Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 64145 (KAR)
G P DHOBALE v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
WP/203883/2025 · 2025-12-15
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64145 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64145 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#$
! % #&!! % #&!"&' "
(!!) *
+
(!)
*
! " # $% & '
&$ $
%&$ $ %& %
! Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%%
(!!! ) %%
* ! +
* ! $ & $
$ ! "
# % & +* &
'
&
, & & & ! -
% $
! ! ./
&
+*
- 3 -
*
! # $% & '
&$ $
%&$ $ %& %
! %%
(!!! ) $ & $
$ ! ! "
# % & 0* &
)'
&
, & & & ! - %
$
!+
! &
- 4 -
%& % 1- %
% 2 % 345 2 %
## #2 % '
647879::946;;<8;3=864>9?>8564@A8;8@B9B=6@ C8@6@694;@A8D3=8@3E84<C@9F8@A8=A83=534556;C9;85 9GHD@A6;79::949=58=
A8;8 @B9 B=6@ C8@6@694; 3=8 G6?85 HD 79::94 C8@6@6948= 43:8?D =6 A9H3?8 ;88E64F @9 ;8@ 3;658 @A8 79::94 9=58= 53@85 ! 64 CC?673@694 9!+
! B CC?673@6949! !C3;;85HD $3=43@3E3 @3@8 5:646;@=3@6>8 =6H<43? $3?3H<=3F6 #G9= ;A9=@ 1@A8 =6H<43?-' BA8=8HD @A8 =6H<43? 587?6485 @9 I<3;A @A8 @=34;G8= 9=58= 53@85 !(! 6;;<85 HD =8;C94584@ 9 345 @A8 :956G685 @=34;G8= 9=58= 53@85 (!(! - 5 -
) A8 73;8 9G @A8 C8@6@6948= 6; @A3@ A8 B3;
B9=E64F 3; 8C<@D 3A;6?53= 3@ 3F3@A34 3?<E 6;@ 6J3D3C<= @ 6; A6; 73;8 @A3@ @A8 C8@6@6948= A3; H884 8?87@85 3; 3 %8:H8=9G @A8 6;@=67@ K87<@6>8 9::6@@88 9G $3=43@3E3 @3@8 :C?9D88; ;;9763@694 #' 6;@=67@ 46@ 6J3D3C<= HD 9@6G673@694 53@85 !+ G9= @A8 C8=695 G=9: !+ @9 !( A8=83G@8= HD 49@6G673@694 53@85 !! # 448K<=8/ ' A8 A3; H884 49:643@85 3; 678/=8;6584@ 9G 6;@=67@ 46@ 6J3D3C<=3 D 9=58= 53@85 !(! 448K<=8/ )@A8=8;C94584@9 64 9!))
! 345 =8;C94584@ 9) 64 9!)+
! A3; H884 @=34;G8==85 @9 @A8 C8@6@6948=-; C?378 3A;6?53=-; 9GG678 3F3@A34 3?<E 6;@ 6J3D3C<=3 864F 3FF=68>85 HD @A8 @=34;G8= 9=58= @A8 C8@6@6948= A3; 3CC=937A85 @A8 =6H<43? HD G6?64F 3CC?673@694 64 CC?673@694 9!+
! ;88E64F 64@8=6:
9=58= 345 @A8 =6H<43? A3; ;@3D85 @A8 @=34;G8= 9=58= 64 =8;C87@9GC8@6@6948=345=8;C94584@9
- 6 -
+ A8=83G@8=
448K<=8/ , 53@85 (!(! 948 :9=8 :956G673@694 9=58= 73:8 @9 H8 C3;;85 HD =8;C94584@ 9 BA8=8HD @A8 C8@6@6948= A3; H88456=87@85@9=8C9=@@9@A85<@DH8G9=8@A8A8359GG678 864F 3FF=68>85 HD @A8 9=58= 53@85 (!(! @A8 C8@6@6948= G6?85 948 :9=8 3CC?673@694 64 CC?673@694 9! ! A8 =6H<43? HD @A8 6:C<F485 9=58= 53@85 !
56;:6;;85 H9@A @A8 3CC?673@694; 94 @A8 F=9<45 @A3@ C8@6@6948= 6; 3 49:643@85 678/=8;6584@ 9G 6;@=67@ 46@ 345 A6; @=34;G8= 6; 49@ C=9@87@85 <458= @A8 =34;G8=<658?648;53@85 !! 83=485 8469= 9<4;8? =6 6?3; $<:3= 3CC83=64F 94 H8A3?G 9G C8@6@6948= A3; 794@84585 @A3@ @A8 $3=43@3E3 @3@8 9>8=4:84@ :C?9D88; A3; 34 3;;9763@694 43:8?D $3=43@3E3 @3@8 9>8=4:84@ :C?9D88; ;;9763@694345@A8DA3>8@A86=9B4HD8/?3B; ;C8=@A8HD8/?3B@A8678/=8;6584@9G6;@=67@46@3?;9 79:8; B6@A64 @A8 :83464F 9G 9GG678 H83=8= 9G @A8 @3@8 46@ 64 >68B 9G @A8 =34;G8= <658?648; 458= ;<7A
- 7 -
76=7<:;@3478;BA84@A8C8@6@6948=H864F@A89GG678H83=8= A8 73449@ H8 @=34;G8==85 794@=3=D @9 @A8 =34;G8= <658?648; 345 64 @A8 73;8 94 A345 A8 A3; H884 @=34;G8==85G=9:3F3@A34@3?<E6;@6J3D3C<=3B6@A9<@ ;A9B64F@A8C?3789GC9;@64F
A8 ?83=485 8469= 9<4;8? G<=@A8= 794@84585 @A3@ @A8 @3@8 9>8=4:84@ H8G9=8 A3=B3=5 847A A3;
G6?85 34 3GG653>6@ 64 9 !,,
! BA8=8HD 6@ A3;
H884 7?3=6G685 @A3@ 3?? 8?87@85 9GG678 H83=8=; 9G @A8 $3=43@3E3@3@89>8=4:84@:C?9D88;- ;;9763@694 @A9;8BA93=89GG678H83=8=;3@@A8@3?<E56;@=67@345@3@8 ?8>8?; 3=8 3?? C=9@87@85 G=9: @A8 @=34;G8= <458= @A8 =34;G8= <658?648; 8478 BA84 @A8=8 H864F 3 7?83= F<658?648; 794@=3=D @9 @A3@ @A8 C8@6@6948= A3; H884 @=34;G8==85
,
3;@?D @A8 ?83=485 8469= 9<4;8? 794@84585 @A3@ =8;C94584@ 9 64 9!))
! 345 =8;C94584@ 9) 64 9!)+
! A3; H884
- 8 -
@=34;G8==85 @9 @A8 C8@6@6948=-; C?378 B6@A9<@ ;A9B64F 34D C?3789GC9;@64F@9@A8C8@6@6948=A8=8G9=8@A8@=34;G8= 9=58=53@85 (!(!6@;8?G6;B6@A9<@J<=6;567@694
4;<CC9=@9GA6;3=F<:84@;@A8?83=4858469= 9<4;8? =8?685 94 @A8 J<5F:84@ 9G 79/9=5643@8 847A 9G @A6;9<=@64@A873;89G !=8C9=@8564
"#!$
4 @A8;8 F=9<45; C=3D85 @9 3??9B @A8 B=6@ C8@6@694;
(
?83=485 79<4;8? 3CC83=64F G9= @A8 =8;C94584@ 9 64 9!))
! 345 =8;C94584@ 9) 64 9!)+
! 794@84585 @A3@ 3; C8= @A8 =34;G8=<658?648;GG67883=8=;9G@A8@3@89::6@@88 A3; H884 C=9@87@85 G=9: @=34;G8= BA84 @A8D 3=8 A9?564F K87<@6>89;@64@A834FA3<@64@A873;894A345 @A8 C8@6@6948= 6; 3 49:643@85 678/=8;6584@ 9G 6;@=67@ 9::6@@88345@A8=86;49H3=G9=A6:@9@=34;G8=>8464 @A8 HD8/?3B; 6@ 6; >8=D 7?83=?D :84@69485 @A3@ 9GG678
- 9 -
H83=8=;9G@A86;@=67@9::6@@88734H8@=34;G8==85B6@A64 @A8 56;@=67@ 6478 @A8 C8@6@6948= A3; H884 @=34;G8==85 B6@A64@A8 6;@=67@ @A8=86; 49 8==9=64 @A8@=34;G8=9=58= C3;;85HD@A89>8=4:84@8794@845@A3@@A8=6H<43? A3;=6FA@?D=8J87@85@A83CC?673@694;G6?85HD@A8C8@6@6948= H8G9=8 @A8 =6H<43? 345 3779=564F?D C=3D85 @9 =8J87@ @A8 C=8;84@B=6@C8@6@694;
! 83=485 556@6943? 9>8=4:84@ 5>973@8 3CC83=64F G9= @A8 =8;C94584@/ @3@8 ;<H:6@; @A3@ 3; C8= @A856=87@694;9G@A6;9<=@3@A3=B35847A@A8458= 87=8@3=D @9 9>8=4:84@ G6?85 3GG653>6@ BA8=8HD 6@ 6; 7?3=6G685 @A3@ 3??
9GG678 H83=8=; 9G $3=43@3E3 @3@8 9>8=4:84@:C?9D88; ;;9763@694647?<58;9GG678H83=8=;
9G @A8 @3?<E 56;@=67@ 345 @3@8 ?8>8? 3=8 C=9@87@85 G=9: @=34;G8=BA84@A8D3=89GG678H83=8=;
83=5 @A8 ?83=485 79<4;8? G9= @A8 C3=@68; 345 C8=<;85@A8B=6@C8@6@694C3C8=;
- 10 -
@6;49@6456;C<@8@A3@@A8C8@6@6948=A3;H884 B9=E64F 3; 8C<@D 3A;6?53= 3@ 3F3@A34 @3?<E 6;@ 6J3D3C<=3 D 9=58= 53@85 !(! =8;C94584@ 9 64 9!))
! 345 =8;C94584@ 9) 64 9!)+
! A3; H884 @=34;G8==85 @9 C8@6@6948=-;
C?378 68 3A;6?53=-; 9GG678 3F3@A34 3?<E 6;@ 6J3DC3<=3A8C8@6@6948=A3;49@H884;A9B434DC?378 9G C9;@64F D 9=58= 53@85 (!(! C8@6@6948= A3; H88456=87@85@9=8C9=@@9A8359GG678
) A86>6;694847A9G@A6;9<=@64@A873;89G #
'A8?5@A3@B6@A9<@;A9B64F@A8C?378 9G C9;@64F @=34;G8==64F @A8 8:C?9D88 73449@ H8 ;365 @A3@ >37347D64@A8?3BA353=6;8;A8=8?8>34@C3=399G @A8;365J<5F:84@A3;H8848K@=37@853;<458=
- 11 -
! ! "
#
! $
! %
&'
&('
! ! &'
&('
&'$&'
#
&(' )
*
! * ! ! +
! %
! ,
" - + 4 @A8 3G9=8;365 F=9<45 3?;9 @A8 @=34;G8= 9G =8;C94584@ 9 64 9!))
! 345 =8;C94584@ 9) 64 9!)+
! HD 9=58= 53@85 !(! - 12 -
345 794G6=:64F @A8 ;3:8 HD 9=58= 53@85 (!(! 6;
<4;<;@3643H?8 >84 @A8 C8@6@6948= B3; 8?87@85 3; 3 6=87@9= 9G 6;@=67@ K87<@6>8 9::6@@88 6J3D3C<=3 6;@=67@ 94 !+ A3; H884 49:643@85 3; 678/ =8;6584@9G6;@=67@46@6J3D3C<= ;;@3@853H9>8@A8 9>8=4:84@ A3; G6?85 3GG653>6@ 7?3=6GD64F @A3@ ?3<;8/ #,'# '#8'9G=34;G8=<658?648;53@85!!+@A3@@A8 9GG678 H83=8=; 9G @A8 $3=43@3E3 @3@8 9>8=4:84@ :C?9D88; ;;9763@694 647?<58; @A9;8 BA9 3=8 9GG678 H83=8=;9G@3?<E356;@=67@345@3@8?8>8?345@A8D73449@ H8@=34;G8==85<4@6?8KC6=3@6949G@A86=@8=:
&9= =835D =8G8=8478 @A8 3GG653>6@ G6?85 HD @A8 @3@8 9>8=4:84@ 64 9 !,,
! H8G9=8 @A8 847A3@A3=B356;8K@=37@853;<458= L' . $
/ 01 2
23
45 ! # +
! 6 7
8
9+ 8):; 3 +
(
). ! ! <)
- 13 -
=$ )
%
! >
6
/
#
:
!, ? 0 @
.5==AA1=5=4 9+)/;
< B
7! 7
,
7 ! A9.;9;
6 =45=5=C ! ! +
! 7
6
! 7! 7
,
%! +
! 78
! ! A9.;9;
6 =45=5=C
! B
/
# + 6
D ! B
! #
- 14 -
! ! + C , ? +
! 6 7
8
! A9.;9;
6 @ 78 :: +8 =5=C
=45=5=C
! =5=C)=4 4 $
A9.; 9;
6 < =45=5=C /
D <
“
!! "#
$ B$
/
# + 6
D !? B
, ?
A9.;9;
6
<=45=5=C
/
# + 6 D !? #
- 15 -
A
, ? 6 ? E
!#
-
6478 @A8 C8@6@6948= 6; 3?;9 9GG678 H83=8= 9G 6;@=67@ K87<@6>8 9::6@@88 9G 6J3D3C<= 6;@=67@ <458= =34;G8= <658?648; A8 73449@ H8 @=34;G8==85 A9B8>8= 794@=3=D @9 @A3@ @A8 6:C<F485 @=34;G8= 9=58= A3; H884 C3;;85>84?3<;8/,# '#8'9G=34;G8=<658?648;!+ 345?3<;8/#'9G=34;G8=<658?648;!3=8948345 @A8 ;3:8 4 @A6; F=9<45 3?;9 @A8 @=34;G8= 9=58= 9G =8;C94584@ 9 64 9!))
! 345 =8;C94584@ 9) 64 9!)+
! HD 9=58= 53@85 !(! 345 794G6=:64F @A8 @=34;G8= HD 9=58= 53@85 (!(! =8I<6=8;@9H8;8@3;658
, &9=@A8G9=8F964F=83;94;@A8B=6@C8@6@694;3=8 %%&' A8 79::94 9=58= 53@85 ! 64 CC?673@694 9!+
! B CC?673@694
- 16 -
9! !C3;;85HD$3=43@3E3@3@8 5:646;@=3@6>8 =6H<43? $3?3H<=3F6 6; ;8@ 3;658 345 794;8I<84@?D @A8 3G9=8;365 3CC?673@694; G6?85 HD @A8 C8@6@6948= H8G9=8 @A8 =6H<43?3=83??9B85
!,* (!) &
!,* ("&' ") &
6;@9 ?9(