Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 64011 (KAR)
M/S SAMARTH ROAD LINES v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
WP/203333/2025 · 2025-11-05
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64011 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64011 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$
%$&!$!$
'$(
! "
# ! # !$
%
" ! "! "
! #
"#
%
! "
! #
"#
%
! "
! # #
%
& $
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
"
! ' (
" ! " $ )
"
! %%
"
" ! %*'
"
! ! %'
+
! "
! ! + $
" ! "
"
"
! ! ! %* ! ! "
, ! %'- ! "
! !+ % ! # !$
" ! ! %
! "
! ! +&$
! . ! "
"! ! !! " ! ! "
! ,&
! - 3 -
,&
!$
/0 1023234506 37 809460 2/37 !4:62 700;35< 94==4>35< 60=3097
!"#$%# &'( & ) #*!+
,- . +
/ !''
0
/ !1
' 0
2 2 -
0
. ,-
2
2
334*
2 -
1 5 % 6"
+7 4
0
/ !8 8! 9
' 0
2 2 -
3
0
/ !:
' 0 1 ; %
2 2
2
63099?@27492/0@?70?602/?2607145A0524 /?A 377:0A 205A06 542393@?2345 A?20A %* 35B3235<83A79462/026?571462?234549944A<6?3572/64:</
- 4 -
205A06 542393@?2345 946 % ?=:;7 ?5A % 37263@27 8C 4?A/010232345068035<0=3<38=0/?A?11=30A242/07?3A 205A06 946 26?571462?2345 49 944A <6?357 >32/ 60710@2 24 ?=?8:6?<3 2?=:; ?5A A37263@2 023234506 /?A 9:=93==0A 2/0 60D:360E052 ?5A 0=3<383=32C @632063? /?2 205A06 @45A32345 4 164B3A35< 946 A37D:?=393@?2345 72?207 2/?2 2/0 83AA06 46 2/036 9?E3=C E0E8067 7/4:=A 542 80 4>535< 9?36 163@0 A0142 =3@0570A ! 944A <6?35 205A067 ?5A 63@0 46 >/0?29=4:6 E0?=7 ?5A 7:@/ 83AA06 ?60 60726?350A 964E 1?623@31?235< 35 2/0 205A06 /0 7:8 @=?:70 B333$ 60726?3527!?5A@4EE377345?<0527964E1?623@31?235< 352/0205A06/?22/0607145A052?:2/4632C>/3=0410535< 2/0 205A06 83A /?A A37D:?=3930A 1023234506 964E 205A06 164@077?5A/?A/0=A450205A06068C5?E0735<?6?F :;;0?5A2>442/0683AA067?7D:?=3930A352/0205A06 20@/53@?= 83A 035< ?<<630B0A 8C 2/0 46A06 60F0@235< 2/0 1023234506,720@/53@?=83A?5A70=0@235<7?3A6335<?6?F :;;0,7 6?571462 =?5A 35 2/0 20@/53@?= 83A 1023234506 /?A 16090660A ?5 ?110?= 809460 2/0 ?110==?20 ?:2/4632C
- 5 -
>/3@/ 8C 327 46A06 A?20A %%* /?A /0=A ?@@01235< 2/0205A06497?3A76335<?6?F:;;0147707735< !
=3@05@0 >?7 35 B34=?2345 49 205A06 @45A32345 ?5A 9:62/06/0=A2/060F0@2345492/01023234506>?760D:360A24 80 60@4573A060A ?7 2/0 7?E0 >?7 3E164106 B05 ?9206 =?170 49 2>4 E452/7 964E 2/0 A?20 49 2/0 46A06 49 2/0 110==?20:2/4632C607145A05201:2C!4EE37734506A3A 542 @4573A06 2/0 <630B?5@0 49 2/0 1023234506 546 2/0 48F0@23456?370A8C2/01023234506
/0 607145A052?:2/4632307 >32/4:2 @4573A0635< 2/0 601607052?2345 49 2/0 1023234506 ?5A 2/0 48706B?2345 E?A0 8C 2/0 ?110==?20 ?:2/4632C A37D:?=39C35< 7 35<6?F :;;0 964E 2/0 205A06 164@077 /?A 3==0<?==C ?5A ?68326?63=C 45 %% 60@4EE05A0A 2/?2 735@0 ! =3@05@0 /0=A 8C ?==3;?6F:5 74 35<6?F :;;0 /?A 8005 @?5@0==0A45%%*?5A35B30>492/07?E032@=0?60A 2/020@/53@?=83A0=3<383=32C497?3A6335<6?F:;;0035< ?<<630B0A8C2/07?E01023234506?5A?542/0683AA06/?A
- 6 -
93=0A >632 102323457 35 4'% ?5A 4
* /37 !4:62 8C 46A06 A?20A %% /?A ?==4>0A 2/0 >632 10232345 ?6?<6?1/ 4% 49 2/0 7?3A 46A0660?A7?7:5A06
< = 2 0
0
&
*
;
9
9 0
> *
&
? & 9 %
22
0
@
035<?<<630B0A8C2/035?@2345452/01?6249 2/0 607145A052?:2/4632307 A071320 2/0 46A06 1?770A 8C 2/37!4:621023234506/?A?1164?@/0A2/37!4:628C93=35<? >632 10232345 35 4%'- 700;35< A360@2345 24 2/0 607145A052?:2/4632307 24 @4573A06 2/0 601607052?2345 E?A0 7:870D:052 24 2/0 0?6=306 46A06 49 2/37 !4:62 /37 !4:62 8C 46A06 A?20A A371470A 49 2/0 7?3A 10232345>32/2/094==4>35<A360@23457
- 7 -
< A 2 -
9
/ ! 0 0 0 0
0 . 2
&% /
2
@
' 023234506 E?A0 C02 ?542/06 601607052?2345 45 94==4>0A 8C ?542/06 601607052?2345 A?20A /?2 >32/4:2 @4573A06?2345 49 2/0 ?94607?3A ?710@2 492/0 E?2206 607145A052 4?:2/4632C 377:0A ? 9607/ 205A06 ?7 106 550G:60 035< ?<<630B0A 8C 2/0 7?E02/0160705210232345
( 0?650A 05346 !4:570= ?110?635< 946 2/0 1023234506 7:8E327 2/?2 2/0 ?@2345 49 607145A052 4 ?:2/4632C35377:35<2/09607/205A06?7106550G:60 37 35 B34=?2345 49 2/0 A360@23457 377:0A 8C 2/0 !446A35?20 05@/ 49 2/37 !4:62 35 327 46A067 1?770A 35 4 ?5A 4%'- /?2 A0713202/060 8035< ? @?20<463@?= 935A35< 8C2/0 ?110==?20
- 8 -
?:2/4632C?7>0==?78C2/0!446A35?2005@/492/37!4:62 60<?6A35< 7?3A 35<6?F :;;0 6?571462 !4E1?5C =?5A 8035< A37D:?=3930A 2/0 607145A052?:2/4632307 /?B0 542 @4573A060A2/083A492/01023234506
0 7:8E327 2/?2 4:2 49 2/0 94:6 83AA067 35<?6?F:;;06?571462!4E1?5C=?5A2/4:</>?72/0 %83AA06/?B35<8005A37D:?=3930A2/60083AA06735@=:A35< 2/0 1023234506 >060 =092 35 2/0 96?CH 4:2 49 >/3@/ 450 ?5?E?526?C?
70@45A =4>072 83AA06 /?A >32/A6?>5 /3E70=9H ?5A 2/0 2/36A 83AA06 /?A 8005 /0=A A37D:?=3930A /37=09245=C2/083A492/010232345062480@4573A060A8C 2/0607145A052?:2/4632307 07:8E327352/0=3</2492/0 A360@23457 377:0A 8C 2/0 !446A35?20 05@/ 49 2/37 !4:62 2/0 607145A052?:2/4632307 ?60 =092 >32/ 54 42/06 @/43@0 8:2 24 ?==42 2/0 @4526?@2 24 2/0 1023234506 0 609067 24 0@2345 %* 49 2/0 ?65?2?;?
6?571?605@C 35 :8=3@ 64@:60E0527 @2 %--- 946 7/462 I @2.$ 35 F:72393@?234549/377:8E3773452/?22/060F0@234549205A06
- 9 -
@?545=C80:5A062/0@36@:E72?5@07@4520E1=?20A:5A06 0@2345%*492/0@2?5A9465442/0660?745
- 060=307:1452/0F:A<E052492/010G!4:62 35 2/0 @?70 49
35
!"#$%&'&# B -
( 9 " B% 7*3 0906635< 24 1?6?<6?1/ 47%% 24 % 49 2/0 7?3A 46A06 /0 7:8E327 2/?2 :5=077 =?6<06 1:8=3@ 35206072 37 A0E45726?20A 2/0 1:8=3@ ?:2/4632307 @?5542 206E35?202/0@4526?@2462/0205A06?72/0@?70E?C80
% 0 7:8E327 35 2/0 3572?52 @?70 1?623@:=?6=C 35 2/0=3</2 492/0 A360@2345 377:0A8C2/37 !4:62 2/06037 54 F:72393@?2345 607145A052?:2/4632307 35 164@00A35< 24 377:0 2/0 9607/ 205A06 >32/4:2 @4E1=C35< >32/ 2/0 A360@2345 49 2/37 !4:62 0 9:62/06 7:8E327 54 E?2063?= 37 1=?@0A 45 60@46A >32/ 60<?6A 24 607145A052?:2/4632307 /?B35< @?5@0==0A 46 60@?==0A 2/0 0?6=306 205A06 05@0 700;7 946 ?==4>35<2/010232345
- 10 -
%% 5 60714570 =0?650A AA32345?= 4B065E052 AB4@?20 9:6537/35< 2/0 4B065E052 !36@:=?67 A?20A %% ?5A %'% 7:8E327 2/?2 39 35 2/0 0B052 49 % 205A06067 ?60 542 ?B?3=?8=0 946 >/?20B06 60?745 35 2/0 205A06 164@077 2/0 607145A052?:2/4632307 7/?== 164@00A 24 35B320 9607/ 205A067 ?5A 2/060 37 54 164B37345 946 @4573A0635< 2/0 42/06 83AA06 35 2/0 205A06 164@077 /0609460/07:8E3272/?2377:?5@0492/09607/205A06?7 106 550G:60 @?5542 80 94:5A 9?:=2 >32/ 0 7:8E327 2/?2 2/0 @36@:=?67 54> 164A:@0A >4:=A 80 2/0 ?57>06 946 2/0@?70492/01023234506
% 0?6A06:70A2/060@46A7
% 023234506 >/4 /?7 1?623@31?20A 35 2/0 205A06 377:0A ?7 106 550G:60 8C 2/0 607145A052 4 37 ?<<630B0A45=C8C2/09?@22/?2>32/4:2@4E1=02345492/0 7?3A205A06164@077607145A0524@4:=A542/?B0377:0 2/09607/ 205A06?7 106 550G:60 023234506 /?760=30A :145 2/0 46A06 1?770A 8C 2/0 !446A35?20 05@/ 49 2/37
- 11 -
!4:62 35 2/0 0?6=306 64:5A 49 >632 10232345 35 4'% >/06035 2/37 !4:62 @4573A0635< 2/0 <64:5A7:6<0A8C2/0102323450672/060358C32746A06A?20A %% /?A /0=A 2/?2 35<6?F :;;0 6?571462 !4E1?5C =?5A 2/0 607145A052 4* 2/06035 >?7 A37D:?=3930A 7 7:@/ 2/0 ?@@012?5@0 49 2/37 205A06 >?7 35B?=3A ?5A /?A ?@@46A35<=C A360@20A 2/0 607145A052 05A06 B?=:?2345 !4EE32200 24 164@00A 9:62/06 35 ?@@46A?5@0>32/205A06542393@?2345
%* /0A4@:E052164A:@0A?2?<04%'242/0 >632 10232345 B3A0 550G:60 164B3A07 2/0 5?E07 49 2/0 83AA067 ?5A 2/036 @4EE06@3?= 83A7 >/3@/ 37 ?7 0G26?@20A /060:5A06
=4 3AA06?E0 #30> !4EE06@3?= 3A7 % &
&
! $ *--
?5E?526?C? *(((
?==35?2/
$ *-- * E07/:;;?11? ?6=?CC? $
- 12 -
=4 3AA06?E0 #30> !4EE06@3?= 3A7 % &
&
! $ *--
! # !
$ *--
% /0@4520523457492/01023234506372/?2352/0 =3</2 49 3AA06 4%35<?6?F /?B35< 8005 /0=A 24 80 A37D:?=3930A 3AA06 4 ?5:E?52?6?C? /?B35< B4=:52?63=C>32/A6?>5?5A2/083A4963?==35?2/3AA06?2 =4 /?B35< 8005 60F0@20A 2/0 607145A052?:2/4632307 4:</224/?B0?@@0120A2/083A492/01023234506
%' 0?650A 05346 !4:570= ?=74 0E1/?73J0A 2/?2 2/0 @4EE06@3?= 83A ?E4:52 49 2/0 1023234506 2/4:</ D:420A ?2 37 ?=>?C7 ?E05?8=0 946 50<423?2345 ?5A 946 9:62/0660A:@2345 24 E?2@/>32/2/0% /0609460 /0 7:8E327 2/060 37 54 164/3832345 46 3E10A3E052 35 607145A052?:2/463230724164@00A>32/2/0160B34:7205A06 35720?A4935B3235<2/09607/205A06
- 13 -
%( 0@2345%*492/0@2%---164B3A35<946 @?5@0==?234549205A0660?A7?7:5A06
$# ( )
! & &
-
2 2
-
3 C
-
-
2
2 -
2 0 0
2
2
2
"
2
B & "
2
22 C
&
2
D, .""
2
"
E
% /:7 2/0 45=C 164B37345 164B3A0A :5A06 @2%---94660F0@234549205A06370@2345%*?70G26?@20A /06035 ?84B0 /0 @36@:E72?5@07 >?66?520A 2/060 946 60F0@234549205A06?60@=0?6?5A@?20<463@
52/03572?52 @?702/09?@27?5A@36@:E72?5@07?60A39906052?5AA37235@2 964E2/0450@4520E1=?20A:5A060@2345%*492/0 @2 %--- /4:</ 2/0 20@/53@?= 0B?=:?2345 49 35<?6?F 6?571462!4E1?5C=?5A/?78005/0=A248035B?=3A35 B30>49 327A37D:?=393@?23452/07?E0@?5542<3B0>?C946
- 14 -
@4573A06?2345492/083A492/01023234506/06035>/47244A 4* 35 2/0 =372 49 83AA067 /37 37 1?623@:=?6=C 35 2/0 ?8705@049?5C710@393@164B37345164B3A0A:5A062/0 @2%---352/3760<?6A
%- 4?D:06C8C2/37!4:62?724?5C164B37345749 =?> :=07 164B3A35< 946 7:@/ ?
@4573A06?2345 =0?650A 05346 !4:570= 60=307 :145 2/0 46A06 49 2/0 !446A35?20 05@/ 49 2/37 !4:62 164A:@0A ?2 550G:60 24 7:8E32 2/?22/0@4573A06?2345492/01023234506,783A3726?@0?8=024 2/07?3A46A06
/0 1?6?<6?1/ 4% 49 2/0 7?3A 46A06 0G26?@20A /06035 ?84B0 >4:=A 45=C 35A3@?20 2/?2 2/0 !4 46A35?20805@/492/37!4:62/?AA360@20A2/0607145A052 ?:2/4632307 24 164@00A 24 0B?=:?20 2/0 205A06 35 ?@@46A?5@0 >32/ 2/0 205A06 542393@?2345 /060 37 54 147323B0 A360@2345 46 35A3@?2345 946 @4573A06?2345 49 2/0 205A06492/01023234506/06035
- 15 -
% 3E3=?637 2/0 46A061?770A352/0>632 10232345 35 4%'- >/06035 ?7 0G26?@20A /06035?84B0 2/37 !4:62 ?2 1?6?<6?1/ 4 /?A A360@20A 2/0 607145A052?:2/4632307 24 @4573A06 2/0 601607052?2345 49 2/0 1023234506 @=?639C35< 2/?2 32 /?A 542 0G160770A ?5C 4135345452/0E06327492/0@?70
/0 ?94607?3A 2>4 46A067 35 2/0 @4573A060A B30>492/37!4:62/?6A=C=05A7?5C@60A05@09462/0@=?3E 49 2/0 1023234506 24 @4573A06 /37 83A 35 2/0 1=?@0 49 % 0=3?5@0 1=?@0A 45 8C =0?650A 05346 !4:570= 24 2/0 F:A<E052492/010G!4:62352/0@?7049
7:16?$ 37 49 54 ?B?3= 35 2/0 9?@2:?= @36@:E72?5@07 49 2/0 3572?52 @?70 /37 37 35 2/0 =3</2 49 2/0 @36@:=?6 A?20A %% 377:0A 8C 2/0 4B065E052 24 E002 2/0 732:?2345 49 545 ?B?3=?83=32C 49 % 205A06 946 ?5C60?745>/?2740B06
?6?<6?1/ 4 49 !36@:=?6 A?20A %% 60?A7?7:5A06
- 16 -
!"#$%&'()*+%%, -% ./0 +%
# 1%2 3
4521- #2 627 % 8999 % 8 ()* :'
.;/0 %)
#$% 2 )<% 1 ()* %=> % , 3
4) % 8?" #> / 4>072 B?=:?20A 63@0" 2/ # (),
70
7- 2)52
-@ A'2: 8" 4-2'% B CD% 6 1C 607 1 - EF>G 1#% ()6
7-
2) 7H'1-@ I, - G JKL6- ()* +%% )<% 1 @M@N@N - %
#
#$% 3
4) # % 7-
6
%
7-
2) 7H0 @M@N@N -
) !"#$% $
!&%) '( ! )%* +
,-. /%* 0 + $
!&% , 0 . $ 12
3! 0 !45
6 ! !7-.!8*9:
;
!@
6
7-
% ()* +% - 6
#DO - P
F2DO% 2 7 ,Q
4) > R%4,4N7H0@ 0E1/?737?AA0A$
* /0?94607?3A!36@:=?6@4520E1=?207377:?5@049 50>205A06352/00B05249%83AA06609:70A24052063524
- 17 -
?<600E052469?3=724106946E2/0@4526?@246A37D:?=3930A >/?20B0660?745
/060=0B?52?=74 2460906240@2345%492/0 @2 %--- >/3@/ 0E14>067 2/0 2?20 24 377:0 A360@23457964E23E02423E0>/3@/60?A7?7:5A06
<$* +,
!
' 2 8
9 2 -9
"
2
2
- 2
"
2
2 0
' /0 !36@:=?6 6090660A 24 ?84B0 37 26?@0?8=0 24 0@2345%492/0@2%---/09?@27352/03572?52 @?70 >4:=A 60B0?= 2/?2 6335<?6?F 6?571462 !4E1?5C =?5A2/4:</>?7%83AA06/?B35<8005A37D:?=3930A/0 @4EE06@3?= 83A D:420A 8C 6335<6?F 6?571462 !4E1?5C 37*-->/3=02/0@4EE06@3?=83AD:420A8C102323450637 4164B3734549=?>37864:</2242/05423@0492/37 !4:6205?8=35<8?6<?35?5A60A:@234549@4EE06@3?=83A24 8635<2/01023234506?71?6>32/%83AA06/01023234506 8035<2/094:62/352/0=350352/0?8705@049?5C710@393@
- 18 -
164B373457 05?8=35< @4573A06?2345 49 2/0 83A 49 2/0 1023234506:5A062/0@36@:E72?5@072/37!4:62A4542700 ?5C<64:5A79463520690605@0352/03A
( 23750@077?6C?=74245420?22/37F:5@2:602/?2 32 37 4105 946 2/0 1023234506 24 1?623@31?20 35 2/0 9607/ 205A06>/3@/3754>377:0A?7106550G:60
32/2/0?84B0>6321023234537A37E3770A
!*+ '$!$( &
% % !