- 1 - !" # $% # $% "%&" ## '&( ) !" ! #" $ Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - %& ' %# ! ( )%"%# % & " ( )%"%# % ( *%"%# & % *# *$&+ #* !% $ *'% , ' ' *! !&#!!#!! - 3 - %- ,- & ,$ . !*#+*!#!' #$+ !#+ . . . ( . / . / . . % / . 012 344536 7895: 5;<1=8 ,$ => <05 =<=: 501;652;< +""05:5183><5::5>5::59<=32?<05;<@ >=: 20=:<032A558>1659AB<0534456638<*827:38;5 =C438B A518D 3DD:15E59 AB <05 F79DC58< 93<59 !#+!#!' 432259AB<05991<1=836581=: 1E16.79D5389. G 991<1=836 3<363A7:3D1 18 =#$+ !#+ - 4 - ! 05>3;<2D1E18D:125<=<05>1618D=><05344536 A:15>6B2<3<593:5<03<=8##"!#+ 3<3A=7<&##4C <05 95;53259 0389:3H38<0 36=8D I1<0 =<05:2 I32 :5<7:818D <= 363A7:3D1 18 3 F554 A53:18D :5D12<:3<1=8 =*$! *!!&'058<05F554:53;059<05363A7:3D1* .5I3:D1C318 :=39 18 >:=8< => 3:93:F1 03A3 I1<018 <05 61C1<2 => 3891H7: E1663D5 <05 9:1E5: => <05 F554 2<=4459 <05E501;6518>:=8<=>03A3<<03<<1C5 <059:1E5:=>3 6=::BA53:18D:5D12<:3<1=887CA5:*# "!&+ ;3C5 18 3:32038985D61D58<C3885:389932059<0501894=:<1=8 => <05 F554 2 3 :5276< => <05 3>=:52319 3;;1958< <05 95;53259 0389:3H38<0 272<31859 D:15E=72 18F7:152 389 27;;7CA59<=<0518F7:152 $ 05;631C38<2>1659345<1<1=87895:5;<1=8&& => <05 =<=: 501;652 ;< 255H18D ;=C45823<1=8 => 2'$ &# ### *>=:<05953<0=><0595;53259I1<018<5:52< 3< <05 :3<5 => "J 45: 3887C =8 <05 D:=789 <03< <05 95;53259I32I=:H18D323;=8<:3;<63A=7:5:18 389I3253:818D383C=78<=> 2!% ### *45:C=8<0< - 5 - I32 >7:<05: 4653959 <03< 05 039 2458< 3 27A2<38<136 3C=78<<=I3:92C591;365K458252 ' 8 25:E1;5 => 8=<1;5 :524=8958< =2 <= $ 34453:59 <0:=7D0 ;=78256 2 45: <05 =:95: 2055< 93<59 !&#,!#!! :524=8958< =! 032 A558 9565<59 >:=C <05 ;3725<1<65=><0545<1<1=8 524=8958<=$>16593I:1<<58 2<3<5C58< 958B18D <05 3E5:C58<2 C395 18 <05 ;631C 45<1<1=8 < I32 ;=8<58959 <03< <05 9:1E5: => <05 F554 43:H59 012 E501;65 18 <05 C19965 => <05 :=39 I1<0=7< 38B 4:5;37<1=83:B C5327:5 389 ;=8<58959 <03< <05 9:1E5: => <05=>>58918D6=::B9198=<0=6939:1E18D61;582532=8<05 93<5=><053;;1958<18L752<1=8227;0 :524=8958<=$ ;388=<A52399659I1<0613A161<B<=43B<05;=C45823<1=8 ;;=:918D6B 4:3B59<=912C122<0545<1<1=8 % 8<05A3212=><054653918D2=><0543:<152 <05 631C2:1A7836>:3C59<05122752389<05:53><5::5;=:959 <055E1958;505;631C38<2 18=:95:<=4:=E5<051:;325 5K3C1859 45<1<1=85: = 32 * 389 D=< 5K01A1<59 - 6 - 9=;7C58<2 83C56B K <= K+ 8 A5036> => <05 :524=8958<2 :524=8958<=$I325K3C185932 *389 1:2<1E121=82212<38<=> 32 *!389D=<5K01A1<59 9=;7C58<283C56BK <=K % 524=8958<=919 8=<653938B5E1958;5 & 05 631C2 :1A7836 AB <05 1C47D859 F79DC58< 0569<03<<053;;1958<<==H463;5=8 3;;=78< => :320 389 85D61D58< 9:1E18D => <05 =>>58918D E501;65 AB 1<2 9:1E5: 32 3 :5276< => I01;0 <05 95;53259 272<31859 18F7:152 389 27;;7CA59 <= <05 18F7:152 05 :1A7836 >7:<05: 0569 <03< <05 ;631C38<2 3:5 58<1<659 <= ;=C45823<1=8=> 2$! ' $# *36=8DI1<018<5:52<3<<05 :3<5 => &J 43 518D 3DD:15E59 AB <05 2319 F79DC58< <05827:38;5 =C438B032>1659<012344536 , C< :55<1 3<16 56H7891 653:859 ;=78256 34453:18D >=: <05 827:38;5 =C438B 032 :31259 <05 >=66=I18D;=8<58<1=82 - 7 - 3 1:2<6B <05 3;;1958< =;;7::59 975 <= <05 85D61D58;5=><059:1E5:=><05F554543:H59<05F55418 <05 C19965 => <05 :=39 I1<0=7< 3;<1E3<18D 38B 1891;3<=: 05:1A7836;=CC1<<59385::=:180=6918D<03<9:1E5:=> <056=::B36=85I3285D61D58<18;37218D<053;;1958< A 5;=896B 1< 12 ;=8<58959 <03< <05 =>>58918D 6=::B123D==92;3::15:2=8<0593<5=><053;;1958< <05 9:1E5: => <05 =>>58918D E501;65 919 8=< 03E5 3 E3619 389 5>>5;<1E59:1E18D61;5825 ; 32<6B ;=82195:18D<053D53893E=;3<1=8=><05 95;53259 <05 =E5:366 ;=C45823<1=8 3I3:959 AB <05 :1A7836 12 =8 <05 01D05: 2195 58;5 205 2=7D0< >=: 366=I18D<05344536 " 8 <05 =<05: 0389 :1 03:383A323443 3A205<<B 653:859 ;=78256 34453:18D >=: <05 ;631C38<2 032:31259<05>=66=I18D;=78<5:;=8<58<1=82 - 8 - 3 1:2<6B <05 3;;1958< =;;7::59 =8 3 3<1=836 1D0I3B059:1E5:=><05.55403943:H59<05E501;65=8 <055K<:5C52195=><05:=3905:5I323C465243;5>=: <05 6=::B <= 4322 05 9:1E5: => <05 6=::B ;3C5 18 3 :320 38985D61D58<C3885:389932059<0501894=:<1=8=><05 43:H59 F554 054=61;5 362=:5D12<5:59 3 3D3182< <05 9:1E5:=><056=::B><5:3<0=:=7D018E52<1D3<1=8 3;03:D5 2055<I32>16593D3182<<059:1E5:=><056=::B =82195:18D <05 23C5 36=8D I1<0 <05 2H5<;0 389 5E1958;5 => <05 43:<152 <05:1A7836:1D0<6B0569<03<<059:1E5:=><056=::B I3285D61D58<18;37218D<053;;1958< A 5;=896B 1< 12 ;=8<58<59 <03< <05 :524=8958<* 827:38;5 =C438B 5K3C1859 1<2 =>>1;5: 32 389 38=<05: I1<8522 32 ! 8 <05 5E1958;5 => ! 05 ;3<5D=:1;366B39C1<<59<03<<059:1E5:=><05=>>58918D6=::B 05693E36193895>>5;<1E59:1E18D61;582532=8<0593<5=> <053;;1958< - 9 - ; 32<6B ;=82195:18D<053D53893E=;3<1=8=><05 95;53259 <05 =E5:366 ;=C45823<1=8 3I3:959 AB <05 :1A7836 12 F72< 389 :532=83A65 58;5 05 2=7D0< >=: 912C12236=><05344536 + 53:9 <05 653:859 ;=78256 34453:18D >=: <05 43:<152 389 45:7259 <05 F79DC58< 389 3I3:9 => <05 :1A7836 # 05;325=><05;631C38<212<03<=8##"!#+ 3< 3A=7< #&## 4C <05 95;53259 0389:3H38<0 36=8D I1<0=<05:2I32:5<7:818D<=363A7:3D1183F554A53:18D :5D12<:3<1=8 87CA5: *$! *!!&' 058 <05 F554 :53;059 <05 363A7:3D1*.5I3:D1 C318 :=39 18 >:=8< => 3:93:F1 03A3 I1<018 <05 61C1<2 => 3891H7: E1663D5 <05 9:1E5:=><05F55443:H59<05E501;65=8<055K<:5C52195 => <05 :=39 < <03< <1C5 9:1E5: => 6=::B A53:18D :5D12<:3<1=8 87CA5: *# *"!&+ ;3C5 18 3 :320 389 85D61D58<C3885:389932059<0501894=:<1=8=><05F554 75<=I01;0<0595;53259 0389:3H38<0 I0=I3221<<18D - 10 - 18 <05 F554 272<31859 D:15E=72 18F7:B 389 27;;7CA59 <= <0518F7:B = 4:=E5 <05 ;325 => <05 ;631C38<2 45<1<1=85: 8= 032 A558 5K3C1859 32 * 8 05: 5E1958;5 205 :51<5:3<59 <05 2<3<5C58<2 C395 18 <05 ;631C 45<1<1=8 CC5913<56B >=66=I18D <05 3;;1958< 3 ;=C46318< I32 6=9D593D3182<<059:1E5:=><056=::B054=61;5:5D12<5:59 31:2<8>=:C3<1=8 54=:<K3D3182<<059:1E5:=><05 6=::B 3245:K! ;5:<1>159;=4B=>1:2<8>=:C3<1=8><5: 3<0=:=7D018E52<1D3<1=8 3;03:D52055<I32>16593D3182< <059:1E5:=><056=::B 3245:K$ ;5:<1>159;=4B=>1836 54=:< 05 4=61;5 362= 9:3I8 3 2H5<;0 32 45: K' ;5:<1>159 ;=4B => :1C5 5<3162 =:C 218D <05 :1C5 5<3162 =:C <05 4=61;5 03E5 4:543:59 <05 24=< 438;0383C3:=C<05259=;7C58<2 1<125E1958<<03<<05 F554I3243:H5918>:=8<=><05903A3 15 =8<055K<:5C5 2195=><05:=39 I01;01233<1=8361D0I3B05:5I32 3C465243;5:5C31818D=8<05:1D0<2195=><05F55405 9:1E5:=><056=::B9:=E53<01D024559389183:320389 - 11 - 18<5661D58<C3885: ;3C5185K<:5C52195=><05:=39389 932059 <05 F554 >:=C <05 0189 2195 75 <= <05 1C43;< 95;53259 0389:3H38<0272<3185918F7:15238927;;7CA59 <=18F7:152 ! = 9124:=E5 <05 ;325 <05 827:38;5 =C438B 919 8=< 5K3C185 <05 9:1E5: => <05 6=::B 82<539 1< 5K3C1859 * 38=>>1;5:=><05827:38;5 =C438B389 *! 38 =>>1;5: >:=C <05 >>1;5 5B=89 <012 <05B 919 8=< 4:=97;5 38B 9=;7C58<2 <= 9124:=E5 <05 5E1958;5 4:5258<59 AB <05 ;631C38<2 =82195:18D <05 5E1958;5 => <05 ;=C46318< ;03:D5 2055< :1C5 5<3162 =:C :54=:< 389 =<05: 2744=:<18D 9=;7C58<2 <05 :1A7836 :1D0<6B 0569 <03< <05 9:1E5: => <05 6=::B I32 85D61D58<18;37218D<053;;1958< $ 05245;1>1;;=8<58<1=8:31259AB<05827:38;5 =C438B12<03<<059:1E5:=><056=::B9198=<4=225223 E3619 389 5>>5;<1E5 9:1E18D 61;5825 3< <05 <1C5 => <05 3;;1958< =I5E5: <05 827:38;5 =C438B 5K3C1859 - 12 - =>>1;136 >:=C 32 I1<8522 8 012 5E1958;5 05 032 ;3<5D=:1;366B2<3<59<03<<059:1E5:=><056=::B05693E3619 9:1E18D61;5825>=:3<:3824=:<E501;65 I01;0I325>>5;<1E5 >:=C$#!#+<=$##!#!!053;;1958<=;;7::59=8 ##"!#+ 05 =>>58918D E501;65 I32 3 D==92 ;3::13D5 E501;65 05:5>=:5 32 =8 <05 93<5 => <05 3;;1958< <05 9:1E5: => <05 =>>58918D E501;65 4=2252259 3 E3619 389 5>>5;<1E5 9:1E18D 61;5825 =825L758<6B <05 ;=8<58<1=8 => <05827:38;5 =C438B<03<9:1E5:=><05=>>58918DE501;65 9198=<03E53E36193895>>5;<1E59:1E18D61;5825;388=<A5 3;;54<59 ' 8:5245;<=>L738<7C12;=8;5:859 ;=82195:18D <05 3D5 389 <05 3E=;3<1=8 => <05 95;53259 <05 ;=C45823<1=8 3I3:959 AB <05 :1A7836 12 F72< 389 :532=83A6558;5 1<9=528=<:5L71:538B18<5:>5:58;5 % 8 E15I => <05 3A=E5 I5 4322 <05 >=66=I18D =:95: - 13 - 1 0534453612 11 05 F79DC58< 389 3I3:9 432259 AB <05 :1A7836 93<59 !#+!#!' 432259 AB <05 991<1=836 581=: 1E16 .79D5 389 . G 991<1=836 363A7:3D1 18 =#$+ !#+12;=8>1:C59 111 05 3C=78< 18 954=21< 12 =:95:59 <= A5 <:382C1<<59<=<05:1A7836 1E 66458918D34461;3<1=823:59124=259=> *+ '# ( % *+ '"%&"( % 12<=6=%%