- 1 - !"# $ % & && '#( ) ! " # $ % &'( & % % % ) % ( % &*( & + (*% +**', Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % ) " # + - ( $ + + ,.#$ + ) !(!((!(* .'%(!(( ) + + ) & & / ) % 01230 405 677568 9: 89:45; <1= 6;>9::91? @940 405 A1?:5?4 1< 856=?5; A12?:58 <1= 405 76=495: 94 9: 46B5? 27 <1=<9?68;9:71:68 ( 09: 677568 9: <985; CD 405 ?:2=6?A5 A1>76?D 6369?:4405E2;3>5?46?;6@6=;;645;!(!((!(*9? 1.'%(!(( 76::5; CD 405 5?91= 9F98 )2;35 6?; 64 86?;#<1=:01=4G405=9C2?68H$1?4053=12?; 1<896C9894D - 3 - . 05 A869>6?4 635; '! D56=: >54 @940 6? 6AA9;5?4 1? (!( 6?; :2:469?5; 3=95F12: 6?; <=6A42=5 9?E2=95: 05=5<1=5 :05 <985; 6 A869> 7549491? C5<1=5 405 =9C2?68 A869>9?3 A1>75?:6491? 1< :(!!!!!%681?3@9409?45=5:464405=6451<(I75= 6??2> <45= A1?:9;5=9?3 405 5?49=5 5F9;5?A5 1? =5A1=; 405 =9C2?68 06: 6@6=;5; 6 :2> 1< :( (,% 681?3 @9409?45=5:4J'I75=6??2><=1>405;6451<7549491?4988 405 ;645 1< =5689K6491? 6?; ;9=5A45; =5:71?;5?4 1( ?:2=6?A5 1>76?D 405=59? 41 ;571:94 405 :6>5 33=95F5;CD405:69;)2;3>5?46?;6@6=;405?:2=6?A5 1>76?D06:7=5<5==5;4057=5:5?46775681?4053=12?; 1<896C9894D * ? 405 7=5:5?4 677568 94 9: >69?8D A1?45?;5; 40644051@?5=%9?:2=5;1<405F509A859?A1882:91?@940405 7189A5786D5;<=62;6?;9>7856;5;4059?:2=5;F509A859? ;9<<5=5?46AA9;5?4:5:71?;5?4105=59?<985;A1>7869?4 6369?:4405;=9F5==6467 09F6E9 09?;51?((!(95 6<45=(;6D:1<4056AA9;5?405=59:?15L786?6491?<1= - 4 - 405 ;586D 05 :69; ;=9F5= 9: 405 1@?5= 1< 405 6?1405= ?;9A6 6= C56=9?3 =539:4=6491? 1( %*( 6?; 94 @6: 9?F18F5; 9? 405 6AA9;5?4 1? !*!(!( @9409? 405 E2=9:;9A491? 1< 405 :6>5 7189A5 :46491? 6369?:4 405 ;=9F5= 2;09= %1 1=B0 69B@6; @01 9: 405 1@?5= 1< 405 F509A85%=5:71?;5?4 1( 9? 405 7=5:5?4 A6:5 1 .%(!(( @6: <985; C5<1=5 405 86?; 140 405 6AA9;5?4: 411B 786A5 9? >5=36 606=6:04=6 4645 C24 405A869>:@5=5<985;9? 86?;401230405D6=5=5:9;9?39? 606=6:4=6 46451?8D41;5<=62;405?:2=6?A51>76?D 051@?5=:1<4054@1A6=:6=59?45=A06?35;6:;=9F5=:1< 405 1405= A6=: 6?; <985; <68:5 A6:5 6369?:4 4@1 ;9<<5=5?4 9?:2=5; F509A85: 6?; 402: =5M25:45; 41 :54 6:9;5 405 E2;3>5?46?;6@6=;1<405=9C2?68 05 ?:2=6?A5 1>76?D 9? 4059= @=9445? :4645>5?4C5<1=5405=9C2?6806::4645;4064405?6>51< 405;=9F5=9:>5?491?5;6:=6467 %1 09F6E9 09?;559: 6 <6B5 ;=9F5= 6?; ?14 ;=9F9?3 405 ?;931 6= C56=9?3 =539:4=6491?1(* +**',6?;9::01@?6:1@?5=1< - 5 - 405 ?;931A6=6?;=64679::01@?6:1@?5=1< ?;9A66=C56=9?3=539:4=6491?1( *(6?; 1 .%(!( 9: <985; C5<1=5 405 86?; =6467 @6: ?14 ;=9F9?3 405 1<<5?;9?3 F509A85 5:71?;5?4 1 9? A1882:91? @940 >5=36 9?:5=45; 405 :69; =6467H: ?6>56:6;=9F5=55?4=2:45;405F509A854140575=:1? @019:?14018;9?3F689;6?;5<<5A49F5;=9F9?389A5?A56:1? 405 ;645 1< 405 6AA9;5?4 05 ;=9F5= A1?45?;5; 4064 401230405?:2=6?A51>76?D06:46B5?4056C1F57856 9406:?146;;2A5;6?D5F9;5?A541:2C:46?49645405:6>5 05D:9>78D<985;405A17D1<4057189AD6:L :75= 405 70141 A17D 1< 405 =539:4=6491? A5=49<9A645 =5:71?;5?4 1 9: 405 1@?5= 1< 405 1<<5?;9?3 F509A85 6?; 405 :6>5 @6:9?5L9:45?A56:1?405;6451<4056AA9;5?4940405 :69;1C:5=F6491?405=9C2?68058;4064=5:71?;5?41: 6?; ( 6=5 E19?48D 6?; :5F5=688D 896C85 41 76D 405 A1>75?:6491? 6?; ;9=5A45; 405 ?:2=6?A5 1>76?D 41 9?;5>?9<D405=5:71?;5?416?;41;571:944056>12?4 @9409?1?5>1?40<=1>405;6451<4051=;5= - 6 - ' 01230 6775886?4?:2=6?A5 A1>76?D 06: A1?45?;5; 4064 1?5=6467 6?; 2;09= 9?45=A06?35; 4059= F509A85: 6?; :01@9?3 405 1405= 75=:1? 6: ;=9F5= 1< 405 F509A85: 405D 06F5 ?14 6;;2A5; 6?D 5F9;5?A5 59405= C5<1=5 405 =9C2?68 1= C5<1=5 405 677588645 12=4 05=5<1=5405=9C2?6806:=93048DA1?:9;5=5;4055F9;5?A5 1?=5A1=;6?;;9=5A45;405?:2=6?A51>76?D41;571:94 4056>12?409:12=4<9?;:?1=56:1?419?45=<5=59?405 :69;1=;5= , ?405=5:284405<1881@9?3& #9$ 05 677568 9: ;9:>9::5; A1?<9=>9?3 4059>723?5;E2;3>5?41<405=9C2?68- #99$ 05 6775886?4?:2=6?A5 1>76?D 9: ;9=5A45; 41 ;571:94 405 A1>75?:6491? 6>12?4 6@6=;5;CD405=9C2?68@9409?1?5>1?40<=1> 405;6451<409:E2;3>5?4- #999$ 05 6>12?4 ;571:945; CD 405 ?:2=6?A5 1>76?D C5<1=5 409: 12=4 :0688 C5 4=6?:>9445;41405=9C2?68<1=40@940- - 7 - #9F$ ? :2A0 ;571:94 405 A869>6?4 9: 75=>9445; 41 @940;=6@ 4055?49=5 6>12?4 681?3 @9409?45=5:46AA=25;1?94 *+, '& ( % 9:41& 81&,(