- 1 - !"# $#%## && '&(&) * ! ! " ! # $ % ! % & $ % ! ' ( ) Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " ! ' ( ) * ""* $ * $ !%"%!"+ +*!"# $ * % $ ""#!"!% , * !"+ * ** * $ - $ % # ( - $ ) ./0/1/203245646%37/8/167/4.956:748/92; 3;;79/</08=4./>:0;?/243200/@7//034/0!%"%!"+ A355/0 92 6+!"# 62 4./ 19B/ 61 4./ /2967 9<9B $:0;/34.9443A:7(./7/92314/77/1/77/04635C793B6:74D - 3 - 167 87/<94=) 8= E.9@. 4./ 5:94 167 A37494962 320 5/A3734/ A655/55962 19B/0 8= 4./ AB3924911 @3?/ 46 8/ 0/@7//0 .6B092;./7/2494B/0167F5.37/E.9@.95@62197?/08=4./ >:0;?/24 320 0/@7// 034/0 ""#!"!% A355/0 92 6,!"+ 62 4./ 19B/ 00949623B 95479@4 320 /559625 3B38:73;9 594492; 34 /03? (./7/92314/7 7/1/77/046354./C*9754AA/BB34/6:74D16787/<94=) ! ./ 5:8>/@4 ?344/7 61 4./ 5:94 95 B320 92 =6,# ?/35:792; # 3@7/5 ;:2435 594:34/0 34 :;:B;362<9BB3;/.9443A:73B:G3H./7/92314/77/1/77/046 354./C5:94A76A/74=D16787/<94=I # 0?944/0B= 4./ 5:94 A76A/74= 679;923BB= 8/B62;/04662/92;3AA3 :830939092;3AA3 :8309 A355/03E3=B/3<92;8/.9204E6562523?/B=.37323AA3 32022/AA3.37323AA3A355/03E3=B/3<92;8/.920.95 62B= 03:;.4/7 :073??3 E.6 95 4./ AB3924911 22/AA3 A355/03E3=B/3<92;8/.920.9503:;.4/792B3E3204.7// ;73205625 23?/B= () 3.30/<9 (!) 22/AA3 (#) - 4 - 3>G:?37(%)900:495@624/24/04.344./5:94A76A/74= 95 3 >6924 13?9B= A76A/74= 320 4./7/ E35 26 A37494962 6E/</7 4./ 7/</2:/ 7/@6705 92 7/5A/@4 61 4./ A76A/74= E35 ?:434/0 92 4./ 23?/ 61 4./ .:58320 320 134./7 7/5A/@49</B=614./0/1/20324523?/B=.32G373AA3.34 4./ AB3924911 .30 7/J:/54/0 167 A37494962 320 5/A3734/ A655/5596261./75.37/E.9@.E357/1:5/0;9<92;795/46 @3:5/6119B92;614./5:94 % /1/20324 65 46 % 19B/0 E7944/2 5434/?/24 30?94492; 4./ 7/B349625.9A 61 4./ AB3924911 320 4./ 0/1/203245563B564./A76A/74=8/92;4./32@/5473B>6924 13?9B= A76A/74= 6E/</7 94 95 @624/24/0 4.34 4./7/ 37/ 4E6 03:;.4/75 61 .32G373AA3 23?/B= 3;3??3 320 32;3??3E.6E/7/2643773=/035A3749/5464./5:945 5:@.4./5:9495830167262>6920/7612/@/5537=A3749/5 4 95 3B56 @624/20/0 4.34 .32G373AA3 320 22/AA3 .30 A/7167?/0 4./ ?37793;/ 61 4./ AB3924911 92 4./ =/37 +, E94.62/32:?324.73=3./293205./957/59092;924./ .6:5/61./7.:58320.3432/K4/24613@7/6:4614./ - 5 - 5:94B320E353@J:97/08=4./6</72?/24167167?3496261 7630 92 4./ =/37 +, ,+ @6?A/2534962 5 "" 92 4.957/;370E357/@/9</08=4./134./7614./AB3924911.34 3A374 AB3924911 E35 A390 5!%""" 8= .32G373AA3 92 4./=/37+ !46E3705./75.37/924./5:94B32055:@. 92@62590/73496261E.9@.5./.307/B92J:95./0./75.37/ 79;.4 494B/ 320 924/7/54 92 4./ A7/5/2@/ 61 4E6 E942/55/5 23?/B=900373?3AA33207322392@/4./AB3924911.30 0/?320/0 ?67/ ?62/= E.9@. E35 3B56 5/44B/0 320 4./ AB3924911 .30 /K/@:4/0 3 7/@/9A4 167 .3<92; 7/@/9</0 ./7 5.37/8=E3=61;6B0320@35.62"!""5./.3026 79;.4494B/67924/7/546</74./5:94A76A/74=/2@/56:;.4 167095?9553B614./5:94 ./793B6:74173?/04./16BB6E92;955:/5 - 6 - ! " # $ , B3924911 /K3?92/0 ./75/B1 35 /K.9894/0 59K4//2 06@:?/245 35 K5 46 , /1/20324 6! /K3?92/0.9?5/B135 /K.9894/0/B/</206@:?/24535 K5 46 23AA7/@934962614.//<90/2@/4./793B 6:74325E/7/0955:/65!320924./31197?349</# 320 % 92 4./ 2/;349</ 320 @625/J:/24B= 0/@7//0 4./ 5:94 35 A73=/0 167 /92; 3;;79/</0 0/1/203245 A7/1/77/0 7/;:B37 3AA/3B 92 6,!"+ ./ *9754 AA/BB34/ 6:74173?/04./16BB6E92;A69245167@62590/734962 % " & ' ( ) & - 7 - % % % " ' ' & & % & * % & & ( !' +& & % % " % , 2 7/3AA7/@934962 4./ *9754 AA/BB34/ 6:74 325E/7/0 A6924 65 46 # 92 4./ 2/;349</ 320 @625/J:/24B= 095?955/0 4./ 3AA/3B @62197?92; 4./ >:0;?/24 320 0/@7// A355/0 8= 4./ 793B 6:74 ;39254 E.9@. 4./ 3AA/BB32450/1/203245 37/ 8/167/ 4.95 6:74 92 4.955/@6203AA/3B - 8 - /372/0 @6:25/B 167 4./ 3AA/BB3245 7/94/73492; 4./;76:205:7;/0924./?/?67320:?613AA/3B5:8?945 4.34 62 A760:@4962 61 4./ 7/@/9A4 034/0 "!"" /<90/2@92; 7/@/9A4 61 5!%""" 320 % 46B35 61 ;6B0 8= AB3924911 92 B9/: 61 ./7 5.37/ 4./ 793B 6:74 .30 097/@4/0 9?A6:2092; 61 4./ 5390 06@:?/24 320 167 A3=?/24 61 543?A 0:4= 4./7/62 5 3;39254 4./ 5390 670/7 3 E794 A/494962 E35 19B/0 92 6!",%"!"+ ./ 5390 E794 A/494962@3?/468/095A65/06162"!!"!!8=E.9@. 49?/ 4./ 5:94 945/B1 E35 0/@7//0 2 4./ E794 670/7 4.95 6:74 .30 7/5/7</0 B98/74= 167 4./ A/494962/75 4./7/92 46 7395/ 4./ 955:/ 92 4./ 3AA/3B ./2 4./ 0/1/203245 19B/0 4./3AA/3B926,!"+32056:;.4467/B=:A624./ 539006@:?/244./*9754AA/BB34/6:743B562/;34/0320 0/@B92/04643G/9246@62590/7349624./53907/@/9A4624./ A7/?95/ 4.34 53?/ 264 8/92; 30?95598B/ 92 4./ B9;.4 61 /@4962 61 4./ /;954734962 @4 +" .:5 B/372/0 @6:25/B1674./3AA/BB32455:8?9454.344./793B6:74320 4./*9754AA/BB34/6:74.3<//77/092264@62590/792;4./ - 9 - 539006@:?/248/92;9230?95598B/924./B9;.461/@4962 61 4./ /;954734962 @4 9235?:@. 35 4./ 5390 06@:?/24 2/94./7 3?6:245 46 3 0//0 61 @62</=32@/ 267 06/5 94 @7/34/32=79;.4494B/67924/7/54924./A76A/74=./5390 06@:?/24 34 4./ ?654 @32 62B= 8/ @62590/7/0 35 32 3@G26EB/0;?/247/@/9A4 955:/0 8=4./AB3924911167.3<92; 7/@/9</05!%"""924./=/37+ !320%46B3561;6B0 / 5:8?945 4.34 43G92; 4./ 5390 06@:?/24 627/@670320 @62590/734962 61 4./ 5390 06@:?/24 95 2/@/5537= 46 @677686734/ 4./ @624/24962 61 4./ 0/1/203245 61 AB3924911 .3<92; 7/B92J:95./0 ./7 5.37/ 92 4./ A76A/74= 8= /K3?9292; 4./ E942/55/5 23?/0 4./7/92 ./7/167/ ./ 5:8?9454.344./>:0;?/243200/@7//A355/08=4./793B 6:743204./*9754AA/BB34/6:745:11/75176?A/7</7594= 167 262@62590/734962 61 4./ ?34/793B /<90/2@/ A760:@/0 62 7/@670 ;9<92; 795/ 46 5:85432493B J:/54962 61 B3E / 3B56 @624/20/0 4.34 592@/ 4./7/ 95 32 30?955962 8= 4./ AB3924911 ./75/B1 92 4./ @7655/K3?9234962 386:4 5./ 0/?32092; % 46B35 61 ;6B0 320 3B56 30?94492; 3 5:? 61 - 10 - 5 "" .3<92; 8//27/@/9</0 35 @6?A/25349628=./7 134./74./539035A/@4614./?344/72//05468/13@467/0 1674./A:7A65/6130>:54?/2461/J:949/5 + 27/5A625/B/372/0@6:25/B3AA/3792;1674./ AB39249117/5A620/24 >:5491=92; 4./ >:0;?/24 320 0/@7// A355/08=4./793B6:74@62197?/08=4./*9754AA/BB34/ 6:745:8?9454.344./AB/3617/B92J:95.?/2461./75.37/ 5/4 :A 8= 4./ 0/1/203245 .35 46 8/ /5438B95./0 920/A/20/24B= /B92J:95.?/24 61 79;.4 5.37/ 79;.4 494B/ 61 9??6<38B/ A76A/74= <3B:/ 61 E.9@. 95 ?67/ 4.32 5""7/J:97/5468/062/924./?322/7G26E246B3E E.9@. 4./ 793B 6:74 320 4./ *9754 AA/BB34/ 6:74 .3</ 43G/29246@62590/734962./7/@/9A4034/0"!""92 32=/</2456:;.4468/A760:@/08=4./0/1/203245@6:B0 264 30<32@/ 4./97 @3:5/ 61 A76<92; 4./ 7/B92J:95.?/24 .34 4./7/ 95 26 ?34/793B /<90/2@/ A760:@/0 8= 4./ 0/1/203245 E94. 7/;370 46 3@J:9594962 61 4./ A76A/74= 5473= 30?955962 8= 4./ AB3924911 95 61 26 @625/J:/2@/5 - 11 - /2@/ ./ 5:8?945 4.34 26 5:85432493B J:/54962 61 B3E 3795/5924.953AA/3B " /370/7:5/04./7/@6705 5 264/0 386</ 7/B349625.9A 8/4E//2 4./ A3749/5 320 4./ 5:94 A76A/74= 8/92; 4./ >6924 13?9B= A76A/74= 264 8/92; 92 095A:4/ 4./ 62B= J:/54962 4.34 7/J:97/5 @62590/734962 95 E./4./7 67 264 4./ AB3924911 .30 920//0 7/B92J:95./0 ./7 5.37/ 79;.4 494B/ 924/7/54 92 13<6:7 61 134./7 320 .:58320 7/5A/@49</B= 61 4./ 0/1/203245 92 @62590/734962 61 7/@/9A4 61 5!%""" 92 4./ =/37 + ! 320 % 46B35 61 ;6B0 92 4./ =/37 !"" 5 79;.4B= 43G/2 264/ 61 8= 4./ 793B 6:74 320 4./ *9754 AA/BB34/ 6:74 4./ A792@9A3B ;76:20 :7;/0 8= 4./ 0/1/203245 95 7/B92J:95.?/24 61 79;.4 61 ./7 5.37/8= 4./ AB3924911924./5:94A76A/74=:@.473253@4962@3262B=8/ 3@@/A4/0468/AB3:598B/91/<90/2@/924./?322/7G26E2 46 B3E 95 300:@/0 23?/B= 4./ 06@:?/24 @6?AB=92; E94. 4./ 7/J:97/?/24 61 /@4962 61 4./ /;954734962 @4 7/@/9A4034/0"!""8/92;@6BB34/73B92234:7/@32264 - 12 - 5:85494:4/ 4./ 5390 7/J:97/?/24 55:?92; /</2 91 4./ 0/1/203245 .30 920//0 A390 5:@. 32 3?6:24 4./ 53?/ E6:B0264>:5491=4./97@B39?61AB3924911.3<92;7/B92J:95./0 ./779;.46</74./5:94A76A/74=.956:741674./A:7A65/ 613AA7/@93492;4./37;:?/245?30/8=4./@6:25/B1674./ 3AA/BB3245 .35 A/7:5/0 4./ 7/@/9A4 034/0 "!"" E.9@.9209@34/5AB3924911A:7A674/0B=7/@/9<92;5!%""" 320 % 46B35 61 ;6B0 :4 4./7/ 95 26 ?/24962 92 4./ 5390 06@:?/24615./.3<92;7/B92J:95./032=5.37/ ! 2 4.34 <9/E 61 4./ ?344/7 4.95 6:74 @32264 1920 32= 9BB/;3B94= 67 977/;:B3794= 92 4./ >:0;?/24 320 0/@7//A355/08=4./793B6:74E.9@.95@62197?/08=4./ *9754AA/BB34/6:74 # @@67092;B=4./3AA/3B95 //0B/55465434/4.3491920//04./0/1/203245.3</ A390 5!%""" 92 4./ =/37 + ! 67 % 46B35 61 ;6B0 35 @B39?/0 9495:A464./?465//G5:@.7/?/0=35?3=8/ 3<39B38B/ 320 A/7?95598B/ :20/7 B3E 4 4.95 >:2@4:7/ - 13 - B/372/0 @6:25/B 167 4./ 3AA/BB3245 5//G5 7/4:72 61 4./ 06@:?/2423?/B=7/@/9A4034/0"!""E.9@.9519B/0 8/167/4./793B6:74./793B6:745.3BB670/77/B/3592; 4./539006@:?/249213<6:7614./0/1/203245 2 <9/E 61 095A653B 61 4./ 3AA/3B A/2092; 924/7B6@:467=3AAB9@3496259132=54320095A65/061 +( '##) % $$ 9546B6+