7./ B<=9A/57 4> ;4512;7245 23 ?2:8?/ 74 8/ ;45>20A/= :5= 7./40=/04>3/57/5;/23?2:8?/748/A4=2>2/= ./ 6/727245/0 .:3 8//5 3/57/5;/= 74 <5=/094 32A6?/ 2A602345A/57 >40 : 6/024= 4> 45/ C/:0 >40 7./ 2 (2012) 8 SCC 734 - 10 - 4>>/5;/ 6<523.:8?/ <5=/0 /;7245 4> ! ./ 4>>/5;/ <5=/0 /;7245 4> ! 23 6<523.:8?/ E27. 2A602345A/57 4> /27./0 =/3;0267245 >40 : 7/0A E.2;. A:C /F7/5=747E4C/:0340E27.>25/40E27.847. :G259 2574 ;4532=/0:7245 :?? 7./3/ >:;73 :5= ;20;<A37:5;/3 4> 7./ ;:3/ :A 4> 7./ 4625245 7.:7 7./ 3<837:5721/ 3/57/5;/ 2A643/= 45 7./ 6/727245/0 ;4<?= 8/ 0/=<;/= =20/;7259 74 <5=/094 32A6?/ 2A602345A/57 >40 : 6/024= 4> 32F A457.3 ;;40=259?C :53E/0 7./ :841/ 64257# :5=604;//=746:337./ >4??4E259 2$ 02A25:?0/1232456/72724523& # 22$ ./ B<=9A/57 4> ;4512;7245 =:7/= (*) 6:33/= 25 4) * 45 7./ >2?/ 4> ?/:05/= ==27245:? 212? #<=9/ :5= #& :?:8<0:92:5=7./B<=9A/57=:7/=*** 6:33/= 25 02A25:? 66/:? 4+* *) 45 7./ - 11 - >2?/ 4> 7./ ?/:05/= ==27245:? 23702;7 :5= /332453 #<=9/ :?:8<0:92 ;45>20A259 7./ B<=9A/574>;4512;7245:0/./0/8C;45>20A/= 222$ ./40=/04>3/57/5;/6:33/=8C7./02:?4<07 >407./4>>/5;/6<523.:8?/<5=/0/;7245*()4> !233/7:32=/ 21$ ./40=/04>3/57/5;/6:33/=8C7./02:?4<07 >40 7./ 4>>/5;/ 6<523.:8?/ <5=/0 /;7245 4>!23A4=2>2/=:3<5=/0 :$ ./0/1232456/727245/0 :;;<3/=233/57/5;/=74 <5=/09432A6?/2A602345A/57>4032FA457.3>40 7./ 4>>/5;/ 6<523.:8?/ <5=/0 /;7245 4> !:5=746:C:>25/4> 3 5=/>:<?7 74 6:C >25/ ./ 3.:?? <5=/094 32A6?/ 2A602345A/57>407E4A457.3 1$ ./ >25/ :A4<57 2> :5C =/64327/= 8C 7./ 6/727245/0 >40 7./ 4>>/5;/ 6<523.:8?/ <5=/0 /;7245*()4>!2340=/0/=748/0/><5=/=74 .2A<5=/0=</2=/572>2;:7245 - 12 - 12$ ./40=/0453/57/5;/6:33/=8C7./02:?4<07 >407./4>>/5;/6<523.:8?/<5=/0/;7245(4> ;723;45>20A/= /92370C 23 =20/;7/= 74 3/5= 8:;G 7./ 02:? 4<07 0/;40=3 :?459 E27. 7./ ;46C 4> 7.23 B<=9A/57 >40 25>40A:7245:5=5//=><?:;7245 ,) #( ! 2374?4 !