Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 64006 (KAR)
RAVINDRA v. SRI SRIKAR M S AND ORS
CCC/200228/2024 · 2025-08-14
H P Sandesh, T M Nadaf
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64006 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64006 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$! "#$# %#!! &
! "
#$$$! %
&& #'!$! Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
(
"
#$$$! () !"%
%! !! " !%
%$!'!$ %$%%
!'$*%$%+
,&
-
($$*%$%
.-
.-
- 3 -
%
.-
/ 012/ 0/134 35 561789:13 6/13;/4 /;5<3 <9;7/61==/135;>?<3355@/70145A16?<3@0/B<:=615;1;@ 1;4 35 16013 1< 6/13;/4 445@5<;16 42<B1@/ /;/316 1==/135;>?<33/7=<;4/;@<(<;@0/5779/<?0/135;>C/?<3/ B013>/1>15;7@3/7=<;4/;@<%
% 057B<;@/:=@=/@5@5<;57?56/49;4/33@5B6/%!<? @0/ <;7@5@9@5<; <? ;451 3 D /B@5<;7 !! 1;4 !% <? @0/ <;@/:=@ <? <93@7 B@
0/ =31A/3 7<9>0@ 5; @0/ =/@5@5<; 3/14717?<66<D7
E5
!"! !" # $ % &'
(&
% )
- 4 -
*
+
( 0/ ?1B@916 :1@35F <? @0/ B17/ 57 @01@ @0/ B<:=615;1;@5;@0/=3/7/;@B<;@/:=@=/@5@5<;7@1@/4@01@0/ D171==<5;@/4CA@0//B395@:/;@<::5@@//B<;7@5@9@/45; @0/A/13!GG(171@B0:1;1>15;7@=/3:1;/;@21B1;BA1;4 0/D17C/5;>=154<;6A7%$ &1;4D17C/5;>C31;4/417 @/:=<313A /:=6<A// C9@ 057 7/325B/7 017 ;<@ C//;
3/>96135H/4 ;<3 =154 D1>/7 B<33/7=<;45;> @< =/3:1;/;@ /:=6<A// 17 @01@ <? 75:56136A 75@91@/4 ><2/3;:/;@ /:=6<A//7 1;4 B<2/3/4 057 ;1:/9;4/3 <2/3;:/;@ >31;@ @ 57 7@1@/4 @01@ 0/ 1==3<1B0/4 3/7=<;4/;@ <! CA ?565;> =/@5@5<; C9@ @0/ 71:/ D17 ;<@ B<;754/3/4 /;B/ @0/ B<:=615;1;@1==3<1B0/4@057<93@CAD1A<?D35@=/@5@5<;5;
<%$!G! %$!*
+ 0/ 6/13;/4 5;>6/ -94>/ CA <34/3 41@/4 ($$%$!'166<D/4@0/D35@=/@5@5<;?56/4CA@0/B<:=615;1;@ D5@01453/B@5<;@<457=<7/<?@0/7154=/@5@5<;=/;45;>C/?<3/ @0/ 19@0<35@A
0/3/1?@/3 3/7=<;4/;@ <! 017 457=<7/4 <? - 5 -
@0/ 7154 =/@5@5<; ?56/4 9;4/3 /B@5<; !(! <? @0/ 13;1@181 49B1@5<; B@ !G'( ?<3 70<3@ I@0/ B@J <; !!$%$!' 4/;A5;>@0/=31A/37<9>0@CA@0/B<:=615;1;@
0/35;B5=16 <?@0/B<66/>/D0/3/@0/B<:=615;1;@D17D<385;>B<;@5;9/4 @</F@31B@@0/D<38?3<:05:B<;@5;9<976AD5@0<9@1;A85;4 <? C3/18 1;4 D5@0<9@ =1A5;> @0/ B<33/7=<;45;> ><2/3;:/;@ 7B16/<3D5@0<9@7/;45;>@0/=3<=<716@<3/7=<;4/;@<!?<3 B<2/35;> 05: 9;4/3 <2/3;:/;@ >31;@ /;B/ 1>15; @0/ B<:=615;1;@ 1==3<1B0/4 @057 <93@ 5; <%$!'!$ %$%% D5@01=31A/3@<453/B@@0/3/7=<;4/;@7?<33/>96135H1@5<;<? 057 7/325B/ ?3<: @0/ 41@/ <? 057 5;5@516 1==<5;@:/;@ 5; @0/ A/13 !GG( 1;4 B<2/3 05:9;4/3 ><2/3;:/;@ >31;@1;4=1A 166 B<;7/K9/;@516 C/;/?5@7 5;B6945;> @0/ 133/137 <? D1>/7 17 =/3<34/341@/4!!$%$!'=177/4CA3/7=<;4/;@<! @ 57 7@1@/4 @01@ 1?@/3 0/135;> C<@0 754/7 @0/ 6/13;/4 5;>6/ -94>/ 166<D/4 @0/ D35@ =/@5@5<; ?56/4 CA @0/ B<:=615;1;@ 254/ ;;/F93/& 453/B@/4 3/7=<;4/;@ <% @< B<;754/3@0/6/@@/3<?3/7=<;4/;@<%41@/4!%$%$%$1;4 =1771==3<=351@/<34/375;1BB<341;B/D5@0@0/61DD5@05;1
- 6 -
=/35<4<??<93D//87?3<:@0/41@/<?3/B/5=@<?B<=A<?7154 <34/3
@ 57 167< @0/ B<;@/;@5<; <? @0/ B<:=615;1;@ @01@ 0/ :14/ 7/2/316 3/=3/7/;@1@5<;7 41@/4 %$'%$%+ %G$*%$!+ 1;4 !%$'%$!+ 3/K9/7@5;> 3/7=<;4/;@ <7% 1;4 ( @< B<:=6A @0/ <34/3 =177/4 CA @0/ 6/13;/4 5;>6/ -94>/1;4=1A166@0/133/137<?71613A=/;75<;/@BD5@0166 B<;7/K9/;@516 C/;/?5@7
0/ 3/=3/7/;@1@5<;7 >52/; CA @0/ B<:=615;1;@ 13/ =3<49B/4 17 ;;/F93/7& 1;4 9@ 5;7=5@/ <? 79C:5@@5;> 3/=3/7/;@1@5<;7 @0/ 3/7=<;4/;@7 012/ ;<@ B<;754/3/4 @0/ 71:/ 1;4 0/;B/ 1==3<1B0/4 @057<93@ CA?565;>@057B<;@/:=@=/@5@5<;
* 0/ :15; B<;@/;@5<; <? @0/ 6/13;/4 /;5<3 B<9;7/6 1==/135;> ?<3 @0/ B<:=615;1;@ 57 @01@ 5;7=5@/ <?
7=/B5?5B<34/3=177/45;/1365/3D35@=/@5@5<;17D/66175;@0/ <34/3 =3<49B/4 1@ ;;/F93/& @0/ 3/7=<;4/;@7 ?156/4 @< B<:=6A@0/453/B@5<;/2/;@0<9>07=/B5?5B@5:/<??<93D//87 D17 >52/; @< B<;754/3 @0/ 3/=3/7/;@1@5<;7 1;4 =177 1==3<=351@/ <34/37 /;B/ B<9;7/6 D<964 2/0/:/;@6A
- 7 -
B<;@/;4 @01@ D0/; @0/ 3/7=<;4/;@7 012/ ;<@ B<:=65/4 @0/ <34/3=177/4CA@0/6/13;/45;>6/-94>/@057<93@017@< ?31:/@0/B013>/71>15;7@@0/3/7=<;4/;@7
' /017?93@0/379C:5@@/4@01@5;3/7=<;7/@<@057 B<;@/:=@ =/@5@5<; 1; 1??54125@ 41@/4 $*$!%$% 57 ?56/4 CA 3/7=<;4/;@<+1;;/F5;>;;/F93/7&!1;4%1;47@1@5;> @01@5;=93791;B/<?@0/<34/3=177/4CA@0/6/13;/45;>6/ -94>/ 1 6/@@/3 D17 D35@@/; @< 3/7=<;4/;@ <% <;
$*$'%$%+ 17 =/3 ;;/F93/&! /7=<;4/;@ <% =177/4 @0/<34/3<;%+!%%$%+1;4@0/71:/D17B<::9;5B1@/4@< 3/7=<;4/;@;<+254/5@76/@@/341@/4$!$!%$%1;471:/57 =3<49B/4 17 ;;/F93/&%
0/ 71:/ D17 ;<@ 1BB/=@/4 CA @057<93@
G 0/ 6/13;/4 B<9;7/6 1==/135;> ?<3 @0/ B<:=615;1;@ 167< ?56/4 1 :/:< 1;4 /;B6<7/4 @0/ <34/3 =177/49;4/3/B@5<;!(!<?@0/B@CA57795;>453/B@5<;7@< 7/;4@0/=3<=<716@<14:5@@0/=<7@5;D05B0@0/B<:=615;1;@ D17D<385;>@<>31;@&5;&154<D/2/3;<@05;>=61B/4C/?<3/ @0/ <93@ CA @0/ B<;B/3;/4 <??5B/3 <? @0/ 49B1@5<;
- 8 -
/=13@:/;@17@<@0/7@1@97<?5:=6/:/;@1@5<;<?@0/<34/3 =177/49;4/3/B@5<;!(!<?@0/49B1@5<;B@
057 <93@ 254/<34/341@/4%$$%%$%@185;>5;@<B<;754/31@5<;<?@0/ <34/3 41@/4 !'$*%$%+ =177/4 5; <%$!'!$ %$%% ?<9;4@01@14/@156/4<34/3D17=177/4CA@0/6/13;/45;>6/ -94>/ D5@0 1 453/B@5<; @< @0/ 445@5<;16 <::5775<;/3 ?<3 9C65B ;7@39B@5<;7 @< B<;754/3 @0/ 6/@@/3 41@/4 !%$%$%$ 1;4@<=1771==3<=351@/<34/37
057<93@@<<8;<@/<?@0/ 6/@@/341@/4!%$%$%$D05B0571B<::9;5B1@5<;1443/77/4 CA @0/ /=9@A 53/B@<3 <? 9C65B ;7@39B@5<; 161C931>5 @< @0/445@5<;16<::5775<;/3?<39C65B;7@39B@5<;1;4?<9;4 @01@@0/71544<B9:/;@577/6?&/F=61;1@<3A1;4/F@31B@/4@0/ 6/@@/3 41@/4 !%$%$%$ 125;> 3/14 @0/ 71:/ @057 <93@ :14/ 1; <C7/321@5<; @01@ @0/ 71:/ D<964 3/2/16 @01@ @0/ =3<=<716 017 C//; :14/ @< 5;B694/ @0/ ;1:/ <? @0/ B<:=615;1;@ 5; @0/ 657@ <? <2/3;:/;@ >31;@ 1;4 ;/B/7713A =/3:5775<; <? @0/ <2/3;:/;@ 5; @01@ 3/>134 017 C//; 7<9>0@
057<93@167<@<<8;<@/<?@0//1365/3<34/3=177/4 CA @057 <93@ 5; <%$!G! %$!* @ =131>31=0&* 1;
<C7/321@5<; D17 :14/ @01@ 5@ :97@ C/ ;<@5B/4 @01@ /;@53/@A
- 9 -
<?@0/B17/<?@0/B<:=615;1;@D17@01@0/017C//;:185;> 7/2/316 3/=3/7/;@1@5<;7 0<D/2/3 3521@/ 49B1@5<;16 ;7@5@9@5<; 014 ;<@ @18/; 1;A 1B@5<; @< 7/;4 057 ;1:/ 4/7=5@/057/;@5@6/:/;@@57?93@0/3B17/@01@<;B/@0/<93@ 014=177/41;<34/3@0/B<;754/31@5<;<?5;B6945;>057;1:/ 5;@0/657@<9>0@@<41@/C1B8@<0576/>16/;@5@6/:/;@1@1; /1365/3=<5;@<?@5:/1;4B1;;<@;<DC/4/?/1@/4<;@0/7<6/ >3<9;4 @01@ 17 <; @0/ 41@/ @0/3/ 57 1 C13 ?<3 79B0 B<;754/31@5<; <? 14:5@@5;> @0/ =<7@ @< >31;@&5;&154 /;B/ =177/4 1; <34/3 @01@ @0/ 4/?/;7/ ;<D 7/@&9= B1;;<@ 012/ @0/ /??/B@ <? 4/?/1@5;> @0/ 35>0@ <? @0/ B<:=615;1;@ D0<7/ ;1:/ D17 ;<@ ?<3D134/4 ?<3 ;< ?196@ <? 057 @ 57 167< <C7/32/4 @01@ @0/ 7@1;4 <? 3/7=<;4/;@ 1BB97/4 5; :96@5=6/ 1??54125@7B1;;<@C/1BB/=@/41;4<34/3/4@<657@@0/:1@@/3 ?<3?31:5;><?B013>/7<;%'$%%$%75;B/;<@1BB/=@/4@0/ ?93@0/3 1??54125@ 41@/4 %$$%%$% D0/3/5; ;;/F93/&!
@< 'D/3/?56/4C/?<3/@0/<93@125;>=177/479B01;<34/3 <;%$$%%$%3/7=<;4/;@71>15;?56/4B<:=651;B/3/=<3@<; %*$%%$%16<;>D5@0;;/F93/7&!@<';;/F93/&!57 @0/ <34/3 =177/4 5; /1365/3 D35@ =/@5@5<; 5/
- 10 -
<%$!G! %$!* 0/; @0/ :1@@/3 D17 657@/4 <;
%'$%%$% 1 79C:5775<; D17 :14/ @01@ <34/3 D<964 C/ B<:=65/4 D5@0
0<9>0 79B0 1 79C:5775<; D17 :14/ 3/7=<;4/;@73/K9/7@/4@0/<93@@<<C7/32/@01@B<:=651;B/ D<964;<@?<3/B6<7/@0/6/>16B<;@/;@5<;7@01@B<964C/3157/4 5; <@0/3 :1@@/37 1;4 B<:=651;B/ :1A ;<@ C/ @3/1@/4 17 =3/B/4/;@ 5; <@0/3 :1@@/37 154 79C:5775<; <? @0/ 6/13;/4 445@5<;1642<B1@//;/316D17@18/;<;3/B<34
0/<93@ B6135?5/4@01@@0/B<:=651;B/5;@0/=3/7/;@B17/:1A;<@C/ @3/1@/4 17 =3/B/4/;@ 5; <@0/3 B17/7 1;4 453/B@/4 @< 3/=<3@ ;/B/7713A B<:=651;B/ CA %$+%$% 93@0/3 1??54125@ 57 ?56/4 <; %+$+%$% D0/3/5; 5@ 57 7@1@/4 @01@ 3/7=<;4/;@ <% 017 D35@@/; 6/@@/3 @< @0/ 35;B5=16 /B3/@13A @< <2/3;:/;@/=13@:/;@<?B0<<649B1@5<;?<31==3<25;> CA >525;> @0/ C/;/?5@7 @< @0/ B<:=615;1;@ B<=A <? @0/ 6/@@/3 41@/4 $$(%$% 57 =3<49B/4 17 ;;F93/&! 1;4 4/@156=3<=<716D177/;@@<@0/<2/3;:/;@
!$ ::/451@/6A 1?@/3 ?565;> <? @0/ 7154 1??54125@ :1@@/3 D17 <34/3/4 @< C/ 657@/4 <; $$%$% 1;4 5@ D17
- 11 -
:14/B6/13@01@5?@0/3/7=<;4/;@7?156@<B<:=6A@0/<34/3 166 @0/ 3/7=<;4/;@7 70166 C/ =3/7/;@ C/?<3/ @057 <93@ ?<3 ?31:5;><?B013>/7
!! 0/ 3/7=<;4/;@7 1>15; ?56/4 ?93@0/3 1??54125@ <;
$+$%$% D0/3/5; 5@ 57 7@1@/4 @01@ 9;4/3 @0/ 7=/B516 B53B9:7@1;B/7B17/<?@0/B<:=615;1;@017C//;B<;754/3/4 CA @0/ <2/3;:/;@ 1;4 <34/3 57 =177/4 <; $($%$% 14:5@@5;> @0/ B<:=615;1;@J7 7/325B/ @< >31;@&5;&154
0/ <34/3<?@0/<2/3;:/;@41@/4$($%$%57167<=3<49B/4 17 ;;/F93/&! 16<;> D5@0 @0/ 7154 1??54125@ 0/ B<:=615;1;@ ?56/4 1; 1??54125@ 5; =93791;B/ <? @0/ 1??54125@ 41@/4 $+$%$% D0/3/5; 3/5@/31@/4 @0/ /1365/3 <34/37 1;4 167< @0/ 6/@@/3 1443/77/4 @< @0/ 445@5<;16 <::5775<;/3 41@/4 !%$%$%$ 1;4 /1365/3 <34/37 =177/4 5; @D< D35@ =/@5@5<;7 @ =131>31=0&!$ <? @0/ 7154 1??54125@ @0/ B<:=615;1;@ 3/?/33/4 @< @0/ <34/37 41@/4 !*$%%$% 1;4 %$$%%$% 1;4 B<;@/;4/4 @01@ 533/6/21;@ 4<B9:/;@7 13/ =3<49B/4 16<;> D5@0 @0/ 1??54125@7 1;4 @057 <93@ 0/64 @01@ @0/ 7@1;4 <? 3/7=<;4/;@7 1BB97/4 5; :96@5=6/ 1??54125@7
- 12 -
B1;;<@ C/ 1BB/=@/4 1;4 <34/3/4 @< 657@ @057 :1@@/3 ?<3 ?31:5;> <? B013>/7 <; %'$%%$% @ D17 7@1@/4 @01@ @0/ <34/3=177/4 CA @0/ <2/3;:/;@ 57;<@ 5; B<;7<;1;B/D5@0 @0/B615::14/CA@0/B<:=615;1;@;=131>31=0<!%@0/ B<:=615;1;@7@1@/4@01@@0/<93@<34/3/4@<657@@0/:1@@/3 <; $$%$% D5@0 1 453/B@5<; @< @0/ 3/7=<;4/;@7 @< C/ =3/7/;@ C/?<3/ @057 <93@ ?<3 ?31:5;> <? B013>/7 5? @0/ 3/7=<;4/;@7?156/4@<B<:=6A@0/<34/3@577@1@/4@01@CA @185;> 9;49/ 1421;@1>/ <? @0/ D<347 E5? @0/ 3/7=<;4/;@7 ?156/4 @< B<:=6A @0/ <34/3L 166 @0/ 3/7=<;4/;@7 70166 C/ =3/7/;@C/?<3/@0/<93@?<3?31:5;><?B013>/71;4CAD1A <?
/:=@A ?<3:165@A D5@0<9@ @0/3/ C/5;> B<:=651;B/ <? @0/ <34/3<;/:<3/1??54125@D17?56/41;4;<@:/@@0/B17/<? @0/B<:=615;1;@
0/<C7/321@5<;:14/5;@0/<34/3<?@057 <93@ 41@/4 %'$%%$% D17 :14/ <; @0/ 3/K9/7@ <? @0/ <2/3;:/;@@01@5@D566;<@C/@3/1@/417=3/B/4/;@5;<@0/3 B17/79@@0/>35/21;B/<?@0/B<:=615;1;@57@01@5;7=5@/<? >525;> <? 7/2/316 3/=3/7/;@1@5<;7 @0<9>0 0/ 57 /;@5@6/4 ?<3 C/5;>B<2/3/49;4/3@0/<2/3;:/;@>31;@D5@0/??/B@?3<:
057 5;5@516 1==<5;@:/;@ 5; @0/ A/13 !GG( @0/ <34/3 41@/4
- 13 -
$($%$% D17 ;<@ 5; B<:=651;B/ D5@0 @0/ 453/B@5<; >52/;
CA @0/ 6/13;/4 5;>6/ -94>/ ; 25/D <? <2/3;:/;@ 34/3 41@/4 $($%$% <; $$%$% @057 <93@ 166<D/4 @0/ /F/:=@5<; 1==65B1@5<; 1;4 D0/; @0/ :1@@/3 D17 657@/4 <; !*$%$%1;4%($%$%@0/3/D17;<?93@0/3=3<>3/775;
@0/ :1@@/3 <D/2/3 <; %($%$% @057 <93@ 453/B@/4 3/7=<;4/;@<%@<C/=3/7/;@C/?<3/@057<93@<;@0/;/F@ 41@/ <? 0/135;>
057 <93@ CA <34/3 41@/4 $($*%$% B<;754/35;> @0/ 79C:5775<; <? @0/ 6/13;/4 445@5<;16 42<B1@/ /;/316 3/>1345;> @0/ <2/3;:/;@ 34/3 41@/4 $($%$% 1;4 79C7/K9/;@ 4/2/6<=:/;@7 0/64 @01@ 5@ 57 1==3<=351@/@<>52/C<@0=13@5/710/135;>C/?<3/B013>/1;4 0/;B/=<7@/4@0/ :1@@/3<;!$*%$%?<30/135;>C/?<3/ B013>/ D0/3/5; 7=/B5?5B166A 453/B@/4 3/7=<;4/;@ <% @< C/ =3/7/;@ C/?<3/ @0/ <93@ CA @0/ ;/F@ 41@/ <? 0135;> ;
!$*%$% 445@5<;16 <::5775<;/3 ?<3 9C65B ;7@39B@5<; D17=3/7/;@C/?<3/@0/<93@1;4:1@@/3B<964;<@C/@18/; 49/@<=19B5@A<?@5:/
- 14 -
!% 0/; @0/ :1@@/3 D17 0/134 3/>1345;> 0/135;> C/?<3/ B013>/ @0/ :15; B<;@/;@5<; <? @0/ 6/13;/4 /;5<3 B<9;7/61==/135;>?<3@0/B<:=615;1;@57@01@@0/<34/341@/4 $($%$%57;<@5;B<;?<3:5@AD5@0@0/<34/3=177/4CA@0/ 6/13;/4 5;>6/ -94>/ 5; @0/ /1365/3 @D< D35@ =/@5@5<;7 1;4 B<9;7/6C3<9>0@@<@0/;<@5B/<?@057<93@@01@@0/71:/57 167< ;<@ 17 =/3 @0/ <34/3 <? @0/ 35;B5=16 /B3/@13A 41@/4 !!$%$!' 1;4 0/;B/ @057 <93@ 017 @< ?31:/ B013>/7 1>15;7@@0/3/7=<;4/;@7 1BB97/4
!( 6/13;/4 445@5<;16 42<B1@/ /;/316 1==/135;>?<3@0/@1@/2/0/:/;@6AB<;@/;4/4@01@D0/;@0/ 453/B@5<;7 5779/4 CA @057 <93@ 5; /1365/3 @D< D35@ =/@5@5<;7 13/B<:=65/4@0/K9/7@5<;<??31:5;><?B013>/1>15;7@@0/ 3/7=<;4/;@7 4</7 ;<@ 1357/ 1;4 @0/ B<;@/:=@ =3<B//45;>7 :1AC/43<==/4
!+ ;3/7=<;7/@<@05713>9:/;@@0/6/13;/4/;5<3 B<9;7/6 1==/135;> ?<3 @0/ B<:=615;1;@ 017 C3<9>0@ @< @0/ ;<@5B/<?@057<93@@0/M94>:/;@<?@0/<;JC6/=/F<93@ 5; @0/ B17/ <? - 15 -
3/=<3@/45; !"#D0/3/5;1@=131>31=0& 5@<C7/32/4D5@03/>134@<@0/B<;49B@<?@0/3/7=<;4/;@/ 167<C3<9>0@@<@0/;<@5B/<?@057<93@@0/M94>:/;@<?@0/ <;JC6/=/F<93@5;B17/<?$% & 3/=<3@/4 5;
'" ( D0/3/5; 1@ =131>31=0&! 457B9775<; 57 :14/ D5@0 3/>134 @< @0/ D<34 IB<;754/3J D05B0 :/1;7 I@< 25/D 1@@/;@52/6A @< 7932/A /F1:5;/ 5;7=/B@ 13B0 @< 6<<8 1@@/;@52/6A@<B<;@/:=61@/:/;@166A@<@05;8<2/3:/451@/ <;>52/0//4@<@18/;<@/<?@<@05;84/65C/31@/6AC/@05;8 <;/7/6?@<3/?6/B@
0/<;JC6/=/F<93@1@=131>31=0&! 017 <C7/32/4 @01@ 1; 1==65B1@5<; <? :5;4 D5@0 3/>134 @< ;/B/775@A @< <C@15; 1;4 /F1:5;/ <;6A 1 ?/D <? @0/ :1;A 4<B9:/;@7:/;@5<;/45;@0/<34/3D056/@0/3/017C//;;< 79B0 1==65B1@5<; <? :5;4 5; 3/7=/B@ <?
@0/ 3/:15;5;> 4<B9:/;@7 D<964 ;<@ C/ 79??5B5/;@ B<:=651;B/ D5@0 @0/ 3/K953/:/;@7<?@0/7@1@9/
- 16 -
! 0/ 6/13;/4 /;5<3 B<9;7/6 167< 3/65/4 9=<; @0/ 4/B575<; <? @0/ ;4031 314/70 5>0 <93@ 5; @0/ B17/ <? )*
+
3/=<3@/4 5; ",'-!. / "0' D0/3/5; 1@ =131>31=0&%$ 3/?/33/4 @< @0/ M94>:/;@ <? @0/ <;JC6/ =/F <93@ 5; @0/ B17/ <? %D0/3/5;017<C7/32/4D5@03/>134 @<@0/D<34IB<;754/3J/167<C3<9>0@@<@0/;<@5B/<?@057 <93@ =131>31=0&%% <? @0/ M94>:/;@ 79=31 D0/3/5; @0/ M94>:/;@ <? <;JC6/ 9=3/:/ <93@ 5; @0/ B17/ <? 1 2
)&3 3/=<3@/4 5; - 04." 4' 3/?/33/4 1;4C3<9>0@@<@0/;<@5B/<?@057<93@=131>31=0&%D0/3/5; 1;<C7/321@5<;D17:14/@01@5?@0/=/@5@5<;/37D/3/4352/;
@< 1;<@0/3 3<9;4 <? 65@5>1@5<; 17 B<;@/;4/4 CA 6/13;/4 B<9;7/6 ?<3 @0/ 3/7=<;4/;@7 5@ 57 1 :<B8/3A <? M97@5B/ 1;4 @0/<93@017@<012/0<657@5B25/D<?@0/:1@@/31;470<964 ;<@:96@5=6A@0/65@5>1@5<;
! 0/ 6/13;/4 /;5<3 B<9;7/6 167< 3/65/4 9=<; @0/ <34/3=177/4 5; @0/ B<;@/:=@ =/@5@5<; CA @0/ 5>0 <93@ <? - 17 -
-945B1@93/1@143175;@0/B17/<?5
$ 5
+ "' ,6","! "0,!","( 1;4 C3<9>0@ @0/ ;<@5B/ <? @057 <93@ @< @0/ 457B9775<; :14/ 5;
=131>31=0 <7G 1;4 !$ / 167<3/65/4 9=<;@0/ M94>:/;@ <?@0/<;JC6/=/F<93@5;@0/B17/<?7/ 8 2 -89. 3/=<3@/4 5; 0( ''"
0/ 6/13;/4 /;5<3 B<9;7/6 3/?/335;> @< @0/7/ M94>:/;@7D<964B<;@/;4@01@@0/<34/3<?@0/<2/3;:/;@ 57 ;<@ 5; B<;7<;1;B/ D5@0 @0/ <34/3 =177/4 CA @0/ 6/13;/4 5;>6/ -94>/ 1;4 @0/ 71:/ 57 ;<@ 5; B<:=651;B/ D5@0 @0/ 6/@@/3 1;4 7=535@ <? @0/ <34/3 =177/4 CA @0/ 6/13;/4 5;>6/ -94>/
!* /13;/4 /;5<3 B<9;7/6 017 167< 3/65/4 9=<; @0/ M94>:/;@ <? @0/ 52575<; /;B0 <? @057 <93@ 5;
<%$(G' %$!G41@/4%+$%%$%$
0/6/13;/4/;5<3 B<9;7/6 3/?/335;> @< @0/7/ M94>:/;@7 D<964 2/0/:/;@6A B<;@/;4 @01@ @0/ <34/3 <9>0@ @< 012/ C//; 14:5@@5;> @0/ B<:=615;1;@ ?<3 >31;@&5;&154 ?3<: @0/ 41@/ <? 057
- 18 -
/:=6<A:/;@ 3/@3<7=/B@52/6A 1;4 ;<@ =3<7=/B@52/6A 17 017 C//;4<;/CA@0/<2/3;:/;@/;B/@0/:1@@/33/K953/7@< C/ B<;754/3/4 1;4 @057 <93@ 017 @< ?31:/ @0/ B013>/7 1>15;7@@0/3/7=<;4/;@7 1BB97/4
!' ; 3/=6A @< @057 13>9:/;@ 6/13;/4 445@5<;16 42<B1@//;/3161==/135;>?<3@0/3/7=<;4/;@7&@1@/D<964 79C:5@ @01@ 17 B<964 C/ 7//; ?3<: @0/ 5:=9>;/4 <34/3 =177/4CA@0/6/13;/45;>6/-94>/1@=131>31=0&%D0/3/5;
5@ 57 B1@/><35B166A :/;@5<;/4 @01@ 5@ D17 @0/ B<;@/;@5<; <? @0/B<:=615;1;@@01@0/D171==<5;@/4@<@0/=<7@<?3<9=& 5;@0/A/13!GG(5;@0/7B0<<6<?3/7=<;4/;@<@0/3/5;
1;4 0/ 014 :<2/4 1; 1==65B1@5<; @< 3/7=<;4/;@ <! ?<3 3/>96135H1@5<; <?
057 7/325B/7 1;4 167< B<2/35;> 057 =<7@ 17 =/3:1;/;@ /:=6<A// 9;4/3 @0/ >31;@&5;&154 /7=<;4/;@ ;<!454;<@B<;754/3@0/1==65B1@5<;1;40/;B/D35@=/@5@5<;
D17?56/45;<%$!G! %$!*
0/6/13;/45;>6/-94>/ CA<34/341@/4($$%$!'166<D/4@0/=/@5@5<;1;4453/B@/4 3/7=<;4/;@<!@<457=<7/<?@0/=/@5@5<;7154@<C/?56/4CA @0/ B<:=615;1;@ =/@5@5<;/3 9;4/3 /B@5<; !(! <? @0/ B@
- 19 -
D5@05; 1 =/35<4 <? @D< :<;@07 ?3<: @0/ 41@/ <? 3/B/5=@ <? B<=A<?@0/7154<34/3/167<C3<9>0@@<@0/;<@5B/<?@057 <93@ =131>31=0&* <? @0/ 5:=9>;/4 <34/3 D0/3/5; 1;
<C7/321@5<; 57 :14/ @01@ =/@5@5<;/3 B<:=615;1;@ 57 ;<@ 7/325;> 5; @0/ ><2/3;:/;@ 7B0<<6 1;4 057 =<7@ D17 ;<@ 1==3<2/49;4/3>31;@&5;&154=35<3@<0571==<5;@:/;@@<@0/ 7154=<7@;4/3@0/B53B9:7@1;B/7@0/<2/3;:/;@B1;;<@ C/453/B@/4@<3/>96135H/@0/7/325B/73/@3<7=/B@52/6A/017 C//; 7/325;> 5; 1 =3521@/ /49B1@5<;16 5;7@5@9@5<; 1;4 :<3/<2/3;<4<B9:/;@713/=61B/4<;3/B<345;79==<3@<? 057 B<;@/;@5<; ;/5@0/3 0/ 017 =3<49B/4 @0/ 1==<5;@:/;@ 6/@@/35779/4CA 3/7=<;4/;@ <+ ;<3 @0/3/ 13/ 1;A3/B<347 @<70<D@01@0/017C//;7/325;>5;@0/71545;7@5@9@5<;75;B/ !GG( / 167< C3<9>0@ @< @0/ ;<@5B/ <? @057 <93@ @01@ @0/ 6/13;/45;>6/-94>/017B1@/><35B166A0/64@01@@0/3/57;< ;//4 @< B<;754/3 @0/ 79C:5775<; <? @0/ 6/13;/4 /;5<3 B<9;7/6?<3@0/=/@5@5<;/35;3/7=/B@<?@0/3/>96135H1@5<;<? @0/7/325B/<?@0/=/@5@5<;/3CA@0/<2/3;:/;@<D/2/3 1@=131>31=0&!$@0/6/13;/45;>6/-94>/017<C7/32/4@01@ 5@ 57 ;/B/7713A @< 453/B@ 3/7=<;4/;@7 <% @< B<;754/3 @0/
- 20 -
71543/=3/7/;@1@5<;<?3/7=<;4/;@;<(1;4=1771==3<=351@/ <34/37 5; 1BB<341;B/ D5@0 61D
0/ 6/13;/4 5;>6/ -94>/ :<964/4@0/3/65/?1;4453/B@/43/7=<;4/;@<%@<B<;754/3 @0/ 6/@@/3 <? 3/7=<;4/;@ <% 41@/4 !%$%$%$ 1;4 =177 1==3<=351@/<34/37<D@0/<2/3;:/;@1717=/B516B17/ B<;754/3/4 @0/ B<:=615;1;@J7 >35/21;B/ 5; 25/D <? @0/ 453/B@5<;75779/4CA@0/6/13;/45;>6/-94>/5;/1365/3D35@ =/@5@5<;1;4167<5;@0/79C7/K9/;@D35@=/@5@5<;1;4=177/4 1;<34/3/;B/@0/K9/7@5<;<??31:5;><?B013>/74</7;<@ 1357/
!G 125;>B<;754/3/4@0/?1B@91617=/B@717D/6617 @0/ :1@/3516 =61B/4 <; 3/B<34 1??54125@7 ?56/4 CA @0/ 3/7=/B@52/3/7=<;4/;@7=/35<45B166A1;4@0/1??54125@?56/4CA @0/ B<:=615;1;@ 79C7/K9/;@ @< @0/ =1775;> <? <2/3;:/;@
34/341@/4$($%$%1;4167<@0/=35;B5=6/761544<D;5; @0/4/B575<;73/?/33/479=31@0/=<5;@7@01@D<9641357/?<3 <93B<;754/31@5<;13/
- 21 -
, -
. , .+
%$ 125;>=/397/4@0/:1@/3516<;3/B<345@57;<@5;
457=9@/ @01@ @0/ B<:=615;1;@ 014 /1365/3 1==3<1B0/4 @057 <93@5;<%$!G! %$!*1;4@0/6/13;/45;>6/-94>/ =177/41;<34/3D05B03/14717?<66<D7& -/ 0
% 1 ! 2!3!4 5&%
% +
%! 3<: @0/ 1C<2/ <34/3 5@ 57 9;/K952<B166A B6/13 @01@ @0/ 6/13;/4 5;>6/ -94>/ D056/ 166<D5;> @0/ =/@5@5<;
453/B@/4 3/7=<;4/;@;<! @< 457=<7/ <? @0/ =/@5@5<; 7154@< C/ ?56/4 CA@0/ B<:=615;1;@ =/@5@5<;/3 9;4/3/B@5<; !(! <? 13;1@18149B1@5<;B@D5@05;1=/35<4<?@D<:<;@07?3<:
@0/41@/<?3/B/5=@<?1B<=A<?@0/ 7154<34/3/;B/5@57 B6/13@01@@0/=/@5@5<;?56/4CA@0/B<:=615;1;@9;4/3/B@5<; !(!<?13;1@18149B1@5<;B@017@<C/B<;754/3/4D5@05;1
- 22 -
=/35<4 <? @D< :<;@07 @ 57 @< C/ ;<@/4 @01@ 1; <34/3 017 C//;=177/4B<;7/K9/;@9=<;@057<34/37@1@5;>@01@@0/3/57 1 C1; 1;4 K9/7@5<; <? 14:5@@5;> 1;4 >31;@5;> @0/ 3/65/? 17 7<9>0@ CA @0/ B<:=615;1;@ B1;;<@ C/ >31;@/4 ; @0/ ?537@ 1??54125@ /=9@A 53/B@<3 <? 9C65B ;7@39B@5<;7 161C931>5 7@1@/4@01@0/017D35@@/;16/@@/3@<3/7=<;4/;@<% <; $*$'%$%+ 1;4 3/7=<;4/;@ ;<% =177/4 1; <34/3 <; %+!%%$%+17=/3;;/F93/&%D0/3/5;5@577@1@/4@01@@0/ 6/@@/3 41@/4 !%$%$%$ D17 =/397/4 1;4 5; @/3:7 <?
@0/ 13;1@18149B1@5<;B@@0/3/57;<=<775C565@A@<14:5@@0/ =<7@<?@0/B<:=615;1;@@<>31;@&5;&1541;41;/;4<37/:/;@ D17 5779/4
0/ 71:/ D17 ;<@ 1BB/=@/4 CA @057 <93@ 1;4 @0/; ?93@0/3 1??54125@ <? 3/7=<;4/;@ <% 1BB97/4 <% /;B6<75;> ;;/F93/7&! @< ' D17 ?56/4 C/?<3/ @057 <93@ D0/3/5; 3/7=<;4/;@ <% 017 3/?/33/4 @< @0/ ;4<37/:/;@ 41@/4 !+$%%$%+ 5779/4 CA @0/ <2/3;:/;@ 17 =/3 ;;/F93/&1;47/2/316=3<=<7167D/3/3/M/B@/4@57167< 7@1@/4@01@@0<9>0@0/35;B5=16/B3/@13A=177/4@0/<34/3 41@/4 !!$%$!' ?<3 =3<2545;> C/;/?5@ <? >31;@ 5; 25/D <? @0/C1;CA@0/<2/3;:/;@@0/7154=3<=<716D173/@93;/4
- 23 -
1;41BB<345;>6A<34/3D17=177/4<;%+!%%$%+
0/B<=A <?71:/D17:138/417;;/F93/&*
0/71541??54125@D17 167<;<@1BB/=@/4CA@057<93@0/;@0/:1@@/3D17657@/4 ?<3 ?31:5;> <? B013>/7 B<:=651;B/ 1??54125@ D17 ?56/4 CA 3/7=<;4/;@<%<;%*$%%$%D0/3/5;1@=131>31=0&+5@57 7@1@/4@01@@057<93@254/<34/341@/4($$%$!'453/B@/4 3/7=<;4/;@ <! 0/3/5; @< 457=<7/ <? @0/ =/@5@5<; D5@05; 1 =/35<4<?@D<:<;@07?3<:@0/41@/<?3/B/5=@<?1B<=A<? 7154 <34/3 ; 25/D <? @0/ 71:/ @0/ 7154 =/@5@5<; D17 457=<7/4 <? 1;4 453/B@/4 3/7=<;4/;@ <% @< /F1:5;/ 1;4 B<;754/3=<7@<?@0/B<:=615;1;@17=/3@0/=3<2575<;7@57 167< 7@1@/4 @01@ 657@ <? B1;4541@/7 =3/=13/4 17 =/3 41@/ <? 1==<5;@:/;@ <? 3<9=& /:=6<A//7 5; =3521@/ 154/4 /49B1@5<;16 5;7@5@9@5<;7 17 <; !$%$%% 1;4 71:/ 57 1;;/F/41@;;/F93/&+
057B<:=651;B/1??54125@D17167< ;<@ 1BB/=@/4 0/; 7/=131@/ 1??54125@ D17 ?56/4 <; %+$+%$%D0/3/5;1@=131>31=0&(5@577@1@/4@01@5;25/D <? 453/B@5<; <? @057 <93@ 41@/4 %'$%%$% @< B<:=6A D5@0 @0/<34/3<?@0/6/13;/45;>6/-94>/3/7=<;4/;@<%017 D35@@/; 6/@@/3 @< @0/ 35;B5=16 /B3/@13A @< <2/3;:/;@
- 24 -
/=13@:/;@<?49B1@5<;?<31==3<25;>CA>525;>C/;/?5@7@< @0/B<:=615;1;@
0/B<=A<?@0/6/@@/341@/4$$(%$%57 :138/417;;/F93/&!9C7/K9/;@6A?93@0/31??54125@D17 ?56/4<;$+$%$%?<30125;>B<:=65/4D5@0@0/<34/31;4 =3<49B/4@0/<2/3;:/;@ 34/341@/4$($%$%14:5@@5;> @0/B<:=615;1;@@<@0/>31;@&5;&154<D@0/K9/7@5<;C/?<3/ @057 <93@ 57 D0/@0/3 @0/ 7154 <2/3;:/;@ 34/3 57 5;
B<:=651;B/ D5@0 @0/ <34/3 =177/4 5; /1365/3 D35@ =/@5@5<; 17 D/661779C7/K9/;@D35@=/@5@5<;
%% <D@057<93@D<964658/@<:18/:/;@5<;<?@0/ <34/3=177/45;<%$!'!$ %$%%
057<93@017163/14A =<5;@/4<9@@0/457B9775<;:14/1@=131>31=07&%*1;4!$ <?@0/7154<34/35;=131>31=0&!'<?@057<34/3
0/6/13;/4 445@5<;1642<B1@//;/316167<C3<9>0@@<@0/;<@5B/<?@057 <93@ =131>31=0&!! <? @0/ 7154 <34/3 D05B0 3/147 17 ?<66<D7 -!! %6
0
3 ! - 25 -
+
%( <D/2/3@0/<=/31@52/=<3@5<;<?@0/<34/35/ =131>31=0&!%3/14717?<66<D7
-!7
60*
%8
! 9 :&'
(,
% %%
$%
& 0%
+
%+ 125;> B<;754/3/4 =131>31=07&!! 1;4 !% 1;4 167<=131>31=07&%*1;4!$5@57B6/13@01@@0/=31A/3:14/ 5; @0/ D35@ =/@5@5<; 4</7 ;<@ ?5@ 5;@< @0/ ?1B@7 1;4 B53B9:7@1;B/7 <D/2/3 @057 <93@ 017 :<964/4 @0/ 3/65/? 1;40/64@01@3/=3/7/;@1@5<;7/;@CA3/7=<;4/;@<(57;<@ B<;754/3/4CA3/7=<;4/;@<!@566@01@41A1;40/;B/5@57 ;/B/7713A @< 453/B@ 3/7=<;4/;@ <% @< B<;754/3 @0/ 71:/ 1;4 =177 795@1C6/ <34/3 1;4 453/B@/4 3/7=<;4/;@ <% @< =177 1==3<=351@/ <34/37 D5@05; ?<93D//87 ?3<:@0/41@/ <? - 26 -
3/B/5=@ <? B<=A <? 7154 <34/3 / 012/ 167< B<;754/3/4 @0/ <34/3=177/45;/1365/3D35@=/@5@5<;;@0/7154D35@=/@5@5<; =/@5@5<;/37<9>0@?<3453/B@5<;@<3/7=<;4/;@<!@<457=<7/ <? @0/ =/@5@5<; ?56/4 9;4/3 /B@5<; !(! <?
@0/ 13;1@181 49B1@5<; B@ 5::/451@/6A 1@ @0/ /1365/7@
0/ 6/13;/4 5;>6/ -94>/ CA <34/3 41@/4 ($$%$!' 453/B@/4 3/7=<;4/;@<!@<457=<7/<?@0/=/@5@5<;D5@05;@D<:<;@07 ?3<: @0/ 41@/ <? 3/B/5=@ <? B<=A <? @0/ 7154 <34/3 BB<345;>6A 3/7=<;4/;@ <! =177/4 <34/3 <; !!$%$!' D05B0017C//;/;B6<7/416<;>D5@0B<:=651;B/1??54125@
0/ 71:/D17;<@1BB/=@/4CA@057<93@
% 125;>=/397/4@0/1??54125@?56/4<;$+$%$% D0/3/5;5@577=/B5?5B166A7@1@/41@=131>31=0&+@01@@0/B17/ <? @0/ B<:=615;1;@ D17 B<;754/3/4 CA @0/ <2/3;:/;@ 1;4 <34/3 017 C//; =177/4 <; $($%$% 14:5@@5;> @0/ B<:=615;1;@ @< >31;@&5;&154 /;B/ 5@ 57 B6/13 @01@ 17 1 7=/B516B17/1;4167<;<@171=3/B/4/;@5;<@0/3B17/7@0/ B17/ <? @0/ =/@5@5<;/3 57 B<;754/3/4 1;4 <34/3 57 =177/4 /?<3/=1775;>7154<34/3@0/<2/3;:/;@017@18/;;<@/<? - 27 -
@0/ <34/3 =177/4 CA @057 <93@ 5; /1365/3 D35@ =/@5@5<; 5/ <%$!G! %$!* 7< 167< @18/; ;<@/ <? @0/ <34/3 <? 446 <::5775<;/3 49B1@5<; /=13@:/;@ 41@/4 !!$%$!'1;4167<@18/;;<@/<?79C7/K9/;@<34/3=177/4 5;D35@=/@5@5<;5/<%$!'!$ %$%%41@/4!'$*%$%+ 0/<2/3;:/;@017>52/;B<;7/;@?<371:/1;4<34/3D17 =177/4
% ; 3/7=<;7/ @< 71:/ 6/13;/4 B<9;7/6 1==/135;> ?<3 B<:=615;1;@ ?56/4 4/@156/4 1??54125@ 7@1@5;> @01@ @0/ B<:=651;B/ 1??54125@ 1;4 167< @0/ <2/3;:/;@ 34/3 41@/4 $($%$%=3<49B/417;;/F93/&!13/;<@5;B<;7<;1;B/ D5@0@0/<34/3=177/4CA@0/6/13;/45;>6/-94>/5;/1365/3 D35@=/@5@5<;1;479C7/K9/;@D35@=/@5@5<;
%* 9C7/K9/;@6A <; !*$%$% :1@@/3 D17 657@/4 ?<30/135;>C/?<3/B013>/
0/3/1?@/3@0/3/D17;<=3<>3/77 5;@0/:1@@/30/;@0/:1@@/3D17657@/4<;$($*%$%5@ 57 <C7/32/4 @01@ B<;754/35;> @0/ 79C:5775<; <? @0/ 6/13;/4 445@5<;16 42<B1@/ /;/316 3/>1345;> <2/3;:/;@ 34/3 =177/4 <; $($%$% 1;4 79C7/K9/;@ 4/2/6<=:/;@ 5@ 57
- 28 -
1==3<=351@/@<>52/C<@0@0/=13@5/710/135;>C/?<3/B013>/ 1;4 @0/ B17/ 57 ;<@ 7/@ 4<D; ?<3 ?31:5;> <? B013>/ C9@ 0/135;>C/?<3/B013>/
%' 0/ 2/3A B<;@/;@5<; @01@ @0/ B<:=615;1;@ <9>0@ @< 012/ C//; >52/; 166 C/;/?5@7 ?3<: @0/ 41@/ <? 057 /:=6<A:/;@ B1;;<@ C/ 1BB/=@/4 9;4/3 @0/ B<;@/:=@ M935745B@5<; 0/ 6/13;/4 5;>6/ -94>/ 5; <%$!'!$ %$%% =13@5B96136A 1@ =131>31=0&!! 017 <C7/32/4 @01@ @0/ =31A/3 :14/ 5; @0/ =/@5@5<; 4</7 ;<@ ?5@ 5;@<?1B@71;4B53B9:7@1;B/70<D/2/3:<964/4@0/3/65/?1;4 453/B@/4 @< B<;754/3 @0/ 3/=3/7/;@1@5<; 1;4 @< =177 1==3<=351@/ <34/37 <D <34/3 017 C//; =177/4 CA @0/ 3/7=<;4/;@77@<D0/@0/3@0/71:/575;@/3:7<?@0/B615:
<? @0/ B<:=615;1;@ <3 ;<@ B1;;<@ C/ 4/B54/4 5; B<;@/:=@ =3<B//45;>7 056/ 4/165;> D5@0 @0/ B<;@/:=@ =3<B//45;>7 @0/<93@017@<@18/;<@/17@<D0/@0/3@0/453/B@5<;5779/4 017 C//; B<:=65/4 @ 57 @< C/ ;<@/4 @01@ 5; /1365/3 D35@ =/@5@5<; 6/13;/4 5;>6/ -94>/ 453/B@/4 3/7=<;4/;@ <! @< 457=<7/ <? @0/ =/@5@5<; ?56/4 9;4/3 /B@5<; !(! <? @0/ B@
- 29 -
D5@05; 1 =/35<4 <? @D< :<;@07 ?3<: @0/ 41@/ <? 3/B/5=@ <?
B<=A<?7154<34/3
0<9>0@0/3/7=<;4/;@7/1365/3=177/41; <34/3 ;<@ 14:5@@5;> 05: ?<3 >31;@&5;&154 C9@ @0/ 3/7=<;4/;@7012/;<DB<:=65/4D5@0@0/453/B@5<;5779/4CA @0/ 6/13;/4 5;>6/ -94>/ 5; 79C7/K9/;@ D35@ =/@5@5<; 1;4 =177/4<34/3
0<9>0@0/6/13;/4/;5<3B<9;7/61==/135;> ?<3B<:=615;1;@D<964B<;@/;4@01@@0/71:/57;<@5;@/3:7 <? @0/ 3/=3/7/;@1@5<; 1;4 B615: :14/ CA @0/ B<:=615;1;@ 5/3/@3<7=/B@52/6AD5@0166C/;/?5@7166@0/7154B<;@/;@5<;7 B1;;<@ C/ B<;754/3/4 5; @0/ B<;@/:=@ =3<B//45;>7 ; @0/ D35@ =/@5@5<; @0/ 453/B@5<; 5779/4 D17 <;6A @< B<;754/3 @0/ 6/@@/3 <? 3/7=<;4/;@ <% 41@/4 !%$%$%$ 1;4 =177 1==3<=351@/ <34/37 <D @0/ <34/3 017 C//; =177/4 14:5@@5;>@0/B<:=615;1;@@<>31;@&5;&154?@0/B<:=615;1;@ 0171;A>35/21;B/5;3/7=/B@<?;<@B<;754/35;>C1B8D1>/7 1;4<@0/3C/;/?5@73/@3<7=/B@52/6A@0/71:/D<964>52/357/ @<1;/DB197/<?1B@5<;1;4@0/71:/B1;;<@C/B<;754/3/4 5;@0/B<;@/:=@=/@5@5<;
0/7B<=/<?B<;@/:=@=3<B//45;>7 57 2/3A B6/13 @057 <93@ 017 @< 7// 17 @< D0/@0/3 @0/ 453/B@5<; 5779/4 D17 B<:=65/4 <3 ;<@ ; 25/D <? 453/B@5<;
- 30 -
>52/; 5; <%$!'!$ %$%% 254/ <34/3 41@/4 !'$*%$%+ 017C//;B<;754/3/41;4<34/357=177/41;4453/B@5<;5779/4 5;/1365/3D35@=/@5@5<;017167<C//;B<:=65/41;45;25/D<? @0/ <34/3 =177/4 CA @0/ <2/3;:/;@ 17 =/3 ;;/F93/&! 16<;> D5@0 @0/ 1??54125@ 41@/4 $+$%$% @0/ K9/7@5<; <? ?31:5;><?B013>/74</7;<@1357/?@0/B<:=615;1;@017><@ 1;A <@0/3 >35/21;B/ 71:/ B1; C/ 1>5@1@/4 5; 7/=131@/ =3<B//45;>7 1;4 ;<@ 5; @0/ =3/7/;@ B<;@/:=@ =3<B//45;>7 0/3/ 13/ ;< :1@/35167 @< ?31:/ B013>/ 1>15;7@ @0/ 3/7=<;4/;@7 1BB97/4 75;B/ @0/ 453/B@5<; 017 C//; B<:=65/4 @0<9>0 D5@0 7<:/ 4/61A D05B0 017 C//; /F=615;/4 5; @0/ 1??54125@ D5@0 1=<6<>5/7 ?<3 4/61A BB<345;>6A =<5;@ ?<3 B<;754/31@5<;571;7D/3/45;;/>1@52/
%G 0/ =35;B5=6/7 6154 4<D; 5; @0/ M94>:/;@7 3/65/4 9=<; CA @0/ 6/13;/4 /;5<3 B<9;7/6 1==/135;> ?<3 @0/ B<:=615;1;@4</7;<@B<:/@<@0/154<?@0/B<:=615;1;@1;4 @0<7/ 012/ C//; 457B977/4 /F/3B575;> <@0/3M935745B@5<;1;4 ;<@ 5; B<;@/:=@ =3<B//45;>7 /FB/=@ @0/ M94>:/;@ <? 5>0 <93@<?-945B1@93/1@143175;5J7B17/ 79=311;4@0/71:/167<;<@B<:/7@<@0/154<?B<:=615;1;@
- 31 -
75;B/@0/453/B@5<;713/B<:=65/4779B0;<B17/017C//; :14/<9@@<=3<B//4?93@0/35;@0/:1@@/3
($ ;25/D<?@0/457B9775<;7:14/1C<2/D/=177 @0/?<66<D5;>
0/<;@/:=@=3<B//45;>75743<==/4
'( )!* $
'( )#* $
57@<