- 1 - ! " #$ $$$%& #$ $ "" '"( % ! ! " # $ % & ' ( Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) *#!) +" , *#!) ! + #, *+,)! # #$ % *+,) + + !"$$ & ' % #- % +( - 3 - % % $ % % . !)))" ) % % % !)")+ % : / 0 / ) $ ' 1 ( 22345657 89 :;5 <=72>5?: @?7 75A355 7@:57 !)))" 4? B) B? :;5 C4D5 BC :;5 5?4B3 464D =725 ;B3@E=3 ';5354?@C:53 35C53357 :B @F G:34@D B=3:1 CB3 F;B3:( 75C5?7@?: BF @?7 ! :B + @35 85CB35 :;4FB=3:4?:;4F 52=D@3%43F:EE5@D 9 :;5 <=72>5?: @?7 75A355 :;5 :34@D B=3: 75A3557:;5F=4:CB3E@3:4:4B?@?7F5E@3@:5EBFF5FF4B?@?7 75AD@357 :;@: :;5 ED@4?:4CCF @DB?2 H4:; 75C5?7@?: BF @?7@355?:4:D57CB3:;F;@355@A;4?:;5F=4:FA;57=D5 E3BE53:45F - 4 - ! ;5C@>4D9E57423554FA=DD57B=:@F=?753 @F@D4?2@99@ @;@?:@>>@ @36@:@>>@ ;5?2D@>>@ 'F:H4C5('?7H4C5( '!37H4C5( 4574FF=5D5FF4574FF=5D5FF ;@?:@7564 457 @;5F;H@34;B8;@=F;4D@;34I@3@4F;355 @<556 . . .! .#.. 56@?@F477@99@ .#'=F8@?7BC.( @7;= .!'7@=2;:534?D@HBC.( @;=D .+'B?BC.!( # *+,-./0 =4:4FB?5CB3E@3:4:4B?@?7F5E@3@:5EBFF5FF4B?;5 ED@4?:4CCF @?7 75C5?7@?: BF @?7 @35 :;5 A;4D735? BC B?5;@?:@7564;5ED@4?:4CCF@653:;@::;5F=4:E3BE53:45F H535 BH?57 @?7 EBFF5FF57 89 B?5 @F@D4?2@99@ FB @?:@99@ 435>@:; H;B ;@7 :;355 H465F 89 ?@>5 - 5 - @;@?:@>>@'C43F: H4C5( @36@:@>>@'F5AB?7 H4C5( @?7 ;@?2@D@>>@':;437 H4C5( ;@?:@7564 :;5 >B:;53 BC :;5 ED@4?:4CCF 75C5?7@?: BF @?7 4F :;5 7@=2;:53 BC :;5 C43F: H4C5 @;@?:@>>@ ;5 B:;53 :HB H465F BC @F@D4?2@99@ ?@>5D9 @36@:@>>@ @?7 ;@?2@D@>>@ 7457 4FF=5D5FF ;535 H@F @ E34B3 D4:42@:4B? 4? B#$""85:H55?;@?:@7564@?7;@?2@D@>>@4? 35FE5A:BC:;5F=4:FA;57=D5E3BE53:45F;5F=4:5?7574? AB>E3B>4F5 75A355 H;535 @F:53? EB3:4B? BC :;5 F=4: E3BE53:9H@F@DDB::57:B;@?2@D@>>@@?7:;5F=4:;B=F5 H@F 5J=@DD9 7464757 85:H55? ;@?:@7564 @?7 ;@?2@D@>>@C:53:;575@:;BC;@?2@D@>>@H;B7457 4FF=5D5FF;53F;@35C5DD:BF;@35BC;@?:@7564:4FF:@:57 :;@: :;5 F=4: E3BE53:45F H535 :347;@?@ E3BE53:45F BC ;@?:@7564 =EB? ;53 75>4F5 :;5 D52@D ;543F ?@>5D9 ED@4?:4CCF75C5?7@?:BF@?7F=AA55757:B:;55F:@:5 5J=@DD9 + %=3:;53 75C5?7@?: BF @?7 H4:;B=: :;5 I?BHD5725 @?7 AB?F5?: BC :;5 ED@4?:4CCF ;@65 >=:@:57 - 6 - :;543?@>5F4?:;53565?=535AB37FBC:;5F=4:E3BE53:45F ;5 5?:39 BC ?@>5F BC 75C5?7@?: BF @?7 4? :;5 3565?=535AB37F4FH4:;B=:@?96@D47:4:D5B3E@3:4:4B? ;575C5?7@?:F@EE5@35775C5?7@?:BC4D57 H34::5? F:@:5>5?: ;5 F@>5 H@F @7BE:57 89 75C5?7@?: BF! :B + ;5 35D@:4B?F;4E 85:H55? :;5 E@3:45F 4F @7>4::57BH5653:;59AB?:5?7:;@::;5F=4:E3BE53:45F @35?B::;5<B4?:C@>4D9E3BE53:45F8=:3@:;53F5DC@AJ=4357 E3BE53:45FBC;@?:@7564@?7:;@:F;5;@F5K5A=:57@ 4DD 7@:57+)"$,$4?C@6B=3BC75C5?7@?:BB?:;58@F4F BC :;5 F@>5 75C5?7@?: B ;@F 85AB>5 :;5 @8FBD=:5 BH?53BC:;5F=4:E3BE53:45F " ? B3753 :B E3B65 :;543 AB?:5?:4B?F ED@4?:4CC B 5K@>4?57 ;53F5DC @F >@3I57 7BA=>5?:F @: K :B K , ;5 75C5?7@?:F 4? FE4:5 BC 854?2 2465? F=CC4A45?:BEEB3:=?4:9747?B:A;BBF5:BD5@7:;54356475?A5 @?7;5?A5:;54356475?A5H@F:@I5?@F?4D - 7 - , ;5:34@DB=3:B8F53657:;@:75C5?7@?:B4? ;53H34::5?F:@:5>5?:;@64?2:@I5?@AB?:5?:4B?:;@::;5 >B:;53BC75C5?7@?:B;@75K5A=:57;53D@F: 4DD@?7 :5F:@>5?: 7@:57 +)"$,$ 89 H;4A; F;5 85J=5@:; @DD ;53 342;: :4:D5 @?7 4?:535F: 4? :;5 F=4: E3BE53:45F 5KAD=F465D9 :B 75C5?7@?: B '7@=2;:53( :;5 75C5?7@?: B;@FC@4D57:BE3B65:;55K5A=:4B?BC:;5 4DD@FF;5 ;@F ?B: E3B7=A57 :;5 4DD @?7 H4:;B=: @?9 7BA=>5?:@39 56475?A5:;5AB?:5?:4B?BC75C5?7@?:BHB=D785<=F: @ >535 @FF53:4B? ;5 :34@D B=3: 89 :;5 <=72>5?: @?7 75A35575A3557:;5F=4:23@?:4?2:;F;@35 5@A;4?:;5 F=4:E3BE53:45F $ 5@37 :;5 D5@3?57 AB=?F5D @EE5@34?2 CB3 :;5 @EE5DD@?:F @?7 :;5 D5@3?57 AB=?F5D @EE5@34?2 CB3 :;5 35FEB?75?:F@?7E53=F57:;5>@:534@DB?35AB37 ) 5@3?57 AB=?F5D CB3 :;5 @EE5DD@?:F AB?:5?757 :;@::;5F=4:E3BE53:45FH535:;5F5DC@AJ=4357E3BE53:45FBC ;@?:@7564:;5>B:;53BC:;5ED@4?:4CCF75C5?7@?:BF - 8 - @?7;5854?2:;5@8FBD=:5BH?53BC:;5F=4:E3BE53:45F 5K5A=:57 ;53 D@F: 4DD @?7 :5F:@>5?: 7@:57 +)"$,$ 85J=5@:;4?2:;55?:435F=4:E3BE53:45F5KAD=F465D94?C@6B=3 BC 75C5?7@?: B H;B 4F ;53 7@=2;:53 : 4F F=8>4::57 :;@:F4?A5 4DDH@F?B:E3B7=A5785CB35:;5:34@DB=3::;5 @EE5DD@?:F ;@65 ?BH FB=2;: :B E3B7=A5 4: 89 @774:4B?@D 56475?A5 4? :;5 E35F5?: @EE5@D @DB?2 H4:; :;5 A53:4C457 ABE45FBC:;5>=:@:4B?3524F:53:@KE@4735A54E:F@?7:;5 A53:4C457ABE9BC:;5 4DD4?@?@EED4A@:4B?=?7533753# =D5 " BC B75 BC 464D 3BA57=35 $), ' ( : 4F AB?:5?757:;@::;57BA=>5?:FFB=2;::B85E3B7=A5789 @774:4B?@D56475?A54F?5A5FF@39CB3E3BE53@7<=74A@:4B?BC :;5 342;:F 4?6BD657 @?7 :;5 @EED4A@:4B? ?557F :B 85 @DDBH57 ;5 >@::53 85 35>4::57 8@AI :B :;5 :34@D B=3: E3B6474?2@?BEEB3:=?4:9:B:;575C5?7@?:F:BE3B65:;543 A@F5 5@3?57AB=?F5D@EE5@34?2CB3:;535FEB?75?:F F:3B?2D9 B8<5A:57 :B :;5 E3B7=A:4B? BC :;5 4DD EB4?:4?2 B=::;@:?B 4DDH@F5653E3B7=A57B3E3B6577=34?2:34@D - 9 - 75FE4:5 :;5 @EE5DD@?:F @FF53:4B? :;@: :;59 85AB>5 :;5 5KAD=F465 BH?53 BC F=4: E3BE53:45F 89 H@9 BC :;5 4DD 5K5A=:574?C@6B=3BC75C5?7@?:B89;@?:@7564:4F AB?:5?757 :;@: :;5 @EE5DD@?:F ;@65 ?B: E3B64757 @?9 <=F:4C4A@:4B? B3 5KED@?@:4B? @F :B H;9 :;5 4DD H@F ?B: E3B7=A575@3D453@?7:;535CB35:;59A@??B:85E53>4::57 :BC4DD4?:;52@EF4?@EE5@D:4F83B=2;::B:;5?B:4A5BC :;4FB=3::;@::;5A53:4C457ABE9BC:;5 4DD?BHFB=2;::B 85 E3B7=A574F?B:A53:4C457 89:;5 =8. 524F:3@38=:89 =?4A4E@D B=?F5D CC4A5 ' =3@F@85 @39@D@9@ 5>8;@64( H;4A;4F?B:@AB>E5:5?:@=:;B34:9=?753D@H:B4FF=5:;5 A53:4C457 ABE9 BC 4DD : 4F AB?:5?757 :;@: :;5 @EE5DD@?:F ;@65?54:;53D@47@?9C@A:=@DCB=?7@:4B?=?7535A:4B?+ BC:;5?74@? 6475?A5A:,"'GA:1CB3F;B3:(352@374?2 H;@:;@EE5?57:B:;5B3424?@D 4DD?B3:;59;@65ED5@757 :;@:4:4FDBF:75F:3B957B3B:;53H4F5=?@6@4D@8D5@?7:;=F :;5 @DD5257 4DD FB=2;: :B 85 E3B7=A57 A@??B: 85 @7>4FF48D5 @F F5AB?7@39 56475?A5 B35B653 4DD ;@F :B 85E3B6574?@AAB37@?A5H4:;5A:4B?,BC:;5A:@?7! - 10 - BC :;5 ?74@? =AA5FF4B? A: $+ @?7 ?B F=A; 5CCB3: 854?2 >@75 89 :;5 @EE5DD@?:F 85CB35 :;5 :34@D B=3: :;5 @EED4A@:4B? C4D57 CB3 @774:4B?@D 56475?A5 7B5F ?B: F@:4FC9 :;5 D52@D 35J=435>5?:F =?753 3753 # =D5 " BC ;5 :34@D B=3: @C:53 AB?F47534?2 5?:435 B3@D @?7 7BA=>5?:@39 56475?A5 ;@F 342;:D9 75A3557 :;5 F=4: @H@374?2 :; F;@35 5@A; H;4A; 7B5F ?B: H@33@?: @?9 4?:53C535?A589:;4FB=3: @64?2 ;5@37 :;5 D5@3?57 AB=?F5D CB3 :;5 E@3:45F:;5EB4?::;@:@34F5FCB3AB?F4753@:4B?@35 ! "#" $ % % %%& % % ' () " % '* - 11 - ! : 4F @? =?74FE=:57 C@A: :;@: :;5 @EE5DD@?:F E@3:4A=D@3D975C5?7@?:BH;BAD@4>F5KAD=F465:4:D5B653 :;5 F=4: E3BE53:45F =?753 :;5 @DD5257 4DD 7@:57 +)"$,$747?B:E3B7=A5B3F55I:BE3B65:;5F@47 4DD 85CB35:;5:34@DB=3:?:;4F@EE5@D:;5@EE5DD@?:F;@65 C4D57@??:53DBA=:B39EED4A@:4B?=?7533753# =D5" BC F55I4?2 :B E3B7=A5 :;5 @DD5257 4DD @F @774:4B?@D 56475?A5 @DB?2 H4:; A53:@4? B:;53 7BA=>5?:F 4?AD=74?2 >=:@:4B?5K:3@A:@?7:@K35A54E:F;5A53:4C457ABE9BC:;5 4DD?BHFB=2;::B85E3B7=A57H;5354F@?5?7B3F5>5?: C3B>L =3@F@85@39@D@9@5>8;@64M45=?4A4E@DCC4A5 @?7?B:C3B>:;5=8. 524F:3@3CC4A5 # 53=F@D BC :;5 @CC47@64: @AAB>E@?94?2 :;5 @EED4A@:4B? =?753 3753 # =D5 " BC H5 C4?7 :;@: :;5354F?B5KED@?@:4B?854?2BCC535789:;5@EE5DD@?:F@F :B:;5H;535@8B=:FBC:;5B3424?@D 4DDH;5:;534:4FDBF: >4FED@A57 B3 B:;53H4F5 =?@6@4D@8D5 B3 H;9 4: H@F ?B: E3B7=A57 85CB35 :;5 :34@D B=3: ;535 4F ?B CB=?7@:4B?@D - 12 - ED5@74?2 B3 @CC47@64: 352@374?2 :;5 DBFF 75F:3=A:4B? B3 ?B?.@6@4D@84D4:9 BC :;5 B3424?@D 4DD @F 35J=4357 =?753 5A:4B? + BC :;5 A: ;535CB35 :;5 A53:4C457 ABE9 7B5F ?B: J=@D4C9 @F @? @7>4FF48D5 F5AB?7@39 56475?A5 ;5 75C5?7@?:F;@65@DFBC@4D57:B75>B?F:3@:5:;@:@774:4B?@D 56475?A5 H;4A; 4F FB=2;: :B 85 E3B7=A57 H@F ?B: H4:;4? :;543I?BHD57257=34?2:34@D75FE4:57=574D425?A5B3:;5 :34@DB=3:H3B?2D935C=F57:B@7>4:4:B3:;@::;5EE5DD@:5 B=3: 35J=435F :;5 7BA=>5?: :B E3B?B=?A5 5CC5A:465 <=72>5?:;5@EED4A@:4B?C4D57F55I4?2@774:4B?@D56475?A5 7B5F?B:>55:@?9BC:;5AB?74:4B?F=?7533753# =D5 "BC @?7@AAB374?2D9:;5@EED4A@:4B?CB3E3B7=A:4B?BC @774:4B?@D 56475?A5 4F D4@8D5 :B 85 35<5A:57 ;5 C4?74?2F 35AB375789:;5:34@DB=3::;@::;5 4DDH@F?B:E3B6574? @AAB37@?A5H4:;D@H?557F:B85@CC43>57 + ;5 :34@D B=3: AB?F47534?2 :;5 B3@D @?7 7BA=>5?:@39 56475?A5 E3BA55757 :B ;BD7 :;@: F=4: E3BE53:45F H535 BC :;5 BH?53F;4E BC ;@?:@7564 H;B 4F ?B?5B:;53:;@?:;5>B:;53BCED@4?:4CCF75C5?7@?:BF - 13 - @?7 :;59 @35 5?:4:D57 CB3 F;@35 @?7 89 :;5 <=72>5?: @?775A35575A3557:;5F=4:;BD74?2:;@::;59@355?:4:D57 CB3 :; F;@35 5@A; ;535 4F ?B 4DD52@D4:9 B3 4?C43>4:9 4? :;5 B3753 E@FF57 89 :;5 :34@D B=3: H;4A; H@33@?:F @?9 4?:53C535?A589:;4FB=3:AAB374?2D9:;5EB4?:FC3@>57 CB3AB?F4753@:4B?4F@?FH5357@?7H5E@FF:;5CBDDBH4?2 4 52=D@3%43F:EE5@D4F;53589 44 ;5 <=72>5?: @?7 75A355 7@:57 !)))"E@FF574?B)89 :;5B=3:BC5?4B3464D=725;B3@E=3 4F;53589 12 '$$$%&( 12 '$( 4F:BDB