- 1 - ! "!#!! ! $% $&'( %$'' ) !"# ! $ ! !! $ ! ! %&"" # %'#( & $ ! ! ! ) $ $ ! ! %&)"& $ $ %')# Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! ! $ " ! !' ! $ $ ! %'&" ) $ ! $ ! " ! $ $ ! ! %&)"& ( $ $ ! " !! $ $ ! ! %&)#& * !$!! + ! !! !! !%'"( # $ ) %'&" * ! !, $! #+ !$ '# ! ! &###"-##"$#)&#" &'#" ! #%' ! %( ! - 3 - ! -(#" " ") ! # !! !!!. $ !$ $! $ ! $ !/$ $$ !/$ $$ + 01230 405 674458 9: ;9:45< =18 7<69::91> ?940 405 @1>:5>4 1= ;578>5< @12>:5; =18 405 A78495: 94 9: 47B5> 2A =18=9>7;<9:A1:7; # 05 A549491>58: C59>3 7@@2:5< 1:# 41 ' 9> 8965 1#)&#" 1= =D7;A28 A1;9@5 :47491> 7;7C28739 A5><9>3 9> 1&###"- 1> 405 =9;5 1= 405 ;578>5< 9E9; 2<35 7>< $ =D7;A28 789:9>3 124 1= 1##"+ 8539:4585< =184051==5>@5A2>9:07C;52><58 5@491>: - ( #" " 7>< ") 1= 405 ><97> 5>7; 1<5 ')" =18 :0184 F.+ 785 :55B9>3 41 G27:0 405@8969>7;A81@55<9>3:9>949745<7379>:44056 - 4 - & !578< 89 7E9 0556:9>30 07?7> ;578>5< @12>:5; =18 405 A549491>58: 89 1A7;B89:0>7 7<7E ;578>5< !930 1284 1E58>65>4 ;57<58 =18 85:A1><5>4 1H47457><8976@07><87;578>5<@12>:5;=18 85:A1><5>41#582:5<4056745897;:1>85@18< > E95? 1= 405 89E7; @1>45>491>: 2835< CI 405 ;578>5<@12>:5;=18C140405A78495:405A19>44074?12;< 789:5=186I@1>:9<587491>9: !" $I7>:?58414057C1E5A19>49:9>405 =18405=1;;1?9>3 5:A1><5>4 1# =9;5< 405 A89E745 @16A;79>4 9> 1##" 7379>:4 7@@2:5< 1: 41 ' 7;;539>3 @1669::91> 1= 405 1==5>@5: 7: :4745< 7C1E5 4 9: 405 - 5 - @1>45>491> 1= 405 @16A;79>7>4 4074 05 9: 405 7C:1;245 1?>589>A1::5::91>1=28E5I1")657:289>37@85: &# 32>47: 7>< 28E5I 1(# 657:289>3 ) 7@85: &' 32>47::942745<74787J739 =D7;A2847;2B70585@18< 1=89304::47><:9>09:>765C24405>7651=1>5 79A7; ?01 9: 405 A85<5@5::18 9> 405 9>4585:4 1= 405 7@@2:5< 9: 7;:1?81>3;I7AA5789>39>40585@18<1=89304:49::4745< 4074 7@@2:5< 1: 41 & 07< :2C69445< 7> 7AA;9@7491> 41 405 5A24I 70:9;<78 787J739 :55B9>3 41 5>458 40598 >765:9>40585E5>2585@18<:?09@0@76541C585J5@45< ) 4 9: :4745< 4074 7@@2:5< 1: 41 & 07E5 485:A7::5< 9>41 405 ;7><: 85=5885< 41 7C1E5 1> #"&#"7C2:5<405@16A;79>7>49>=9;40I;7>327357>< 4895< 41 <9:A1::5:: 096 =816 405 ;7><: 9> G25:491> 05 @16A;79>4 ?7: =9;5< 9> 409: 85378< ?940 ;7>< A1;9@5 ?01 07E5 <985@45< 405 7@@2:5< >14 41 9>458=585 ?940 405 A1::5::91> 1= 405 @16A;79>7>4 4 9: :4745< 4074 @16A;79>7>4 07: =9;5< 405 :294 9> 1-(#" 7>< 1C479>5< 405 18<58 41 679>479> :4742:%G21 7379>:4 405 - 6 - 7@@2:5<>405657>49651>"&")#"4057@@2:5< 785:79<4107E5485:A7::5<9>41405;7><:9>G25:491>CI C89>39>3 487@418 7>< 48I9>3 41 A;1230 405 ;7><: 05> 85:A1><5>4 1# 1CJ5@45< =18 405 :765 7@@2:5< 07E5 7C2:5< 096 9> =9;40I ;7>32735 7>< 7::72;45< ?940 :41>5: 7>< :49@B: 05 9>@9<5>4 ?7: ?94>5::5< CI 405 >5930C1289>3;7><1?>58:?0107E5A7@9=95<405<9:A245 05 7@@2:5< 07E5 @8969>7;;I 9>4969<745< 405 @16A;79>7>4 41 47B5 A1::5::91> 1= 405 ;7><: 9> G25:491> =18@9C;I 0585=185 405 @16A;79>4 ?7: =9;5< ?940 ;7>< A1;9@5 :47491> C24 >1 @8969>7; @7:5 ?7: 8539:4585< 7379>:4 405 7@@2:5< !5>@5 85:A1><5>4 1# 85G25:45< 405 897; 12844147B5@13>9D7>@51=4051==5>@5: ( 05 897; 1284 85=5885< 405 674458 =18 9>E5:4937491> 41 ;7>< A1;9@5 2><58 5@491> )&+ 1= 8 4 9: :4745< 4074 405 A1;9@5 07E5 =9;5< F. 85A184 :4749>3 4074 >1 :2@0 9>@9<5>4 07< 47B5> A;7@5 7: @1>45><5< CI 405 @16A;79>7>4 7>< :9>@5 405 :294 =9;5< CI 405 @16A;79>7>4 ?7: A5><9>3 C5=185 405 9E9; 1284 405 - 7 - @8969>7;@7:5@76541C5=9;5<41:485>3405>405@1>45>491> 1=405@16A;79>7>447AA578:407485:A1><5>41#07< =9;5< A8145:4 A549491> C5=185 405 897; 1284 7>< 07< 7;:1 =9;5< 09: :?18> :474565>4 05 897; 1284 A81@55<5< 41 A7::40518<58<745<-"-#"-85J5@49>3405F.85A184 47B9>3 @13>9D7>@5 1= 405 :79< 1==5>@5: 7>< 8539:4585< 1&###"- ' 07E5 31>5 4081230 405 18<58 <745< -"-#"- A7::5< CI 405 897; 1284 85J5@49>3 405 F. 85A184 7>< 47B9>3 @13>9D7>@5 1= 405 1==5>@5: A2>9:07C;5 2><585@491>:-(#""7><")1= 05897;128407:>147::93>5<7>I857:1>5K@5A4:4749>3 4074 85:A1><5>4 1# 07: =9;5< 09: :?18> :474565>4 85378<9>37C2:9>37><7::72;49>3096CI4057@@2:5<1 <1@265>4:18140585E9<5>@5785A81<2@5<41:2C:47>49745 :2@0@1>45>491> - 49::4745<40747@@2:5<19:7;857<I<57< @@2:5<1:#41'785C5=185409:1284:55B9>341G27:0 - 8 - 405@8969>7;A81@55<9>3:9>949745<7379>:4405605=7@4: 1= 405 @7:5 >788745< 7C1E5 4074 40585 ?7: 7 <9:A245 85378<9>3 1?>58:09A 1= 405 ;7><: 9> G25:491> 7>< 85:A1><5>41#07<=9;5< 405 :2949> 1-(#" =18 A5867>5>4 9>J2>@491> 7379>:4 7@@2:5< 1: 41 & 9: 7<69445< 4 9: :4745< 4074 405 :79< :294 @765 41 C5 <9:69::5< E9<5 J2<365>4 <745< #""'#"# 289>3 A5><5>@I 1= 405 @9E9; :294 85:A1><5>4 1# 7AA578: 41 07E5 =9;5< 405 A85:5>4 @16A;79>4 05 1>;I 7;;537491> 7379>:4 7@@2:5< 1:# 41 'A549491>58: 9: 4074 405I 07E5 485:A7::5< 9>41 4057389@2;4287; ;7><: 7><4895< 41 A;1230 405:765?94040505;A1=405487@418 <69445<;I405:294 9>1-(#"?7:A5><9>3C5=185405897;12847>< 94 9: :4745< 4074 405 18<58 41 679>479> :4742:%G21 ?7: A7::5< 9> 405 :79< :294 ><58 :2@0 @98@26:47>@5: <1 >14 =9>5 7>I 857:1> =18 85:A1><5>4 1# 41 82:0 41 405 A1;9@5:47491>9>:457<1=:55B9>3>5@5::78I18<58=816405 9E9;128405>E5:493749>3==9@587=458>149@5=9;5<405 F.85A184:A5@9=9@7;;I:4749>34074405@8969>7;@7:5@765 - 9 - 41C5=9;5<41:485>3405>405@9E9;:294A5><9>3C5=185405 897;1284!5>@5=9><@1>:9<587C;5=18@59>4051A9>91> 5KA85::5< CI 405 >E5:493749>3 ==9@58 4074 85:A1><5>4 1# 41 :485>3405> 09: @;796 1E58 405 7389@2;4287; ;7><: 07: =9;5< 405 @16A;79>4 0585 785 7C:1;245;I >1 6745897;: 41 @1>:494245 405 1==5>@5: 7: 7;;535< 7>< 8539:487491>1=405@8969>7;@7:59:9>7C2:51=A81@5::1= ;7? " @@18<9>3;I 7>:?58 405 7C1E5 A19>4 9> 405 7><A81@55<41A7::405=1;;1?9>3 05@8969>7;A549491>9: 05 @8969>7; A81@55<9>3: 9>949745< 7379>:4 405 A549491>58:7@@2:5< 1:# 41 ' 9> 1&###"- 1> 405 =9;5 1= 405 ;578>5< 9E9; 2<35 7>< $ =D7;A28 789:9>3 1241= 1##" 9>8965 1#)&#" 1= =D7;A28 A1;9@5 :47491> 7;7C28739+ 8539:4585< =18 405 - 10 - 1==5>@5 A2>9:07C;5 2><58 5@491>: - ( #" "7><")1=9:058CIG27:05< *( $!!' # 9:41;1&(