- 1 - ! " #$" #$ "" %&' ( ! " # $%&' ( ) * #+ , -% - # Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - +- - - # !!&' .- -$%$ & , + , / #+, -0& - # 0 +, -1 - +, - - + .- - # !!&' .- -$%$ $ + , #+ # -0$ - # +- .- - 3 - - # !!&' .- -$%$ #+ -1$ - # +- .- - # !!&' .- -$%$ 1 + )* .- -$%$01 ( ) * 10)* &+&& ! # $&&0 &+&& ! . # - - 4 - - 2 2 $ )-2 * 34567786945:498;<=>384?5@A8AB6994?C4?D@85>4E?>38 F@;CG8?> 6?; 6H6A; 76558; E? $&&0 4? E&+&& <=;;9 8?4EA4I49@;C86?; 4;6A6?; 4;6AE?CAE@?;E:946<494>=6?;D@6?>@G & 86A; A4 @;36A536? 986A?8; BE@?589 :EA 6778996?> 6?; A4 656I6A6F 6>3 986A?8; BE@?589 :EA A857E?;8?>5E>E 3. A4 @;36A536? 986A?8; BE@?589 >6J4?C >345 E@A> >3AE@C3 >38 F@;CG8?> 6?; 6H6A; 76558; <= >A4<@?69 HE@9; BE?>8?; >36> EH?8A E: >38 I834B98 A8G64?8; 8K!76A>8 E94B836I8A8C45>8A8;B6586C64?5>>38;A4I8AE:>38E::8?;4?C I834B98 4?IEJ4?C 7AEI454E?5 E: 8B>4E? % E: B> 6?; 8B>4E? % E: B> 6C64?5> >38 EH?8A E: >38 E::8?;4?C I834B98H?8AE:E::8?;4?CI834B98A8G64?8;8K!76A>86?;?E> B36998?C8;>387AEI454E?55>6>8;5@7A6384?5@A6?B8BEG76?= 8K6G4?8; 4>5 E::4B4695 >E 7AEI8 >384A B658 >36> >38 EH?8A - 5 - 8?C6C8; >38 ;A4I8A H3E ;4; ?E> 36I8 6 I694; ;A4I4?C 94B8?58 EH8I8A A4<@?69365?E>BE?54;8A8;564;6578B>E:>38G6>>8A 6?; :65>8?8; 946<494>= E? >38 4?5@A6?B8 BEG76?= >E 76= BEG78?56>4E?6>:4A5>4?5>6?B86?;A8BEI8A>3856G896>8A :AEG >38 EH?8A E: E::8?;4?C I834B98 E <@>>A855 345 6AC@G8?>5 38 948; E? F@;CG8?> E: 4I454E? 8?B3 E: >345 E@A> 4? E$+&';6>8;&&&06?;E0&'1+&';6>8; 0&&0 BE?>8?;4?C >36> 4: >38 B658 45 G6;8 E@> >36> >38 EH?8AE:>38E::8?;4?CI834B9878AG4>>8;>3878A5E??E>36I4?C I694; ;A4I4?C 94B8?58 >E ;A4I8 >38? 4?5@A6?B8 BEG76?= 45 ?E> 946<98>E76=>38BEG78?56>4E?>45>38EH?8AE:>38E::8?;4?C I834B98 484?5@A8; H3E45946<98>E76=BEG78?56>4E??5E:6A 65 A4<@?69 36I4?C BE?54;8A8; >38 G6AA48; ;6@C3>8A5 65 ;878?;6?>5 E: ;8B8658; 38 5@<G4>5 >36> ;6@C3>8A5 H8A8 G6AA48; 6?; 36; CE?8 E@> E: :6G49= 6?; 38?B8 >38= 6A8 ?E> 8?>4>98; >E <8 BE?54;8A8; 65 ;878?;8?>5 E? >38 ;8B8658; E <@>>A8553456AC@G8?>5 38A8948;E?F@;CG8?>E:E?L<9878K E@A> 4? B658 E: 4? 78B46986I88>4>4E? )4I49* E5&&&$!&&&+&% ;8B4;8; E? 0&&$ 76A>4B@96A9=E?76A6CA6735E06?; H38A84>45389;>36> - 6 - G6AA48; ;6@C3>8A5 6A8 ?E> 8?>4>98; >E <8 BE?54;8A8; 65 ;878?;6?>5 E? >38 ;8B8658; H3498 BE?54;8A4?C ;8;@B>4E? >EH6A;5 78A5E?69 8K78?585 ? >3858 CAE@?;5 38 5E@C3> >E 699EH>386778696?;58>654;8>38F@;CG8?>6?;EA;8A76558; <=A4<@?69:65>8?4?C946<494>=E?>384?5@A6?B8BEG76?=>E76= BEG78?56>4E? 6> :4A5> 4?5>6?B8 6?; A8BEI8A 56G8 :AEG >38 4?5@A8; 8:@>4?C >38 5@<G4554E? E: 986A?8; BE@?589 :EA 6778996?> A4656I6A6F6>3 BE?>8?;8;>36>>38:6B>5E:>38 B6584?>38F@;CG8?>5A8948;@7E?<=BE@?589:EA6778996?>56?; :6B>5E:B658E?36?;6A88?>4A89=;4::8A8?>?B658E:F@;CG8?> E: 4I454E? 8?B3 E: >345 E@A> >38A8 45 B986A :4?;4?C >36> >38 4?5@A8ABE?5B4E@59=EAJ?EH4?C9=H899E:>38:6B>>36>>38;A4I8A E: >38 E::8?;4?C I834B98 H65 ?E> 3E9;4?C I694; ;A4I4?C 94B8?58 8?C6C8;34G>E;A4I8>38I834B983E586A8>38B4AB@G5>6?B85 @?;8AH34B34I454E?8?B376558;6?EA;8A>36>>384?5@A6?B8 BEG76?= 45 ?E> 946<98 >E 76= BEG78?56>4E? ?5E:6A 65 BE?>8?>4E?6<E@>G6AA48;;6@C3>8A545BE?B8A?8; >38F@;CG8?> E: E?L<98 78K E@A> 4? >38 B6585 E: - 7 - 6?; !6A8?E><AE@C3>>E>38?E>4B8E:>38E?L<9878KE@A>4? >38B658E:88754J36 @7A6?<E>3B6585 E?L<9878KE@A> 365BE?54;8A8;>38:6B>>36>8I8?G6FEAG6AA48;86A?4?C5E?5 6?; G6AA48; ;6@C3>8A5 6A8 8?>4>98; >E <8 BE@?>8; 65 ;878?;6?>5E:>38 ;8B8658;6?;>E<8BE@?>8; H3498G6J4?C ;8;@B>4E? >EH6A;5 78A5E?69 8K78?585 3858 >HE F@;CG8?>5 H8A8?E><AE@C3>>E>38?E>4B84?>38F@;CG8?>E:E?L<9878K E@A>4?>38B658E: )5@7A6* 5E>38F@;CG8?>45 ;45>4?C@4536<98?D@6?>@G695E 385@<G4>5>36>>A4<@?69365 7AE78A9= BE?54;8A8; >38 B658 6?; 6H6A;8; 677AE7A46>8 BEG78?56>4E? H34B3 45 F@5> 6?; 7AE78A 6?; ;E85 ?E> B699 :EA 4?>8A:8A8?B86?;>3@5 5E@C3>>E;45G455>38677869 $ 6I4?C386A;BE@?58967786A4?C:EA>3876A>4856?; 78A@54?C 8?>4A8 A8BEA;5 7E4?>5 >36> HE@9; 6A458 :EA BE?54;8A6>4E?6A8- 4* #38>38A A4<@?69 45 F@5>4:48; 4? :65>8?4?C >38 946<494>= 7A4G6A49= E? >38 4?5@A6?B8 BEG76?= >E 76= )&&* 0$ &&&$ '& - 8 - 6?; 5@<58D@8?>9= >E A8BEI8A >38 56G8 :AEG >38 4?5@A8AM 44* #38>38A >38 BEG78?56>4E? 6H6A;8; <= >38 A4<@?69<8:4>4?>388K7A8554E?F@5>BEG78?56>4E? 4: ?E>H38>38A4>A8D@4A854?>8A:8A8?B8M @A 6?5H8A >E >38 6<EI8 7E4?>5 :EA BE?54;8A6>4E? 6A8<E>34?6::4AG6>4I8 :EA>38:E99EH4?C- 1 ")*+- 38 BE?>8?>4E? E: >38 986A?8; BE@?58967786A4?C:EA>386778996?>!4?5@A6?B8BEG76?=45>36> >38EH?8AH65796B8;8K!76A>86?;>384?5@A6?B8BEG76?=365 986;8I4;8?B86?;7AE;@B8;;EB@G8?>>E53EH>36>>38;A4I8A H65 ?E> 3E9;4?C I694; ;A4I4?C 94B8?58 >E ;A4I8 >38 E::8?;4?C I834B988365695EA8:8AA8;>E>387E94B8A8BEA;H38A84?>38 7AEI454E?5 E: 8B>4E? % 6?; % E:B> 4?IEJ8; 6C64?5> >38 EH?8A E: >38 I834B98 65 H899 65 >38 ;A4I8A E: >38 I834B98 3858 :6B>5 E: >38 B658 6A8 9E5> 54C3> <= >38 >A4<@?69 H3498 BE?54;8A4?C>38B658>EEA;8A>384?5@A6?B8BEG76?=7A4G6A49= >E 76= >38 BEG78?56>4E? 6?; A8BEI8A >38 56G8 :AEG >38 - 9 - 4?5@A8A 38 A8946?B8 796B8; E? >38 F@;CG8?> E: EEA;4?6>8 <8?B3E:>345E@A>H499?E>BEG8>E>3864;E:>384?5@A6?B8 BEG76?= :EA >38 54G798 A865E? >36> >38 :6B>5 4? >3E58 B6585 6?; >38 :6B>5 E? >38 B658 E? 36?; 65 365 <88? A4C3>9= BE?>8?;8; <= >38 986A?8; BE@?589 67786A4?C :EA >38 A857E?;8?>+B964G6?>6A8>E>699=;4::8A8?>38A845B986A:4?;4?C 4? >38 F@;CG8?> A8:8AA8; >36> >38 EH?8A BE?5B4E@59= 36I4?C J?EH98;C8 E: >38 :6B> >36> >38 ;A4I8A H65 ?E> 3E9;4?C 677AE7A46>8 I694; 94B8?B8 8?>A@5>8; 34G >E ;A4I8 >38 I834B98 8A84?4?>38B658 >38EH?8AH65796B8;8K!76A>838A845?E G6>8A469E?A8BEA;>E53EH>36>>38EH?8ABE?5B4E@59=36I4?C J?EH98;C8 E: >38 :6B> >36> >38A8 45 ?E I694; ;A4I4?C 94B8?58 8574>88?>A@5>8;>3878A5E?>E;A4I8>38E::8?;4?CI834B98? >3858 B4AB@G5>6?B85 >38 F@;CG8?>5 A8:8AA8; 5@7A6 H499 ?E> BEG8 >E >38 64; E: >38 6778996?>!4?5@A6?B8 BEG76?= ;45>4?C@4536<98 E? :6B> 6?; 6A8 67794B6<98 #38A865 A4C3>9= BE?>8?;8; <= >38 986A?8; BE@?589 67786A4?C :EA> >38 A857E?;8?>+B964G6?> >38E?L<9878KE@A>4? H6A6? 4?C3 6>76A6EG6;84>I8A=B986AH3498455@4?CC@4;894?85 >38 B4AB@G5>6?B85 H38A8 >38 4?5@A6?B8 BEG76?= 45 7A4G6A49= <8 G6;8 946<98 >E 76= >38 BEG78?56>4E? 6?; A8BEI8A >38 56G8 - 10 - :AEG>384?5@A8A345365<88?:E99EH8;<=>38E?L<9878K E@A> 4? 677@ 6;6I B658 ? 948@ E: >38 F@;CG8?>5 E: >38 E?L<98 78K E@A> @7A6 H8 3E9; >36> >38A8 45 ?E 4?:4AG4>= BEGG4>>8; <= >38 A4<@?69 H3498 ;4A8B>4?C >38 4?5@A6?B8 BEG76?= 7A4G6A49= 946<98 >E 76= >38 BEG78?56>4E? 6?; 5@<58D@8?>9= A8BEI8A >38 56G8 :AEG >38 4?5@A8A ? >3858 B4AB@G5>6?B85 >38 :4?;4?C5 E: >38 >A4<@?69 6A8 F@5>4:48; BBEA;4?C9= H8 6?5H8A >38 7E4?> E 4? >38 6::4AG6>4I8 6?; BE?:4AG8;>3856G8 % ")*+ - E :6A 65 >38 D@6?>@G E: BEG78?56>4E?45BE?B8A?8; >38986A?8;BE@?58967786A4?C:EA >38 6778996?>!4?5@A6?B8 BEG76?= HE@9; BE?>8?; >36> >38 G6AA48;;6@C3>8A56A8BE?54;8A8;H3498B69B@96>4?C:EA>389E55 E: ;878?;8?B= BE@?>4?C >38G H3498 ;8;@B>4?C 78A5E?69 8K78?585 6?; 796B8; A8946?B8 E? >38 F@;CG8?> E: >38 E?L<98 78KE@A>4? @7A6 ' 6I4?C386A;>38986A?8;BE@?58967786A4?C:EA>38 6778996?>!4?5@A6?B8BEG76?= H836I8CE?8>3AE@C3>388?>4A8 F@;CG8?>E: EH8I8A >38F@;CG8?>76558;<= >38E?L<9878KE@A>4? "6?; # - 11 - 5@7A66A8?E>6>699B4>8;6?;;45B@558;4?>38F@;CG8?>E: ?>3858B4AB@G5>6?B85 >38564;F@;CG8?> 45 ;45>4?C@4536<98 6?; ?E> 67794B6<98 >E >38 :6B>5 E: >38 B658E?36?;?I48HE:>3896H964;;EH?<=>38E?L<98 78K E@A> 4? 6?; # G6FEA G6AA48;6?;86A?4?C5E?65H89965>38G6AA48;;6@C3>8A 6A8 695E 8?>4>98; >E <8 BE@?>8; 65 ;878?;8?> E: >38 ;8B8658;?I48HE:>3856G8 H83E9;>36>>38>A4<@?69 365 A4C3>9= BEG8 >E >38 BE?B9@54E? >36> >38 G6AA48; ;6@C3>8A56A8695E8?>4>98;>E<8BE@?>8;65;878?;8?>E? >38 ;8B8658; 6I4?C CE?8>3AE@C3>38 8?>4A8F@;CG8?> 6?;6H6A;E:>38BE?B8A?8;>A4<@?69 H8:4?;?E4?:4AG4>= 4?>38F@;CG8?>E:>38>A4<@?696?;6BBEA;4?C9= H86::4AG >38 56G8 6?5H8A4?C >38 7E4?>5 :EA BE?54;8A6>4E? 4? 6::4AG6>4I86?;6C64?5>>384?5@A6?B8BEG76?= EA>38:EACE4?CA865E?5 H87655>38:E99EH4?C- - 12 - 4* 386778695>6?;5;45G4558; 44* 386GE@?>4?;87E54><8>A6?5G4>>8;>E>38 >A4<@?69:EA;45<@A58G8?> 444* 38 <696?B8 6GE@?> 69E?C H4>3 4?>8A85> 65 6H6A;8; <= >38 >A4<@?69 53699 <8 ;87E54>8; <= >38 4?5@A6?B8 BEG76?= H4>34? 54K H88J5 :AEG>38;6>8E:A8B847>E:BE7=E:>345EA;8A <8:EA8>38BE?B8A?8;>A4<@?69 4I* 38 677EA>4E?G8?> 6?; ;45<@A58G8?> E: BEG78?56>4E?456578A>38;4A8B>4E?5455@8; <=>38>A4<@?69 I* EEA;8A65>EBE5> 8?; >38 >A469 E@A> A8BEA;5 :EA>3H4>3 8?6<94?C >38 4?5@A6?B8 BEG76?= 65 H899 65 >38 B964G6?>5 :EA ;87E54>4?C 6?; H4>3;A6H4?C E: >38 BEG78?56>4E? ,- %"' $ ,- %' $ +45>E- 9E-'+-