- 1 - !!!" # $%$$ !&& '&( ) !"#$# % $$ & !"#$' # $# !% !""" " () " * Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ "" !'% !"#" "% ' !"#+ , ( ) ! %$!-!++' %%!!% . '$ " - % $- /!% - 3 - # $$ & & & 0 %'!'!%# " "- $ %$ %' *() ' #$ 0 & /'$ "' - ## 0 !+!%# !% !"%- , ( & "1 & '-1 & "23- % && #$ ) - 4 - & & %#+% '%+ %#%+ -#++ ( ) & & & & & && & 0 & & & 4 %!$ ( 4 ) 567899:8;67<=25:9;86>26??<:6>@8@@A6:B:C<=25: DEC@F:>2 8>C C:GA:: C82:C %#%+ 9877:C 6> 3-#3?++3>25:?6;:3?25:CC6263>8; 6B6;EC@: ( A>)6C8AH5:A:6>8?2:AA:?:AA:C238725:IA68; 3EA2J ?3A<A:B62=KL56G567G3>?6AF:C<=25:DEC@F:>28>C3AC:A C82:C%#+%9877:C6>37'3?%+8>C'3? % 3> 25: ?6;: 3? 25: CC6263>8; 672A6G2 8>C :7763>7 EC@:6C8AH5:A:6>8?2:AA:?:AA:C238725:I&6A7299:;;82: 3EA2J?3A<A:B62=K - 5 - % 5:8<3B:7E626> 3-#3?++67?6;:C<= 25:9;86>26??899:;;8>25:A:6>7::M6>@?3;;3L6>@A:;6:?7 N ! " ! # $%&& ! & $ ! ! '$()*)()) )$+$*)( & ,-., .* +$$*., / / ! ! $ / ! ! / 0 ! 1 & 0 $2 G3>2:>C6>@ 25829;86>26??8>CC:?:>C8>23%8A: 25:73>73?C:?:>C8>23:?:>C8>237#23$8A:25: 73>73?C:?:>C8>23%:?:>C8>235878>325:A73> <=>8F:8>F8>2583L53587<::>@6B:>6>8C39263> 23 8>325:A ?8F6;= 87 7EG5 5: 67 >32 F8C: 98A2= 6> 25: 7E62;86>26??8>CC:?:>C8>2378>C%8A:25:F:F<:A7 3?86>CED36>2?8F6;=8>C258225:A:587<::>>398A26263> - 6 - 3?25:7E627G5:CE;:9A39:A26:7582C:?:>C8>237#23$ 8A:F8C:8798A2=2325:7E628773F:3?25:7E6262:F73? 25:9A39:A26:7728>C6>25:6A>8F:7:?:>C8>23<:6>@ 25::;C:72F:F<:A6725:8A283?25:?8F6;=;33M6>@8?2:A 25: D36>2 ?8F6;= 9A39:A26:7 5: 7E62 G5:CE;:! 8>C 9A39:A26:758B:<::>8GOE6A:C?A3F25:D36>2?8F6;=?E>C7 8>C6>G3F:C:A6B:C?A3F25:D36>2?8F6;=9A39:A26:73?25: 8>G:72A8;9A39:A2=<= 25:C:?:>C8>23 87M8A28 3? 25: ?8F6;=6>25:>8F:3?C:?:>C8>23# 582;86>26??9EAG587:C;8>C782B6;;8@:6998;8@83> EA8C!28;EM6C8AC672A6G2?A3F5679:A73>8;73EAG:8>C 6>G3F: L56G5 8A: 25: 7:;?!8GOE6A:C 9A39:A26:7 3? 25: 9;86>26??;86>26??587<::>A:76C6>@7:98A82:;=6>893A263> 3?9A39:A2=<:8A6>@3"+3?6998;@83>B6;;8@:8>C8;73 F8>8@6>@ 8>C GE;26B826>@ 567 ;8>C7 9:A73>8;;= ?A3F 25: C82: 3? 627 9EAG587: :?:>C8>2 3% L87 8 3B:A>F:>2 7:AB8>2 L3AM6>@ 6> B8A63E7 93727 6> 3!39:A826B: :98A2F:>2 6> 25: 858A8752A8 282: 67 :;C:72 73> C:?:>C8>23#A:76C:78;3>@L625C:?:>C8>235:;96>@ - 7 - 56F F8>8@:25: D36>2 ?8F6;= 9A39:A26:7 :?:>C8>2 37% 23$58B6>@L3>3B:A25:G3>?6C:>G:3?C:?:>C8>2387 25: 9;86>26?? L87 A:76C6>@ 7:98A82:;= L625 8> 6>2:>263> 23 :PG;EC: 25: 9;86>26?? ?A3F 25: 7E62 7G5:CE;: 9A39:A26:7 58B: GA:82:C LA3>@ C::C7 8>C A:G3AC7 :?:>C8>2 3% 58C8;73GA:82:C8C::C3?@6?26>A:79:G23? =3%"3? 6998;@83>B6;;8@:6>25:>8F:3?C:?:>C8>23#5:@6?2 C::C C82:C "+$ :P:GE2:C <= C:?:>C8>2 3 6> ?8B3EA 3? C:?:>C8>2 3# 753L6>@ 8>F8>25A83 87 25: @E8AC68>3?F6>3A676>B8;6C5:7E<D:G2F822:A3?25:786C @6?2A:F86>:CD36>2?8F6;=9A39:A2=26;;C82:8725:C::C3? @6?2587>32<::>8G2:CE93> 582 25: 7E62 6> 3++ 58C <::> ?6;:C <= C:?:>C8>2 3 6> L56G5 5: 587 753L> 8;; 25: 9A39:A26:7 87D36>2?8F6;=9A39:A26:7L56G5?8G2587>32<::>C679E2:C :B:><= C:?:>C8>2 37%23$ L53 58B: 899:8A:C 6> 25: 786C7E62:?:>C8>23%587F8>8@:C23:>2:A567>8F: 6>25:A:B:>E:A:G3AC78>C28M6>@E>CE:8CB8>28@:3?25: :>2A6:7 25:A:6> 587 3<286>:C A:@672:A:C 98A26263> C::C 6> - 8 - ?8B3EA 3? 567 325:A 2L3 73>7 6: C:?:>C8>2 37" 8>C $ 5: 98A26263> C::C 67 C82:C "+'- 5: 786C C3GEF:>267GA:82:C8>C>32<6>C6>@3>25:9;86>26??5: ;8>C6> =3"3?E75>33A6;;8@:679EAG587:C?A3F25: D36>2?8F6;=6>G3F:L56G5678;738CF622:C6>25:786C7E62 6> 3++5:786C7E626> 3++L87 L625CA8L> 7 7EG5 25: 9;86>26?? C:F8>C:C ?3A 98A26263> 8>C7:98A82:9377:7763>3?567758A:6>25:7E629A39:A26:7 :>68; 3? L56G5 @8B: A67: 23 G8E7: 3? 8G263> 6> 25: 7E62 :>G:25:9A:7:>27E627::M6>@25:A:;6:?87>32:C8<3B: # 5:LA622:>7282:F:>267?6;:C<=25:C:?:>C8>2 3% L56G5 67 8C392:C <= C:?:>C8>2 37# 23 $ 5: 8;;:@8263>7 F8C: 6> 25: 9;86>2 587 <::> C:>6:C 2 67 G3>2:>C:C 2582 25:A: L87 8 9A63A 98A26263> 8F3>@72 25: 9;86>26?? 8>C C:?:>C8>2 37 8>C % 9EA7E8>2 23 L56G5 25:= 58B: <::> A:76C6>@ 7:98A82:;= 8>C :>D3=6>@ 25:6A A:79:G26B: 93A263>7 3? 25: ;8>C 8;;322:C 6> 786C 98A26263> 582 25: 9;86>26?? 587 C:;6<:A82:;= >32 F:>263>:C G:A286> ;8>C:C9A39:A26:7762E82:C6>25:6998;@83>B6;;8@:L56G5 58B: <::> 9EAG587:C <= C:?:>C8>2 3 6> 25: >8F: 3? - 9 - 25:9;86>26??6>25:=:8A+$"L5:>5:L87DE72%=:8A7 3? 8@: 6>G: 25: 98A26263> 587 8;A:8C= 28M:> 9;8G: 9;86>26?? G8>>32 7::M 23 A:39:> 25: 78F: 3> 25: <8767 3? ?8;7: 8;;:@8263>7 5: 8;;:@8263> 3? C:?:>C8>2 3 8GOE6A6>@ 25: 9A39:A2= 6> 25: >8F: 3? C:?:>C8>2 3# 67 ?8;7:8>C6>G3AA:G25:;8>C =3"3?E75>33AB6;;8@: F:87EA6>@ %$ 8GA:7 % @E>287 587 <::> 9EAG587:C <= C:?:>C8>2 3# ?A3F 567 3L> 73EAG: 3? 6>G3F: L56G5 67 5677:;?!8GOE6A:C9A39:A2=5:;8>C76> =3%F:87EA6>@ + 8GA:7 # @E>287 =3%$ F:87EA6>@ # 8GA:7 8>C =3'F:87EA6>@'8GA:7#-@E>2878A:8;;762E82:C82 6998;@83> B6;;8@: 8A: >32 7:;?!8GOE6A:C 9A39:A26:7 3? 25: 9;86>26?? " :A:;=<:G8E7:25:C::C3?78;:L87:P:GE2:C 6> 567 >8F: 5: L3E;C >32 <:G3F: 25: 3L>:A 3? 25: 9A39:A2= 87 5: L87 F6>3A 5: 8;;:@8263> 3? 9;86>26?? A:76C6>@7:98A82:;=8>CGE;26B826>@25:;8>C76>6998;@83> B6;;8@: 87 7EG5 67 C:>6:C :>G: 73E@52 ?3A C67F6778; 3? 25:7E62 - 10 - $ 3>76C:A6>@ 25: 9;:8C6>@7 3? 25: 98A26:7 ?3;;3L6>@677E:7L:A:?A8F:C<=25:A68; 3EA2 N 5:25:A 9;86>26?? 9A3B:7 2582 25: 7E62 9A39:A26:7 8A: 6>CE36>2?8F6;=9A39:A26:7;68<;:?3A98A26263>Q % 5:25:A C:?:>C8>2 3% 9A3B:7 2582 7E62 9A39:A26:7 8A: D36>2 ?8F6;= G398AG:>:A 9A39:A26:7 58B: <::> 98A26263>;3>@<8GM878;;:@:C6>25:6ALA622:>7282:F:>2Q # 5:25:A 9;86>26?? 9A3B:7 2582 5: 67 :>262;:C ?3A 98A26263>8>C567R758A:3B:A25:7E627G5:CE;:!8>C 9A39:A26:7<=F:2:78>C<3E>C7Q " 5:25:A 9;86>26?? ?EA25:A 9A3B:7 2582 25: A:@672:A:C @6?2 C::C 3$+$! C82:C !"!+$ 8>C 98A26263> C::C 3-'-!'+ C82:C "!!+'- 8A: >E;; 8>C B36C 8>C6>:??:G26B:8@86>72567A6@527Q $ 5:25:A9;86>26??67:>262;:C?3AG3AA:G263>3?:>2A6:76> 25: 7Q 5823AC:A3AC:GA::QS 3>76C:A6>@25:8B:AF:>27F8C:6>25:LA622:> 7282:F:>2 A:@8AC6>@ 25: 9A39:A2= <:8A6>@ 37% %$ 8>C '3?25:9A39:A26:7<=3AC:AC82:C-#%+25:A68; 3EA2C6A:G2:C236>G;EC:25:786C9A39:A26:76>25:7E62 ' > 3AC:A 23 9A3B: 25: G87: 9;86>26?? :P8F6>:C 56F7:;?87 8>C@32:P56<62:C""C3GEF:>2787P7 23 "" L3 L62>:77:7 58B: <::> :P8F6>:C 3> <:58;? 3? - 11 - C:?:>C8>27 87 8>C % 8>C @32 :P56<62:C "$ C3GEF:>27F8AM:C87P723"$ >899A:G68263>3? 25::B6C:>G:25:A68; 3EA28>7L:A:C677E:37#"6> 25: 8??6AF826B: 8>C 677E: 37% 8>C $ 98A2;= 6> 25: 8??6AF826B:8>CG3>7:OE:>2;=C:GA::C25:7E6287E>C:A1 345#65 37 & 08 7 1 $$ & ! * ) ! 9 $$( & !( !:9 $$-.& !. ,! ;! '$+* /! ;! < & = / 0 0 0 ;! / 0 = $ 7 = = ! 0 0 & 00 ;!$ >9 $(+ %?% / ! && $ > & / !$ #0 & ! 2 - 12 - - :6>@8@@A6:B:C<=25:DEC@F:>28>CC:GA::3? 25: A68; 3EA2 23 25: :P2:>2 3? ;8>C 6> =373% %$ 8>C ' 8>C 25: 53E7: 9A39:A2= 3"+ 762E82:C 82 6998;@83> B6;;8@: 9;86>26?? 9A:?:AA:C 899:8; 6> 3'%+ 6F6;8A;=<:6>@8@@A6:B:C<=25:C:GA:: 6> A:79:G2 3? 325:A 62:F7 3? 25: 7E62 9A39:A2= ;:@8; A:9A:7:>2826B:7 3? C:?:>C8>2 37% " 8>C $ 9A:?:AA:C 3'% + 3>76C:A6>@ 25: @A3E>C7 EA@:C 25: &6A72 99:;;82: 3EA2 ?A8F:C 25: ?3;;3L6>@ 936>27 ?3A 627 G3>76C:A8263>1 N) 5:25:A 25: 7E62 9A39:A26:7 6>G;EC6>@ 25: >3> 7E62 7G5:CE;: 9A39:A2= 8A: 25: D36>2 ?8F6;= 9A39:A26:7 3? 25: 9;86>26??8>CC:?:>C8>27Q %) 5:25:A25:C:?:>C8>27H9A3B:258225:A:678;A:8C=8 9A63A98A26263>6>25:7E62878;;:@:C6>25:6AC:?:>G:Q #) 5:25:A25:@6?2C::C8>C98A26263>C::C8A:>E;;8>C B36C8>C6>:??:G26B:3>25:A6@5273?25:9;86>26??7 ") 5:25:A25:DEC@F:>28>CC:GA::9877:C<=25:A68; 3EA2 67 :AA3>:3E7 8>C G89A6G63E7 8>C 2582 25: 78F: 67 >32 6> 8GG3AC8>G: L625 ;8L 8>C 25:A:<= ;68<;: 23 <: 6>2:A?:A:CL625Q $) 5823AC:A3AC:GA::QS - 13 - >A:!899A:G68263>3?:B6C:>G:8>7L:A:C936>2 37 8>C # 6> 25: 8??6AF826B: 936>2 37% 8>C " 6> 25: >:@826B:8>CG3>7:OE:>2;=9877:C25:?3;;3L6>@3AC:A1 ! 5$$ '$. --* 5$$'$. -- @5 & $ % 1 < !& 49 '$ , **) ---* 9 %/A ! & $ > & 0$ /9 0 !0 &&< !& 0$ B !< !& 5$$'$. --* 5$$'$. --$2 :6>@ 8@@A6:B:C <= 25: C67F6778; 3? 3'%+25:9;86>26??67<:?3A:2567 3EA2 % 567 3EA2<=3AC:AC82:C%%%8CF622:C 25:899:8;23G3>76C:A25:?3;;3L6>@7E<728>268;OE:7263>3? ;8L 3C % 0 < ! 9 $'$ ( -. ;! D! < & !! & '$5& 5 ? !4$9$'$-**6"$?$,$E2 - 14 - # A6 8G56> 858D8> ;:8A>:C G3E>7:; 899:8A6>@ ?3A 25: 899:;;8>2 9;86>26?? 28M6>@ 2567 3EA2 25A3E@5 25: A:G3AC7 7E<F627 2582 25: 3>;= @A6:B8>G: 3? 25: 9;86>26?? 899:;;8>2 5:A:6> 67 23 25: :P2:>2 3? 25: C:GA:: 9877:C <= 25: A68; 3EA2 G3>?6AF:C <= 25: &6A72 99:;;82: 3EA2 @A8>26>@ 98A26263> 6> A:79:G2 3? ;8>C7 <:8A6>@ =37% %$ 8>C ' 3? 6998;@83> B6;;8@: : 7E<F627 2582 8CF622:C;= 25: 78;: C::C 6> A:79:G2 3? 25: 786C ;8>C7 728>C 6> 25: >8F: 3? 25: 9;86>26?? L56G5 67 9EAG587:C6>567 >8F:?A3F 25: ?E>C7 8>C25: A:73EAG:7 8CB8>G:C <= 567 F82:A>8; E>G;: 5: 786C 9A39:A2= 587 >:B:A<::>25:98A23?A:F86>:CD36>2?8F6;=9A39:A2=: A:?:A72398A8@A8953%3?25:9;86>26> 3++ 8 7E62 L56G5 587 <::> ?6;:C <= ?825:A 3? 9;86>26?? 8>C C:?:>C8>2 3% 8>C @A8>C?825:A 3? C:?:>C8>27 3# 23 $ 9A3CEG:C82P#-8>C7E<F6272582:B:>C:?:>C8>23 58C 8CF622:C E>:OE6B3G8;;= 2582 25: 786C ;8>C7 8A: 25: 7:;?!8GOE6A:C9A39:A2=3?25:9;86>26??5826>25:;6@523? 25:8?3A:786CG6AGEF728>G:725:A68; 3EA28>C25:&6A72 - 15 - 99:;;82: 3EA23E@52>322358B:5:;C258225:786C;8>C7 23<:25:D36>2?8F6;=9A39:A2=8F:>8<;:?3A25:98A26263> 8773E@52?3A<=25:C:?:>C8>27:7E<F6276>8>=:B:>2 25:9;86>26?? 587 8;6:>82:C 62:F37% %$8>C '23 25: 256AC 98A26:7 25: C:?:>C8>27 <:6>@ 8L8A: 3? 25: 78F: 58B:>:625:AG58;;:>@:C25:786C78;:>3A58B:F8C:25: 9EAG587:A78798A26:72325:7E623:??:G26B:C:GA::G3E;C <:9877:C<=25:A68; 3EA28>C25:&6A7299:;;82: 3EA2 : ?EA25:A 7E<F627 2582 >3 677E: 587 <::> ?A8F:C :625:A <= 25: A68; 3EA2 3A <= 25: &6A72 99:;;82: 3EA2 6> 2567 A:@8AC:76C:725:786C;8>C758B:>32<::>6>G;EC:C6> 25: 7G5:CE;:C 23 25: 9;86>2 567 L3E;C @3 23 25: A332 3? 25:F822:A67:>262;6>@25:C:?:>C8>237%23$2358B: 8>=758A:6>25:9A39:A2=L56G5879:G2587<::>;37276@52 <=25:A68; 3EA28>C25:&6A7299:;;82: 3EA2:>G:5: 7::M7 ?3A 8>7L:A6>@ 25: 7E<728>268; OE:7263> 3? ;8L 6> ?8B3EA 3? 25: 9;86>26?? <= 8;;3L6>@ 25: 899:8; 23 25: 786C :P2:>2 - 16 - " :A G3>2A8 A6 D8= EF8A ;:8A>:C G3E>7:; 8;3>@ L625 A6 8B6 826; ?3A 25: A:793>C:>27 C:?:>C8>27 7E<F62 6> E>673> 2582 8CF622:C;= 9;86>26?? L87 DE72 8<3E2 % =:8A7 3? 8@: L5:> 25: ;8>C7 <:8A6>@ 6> =37% %$ 8>C ' 3? 6998;@83> B6;;8@: L:A: 9EAG587:C6>567>8F:5:?8G23?5:<:6>@6>G898<;:3? 58B6>@5673L>73EAG:3?6>G3F:8225:2:>C:A8@:677:;?! :P9;8>823A= L8AA8>26>@ >3 G3AA3<3A8263> 2 67 ?EA25:A 7E<F622:C 2582 253E@5 25: 9;86>26?? G3>2:>C:C 2582 25: F82:A>8;E>G;:58C8CB8>G:C25:?E>C78>CA:73EAG:7?3A 25:9EA937:3?9EAG5876>@3?25:786C;8>C>3:B6C:>G:6> 2567A:@8AC587<::><A3E@523>A:G3AC5:=7E<F622582 76>G: 25: A68; 3EA2 587 >:@82:C 25: G;86F 3? 25: C:?:>C8>27 3? 9A63A 98A26263> 25: ;8>C <:8A6>@ =37% %$ 8>C' 3?6998;@83> B6;;8@: L56G5 372:>76<;=7233C 6>25:>8F:3?9;86>26??587<::>A6@52?E;;=6>G;EC:C6>25: ?8F6;=532932G58>C25:78F:587<::>C6B6C:C:OE8;;=23 8;;25:;:@8;5:6A73?C:?:>C8>232677E<F622:C2582 253E@5 2:G5>6G8;;= >3 7:98A82: 677E:7 L:A: ?A8F:C 25: - 17 - 98A26:7 L:A: 8L8A: 3? 25: 9;:8C6>@7 8>C 25:= 58B: @3>: 6>23 25: 2A68; L625 25: 786C E>C:A728>C6>@ :76C:7 L56;: 8>7L:A6>@ 677E: 3# 25: A68; 3EA2 587 8CC6263>8;;= 8CB:A2:C232567879:G23?25:F822:A25:A:?3A:25:78F: G8>>32 <: ?3E>C 23 <: C:?:G2 6> 25: 899A:G68263> 3? 25: :B6C:>G:<=25:A68; 3EA28>C25:&6A7299:;;82: 3EA2 :>G:7::M7?3A8>7L:A6>@25:7E<728>268;OE:7263>3?;8L 6>25:8??6AF826B:8>C9A8=723C67F67725:899:8; $ :8AC9:AE7:C25:A:G3AC7 5: A:;8263>7569 <:2L::> 25: 98A26:7 67 >32 6> C679E2: 53E@5 25: C:?:>C8>27 58C G3>2:>C:C 2582 25: 3A6@6>8; 7E62 9A39:A26:7 L:A: 7E<D:G2 F822:A 23 9A63A 98A26263>25:=58B:?86;:C237E<728>2682:25:786C?8G2EF A:7E;26>@ 6> 98A26263> 8>C 8;;32F:>2 3? 25: 758A:7 <= 25: A68; 3EA25:A:@E;8A899:8;?6;:C<=25:C:?:>C8>276> 3'%% 58B6>@ <::> C67F677:C 25: 78F: 587 82286>:C?6>8;62= - 18 - ' >;=325:A 879:G23? 25: F822:A 67L625 A:@8AC 23 ;8>C7 6> =37% %$ 8>C ' 3? 6998;@83> B6;;8@: 5:G87:3?25:9;86>26??879;:8C:C6>5679;86>26725825: 58B6>@ <::> 7:98A82:C ?A3F 25: ?8F6;= L87 A:76C6>@ 7:98A82:;= 6> 567 53E7: <:8A6>@ 3"+ 82 6998;@83> B6;;8@:8>CL87GE;26B826>@;8>C76> =37%%$8>C' 6>C:9:>C:>2;= L6253E2 8>= 86C 3A 8776728>G: ?A3F 25: ?8F6;= 5: 786C G3>2:>263> 3? 25: 9;86>26?? 587 8;73 <::> >:@82:C <= 25: A68; 3EA2 87 25: 9;86>26?? 587 ?86;:C 23 9A3B:25:73EAG:3??E>C7?3A8GOE676263>3?25:786C;8>C7 6> 567 >8F: 53E@5 25: 9;86>26?? 58C 9;:8C:C 2582 25: ?E>C7 ?3A 9EAG587: 3? 786C ;8>C7 L:A: F8C: 8B86;8<;: <= 567 F82:A>8; @A8>C?825:A 9;86>26?? 587 >:625:A :P8F6>:C 8>= 6>C:9:>C:>2 L62>:77 >3A 587 <A3E@52 3> A:G3AC 8>= 9;8E76<;: :B6C:>G: 6> DE726?6G8263> 3? 567 G;86F 3? 25: 8?3A:786C 25A:: 62:F7 3? ;8>C7 <:6>@ 567 7:;?!8GOE6A:C 9A39:A2= - 19 - - &EA25:A 25: 9;:8C6>@ G3>286>:C 6> 3++<=C:?:>C8>23G3>2:>C6>@2582;8>C7 =37% %$ 8>C ' 3? 25: 6998;@83> <:6>@ 7:;?! 8GOE6A:C 9A39:A2= F8= 58B: 23 <: G3>72AE:C L625 A:?:A:>G: 23 25: 325:A D36>2 ?8F6;= 9A39:A26:7 8CF622:C;= 9377:77:C<=C:?:>C8>235:786C8B:AF:>2L6;;58B: 23<:G3>72AE:C6>8F8>>:A25825:L3E;C58B:9EAG587:C 25: ;8>C7 ?A3F 8>C 3E2 3? 25: D36>2 ?8F6;= ?E>C7 8>C 73EAG:787>36>C:9:>C:>273EAG:3?6>G3F:679;:8C:C<= 56F:625:A>8>=:B:>225:786C7E626> 3++ 67 7282:C 23 58B: <::> L625CA8L> <:?3A: 25: 78F: G3E;C A:8G5 25: ;3@6G8; G3>G;E763> > 2582 B6:L 3? 25: F822:A :B:>25:786C;8>C76> =37%%$8>C3'58B:23<: 28M:> 87 25: D36>2 ?8F6;= 9A39:A26:7 87 A6@52;= 5:;C 73 <= 25:A68; 3EA28>C25:&6A7299:;;82: 3EA2 + :>G: 25: 7E<728>268; OE:7263> 3? ;8L A867:C 8<3B: 67 8>7L:A:C 8GG3AC6>@;= 5: A68; 3EA2 8>C 25: &6A72 99:;;82: 3EA2 8A: DE726?6:C 6> G3>76C:A6>@ ;8>C7 6> =37% %$ 8>C ' 87 8 D36>2 ?8F6;= 9A39:A26:7 8>C - 20 - 8L8AC6>@ 758A: 6> 8;; 25: 7E62 9A39:A26:7 6>G;EC6>@ 25: 8?3A:786C25A::62:F79A39:A2=238;;25:?8F6;=F:F<:A7 3:AA3A3A6;;:@8;62=G8><:?3E>C99:8;;8GM7F:A62 GG3AC6>@;=25:899:8;67C67F677:C *+ '$$( %! 6723 ;3#