- 1 - ! " # $%#&'()*#'' + ! " # $% ! " $ $ # $ & '("# & $ ) * * $ $+ & '** , $ & $ && $ '& Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ & & $ $ % $ $- " " $- # ./ 01234567578 67 1 '** 17 8./ 964/ 19 4/5:7/;;;68617546<64=;>/57;&6?5@53=:"91: A.1:8 B:654 1=:8+# :/>6A8/:/; 91: 8./ 199/70/ 3=76A.5C4/ =7;/: /08617 ' 19 />1865C4/ 7A8:=2/78A 08 "91: A.1:8 B 08+# 6A 623=>767> 8./ ?=;>2/78 19 50D=68854 ;58/; ) * * 50D=68867> 8./ :/A317;/78500=A/;91:8./5C1</A56;199/70/ * &1: 8./ A5E/ 19 017</76/70/ 8./ 35:86/A 5:/ :/9/::/;815A3/:8./6::57EC/91:/8./:6541=:8 ' ./01234567578.5A964/;8./3:6<58/012345678 67 1 ** C/91:/ 8./ :654 1=:8 5>567A8 8./ 500=A/; 544/>67> 01226AA617 19 8./ 199/70/ 3=76A.5C4/ =7;/:/08617'19 08 86A8./0178/78617198./ 01234567578 8.58 ./ F5A .5<67> 01:;654 :/458617A.63 F68. - 3 - 8./ 500=A/; A670/ * =:67> &/C:=5:@ * 8./ 500=A/; 533:150./; 8./ 01234567578 57;A1=>.8 91: 4157 19 A 81 2//8 .6A 95264@ 7/0/AA686/A ./ 0123456757857;.6AA17.5</3:126A/;815::57>/91:8./ A52/57;5001:;67>4@>5</A 818./500=A/; F.1 5>://; 81 :/35@ 8./ A52/ %./7 8./ 01234567578 67A6A8/;91::/8=:767>8./521=788./500=A/;6AA=/;8./ 0./D=/5A3/: G ;58/; * 91:A %./7 8./ 0./D=/ F5A 3:/A/78/; 91: /705A.2/78 8./ A52/ F5A ;6A.171=:/; 91: B67A=99606/78 9=7;A+ 67 8./ 5001=78 19 8./ 500=A/; />54 71860/ 5A 3/: G ' F5A 6AA=/; 81 8./ 500=A/; 054467> =317 .62 81 :/35@ 8./ 0./D=/521=78 7A8/5;19:/35@67>8./0./D=/521=78 8./ 500=A/; .5A 6AA=/; :/34@ 5A 3/: G C@ 85E67> =78/75C4/ ;/9/70/ ./:/C@ ./ .5A 0122688/; 8./ 199/70/ 3=76A.5C4/ =7;/: /08617 ' 19 8./ 08 ./:/91:/ 8./ 01234567578 :/D=/A8/; 8./ :654 1=:8 81 85E/01>76H570/198./199/70/57;816768658/4/>54508617 5>567A88./500=A/; - 4 - ./:6541=:8811E01>76H570/198./199/70/ :/>6A8/:/; 8./ 0:626754 05A/ 57; A=2217/; 8./ 500=A/; ./500=A/;533/5:/;C/91:/8./:6541=:834/5;/;718 >=648@57;04562/;81C/8:6/; ./01234567578/G5267/; .62A/495A% 57;>1825:E/; GA 8167A=331:8 .6A 0178/78617 ./ 500=A/; .5A ;/76/; 544 8./ 670:6267581:@258/:654A67.6AA858/2/78=7;/:/08617'' 19: 57;/G5267/;.62A/495A% ./:6541=:8 598/: 85E67> 6781 017A6;/:58617 544 8./A/ 258/:654A 17 :/01:;052/818./01704=A6178.588./012345675786A718 A=00/AA9=4 67 3:1<67> 8./ >=648 19 8./ 500=A/; C/@17; :/5A175C4/ ;1=C8 57; 8./:/91:/ 35AA/; 8./ 623=>7/; ?=;>2/781950D=68854 /67>5>>:6/</;C@8./A52/8./ 012345675786AC/91:/8.6A1=:8 $/5:; :6 525;53=: 4/5:7/; 01=7A/4 91: 8./533/4457857;:6.6<5757; 588575A./8864/5:7/; 01=7A/4 91: 8./ :/A317;/78 /:=A/; 8./ 258/:654A 17 :/01:;6704=;67>8./:6541=:8:/01:;A - 5 - 7 <6/F 19 8./ :6<54 0178/78617A =:>/; C@ 4/5:7/;01=7A/491:8./35:86/A8./316788.58F1=4;5:6A/ 91:2@017A6;/:586176A @57AF/:818./5C1</316786A678./B + 91:8./91441F67> ( 86A8./0178/78617198./012345675788.588./ 500=A/; .5; 5<564/; 4157 19 A 3:126A67> 81 :/35@8./A52/F68.675A.1:83/:61; 1F5:;A:/35@2/78 198./A56;521=788./500=A/;.5;6AA=/;0./D=/5A3/: G F.60. 052/ 81 C/ ;6A.171=:/; 5A 8./:/ F5A 67A=99606/789=7;A678./5001=78198./500=A/; 7A368/ 19A/:<60/194/>5471860/8./500=A/;.5A718:/356;8./ 0./D=/521=78 78./18./:.57;./.5A6AA=/;:/34@ - 6 - 71860/5A3/: G C@85E67>=78/75C4/;/9/70/ ./:/C@ 8./ 500=A/; .5A 0122688/; 8./ 199/70/ 3=76A.5C4/ =7;/: /08617'19 08 1 3:1</ .6A 0178/78617 8./ 01234567578 /G5267/; .62A/49 5A % 57; .5A :/68/:58/; 8./ 0178/786175A85E/7678./3:6<58/012345678 ./F687/AA F5A 0:1AA/G5267/; C@ 8./ 4/5:7/; 01=7A/4 91: 8./ 500=A/; ./ 8/71: 19 0:1AA/G526758617 ;6A041A/A 8.58 8./ 500=A/; .5A ;6A3=8/; 5<56467> 19 4157 9:12 8./ 01234567578 78./18./:.57;686A.6A0178/786178.58 ./F5A677//;19415719A 57;8./:/91:/./ .5A 533:150./; 6;;.5A6:6 1=.5:;5 5.5E5:6 6268/; 6?5@53=: 57; >18 A5708617/; 8./ 4157 8.:1=>. 8./ ;5=>.8/:198./01234567578F.1F5AF1:E67>8./:/57; 5AA/0=:68@./.5A6AA=/;8./C457E0./D=/ G ./ A52/F5A26A=A/;C@8./01234567578F68.8././4319.6A ;5=>.8/: .=A 68 6A .6A 0178/78617 8.58 8./:/ 6A 71 4/>544@ :/01</:5C4/ ;/C8 C=8 8./ 0./D=/ I G F.60. - 7 - F5A C457E .5A C//7 26A=A/; C@ 8./ 01234567578 57; 8./:/91:/./6A/78684/;81C/50D=688/; ) G 6A8./:/34@71860/6AA=/;C@8./500=A/; 588.//5:46/A83167819862/ A3/:8./;/9/70/85E/7C@ 8./500=A/;67 G ./.5;533:150./;8./;5=>.8/:19 8./01234567578F.1F5AF1:E67>676;;.5A6:61=.5:;5 5.5E5:6 6268/; 6?5@53=: 57; :/D=/A8/; ./: 91: .57; 4157 ./4/788./521=7819A 57;811E8./ A6>7/;C457E0./D=/C/5:67>1 '6 / G </7 F./7 8./ 500=A/; 533:150./; 8./ ;5=>.8/: 19 8./ 01234567578 57; /G3:/AA/; .6A F64467>7/AA 81 :/35@ 8./ 4157521=7857;5AE/;./:81:/8=:78./A56;0./D=/A./ .5;718:/8=:7/;8./A52/ ./0./D=/67D=/A8617F5A 26A=A/; C@ .57;67> 68 1</: 81 8./ 01234567578 57; 8./:/91:/./.5A718:/356;8./0./D=/521=78 ./ 500=A/; .5A A8/33/; 6781 8./ F687/AA C1G 57; ;/31A/; 5A % $/ .5A :/68/:58/; .6A 0178/78617 85E/7 ;=:67> 8./ 0:1AA/G526758617 19 8./ 01234567578 8.58 ./ F5A 67 7//; 19 A ;=:67> 3:64 * - 8 - 57; F/78 81 6;;.5A6:6 1=.5:;5 5.5E5:6 6268/; 6?5@53=: F./:/ .1C.5 6:5;5: I 8./ ;5=>.8/: 19 8./ 01234567578F5AF1:E67> $/53346/;91:4157678./ 57E 57; 8./ A56; 4157 F5A A5708617/; ./ 57E 5A 3/: 68A 3:10/;=:/ 1C8567/; 8./ C457E 0./D=/ %68.67 8.:// 2178.A ./ F/78 81 8./ A56; 57E 81 :/35@ 8./ 4157 521=78C=8A56;.1C.5 6:5;5:A858/;8.58A./.5A718 C:1=>.8 8./ C457E 0./D=/ 7 8./ 2/57 862/ ./ .5A :/0/6</;8./71860/9:128./01234567578 =:67>0:1AA/G5267586178./F687/AA5;2688/; 8.58 69 5 3/:A17 F578A 81 5<564 4157 9:12 8./ 57E ./ A.1=4;C/8./2/2C/:198./A56; 57E57;.5A813:1<6;/ A=:/8@ ./ 53346058617 91: 4157 A.1=4; C/ 3450/; C/91:/ 8./ 15:;196:/081:A57;598/:.6A533:1<548./4157F644 C/ A5708617/; $/ 54A1 5;268A 8.58 17 A5708617 19 8./ 415768F644C/0:/;68/;81.6A 57E5001=7857;./.5A81 F68.;:5F 8./ A52/ 9:12 .6A 57E 5001=78 174@ $/ 9=:8./:5;268A8.58698./0./D=/6A>6</75AA/0=:68@8./ A52/.5A81C/.57;/;1</:818./575>/:198./ 57E - 9 - ./F687/AA9=:8./:5;268A8.58698./:/F5A57@26A=A/19 8./0./D=/012345678A.1=4;C/41;>/;F68.8./ 15:;19 6:/081:C=8./.5;718964/;57@012345678/68./:F68.8./ 15:;196:/081:1:F68.8./31460/ </7598/::/0/63819 8./ 4/>54 71860/ 5A 3/: G ' ./ .5A 718 964/; 57@ 012345678 * ./ :/34@ 71860/ I G 0:1AA/G526758617 19 % 57;/<6;/70/19% ;6A041A/8.588./500=A/;.5A 5;2688/; 8.58 G C/417>A 81 .6A 57E 5001=78 57; ./ .5AA6>7/;8./A52/ %./78./500=A/;5;268A6AA=570/ 19 8./ 0./D=/ F68. .6A A6>758=:/ 8./ 3:/A=238617 =7;/: /08617A 57; ') 19 8./ 08 F1=4; 5:6A/ 57; 8./ C=:;/7 A.698A 17 8./ 500=A/; 81 :/C=8 8./ 4/>54 3:/A=238617 ' 1.6>.46>.88./31A686171945F178./A=C?/08 25@:/9/:818./;/06A617198./$17+C4/3/G1=:867 1 F./:/67 8./ 3/G 1=:8 C@ 1 "* )#)( - 10 - :/9/::67> 81 68A /5:46/: ;/06A617 ./4; 67 35:5>:53. 1A ' 57;'5A=7;/: ! " # $ # $ " $ " $ " % &" ! # " " #$$ # $ ' ()* +# " $ $ , 25@54A1:/9/:818./;/06A617198./$17+C4/ 3/G 1=:8 67 2 F./:/67 8./ 8.:// =;>/A /70. 19 8./ 3/G 1=:8 ;6A0=AA/; 58 4/7>8. 5C1=8 8./ 31A68617 19 45F F68. :/>5:; 81 8./ C=:;/7 19 3:119 67 8./ 199/70/ 3=76A.5C4/=7;/:/08617'19 08 8:/9/::/;8168A 2 "* *#*' - 11 - /5:46/:;/06A61767 357; ./4;6735:5>:53.1A 57;5A=7;/: (+ " #$ "! " $ ' ((- ' ()* +' ./ 0 # 1" 1 " # $ 2 3 4" 5"'6 $ $ 7 # " $ ' () * +# $ " " $ 8 " $ $ 8 " " $ $ + # $ " # 3 * ))' - 12 - 1 " $ " " 9 , (:; < + = # " $ $ 93 8 $ $ ' $ "# $ (%* # # ' ((- ' () + >' * > "'?#$$ @ . /# # $ # $ ? &8. /#$ $ $ (- &" $ ! " ! ! $ " # @' "> !? #$ 7 &" ! # " " #$ $ # $ - 13 - ' ()* +# " $ $ .& / 25@54A1:/9/:818./;/06A617198./$17+C4/ 3/G1=:867! " # $ ! # % 4F./:/6768 6A./4;6735:5>:53.1 (5A=7;/: A ! $ # $ " $ # ' () * + 8 ; B$"# $ " 9 # " $ $ " $ " " $ 9 4 * * ) - 14 - # $ # $ " " 8 ' () * + #C $ B #" 9 " #$ ' ()* + +" "#' ()+ 8 " 9 " # $ " 8 " .=A8./31A686171945F178./A=C?/086A</:@ F/44 A/884/; 9 8./ A52/ 5:/ 53346/; 81 8./ 9508A 57; 06:0=2A8570/A 19 8./ 3:/A/78 05A/ 52 19 8./ 1367617 8.588./01234567578.5A;6A0.5:>/;.6A6768654C=:;/719 3:1<67> /G6A8/70/ 19 4/>544@ :/01</:5C4/ ;/C8 A670/ 8./ 500=A/; .5A 5;2688/; 6AA=570/ 19 0./D=/ F68. .6A A6>758=:/ ./C=:;/78./7A.698A178./500=A/;81:/C=8 8./A56;3:/A=238617 - 15 - ( ./ 500=A/; .5A 85E/7 67017A6A8/78 ;/9/70/A A 3/: G 68 6A .6A 0178/78617 8.58 ./ .5; 5<564/; .57;4157 19 A 9:12 .1C.5 6:5;5: I 8./ ;5=>.8/: 19 8./ 01234567578 57; .57;/; 1</: 8./ C457E 0./D=/81./:5AA/0=:68@ =8;=:67>0:1AA/G526758617 19 % 8./ 500=A/; 0178/7;A 8.58 ./ .5; 5<564/; 4157 9:12 6;;.5A6:6 1=.5:;5 5.5E5:6 6268/; 6?5@53=: F./:/.1C.5 6:5;5:6A57/2341@// ./500=A/;F./7 A8/33/; 6781 8./ F687/AA C1G 57; ;/31A/; 5A % .5A 9=:8./: A858/; 8.58 ./ .5; A=C2688/; 57 53346058617 81 6;;.5A6:61=.5:;55.5E5:66268/;6?5@53=:91:>:578 19 4157 ./ A52/ F5A 500/38/; 57; 8./ 4157 F5A A5708617/;C@8./ 57E ./521=78F5A0:/;68/;81.6A 57E 5001=78 1 A0:53 19 353/: 6A 3:1;=0/; C@ 8./ 500=A/;81A=CA8578658/.6A0178/78617678.58:/>5:; $/ 01=4; .5</ A=2217/; 8./ 2575>/: 19 8./ 57E 1: ./ 01=4;.5</3:1;=0/;.6A0./D=/C11E81A.1F8.58./.5A 5<564/;415719A 9:128./A56; 57E - 16 - 78/:/A867>4@ 8./ 500=A/; .5; 718 01234567/; 81 8./ 15:; 19 6:/081: 1: 81 8./ 31460/ 5>567A8 .1C.5 6:5;5: 91: .5<67> :/0/6</; 8./ 0./D=/ I G ./ 500=A/; .5A 718 67A8:=08/; 8./ 57E 81 A813 35@2/78 F./7 .1C.5 6:5;/: .5A :/9=A/; 81 :/8=:7 8./ C457E 0./D=/A56;81.5</C//76AA=/;C@.625AA/0=:68@ ./ 017;=08198./500=A/;6785E67>67017A6A8/7834/5A57;.6A 9564=:/ 81 3:1C5C46A/ .6A ;/9/70/ 25E/A .62 465C4/ 91: 017<608617 ) .5</>17/8.:1=>.8./623=>7/;?=;>2/7819 50D=68854 35AA/; C@ 8./ :654 1=:8 ./ :654 1=:8 .5A 3:10//;/;8150D=688./500=A/;A14/4@178./>:1=7;8.58 8./01234567578.5A7183:1;=0/;57@;10=2/7881A.1F 8.58 ./ .5A 4/78 A 81 8./ 500=A/; 57; 54A1 35@2/78 19 8./ A56; 521=78 C@ 8./ 01234567578 6A 67 <61458617 19 /08617 *)" # 19 8./ 7012/ 5G 08 .=A 8./ :654 1=:8 91:2/; 57 1367617 8.58 :/</:A/ C=:;/7 46/A 17 8./ 01234567578 81 3:1</ 8.//G6A8/70/19 4/>544@:/01</:5C4/;/C8 ./:6541=:8F.144@26A4/5;A - 17 - 68A/496791:267>A=0.13676176>71:67>8./A/884/;31A68617 1945F %./78./500=A/;.5A85E/767017A6A8/78;/9/70/ 598/: 5;268867>6AA=570/ 19 8./ 0./D=/ F68. .6A A6>758=:/ 57; 9564A 81 3:1C5C46A/ 8./ A52/ 8./ C=:;/7 F644 7/</: A.698 17 8./ 01234567578 5A 8.58 F644 718 521=78 81 :/C=8867> 8./ 4/>54 3:/A=238617 $/70/ 8./ 623=>7/; ?=;>2/781950D=6885435AA/;C@8./:6541=:86A465C4/81 C/A/85A6;/ * $/5:; 4/5:7/; 01=7A/4 91: 8./ :/A317;/78 17 A/78/70/ * /5:7/; 01=7A/4 91: 8./ :/A317;/78 A=C268A 8.5867A8/5;196231A67>A=CA85786</A/78/70/:/5A175C4/ 967/25@C/6231A/;178./500=A/; ** 7<6/F198./5C1</57AF/:8./5C1</31678 678./ 57;3:10//;8135AA8./91441F67> "6# ./0:626754533/546A& - 18 - "66# ./ 623=>7/; ?=;>2/78 19 50D=68854 ;58/; ) * * 35AA/; 67 :626754 5A/ 1 '** C@ 8./ 4/5:7/; ;;6861754 6<64 =;>/ 57; & 6?5@53=: 6A ./:/C@A/85A6;/ "666# 17A/D=/784@ 8./ :/A317;/78500=A/; 6A 017<608/; 91: 8./ 199/70/ 3=76A.5C4/ =7;/: /08617'198./ 08 $/6AA/78/70/; 81 35@ 967/ 19 A "=3//A &698//75E.A74@#F68.6753/:61;198.:// 2178.A 9:12 81;5@ 57; 67 ;/95=48 19 35@2/78 19 967/ ./ A.544 =7;/:>1 A6234/ 623:6A172/7891:53/:61;1917/@/5: "6<# =8198./967/521=7881C/;/31A68/;C@ 8./ :/A317;/78500=A/; 5 A=2 19 A ) 6A1:;/:/;81C/356;818./ 533/44578012345675785A0123/7A58617 - 19 - />6A8:@ 81 A/7; C50E 8./ :654 1=:8 :/01:;A 5417> F68. 013@ 19 8.6A ?=;>2/78 91: 6791:258617 57; 7//;9=4 508617 ,( # ' " 6A81 41