Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 64162 (KAR)

RATHNAMMA AND ORS v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

WP/200081/2024 · 2025-10-23

M G S Kamal

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " # $%&!%!% '(!) ! "# $ ! "# % &# ! "# " % ! "# $ ! "# Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & & ! "# ! "# ! & ! "# ' % ! "# # ( & ! "# ) * + , ,, &### ,, ! "# - 3 - % ,, ! "# " ,, ! "# ,, ! "# & , ,, ,, ! "# , # ) *$ + , , , *+ , , # # # ! ,, # ( , " , , , , - *+ , ##%#% % , '!#% ##%#% ( , % " , , , , ., / ' , - *+ , - 4 - ' , " , # , " ( / ,- *+ / , , ,$ , ./ 0$ * 0$+ 12 32454567289 :82 ;2<682 4159 6=84 922>57? <6@@6A57?82@52<9 !"#$% %##& ' ( ) ' '*+*,'' -./ &- ' , '',0 11 1 ' 234522.672#8$61 11 ( ' ' *'1 ' *+ * ,'' ./ &- ' , 9 : ' 8## 2;20 - 5 - < '8 ## 2;2 ' *+ %# =# #+ ( 3 ' =:' 0 ! 6 =:' 7 - > ? :926<412324545672895941:4412BA282599=2C A541 9:?=D:@5 E154 :9 328 ,68F./ 57 ,68F 6 57 82932E46<@:7C57B 6"46:72G42746<&:E8292:E1 ;257? ?8:742C " :E829 %! ?=74:9 954=:42C :4 1:13=8 5@@:?25C:8:@=>:7C59485E457<5@2 6 &% !C:42C##'!#:9328772G=82946'386C=E2C :@67? A854 32454567 16=?1 412 @:7C9 A282 ?8:742C 57 <:D6=86<41232454567289412587:F29A282764274282C57 412 82D27=2 82E68C9 1:4 41282 A:9 E284:57 57428<2827E2 ;B412829367C274:=416854529E67948:5757?41232454567289 46<5@2:9=5457 6 "6<'!&67412<5@26<857E53:@ =795<<5C:8A15E1A:9C2E822C67#!''" - 6 - % 1:4 412 32454567289 1:C F:C2 823829274:4567 922>57? 2748B 6< 41258 7:F29 57 412 82D27=2 82E68C9 57 82932E4 6< 412 :<6829:5C 3863284B 7 82936792 412826< 829367C274 6" 599=2C :7 27C6892F274 D5C2 6' C:42C#&###:9328772G=82C2E@5757?41282H=294 6< 32454567289 67 412 382F592 41:4 412 9=;I2E4 @:7C 1:9 ;227 1:7C2C 6D28 46 412 ,68294 23:84F274 :7C 412 C24:5@96<E6@=F7 6'6<82E68C6<85?149A2827644:@@B57? A541C24:5@96<E6@=F7 6# " 459412<=84128E:926<4123245456728941:4412 829367C274=416854529 16A2D28 ;:92C 67 E284:57 E6FF=75E:45679 A15E1279=2C3=89=:7446:6D287F274 8C28C:42C# # #386C=E2C:@67?A541772G=82 *:4:?2 6'&+6<412A85432454567:82E@:5F57?41:4412 9=;I2E4 @:7C :@67? A541 412 64128 @:7C9 1:D2 ;227 E6795C282C :9 .C22F2C <68294/ A5416=4 386D5C57? :7B 9=8D2B 7=F;289 F2:9=82F2749 68 :7B 64128 3:845E=@:89 1:4412386E299:C6342C;B412829367C274=416854529 59E6748:8B46412386D5956796<412:87:4:>:,68294E4 - 7 - '&% J128257:<428 82<2882C 46 :9 .412 E4 '&%/ <68 ;82D54BK 2:872C E6=792@ <68 412 32454567289 932E5<5E:@@B 82<28857?462E4567"6<412E4'&%E67427C2C41:45< 412829367C274=416854529F6823:845E=@:8@B412,68294 23:84F27457427C46482:4412@:7C957E@=C57?412@:7C9 ;257?E@:5F2C;B41232454567289:9:82928D2<68294412B :8282H=582C46599=2:7645<5E:45675741:482?:8C:7C67@B 4127 412B E:7 E@:5F 412 @:7C 46 ;2 412 <68294 @:7C 2 9=;F549 A127 :CF5442C@B 412 9=;I2E4 @:7C 1:9 ;227 ?8:742C57<:D6=86<41232454567289;B599=57?9:?=D:@5E154 57,68F 6:7C4129:F27641:D57?;227A541C8:A7 68 E:7E2@@2C ;B 412 829367C274 82D27=2 :=416854529 1:7C57? 6D28 412 9:5C @:7C 46 412 ,68294 23:84F274 A5416=4 <6@@6A57? C=2 386E299 6< @:A :7C E6792H=274@B C2E@5757? 46 27428 412 7:F29 6< 412 32454567289 57 412 82D27=282E68C959:8;548:8B=782:967:;@2:7C82H=582946 ;257428<282CA541 282@529=36741268C2893:992C;B412 668C57:42 ;27E1 6< 4159 6=84 57 - 8 - J K 2 :@96 82@529 =367 412 I=C?F274 6< 412 5D59567 27E1 6< 4159 6=84 57 ! J " "# " $ # K 46 9=;F54 41:4 A5416=4 :C12827E2 46 412386D5956796<412E4'&%F6823:845E=@:8@B2E4567" 412826< 412 829367C274 =416854529 E:7764 C27B 412 32454567289 41258 85?14 46 27I6B 41258 3863284B 57 428F9 6< 412 ?8:74 :@82:CB F:C2 57 41258 <:D6=8 27E2 12 922>9 <68:@@6A57?6<412A85432454567 & ! @2:872C CC54567:@ 6D287F274 CD6E:42 A15@2 82<28857? 46 412 94:42F274 6< 6;I2E45679 <5@2C9=;F54941:4412@:7C957H=2945671:C;2271:7C2C 6D2846412,6829423:84F27457412B2:8'!A15@2412 ?8:74 57 H=294567 1:9 ;227 F:C2 57 412 B2:8 '!# 7 64128A68C9129=;F54941:4412?8:74F:C257<:D6=86< 41232454567289A:99=;92H=27446412C:4267A15E1@:7C9 1:C ;227 1:7C2C 6D28 46 412 ,68294 23:84F274 - 9 - 6A2D28957E241282D27=22748529A282764F:C2574159 82?:8C 41282 59 :7 28868 57 599=57? 412 9:?=D:@5 E154 57 <:D6=86<41232454567289 2:@969=;F54941:44129=;I2E4 @:7C9 1:D2 ;227 57E@=C2C 57 412 @594 6< .C22F2C <68294/ 3=89=:74 46 412 C582E4567 599=2C ;B 412 670;@2 =382F2 6=84 6< 7C5: D5C2 549 68C28 C:42C ''& 3:992C 57 $ % 2 9=;F54941:4: I6574 9=8D2B 1:9 ;227 E67C=E42C 57 41:4 412 @:7C ;257? E@:5F2C;B41232454567281:9;2275C2745<52C:9@:7C<:@@57? A54157 412 C22F2C <68294 :82: 2 <=84128 9=;F549 41:4 412821:9;22776:?85E=@4=8:@:E45D54529 2<:58@B9=;F549 41:4 416=?1 412 9:?=D:@5 E1549 1:D2 ;227 599=2C 76 386E22C57?946A541C8:A6882D6>24129:5C9:?=D:@5E1549 1:9;22757545:42C;B412829367C274=416854529 2:@96 9=;F54941:4412829367C274=416854529A5@@@66>5746412 38638524B6864128A5926<412?8:7468C289:7C:@96A6=@C @66>5746412F:77286<1:7C57?6D284129=;I2E4@:7C946 412,6829423:84F274:7C412E6F3@5:7E25<:7B46412 386D595679 6< 412 E4 '&% A6=@C ;2 9485E4@B :C1282C 46 - 10 - :<428 :<<68C57? 9=<<5E5274 633684=754B 46 412 32454567289 27E212922>9<68C59369:@6<41232454567A54172E299:8B C582E456757415982?:8C =;F599567594:>276782E68C ! 2:8C28=92C41282E68C9 ' 12825976C593=42A541412<:E441:4412@:7C57 B 6" F2:9=857? ! :E829 6=4 6< A15E1 & :E829 % ?=74:9 6< @:7C 1:D57? ;227 ?8:742C 57 <:D6=8 6< 412 32454567289 2:E1 6< 412 32454567289 ;257? 27454@2C <68 " :E829 %# ?=74:9 1282 59 :@96 76 C593=42 6D28 412 <:E4 41:441232454567289A282599=2CA5419:?=D:@5E15457,68F 667##'!#5794:74 6A2D28412587:F291:D2 764 ;227 274282C 57 412 82D27=2 82E68C9 2454567289 1:C 2D27 :3386:E12C 412 5D5@ 6=84 ;B <5@57? : 9=54 57 6 "'!&57A15E1412B1:D26;4:572C:C2E82257 41258<:D6=8A15E182:C9:9=7C28 # . ' ' - 11 - ' ' , '> , 7 " *,'7 % - > , ' ' @ ' A = , - ' < ' ,' ' '' '? # 12 829367C274 L =416854529 67 412 64128 1:7C :82 C2E@5757? 46 E6795C28 412 82H=2946< 32454567289 4627428412587:F25741282D27=282E68C967412382F592 6<4129=;I2E4@:7C1:D57?;2271:7C2C6D2846412,68294 23:84F274F=E13856846599=:7E26<412?8:74E2845<5E:42 57<:D6=86<41232454567289 28=9:@6<41282E68C9<=8412882D2:@41:441282 1:9 ;227 76 7645<5E:4567 599=2C ;B 412 829367C274 =41685452957E@=C57?;B412,6829423:84F274C2E@:857? 82928D57?412@:7C9;2@67?57?4641232454567289254128:9: 4:@=>:<6829468C59485E4<682946841282928D2C<68294:9412 E:92F:B;212?8:74F:C2:7C4129:?=D:@5E154599=2C - 12 - 57 <:D6=8 6< 412 32454567289 59 :@96 :CF5442C@B 9=;959457? 2D27 45@@ 46C:B 12 94:@2F:42 16A2D28 59 E67457=57? :9 :EE68C57? 46 412 829367C274 L 4:42 E284:57 @:7C9 57E@=C57?412@:7C9;257?E@:5F2C;B412324545672891:D2 ;227 E6795C282C :9 .C22F2C <68294/ 6A2D28 76 3:845E=@:891:D2;227<=875912C57415982?:8C 7 412 @5?14 6< 412 :<6829:5C <:E49 :7C 412 9=;F5995679F:C2;B412@2:872CE6=792@<684123:84529 4159 A854 32454567 59 % A541 412 <6@@6A57? C582E45679 12 32454567289 91:@@ F:>2 : <8291 823829274:4567 :@67? A541 :@@ C6E=F2749 I=945<B57? 41258 E@:5F 6D28 412 3863284B 46 829367C274 6 2E824:8B 23:84F274 6< 2D27=2 A54157 %# C:B9 <86F 412 C:42 6< 82E25346<E2845<52CE63B6<415968C28 29367C274 6 2E824:8B 23:84F274 6< 2D27=2 :<428 ?5D57? 9=<<5E5274 633684=754B 46 41232454567289:9A2@@:923=4B67928D:4686< ,68294 =;5D59567 5C:8 A16 59 829367C274 - 13 - 6 128257 3:99 :3386385:42 68C289 F682 3:845E=@:8@BC2428F5757?4127:4=826<412@:7C :7C :@96 A541 82?:8C 46 412 ?8:74 F:C2 57 <:D6=86<41232454567289 <5459<6=7C41:4412@:7C9?8:742C57<:D6=86< 412 32454567289 46 ;2 D:@5C :7C 9=;959457? 829367C274 691:@@ 599=2<=84128C582E456746 829367C274 6946"463:9972E299:8B68C289 =367412:33@5E:4567<5@2C;B41232454567289<68 2742857?412587:F295741282D27=282E68C9 < 54 59 <6=7C 64128A592 12 91:@@ 3:99 :3386385:42 68C289 :CD28457? 46 <:E49 :7C @:A 7:88:42C 128257:;6D2 :7C E6FF=75E:42 412 9:F24641232454567289 12 2G28E592 :9 C582E42C :;6D2 91:@@ ;2 =7C284:>27:7CE6F3@242CA54157:32856C6<& F67419 <86F 412 C:42 6< 412 32454567289 9=;F54457?41258823829274:45679:9:;6D2 - 14 - , 4 59 F:C2 E@2:8 41:4 957E2 412 32454567289 1:D2 ;227 57 3699299567 6< 412 @:7C 57 428F9 6< 412 ?8:74 68C28 957E2 412 B2:8 '!# 41258 369929956791:@@764;2C594=8;2C45@@41268C289 :9C582E42C:;6D2:823:992C 541 412 :;6D2 6;928D:45679 412 32454567 94:7C9 % !*( '%!%) & 594 6@ 6!