Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 64110 (KAR)
SAIBANNA @ SABANNA v. SHIVARAJ PATIL AND ANR
MFA/202219/2017 · 2025-08-21
Shivashankar Amarannavar
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64110 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64110 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!"
"!#"
$ %""&"&
""''
(&) *
! "#
$ % &
! " '
' (
)
*+**,",-
-",#
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
)) '
. ! "# $ % ) "/ ''
) &
) )
"0, %"& )
)
'
#""#"0 '
)
+,##"+ )
)'
) ) '
1
'
%! 234 566758 34 9387: ;< =27 5667885>= ?853@5>= 477A3>B7>25>?7@7>=C9?C@67>45=3C>545D5E:7:3>=27 FG:B@7>= 5>: 5D5E: :5=7: #""#"0 65447: 3> C+,##"+;<=27E87>3CE3H38'G:B75>: 585;GE5B3
- 3 -
# 75E:=27875E>7:?CG>4789CE=275667885>=5>:
=27 875E>7: ?CG>478 9CE E746C>:7>= C 3>4GE5>?7 ?C@65><
#, 75E>7: ?CG>478 9CE =27 5667885>= ?853@5>= DCG8: ?C>=7>: =25= =27 5??3:7>= 254 =5A7> 685?7 3> =27 <75E#"+5>:5==25==3@7=275667885>=?853@5>=D54 5B7:0<75E45>:27D54:E3H7E2C8:3>B:E3H3>B83?7>47=C :E3H7=273B2=C=CE723?87275667885>=?853@5>=254 4G4=53>7:47H7>9E5?=GE745>:27254;77>5:@3==7:9CE :5<4 C?=CE 254 B3H7>
I"# :345;383=< ?7E=393?5=74=5=3>B=25==27E734#J:345;383=<=C=27D2C87 ;C:<,C?=CE254B3H7>=27:345;383=<?7E=393?5=754 67E
I""4=5=3>B=25==275667885>=?853@5>=3425H3>B J C967E@5>7>= :345;383=< 7 4G;@3=4 =25= :G7=C =27 5??3:7>= =27 5667885>= ?853@5>= 254 4G4=53>7: 275: 3>FGE<5>:5467E7H3:7>?7C9C?=CE27345;87=C EC=5=7234>7?AC>8<=C=277I=7>=C9#!=C"#:7BE7745>: =27E79CE727?5>>C=:E3H7=27H723?8774G;@3=4=25==27 E3;G>58 254 >C= =5A7> 3>=C ?C>43:7E5=3C> =25= 3@685>=
- 4 -
93I7:E7KG3E74=C;7E7@CH7:;<C67E5=3C>5>:9CE=25==27 5667885>= ?853@5>= E7KG3E74 9G=GE7 @7:3?58 7I67>474 27E7345:3493BGE5=3C>C9=2795?75>:=27E79CE7=27E734 5 8C44 C9 6EC467?=4 C9 @5EE35B7 C>43:7E3>B =27 C??G65=3C>C9=275667885>=?853@5>==273>?C@7=5A7> ;<=27E3;G>585=4-###*67E@C>=234C>8CD7E43:7 27 ?C@67>45=3C> 5D5E:7: =CD5E:4 8C44 C9 5@7>3=374 ;< =27E3;G>5834C>=278CD7E43:77>?76E5<4=C588CD=27 566758
# 75E>7: ?CG>478 9CE E746C>:7>= C
3>4GE5>?7 ?C@65>< DCG8: ?C>=7>: =25= =27 E3;G>58 254 E3B2=8< =5A7> =27 :345;383=< 5= "J 5>: =27 3>?C@7=5A7> ;<=27E3;G>5834584C6EC67E5>:?CEE7?=74G;@3=4=25= =27E7 5E7 >C BECG>:4 9CE 7>25>?7@7>= C9 =27 ?C@67>45=3C>7>?76E5<7:=C:34@344=27566758
# 5H3>B 275E: =27 875E>7: ?CG>478 9CE =27 5667885>=5>:E746C>:7>=C3>4GE5>?7?C@65><=234 CGE= 67EG47: =27 3@6GB>7: FG:B@7>= 5>: 5D5E: 5>: E358CGE=E7?CE:4
- 5 -
#+ 27 5??3:7>= 5B7 5>: C??G65=3C> C9 =27 5667885>= * ?853@5>= 5E7 >C= 3> :346G=7 27 5??3:7>= 254 =5A7> 685?7 3> =27 <75E #"+ 5B7 C9 =27 5667885>= * ?853@5>= D54 0 <75E4 5>: 234 C??G65=3C> D54 :E3H7E I"+34 =27 :E3H3>B83?7>47 C9=27 5667885>=* ?853@5>= 27 :5=7 C9 344G5>?7 C9 =27 453: :E3H3>B 83?7>47 34
"!#"#",C>43:7E3>B=27:E3H3>B83?7>47=275667885>= ?853@5>=345G=2CE3L7:=C:E3H73B2=C=CE723?87
#0 27CCE:3>5=77>?2C9=234CGE=3>=27?547 C9
3> !!"# ! $ % & & '( 254 ?C>43:7E7: =27 @C>=28< 3>?C@7 C9 =27 :E3H7E 2C8:3>B :E3H3>B83?7>47D3=2=E5>46CE=7>:CE47@7>=5>:83?7>47=C :E3H7 =27 275H< =E5>46CE= H723?87 5= 4####* 67E @C>=2
- 6 -
#! >=27?547C>25>:=275667885>=?853@5>=34 2C8:3>B :E3H3>B 83?7>47 =C :E3H7 3B2= C=CE 723?87 C>43:7E3>B =27 453: 5467?= =27 3>?C@7 =5A7> ;< =27 E3;G>58 5= 4-###* 67E @C>=2 34 C> =27 8CD7E 43:7 C>43:7E3>B=27>5=GE7C9H723?875G=2CE3L7:=C:E3H7G>:7E =27 83?7>47 =27 3>?C@7 C9 =27 5667885>= ?853@5>= E7KG3E74=C;7=5A7>5=4"###*67E@C>=2
#- 4 67E =27 :7?343C> C9 =27 C>M;87 G6E7@7 CGE= 3> =27 ?547 C9 ) E76CE=7:3>* !+, - ..
'"!3=34278:=25=3>=27?547 C9 4789*7@68C<7: 67E4C> 3> 5::3=3C> #J C9 74=5;83427: 3>?C@742CG8:;7@5:7D27E7=275B7C9=27H3?=3@5==27 =3@7C95??3:7>=D54;78CD#<75E4>=27?547C>25>:
=27 5667885>= ?853@5>= D54 :E3H7E 5B7: 0 <75E4 5>: =27E79CE727347>=3=87:=C9G=GE76EC467?=45=#JC9234 3>?C@7
"# C>43:7E3>B=275B7C9=27H3?=3@=27@G8=36837E 566837:;<=27E3;G>585="0346EC67E
- 7 -
"" 27 5667885>= ?853@5>= 254 4G4=53>7: 47H7> 9E5?=GE7427254G>:7EBC>74GEB7E<5>:27D545:@3==7: 3>=272C463=589CE:5<465E=9EC@=25==27E7D545 275: 3>FGE< D27E73> =27 5667885>= ?853@5>= 254 ;77> =E75=7: ;< 7>7E58 GEB7C> D2C 254 344G7: :345;383=< ?7E=393?5=7 54 67E
I"# D27E73> =27 :345;383=< C9 =27 5667885>=?853@5>=344=5=7:54#JC97>=3E7;C:< 34 =27 CE=2C67:3? 4GEB7C> D2C 254 344G7: =27 :345;383=< ?7E=393?5=7 54 67E
I"" D27E73> 3= 34 4=5=7: =25= =27 5667885>=?853@5>=3425H3>B67E@5>7>=:345;383=<C9 J C9 234 E3B2= G667E 83@; =25= 34 "J C9 =27 D2C87 ;C:< C?=CE 254 4=5=7: 3> 234 7H3:7>?7 =25= =27 5667885>=?853@5>=345;87=CEC=5=7234>7?AC>8<G6=C#! =C"#:7BE775>:=27E7345:3493BGE5=3C>C9=2795?7C9=27 5667885>=?853@5>=
" C>43:7E3>B 588 =2747 5467?=4 =27 :345;383=< =5A7>;<=27E3;G>585="J34C>8CD7E43:727E79CE7 =27:345;383=<=C;7=5A7>34#J
- 8 -
", C>43:7E3>B =27 5;CH7 5467?=4 =27 8C44 C9 9G=GE73>?C@7C9=275667885>=?853@5>=344"###*N #JO4"+!##*I"I"0I#JO4",0#!!#*
" C>43:7E3>B =27 >G@;7E C9 9E5?=GE74 =27 E3;G>58 254 E3B2=8< 5D5E:7: 5 4G@ C9 4####* =CD5E:4=27653>5>:4G997E3>B
" 27 E3;G>58 ?C>43:7E3>B =27 @7:3?58 ;3884 254 E3B2=8< 5D5E:7: =27 ?C@67>45=3C> =CD5E:4 @7:3?58 7I67>4745=4 ##,*
"+ 275667885>=?853@5>=254;77>5:@3==7:=C =27 2C463=58 9CE :5<4 C>43:7E3>B =27 45@7 =27 E3;G>58 254 E3B2=8< 5D5E:7: =27 ?C@67>45=3C> =CD5E:4 5==7>:5>=M4 ?25EB74 9CC: >CGE342@7>= 5>: ?C>H7<5>?7 7I67>4743>54G@C94 ##*
"0 C>43:7E3>B =25= =27 5667885>= ?853@5>= 254 4G4=53>7: 47H7> 9E5?=GE74 5>: 234 5HC?5=3C> D54 :E3H3>B =27 8C44 C9 3>?C@7 :GE3>B =27 853: G6 67E3C: 254 =C ;7
- 9 -
=5A7>9CE#+@C>=2427E79CE7=275667885>=?853@5>= 347>=3=87:=C8C44C93>?C@7:GE3>B=27853:G667E3C:3>5 4G@C94"###*I+O40###*
"! 275667885>=?853@5>=D545B7:0<75E454 C>=27:5=7C95??3:7>=5>:27D54G>@5EE37:27E7345 :3493BGE5=3C> C9 95?7 C9 =27 5667885>= ?853@5>= G7 =C =27 45@7 =27E7 34 8C44 C9 6EC467?=4 C9 @5EE35B7 C>43:7E3>B=2745@7=275667885>=?853@5>=347>=3=87:
=C 8C44 C9 5@7>3=374 5>: 7>FC<@7>= 3> 8397 3> 5 4G@ C9 4#####*
"- 27 C?=CE 254 4=5=7: =25= 3@685>=4 5E7 93I7: 5>:9CEE7@CH58C9=2745@7=275667885>=?853@5>=254 =C 3>?GE =27 7I67>474 C9 4,####* 27E79CE7 =27 5667885>=?853@5>=347>=3=87:9CE?C@67>45=3C>=CD5E:4 =279G=GE7@7:3?587I67>4743>54G@C94,####*
# C>43:7E3>B =27 5;CH7 5467?=4 =27 5667885>= * ?853@5>=347>=3=87:=C?C@67>45=3C>54G>:7E*
- 10 -
"+
,-./ 012,3/-453 12,3/-453 -6-7.,.894:5/;74
" CD5E:4 8C44 C9 9G=GE7 3>?C@7 4",0#!!#*
CD5E:4 653> 5>: 4G997E3>B 4#####* , CD5E:4
CD5E:4 @7:3?58 7I67>474 4 ##,*
CD5E:4 5==7>:5>=M4 ?25EB74 9CC: >CGE342@7>= 5>: ?C>H7<5>?77I67>474 4 ##* + CD5E:4 8C44 C9 3>?C@7 :GE3>B=27853:G667E3C: 40###* 0 CD5E:4 8C44 C9 5@7>3=3745>:7>FC<@7>= C98397 4#####* !
CD5E:4 )G=GE7 @7:3?58 7I67>474 4,####*
4-+ /
<
" 27 5667885>= ?853@5>= 34 7>=3=87: =C =C=58 ?C@67>45=3C>C94,!0,*545B53>4=4""+"#,* 5D5E:7:;<=27E3;G>58
>H37DC9=275;CH7=279C88CD3>B/
- 11 -
! 2756675834588CD7:3>65E=
27 5667885>= ?853@5>= 34 7>=3=87: =C =C=58 ?C@67>45=3C> C9 4,!0,* 54 5B53>4= 4""+"#,*5D5E:7:;<=27E3;G>58
27E5=7C93>=7E74=5>:=27CE:7EC9:76C43=65447: ;<=27E3;G>58E7@53>7:G>58=7E7:
27 E746C>:7>= C * 3>4GE5>?7 ?C@65>< 42588 :76C43==27?C@67>45=3C>5@CG>=D3=23>567E3C:C9 #+ D77A4 9EC@ =234 :5< 95383>B D23?2 3= 34 835;87 =C 65<3>=7E74=5==27E5=7C9-J65=38865<@7>=
27 5667885>= ?853@5>= 34 7>=3=87: 9CE E787547 C9 7>=3E7?C@67>45=3C>5@CG>=
".< ("&"&) %! '' 34=C"8C"! =/A