Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63994 (KAR)
SADDAM HUSSAIN @ SADDAM, v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.A/200352/2025 · 2025-12-19
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63994 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63994 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #
$$
%&'%(( &) $$
%&'%(( * $$
%&'%((
&
)
! " # $
"# # #
%
"# # #
# &
& '
Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
( ( ' &
!( ")
"&$
!&$"
! " $ **
&&
+,
&& ! " **
&&$
(
'
**
&&
"
"
(
"
""
*!&$ *!&$ !&$ -&-!&$ -!$ ' *" &&- -!$!$-!$!$-!&$!$" ! $
&
#
&
)
. -
&+-,,
+
&
# # .#
# '
-
# # ! $
! " # $
- 3 -
"# # #
"# # # # &
& '
( ( ' &
!( ")
"&$
"
"
! $
&&
+,-
&&! " **
&&$
(
'
+
**
&&
"
" (
"
""
*!&$ *!&$ !&$ -& -!&$ -!$
' * " &&- -!$!$ -!$$ -!&$ !$ " ! $
&
#
&
)
. #
(
&
- 4 -
, (
/
& . &&
*,&
! " # $
"# # #
"# # #
# &
& '
( ( ' &
!( ")
"&$
"
"
! $
&& +
&& ! " **
&& $
(
'
-
**
&&
"
" (
"
""
*!&$
- 5 -
*!&$!&$-&-!&$ -!$
' *
" &&- -!$!$ -!$!$ -!&$!$ " ! $
&
#
" (
&&&
" 0
" ( 1
"'
2 ( #
+#
34546374489948:5874;<:4=>?8@@A54=B5- 8C= + AC=47 4@6<BC !&$ B; @34=A:4= 85645 8C= @34=A:4=7<>45!74D4C6<BCB; 67B@<6<45$ @6**!;B7 53B760
! $ @61$544E<CF8C6<@<986B7?>8<:<C7<G4 B**
&& ;B7 634 B;;4C@45 9AC<538>:4 AC=47 4@6<BC5 *!&$*!&$!&$-&-!&$-!$748=H<63 4@6<BC*B;38786<?8?8?88C3<68&&-8C=AC=47 4@6<BC5-!$!7$-!$!5$8C=-!&$!D$B;
! $ @6
& 34;8@6587485AC=47
- 6 -
34 =4@4854= 853H8C63 H3B <5 634 5BC B;
7459BC=4C6 B& H85 >7BAF36 6B 634 9B:<@4 5686<BC BC &,*&&>?634G4G>475B;6349A>:<@BC6348::4F86<BC 6386 34 38= 8664G964= 6B @BGG<6 634;6 B; <7BC H<C=BH >875C63458G4=8?868>BA6,-9G634GB6347 B;634=4@4854=H85<C;B7G4=>?6349B:<@48C=H8585E4= 6B68E43475BC3BG48;647@BAC54:<CF'3<:4866349B:<@4 5686<BC 347 5BC 5A==4C:? @B::8954= =A4 6B 8C 49<:496<@ 54<IA74 4 H85 <GG4=<864:? 53<;64= 6B 8<@3A7 C56<6A64 B; 4=<@8: @<4C@45 8<@3A7 !$ H3474 34 H85 8=G<664= C;B76AC864:? BC &*&& 86 8>BA6 &- 9G 34 5A@@AG>4= C &*&& 7459BC=4C6 B&
@BG9:8<C8C6 G8=4 8 56864G4C6 5686<CF 6386 347 5BC H85 5A;;47<CF ;7BG 49<:495? 5<C@4 @3<:=3BB= 6386 34 38= @B::8954= =A4 54<IA74 8C= 6386 534 38= CB F7<4D8C@4 B7 8::4F86<BC 8F8<C56 8C?
9475BC <C 74594@6 B; 634 58G4 854= BC 63<5 56864G4C6 634 9B:<@4 74F<56474= B*
&&
- 7 -
- BH4D47 BC +&& 7459BC=4C6 B& :B=F4=854@BC=@BG9:8<C68::4F<CF6386BC&,*&&86 8>BA6&-9G634=4@4854=H858558A:64=>?8@@A54= 9475BC5<C@:A=<CF97454C68994::8C65C487634@BG9BAC=B; 8@@A54=B25745<=4C@48C=6386@8564>854=8>A548C= 6374865 H474 3478:= 34748;647 34 H85 68E4C 6B 634 9B:<@45686<BC854=BC63<5H7<664C@BG9:8<C6@7<G4H85 74F<56474=<C7<G4B**
&&
487C4= @BAC54: 899487<CF ;B7 634 8994::8C65 74<64786<CF 634 F7BAC=5 A7F4= <C 8:: 634 63744 89948:5 5A>G<65 6386 487:<47 D475<BC F<D4C >? 634 @BG9:8<C8C6 BC &*&& @:487:? 8>5B:D45 8:: 9475BC5 B; :8G4 8C= 8667<>A64534=4863<55B:4:?=A46B49<:495?45A>G<65 @BG9:8<C8C634754:;8=G<656386=4@4854=H85>7BAF366B 6349B:<@45686<BC;B78664G964=634;68C=CB69A75A8C66B 8C? 8558A:6 34 4=<@8: 4@B7=5 9:8@4= BC 74@B7= =<5@:B548:BCF568C=<CF3<56B7?B;49<:495?8:@B3B:<5G8C= 8:5B =7AF 8>A54 3474;B74 34 5A>G<65 6386 54@BC= @BG9:8<C6 <5 8C 8;64763BAF36 :B=F4= 8;647 74F<56786<BC B;
- 8 -
B*
&& 8C= <5 <C@BC5<564C6 H<63 G4=<@8: 8C= @BC64G9B78C4BA5 74@B7=5 3474;B74 34 @BC64C=5 6386 8::4F86<BC5 AC=47 634 97BD<5<BC5 B;
! $ @6 874 D8FA4BGC<>A58C=AC5A99B764=>?97<G8;8@<4G8647<8:5 3474;B74 5686A6B7? >87 AC=47 4@6<BC B; 634 ! $ @6HBA:=CB6899:? :487C4= @BAC54: 899487<CF ;B7 7459BC=4C6 B&
@BG9:8<C8C6 385 ;<:4= B>J4@6<BC 8C= 385 97B=A@4= =B@AG4C65 =4GBC56786<CF 6386 8:: 634 8@@A54= 9475BC5 38D4 FB6 8C64@4=4C65 '3<:4 @BAC647<CF 634 8994::8C651 @BC64C6<BC 6386 634 54@BC= @BG9:8<C6 H85 >4:864=:? :B=F4= 34 HBA:= 5A>G<6 ;7BG 3<5 8==<6<BC8: =B@AG4C65 6386 @BG9:8<C6 H85 <C;8@6 :B=F4= BC &&&3BH4D476349B:<@4B;;<@<8:538D44C64768<C4= 63458<=@BG9:8<C68C=@7<G4<574F<56474=BC+&& 4 HBA:= 63474;B74 @BC64C= 6386 7459BC=4C6 B& H3B >4:BCF56B=4974554=@:8558C=3475BC;B7CB7485BCH85 8>A54= 8C= 54D474:? 8558A:64= H3<@3 385 745A:64= <C6B =4863 8C= 63474;B74 <6 <5 CB6 8 ;<6 @854 6B F78C6
- 9 -
8C6<@<986B7?>8<:8563474<58@:487>87AC=474@6<BC5 8C= B;
! $ @6
+ 487C4= <F3 BA76 BD47CG4C6 :48=47 899487<CF ;B7 7459BC=4C6 B 385 547<BA5:? B99B54= F78C6B;8C6<@<986B7?>8<:
, 3<5BA76385@874;A::?947A54=634@BG9:8<C6 74@B7=5 G4=<@8: =B@AG4C65 8C= B6347 G8647<8:5 9:8@4= BC 74@B7= 6 <5 AC=<59A64= 6386 ;<756 56864G4C6 =864=&*&&F<D4C<GG4=<864:?8;647634=4863B;634 =4@4854= 74@B7=5 634 @BG9:8<C8C6 38= CB6 8667<>A64= 634 @8A54 B; =4863 =A4 6B 8558A:6 G8=4 >? 63454 8994::8C65
8@@A54= 9475BC5 34 56864G4C6 74;475 6B =4@4854=5A;;47<CF;7BG49<:495? 34G4=<@8:74@B7=5855AG4@7<6<@8:5<FC<;<@8C@4 8663<5568F4'3<:4634=4@4854=H85 56<::97454C6<C634 9B:<@4 5686<BC 34 5A;;474= @BCDA:5<BC5 8C= H<63 634 855<568C@4 B; 634 9B:<@4 B;;<@<8:5 H85 <GG4=<864:? 53<;64= 6B 634 3B59<68: 34 @BC64G9B78C4BA5 G4=<@8: 74@B7=5
- 10 -
=<5@:B54 8 3<56B7? B; 49<:495? 8:@B3B: =494C=4C@4 8C= =7AF8>A54!F8CJ8$3474@B7=5;A76347<C=<@86463865A@3 5A>568C@48>A54H85 <C 4K<564C@4 ;B7C487:?
;BA7 GBC635 97<B76B634<C@<=4C6 * C 634 >8@E=7B9 B; 634 8;B7458<= G4=<@8: 4D<=4C@463<5BA763858=D4764=6B63454@BC=@BG9:8<C6 =864= +&& H3474<C 8::4F86<BC5 B; AC:8H;A:
8554G>:? 8558A:6 8C= @8564>854= 8>A54 874 G8=4 6 63<5JAC@6A7463458<=@BG9:8<C689948756B>4G8647<8::? <C@BC5<564C6 H<63 634 487:<456 D475<BC 85 H4:: 85 634 G4=<@8:4D<=4C@4BC74@B7= CB6347 @7A@<8: =B@AG4C6 6386 G47<65 @BC5<=4786<BC <5 634 ;<C8: G4=<@8: B9<C<BC <55A4= >? 634 8<@3A7 C56<6A64 B; 4=<@8: @<4C@45 8<@3A7 9BC 4K8G<C86<BC B; 634 8A6B95? ;<C=<CF5
" 749B76 3<56B9863B:BF? 749B76 3B59<68: @854 53446 8C= 634 >7<4;
;8@65 B; 634 @854 634 G4=<@8: 8A63B7<6? 385 B9<C4= 6386 634 @8A54 B; =4863 <5 @BC5<564C6 H<63 686A5 9<:496<@A5
- 11 -
!54<IA745$ C :<F36 B; 63<5 G4=<@8: 4D<=4C@4 CBH 9:8@4= >4;B74 634 BA76 >? 634 :487C4= <F3 BA76 BD47CG4C6 :48=47 634 LA456<BC 6386 87<545 ;B7 @BC5<=4786<BC <5 H346347CB6H<63568C=<CF634<CDB@86<BCB;B;;4C@45AC=47 634
!74D4C6<BCB; 67B@<6<45$ @66345686A6B7?>87 @BC68<C4=AC=474@6<BC58C= B;63458<= @6HBA:= B947864<C63497454C6;8@6A8:G867<K 34 BC1>:4 A974G4 BA76 <C
749B764= <C ! " # $$ 385 34:= 6386 H3474 CB 97<G8 ;8@<4 @854 <5 G8=4 BA6 634>87AC=47 4@6<BC5 8C= B;
634
! $ @6HBA:=CB6899:?8C=634BA76<5CB6 =4CA=4=B;<659BH476BF78C68C6<@<986B7?>8<:
& C 634 97454C6 @854 634 G8647<8: BC 74@B7= 9876<@A:87:? 634 G4=<@8: 4D<=4C@4 <C=<@8645 6386 634 =4@4854=H85>7BAF366B6349B:<@45686<BC86634<C568C@4 B; G4G>475 B; 634 9A>:<@ H3B 38= 8::4F4= 6386 34 H85 ;BAC=@BGG<66<CF634;6B;<7BC>8756<58:5B74:4D8C66B
- 12 -
CB64 6386 634 56864G4C6 B; 634 GB6347 74@B7=4= BC &,*&& =<5@:B545 6386 634 =4@4854= 38= <C5<564= BC >4<CF 98<= 8 5AG B; 5
BC 634 GB7C<CF B; 634 <C@<=4C6 '34C 63454 @<7@AG568C@45 874 4K8G<C4= <C @BCJAC@6<BC H<63 634 G4=<@8: 74@B7=5 <C=<@86<CF 49<:495? 8C=5A>568C@48>A5463<5BA76<5B;634@BC5<=474=D<4H 6386 634 946<6<BC475 38D4 G8=4 BA6 8 @854 ;B7 F78C6 B;
=<5@746<BC87? 74:<4; AC=47 4@6<BC - B; 7 34 >4:864=8C=<G97BD4=8::4F86<BC5@BC68<C4=<C63454@BC= @BG9:8<C6HBA:=C4@45587<:?74LA<748=JA=<@86<BC868;A:: ;:4=F4=67<8:
- "B7 634 ;B74FB<CF 7485BC5 63<5 BA76 97B@44=5 6B9855634;B::BH<CF
::6346374489948:5874%% &
34B7=47=864=&&98554=>?634BA76B;
==<6<BC8: <567<@6 8C= 455<BC5 (A=F4 8<@3A7 <C
- 13 -
7:<5@B+,
&& 7:<5@B+,-
&& 8C= 7:<5@B+
&&87454685<=4 34 7459BC=4C6/B:<@4 874 =<74@64= 6B 74:4854 634 8994::8C65
8@@A54= B5 - 8C= + BC >8<: <C 634 4D4C6B;634<7877456<C@BCC4@6<BCH<637<G4B**
&& ;B7634B;;4C@459AC<538>:4AC=474@6<BC5*!&$*!&$ !&$-&-!&$-!$748=H<634@6<BC*B;
38786<?8 ?8?8 8C3<68 &&- 8C= AC=47 4@6<BC5 -!$!7$-!$!5$8C=-!&$!D$B;
! $ @65A>J4@66B 634;B::BH<CF@BC=<6<BC5 <$ 34 8994::8C65 538:: 899487 >4;B74 634 CD456<F86<CF ;;<@47 H<63<C ;<;644C !$ =8?5 ;7BG634=864B;74@4<96B;8@476<;<4=@B9?B;63<5 JA=FG4C68C=538::4K4@A6489475BC8:>BC=;B7 85AGB;5
!A9445C48E3BC:?$ 48@3 H<63 BC4 5A746?
;B7 634 :<E4 5AG 6B 634 586<5;8@6<BCB;634CD456<F86<CF;;<@47
- 14 -
<<$ 34 8994::8C65 538:: @BB947864 H<63 634 <CD456<F86<BC 8C= 538:: 899487 >4;B74 634 CD456<F86<CF;;<@47858C=H34C74LA<74= <<<$ 34 8994::8C65 538:: CB6 <C 8C? G8CC47 68G947 H<63 634 97B54@A6<BC H<6C45545 B7 4D<=4C@44<6347=<74@6:?B7<C=<74@6:? <D$348994::8C65538::CB6:48D4634JA7<5=<@6<BC B;6347<8:BA76H<63BA697<B7947G<55<BC
,& % ( #
<56B-:B 65<