- 1 - ! !" " # $%!! $ ! " #$!$$ % ! # % $ $ && ! ! & ! '!!$ (()& ! " #$ !' * ! $ # % # !+! & ! !!& !& $ % ,,, !!! $ ! & $ #% () () ()#%#-% &) &. ) ( / & Digitally signed by NARAYANA UMA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ ' , ! 0$ !' ! # 0$ !' !% ! 123435!$!-623$27829123-14:+;-719<+3=81 >1=5=5+-13 2-4 ?=! 535@2 531?2=8 9123-14 5A8 +;3= +B13-?1-=912413<+3=81317>+-41-=+! ,=2=1! ! 81 >1=5=5+-132::;714 +! 57 C1<+31 =857 +;3= 711D5-A A32-= +< 2-=5:5>2=+3E C259 5- 35?1 +! & +< 317>+-41-=,+95:1 =2=5+- <+3 =81 +<<1-:17 >;-5782C91 ;-413 1:=5+-7 , () (), ()#%#-% &) &. +< =81 -452-1-29+41#<+378+3=FG%2-41:=5+-7)2-4 ( +< =81 3+=1:=5+- +< 859431- <3+? 1H;29 <<1-:17 := & #<+378+3=F :=G%! &'()*+,+-(*),( ! = 57 =81 :271 +< =81 >3+71:;=5+- =82= =81 :+?>925-2-= 2-4 2::;714 +7! 2-4 6131 D-+6- =+ 12:8 +=813!812::;714+! ;714=+B575=813>231-=7G8+;71+<=1- - 3 - 27 7;:8 299 =81 <2?59E ?1?C137 +< =81 B5:=5? 6131 D-+6- =+ =81 <2?59E ?1?C137 +< =81 2::;714! = 57 7=2=14 5- =81 :+?>925-==82=+- .!&!&& 23+;-4 &!&&2!?!=812::;714 +7! 2-461-==+=81:+991A1+<=81B5:=5?2-4=++D813=+ =81-12317=9+4A12-47=2=14=+82B1:+??5==1471H;292772;9=! - !&.!& 23+;-4 &!&& >!?! =81 >1=5=5+-13 81315- 2-4 2::;714 +! 7=2=14 =+ 82B1 =2D1- 813 =+ =81 8+;71 +< 813 A32-4?+=813 68131 =81 2::;714 +! 627 7=2E5-A 5- 2 3++? 2-4 2::;714 +! 7=2=14 =+ 82B1 2==1?>=14 =+ +;=32A1 813 ?+417=E! :+?>925-= :2?1 =+ C1 31A57=1314 +- !& !& 2A25-7= 71B1- 2::;714! 81 @;35745:=5+-29 >+95:1 82B1 31A57=1314 2 :271 2A25-7= 299 +< =81?! <=13 :+-4;:=5-A 5-B17=5A2=5+-7;C?5==14=81:823A17811=! ! =57=817;C?5775+-+<=819123-14:+;-719<+3=81 >1=5=5+-13=82==81>1=5=5+-13575--+:1-=+<=812991A14+<<1-:17 2-4 81 827 C11- <29719E 5?>95:2=14 5- =81 :271! 8+;A8 =81 2991A14 5-:541-= 57 7=2=14 =+ 82B1 =2D1- >92:1 +- !&.!& 23+;-4 &!&& >!?! 2 :+?>925-= :2?1 =+ C1 31A57=1314 +- !& !& =82= 5=719< 6+;94 5-45:2=1 =82= 5= 57 2 <2971 :271 685:8827C11-31A57=13142A25-7=299=81?1?C137+-+-1+3 - 4 - =81 +=813 >31=1H= =+ 823277 =81?! 2D5-A 7;:8 7;C?5775+-7 9123-14:+;-719<+3=81>1=5=5+-13>32E7=+299+6=81>1=5=5+-! ! 9123-145A8+;3=+B13-?1-=912413 #<+3 78+3= FG% B181?1-=9E +>>+714 =81 7254 7;C?5775+-7 2-4781<;3=8137;C?5==14=82==815-:541-==8+;A8824=2D1- >92:1 9+-A 2A+ =81 <2:= 31?25-7 =82= =8131 627 2 :+-7=2-= =8312= CE 2::;714 +7! 2-4 =+ =81 <2?59E ?1?C137 +< =81 B5:=5?! 8131<+31 781 454 -+= <591 2-E :+?>925-=7 2= =81 1239517=!5-:1=812991A14+<<1-:157815-+;75--2=;31711D5-A 2-=5:5>2=+3E C259 :2--+= C1 >13?5==14 2-4 5= 78+;94 -+= C1 299+614! 2D5-A 7;:8 7;C?5775+-7 9123-14 >32E7 =+ 457?577=81>1=5=5+-! )! 2B5-A 81234 9123-14 :+;-719 <+3 =81 317>1:=5B1 >23=5172-4297+>13;714=812B13?1-=7+<=81:823A17811=27 =819123-14:+;-719<+3=81>1=5=5+-138277;C?5==14=82==8131 5724192E5-9+4A5-A=81:+?>925-=827=+C12::1>=14+-A+5-A =83+;A8 =81 :+-=1-=7 +< =81 :823A17811=! 2B5-A :+-7541314 =814192E5-9+4A5-A=81:+?>925-=2-4=8172?1827-+=C11- 1H>925-14>3+>139EA32-=5-A2-=5:5>2=+3EC259+-7;:8:+?>925-= 6+;94C1@;7=5<514!77;:82?+<=81:+-7541314+>5-5+-=82= - 5 - =81 >1=5=5+-13 827 ?241 +;= 2 :271 <+3 A32-=5-A 2-=5:5>2=+3E C259! (! ::+345-A9E>3+:114=+>277=81<+99+65-A 8135?5-291=5=5+-57 81 >1=5=5+-13 57 +341314 =+ C1 1-923A14 +- C259 5- =81 1B1-=+<85723317=5-35?1+! &+<317>+-41-=+95:1 =2=5+-! 81 >1=5=5+-13 57 4531:=14 =+ 2>>123 C1<+31 =81 -B17=5A2=5-A <<5:1365=85-+-1?+-=8<3+?=8142=1+<31:15>= +<:+>E+<=857+34132-4+-8572>>1232-:1=81-B17=5A2=5-A <<5:13 78299 1-923A1 85? +- C259 7;C@1:= =+ =81 <+99+65-A :+-45=5+-7, #5% 81 >1=5=5+-13 78299 <;3-578 2 >137+-29 C+-4 <+327;?+<7!&&&&&,#;>1176+92D87 +-9E%65=8=6+7;31=517<+3=8195D17;?=+=81 72=57<2:=5+-+<=81-B17=5A2=5-A <<5:13! #55% 81 >1=5=5+-13 78299 :++>132=1 65=8 =81 5-B17=5A2=5+-! - 6 - #555% 81 >1=5=5+-13 78299 -+= =8312=1- =81 >3+71:;=5+- 65=-17717 2-4 297+ -+= 82?>13 =81>3+:1145-A7+<=81:+;3=! #5B% 81 >1=5=5+-13 78299 -+= :+??5= 75?5923 +<<1-:17! #B% 81 >1=5=5+-13 78299 2>>123 C1<+31 =81 -B17=5A2=5-A <<5:13+3=81+;3=272-4681- 31I;5314! -:2715<=81>1=5=5+-13B5+92=172-E+<=81C259:+-45=5+-7 277=2=142C+B1=81>3+71:;=5+-6599C12=95C13=E=+711D<+3 :2-:1992=5+-+<C259! !./ 0! 1 % $77 57=+! .9+!