Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63871 (KAR)
DYANIYAL v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.RP/200050/2023 · 2025-07-11
V Srishananda
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63871 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63871 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#!$
#$
%
&'%()*+
%)) ,
! "
#
$
" %#
! "#
$
&' (% $
(
) $
)
)$
%& % &%%% $ )
)
%%* % %'% %
R Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$
(
+)
" +)
#
,-./.0-/122.-34-5-.-4-5-67-.4-1,-.5,/62859,1 :2.37,.,;09025<,303025,.-5/=3503-,//41,-.5,/0>7 28.32;,.5=,531,-/,.:2.37,3-3,
,;09025,303025,.0937,-6689,/?7298::,.,/-52./,. 2:625;063025052%& % &/-3,/%%%2537,:01, 37, 2: 37, //1 0;01 )8/>, -5/ )$ 8=5-@-/ -5/ 9,53,56,/-985/,. !"#$%& '( )*& &
+,- . , '"$$$-/
- ! + . . . . - 3 -
&
+,- , '$"$$$-/
- #$%&
+ . . . . &
, $$-/
- '( )*&
+ . . . . 0
. . 1
,05>->>.0,;,/@437, ./,.2:625;063025-5/9,53,56, -6689,/<.,:,..,/-5-<<,-12537,:01,2:37,//1093.063 -5/,990259)8/>,0/-.903305>-3-9-;-A-14-505.12 %%* %
,-.5,/)8/>,0537,$0.93<<,11-3,28.3-:3,.9,68.05> 37, .,62./9 7,-./ 37, -.>8=,539 2: 37, <-.30,9 -5/ -112?,/ 37,-<<,-105<-.3-5/=2/0:0,/37,9,53,56,-985/,. 0 . & # %
02+. 3#$!-$'!$$$
/
- 4 -
&
-
+ + . .4. , '$"$$$-/
#$% " +
. . .#. . '( " '$ )* &" ! # '1
,05> :8.37,. ->>.0,;,/ @4 37, 9-=, -6689,/ 09 @,:2., 370928.3 * .0-/122.-34-5-.-4-5-67-.4-1,-.5,/62859,1:2.37, .,;09025<,303025,..,03,.-305>37,>.285/98.>,/0537,.,;09025 <,303025 ?281/ 6253,5/ 37-3 37,., -., 9,.0289 1-685-, 05 37, 6-9,2:37,<.29,683025?70677-9@,,50>52.,/@437,1,-.5,/ .0-1)8/>,-5/52362590/,.,/@437,1,-.5,/)8/>,0537,$0.93 <<,11-3,28.3.,981305>05=096-..0->,2:B89306, ' 833.,9905>7096253,5302597,?281/05;03,37,-33,53025 2:37,28.33237,9<23<-567-5-=--5/37,2.-13,930=2542: (9 -5/ -5/ 6253,5/,/ 37-3 6253,539 2: 37, 9<23 <-567-5-=-?281//,<06337-337,0560/,537-92668..,/.0>73 05:.2532:37,2::06,2:37,0.61,59<,632.2:2106,8337,
- 5 -
9<23<-567-5-=-7-9@,,5/.-?52537,5,C3/-4-5/@437,5 37,2::,5/05>-832.06A97-?-5/3?2?7,,1,.7-/-1.,-/4@,,5 970:3,/ :.2= 37, <1-6, 2: 37, -660/,53 -5/ ?-9 <-.A,/ 05 37, <.,605632:37,<2106,93-3025
,:8.37,.6253,5/,/37-337,9,-.,37,9,.0289-9<,639 2: 37, =-33,. ,9<,60-114 ?701, -99,9905> 37, .-975,99 -5/ 5,>10>,56,2537,<-.32:37,.,;09025<,303025,.70>77-5/,/ -630;034 2: 37, <2106, 05 970:305> 37, -832 .06A97-? :.2= 37, <1-6, 25 37, -660/,53 32 37, <.,60563 2: 37, <2106, 93-3025 ?037283 625/86305> 37, 9<23 <-567-5-=- 7-9 9,.028914 <.,B8/06,/37,.0>7392:37,<,303025,.-5/928>7332-112?37, .,;09025<,303025 & ,-1926253,5/,/37-332-99,9937,.-97-5/5,>10>,56, 2537,<-.32:37,.,;09025<,303025,.?701,/.0;05>37,2::,5/05> -832 .06A97-? 1,-.5,/ .0-1 )8/>, 7-9 0>52.,/ 37, =-3,.0-1 ,;0/,56, <1-6,/ 25 .,62./ .,981305> 05 =096-..0->, 2: B89306, -5/928>73:2.-112?05>37,<,303025 % -9314 .0 -/122. -34-5-.-4-5-67-.4- ?281/ 6253,5/ 37-337,1,-.5,/.0-1)8/>,7-962==033,/>.-;,,..2.05523 <.2<,.14 .,62./05> 37, 93-3,=,53 2: 37, -6689,/ 05-9=867 -9
- 6 -
0593,-/2:5-=05>37,67-.>,97,,3?035,99,937,0.58=@,.-9 <,. 67-.>, 97,,3 7-9 @,,5 =,53025,/ 05 37, D8,930259 37-3 ?,., :.-=,/ @4 37, 1,-.5,/ .0-1 )8/>, .,981305> 05 9,.0289 <.,B8/06,3285/,.93-5/37,6-9,2:37,<.29,683025?7,.,@4 -6689,/6281/523:8.5097<.2<,.,C<1-5-3025-5/37,.,:2.,37, 0=<8>5,/ ./,. 2: 625;063025 -5/ 9,53,56, 5,,/9 32 @, 9,3 -90/,
=3503- ,//4 1,-.5,/ 0>7 28.3 2;,.5=,531,-/,.98<<2.3937,0=<8>5,/B8/>=,53
7,?281/6253,5/37-337,-11,>,/1-<9,92.1-685-,05 625/86305>37,3.0-1@,:2.,37,.0-128.3?-9523D8,93025,/ @,:2.,37,$0.93<<,11-3,28.3@4.-0905>5,6,99-.4>.285/905 37,-<<,-1=,=2.-5/8=
7,?281/:8.37,.6253,5/37-31-<9,92.1-685-,<2053,/ 283@437,.,;09025<,303025,.?281/523 6-89,9,.0289 /,533237,2;,.-116-9,2:37,<.29,68302505-9=867-93729, 1-<9,9 -., 2514 32 @, 3,.=,/ -9 0..,>81-.034 -5/ 523 011,>-1034 -5/3789928>73:2./09=099-12:37,.,;09025<,303025
- 7 -
7,-1926253,5/,/37-3625/8632:37,-6689,/-998=,9 0=<2.3-56, 9225 -:3,. 37, 0560/,53 ,;09025 ,303025,. @,05> 37,/.0;,.2:37,-832.06A97-?/0/5236-.,32970:337,05B8.,/ 3237,729<03-1@83.-5-?-4:.2=37,9<237,.,:2.,.,;09025 <,303025,.
6-5523 <1,-/ -54 =030>-305> 60.68=93-56,9 @,:2., 370928.3
7, -192 6253,5/,/ 37-3 37, $0.93 <<,11-3, 28.3 7-9 =2/0:0,/ 37, 9,53,56, @4 .,/8605> 37, 0=<.0925=,53 @4 90C =25379-5/928>73:2./09=099-12:37,.,;09025<,30302505 * -;05> 7,-./ 37, -.>8=,539 2: 1,-.5,/ 62859,1 :2. 37, <-.30,9 3709 28.3 <,.89,/ 37, =-3,.0-1 25 .,62./ =,3068128914 '
5 9867 <,.89-1 2: 37, =-3,.0-1 25 .,62./ -9 6281/ @, 9,,5 :.2= 37, 67-.>, 97,,3 =-3,.0-1 37, 6-9, 2: 37, <.29,683025 ?281/ .,;,-1 37-3 05 .,9<,63 2: - .2-/ 3.-::06 -660/,53 37-3 2668..,/ 25 % % & 05;21;05> -5 -832 .06A97-?@,-.05>.,>093.-30252& &''-5/-=232.6461, @,-.05> .,>093.-3025 2& % 25 703->8<<-,1-A,.- =-05.2-/05:.2532:37,2::06,2:37,0.61,59<,632.2:2106, -62=<1-0536-=,32@,12/>,/?037703->8<<-<2106,93-3025
- 8 -
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
:3,. 372.28>7 05;,930>-3025 67-.>, 97,,3 6-=, 32 @, :01,/->-059337,.,;09025<,303025,.7,.,05/=033,/1467-.>, 97,,3?-952367-11,5>,/@437,.,;09025<,303025,.0:37,<2106, 7-;,62==033,/-54,..2.0505;,930>-305>37,=-33,.<.2<,.14
- 9 -
7,.,-:3,.37,.0-128.3322A62>50E-56,2:37,2::,56, <85097-@1,85/,.,63025'&%2:37,5/0-5,5-12/, -5/,63025 '2:37, 5/0-5232. ,7061,9639,68.,/37, <.,9,56,2:37,-6689,/-5/.,62./,/37,<1,-
7,.0-128.3,62./9/,<06337-337,-6689,/<1,-/,/ 523>80134-5/37,.,:2.,3.0-1?-97,1/
52./,.32@.05>72=,37,>80132:-6689,/<.29,683025 ,C-=05,/ 90C ?035,99,9 -9 (9 32 * -5/ <1-6,/ 25 .,62./ 3,5/268=,539?7067?,.,,C70@03,/-5/=-.A,/-9C %
2/28@30537,6.299,C-=05-30252:(?720925, 2: 37, ?035,99,9 32 9<23 =-7-E-. 03 09 ,10603,/ 37-3 37, -832 .06A97-?-5/37,=232.6461,?,.,970:3,/:.2=37,<1-6,2:37, 0560/,53 -5/ ?,., <-.A,/ ?03705 37, <.,605639 2: 37, <2106, 93-3025 * 3 09 -192 ,10603,/ 05 37, 6.299,C-=05-3025 37-3 37, <-567-5-=- 7-9 @,,5 /.-?5 5,C3 /-4 2: 37, -660/,53 $8.37,.0309,10603,/37-3 ::06,2:37,0.61,59<,632.2:2106, 09-.285/FA=-5/37,.,09-62=<285/-5/-@8.0-1>.285/ -@283%%=,3.,9-?-4
- 10 -
' 309:8.37,.,10603,/37-337,.,09-.2-/78=<05:.2532: 37, ::06,2:37,0.61,59<,632.2:2106,,/,50,/37-37, 7-9 :-19,14 /,<29,/ @,:2., 37, 28.3 37-3 7, 7-9 523 <-.3060<-3,/0537,<-567-5-=-<.26,,/05>
7,99093-538@59<,632.2:2106,?72625/863,/37, 9<23=-7-E-.09,C-=05,/-9(57096.299,C-=05-3025 37, /,:060,560,9 2. 1-685-, 28>73 32 7-;, @,,5 ,10603,/ ?7067 -.,<2053,/283@437,1,-.5,/62859,1:2..,;09025<,303025,. 83 98.<.0905>14 523 ,;,5 - 98>>,93025 09 <83 32 ( ?037 .,>-./3237,970:305>2:-832.06A97-?2.=232.6461,:.2=37, 9<23@,:2.,37,9<23=-7-E-.?-9625/863,/ & -;05> .,>-./ 32 37, /,-37 @,05> 6-89,/ 25 -662853 2: 05B8.0,99893-05,/0537,.2-/3.-::06-660/,53-5/3-A05>523,2: 37,:-6337-337,.,095267-11,5>,3237,67-.>,97,,30537, .,;09025-1 B8.09/063025 3709 28.3 /2,9 523 :05/ -54 <-3,53 :-638-1 ,..2. 2.
,..2. 2: B8.09/063025 05 .,62./05> -5 2./,. 2: 625;063025-9097,1/0537,6-9,2:
.,<2.3,/05
- 11 -
% ?2 28.39 7-;, 6259093,5314 -<<.,60-3,/ 37, =-3,.0-1 ,;0/,56,<1-6,/25.,62./-5/37,.,-:3,..,62./,/-52./,.2: 625;063025
(701,92.,62./05>-52./,.2:625;063025030952306,/@4 37, .0-1 28.3 37-3 37,., 09 52 ,C<1-5-3025 2::,.,/ @4 37, -6689,/ -3 37, 30=, 2: .,62./05> -6689,/ 93-3,=,53 -9 09 6253,=<1-3,/85/,.,63025 2:2/,2:.0=05-1.26,/8.,
5 3709 .,>-./ 37, -.>8=,53 <83 :2.37 25 @,7-1: 2: 37, <,303025,.-998=,90=<2.3-56,
(701,03 09=-5/-32.4/8342:37,1,-.5,/.0-1)8/>,32 .,62./37,-6689,/93-3,=,53-9096253,=<1-3,/85/,.,63025 2: 37, 2/, 2: .0=05-1 .26,/8., 37, 9-=, 09 523 <8.<29,1,99,62./05>2:-6689,/93-3,=,5309-5 0=<2.3-53 93->, 2: 37, .0-1 ?7,., 37, -6689,/ ?281/ @, >0;,5 -5 2<<2.385034 32 ,C<1-05 37, 056.0=05-32.4 60.68=93-56,9 -5/ -112?937,-6689,/32<1-6,709 7,.;,.9025?037.,>-./3237, 0560/,53
: 37, .,62./05> 2: 37, -6689,/ 93-3,=,53 039,1: 09 0=<.2<,.2.625:8905>2.62=<.09,92:62=<285/9,53,56,903
- 12 -
?011@,/0::06813:2.37,-6689,/32<1-6,709,C<1-5-30253237, 056.0=05-32.4=-3,.0-19
-3,5- 2: B8/060-1 <.252856,=,539 7-;, 30=, -5/ ->-05 6-83025,/37,.0-128.3-93272?-6689,/93-3,=,530932@, .,62./,/
9->, 2: 52562=<.,7,5/0@1, ?2./9 10A, ( (* 2. ( 2. 62=<106-3,/ =,/06-1 3,.=9 97281/ @, -;20/,/?701,.,62./05>37,-6689,/93-3,=,53 * (7,.,;,.0309<,.=0990@1,0:3,67506-13,.=9-.,9<2A,5 32@4?035,99,9030937,/8342:37,28.3323.-591-3,37,=32 2./05-.41-5>8->,?70670985/,.93-5/-@1,@4-62==25=-5 -5/9867056.0=05-32.4=-3,.0-19-.,32@,<830537,-6689,/ 93-3,=,53-5/9,,A5,6,99-.4,C<1-5-3025 '
:3,537,-6689,/93-3,=,5309523705>@83G62<4<-93,H 2: 37, ,C-=05-302505670,: 2: - ?035,99 ?7067 9,.;,9 52 <8.<29, 52. 03 6-5 @, 62593.8,/ -9 <.2<,. 62=<10-56, 2: 37, =-5/-32.4.,D80.,=,532:.,62./05>37,-6689,/93-3,=,53
0=, -5/ ->-05 B8/060-1 <.252856,=,539 7-;, 61,-.14 .81,/ 37-3 9867 <.-6306, =893 @, /,<.,6-3,/ ,9<03, 9867
- 13 -
-8372.03-30;, <.252856,=,539 37, 0=<.2<,. :.-=05> 2: 37, D8,9302590537,-6689,/93-3,=,53096253058,/ & 7,.,:2., 03 09 5,6,99-.4 :2. 3709 28.3 32 256, ->-05 .,03,.-3, -11 37,9, 6-./05-1 <.0560<1,9 -9 32 72? -6689,/ 93-3,=,530932@,.,62./,/ % 3095,,/1,9932,=<7-90E,37-3030937,/8342:37,)8/>, 32681128337,056.0=05-32.4=-3,.0-19:.2=37,3,930=2542:37, <.29,683025?035,99,9-5/37,5<8303-6.2993237,-6689,/-5/ 9,,A,C<1-5-3025
:37,D8,930259-.,52562=<.,7,5/0@1,2.0537,5-38., 2: G62<4 <-93,H 2: 37, ,C-=05-302505670,: 2: 37, <.29,683025 ?035,99,9 9867 93-3,=,539 -., 32 @, 62590/,.,/ -9 0=<.2<,. 62=<10-56,-5/05->0;,56-9,03=-4-192.,981305.,;,.905> 37,B8/>=,530:03097,1/->-059337,-6689,/
537,6-9,257-5/52/28@3-909.0>7314<2053,/283 @4 1,-.5,/ 62859,1 :2. 37, .,;09025 <,303025,. 37-3 ?701, .,62./05> 37, 056.0=05-32.4 60.68=93-56,9 :.2= 37, /,<2903025 2:(37,.0-1)8/>,7-989,/37,?2./9G(9H5232514-3 25,0593-56,@8305628<1,2:0593-56,9
- 14 -
2?,;,. 3-A05> 523, 2: 37, =-3,.0-1 25 .,62./ 05 - 68=81-30;,=-55,.370928.3092:37,62590/,.,/2<0502537-3 523<83305>-6.29937,3,930=2542:(?720937,99093-53 8@59<,632.2:2106,?72.,>093,.,/37,6-9,-5/625/863,/ 37,9<23=-7-E-.-125,?281/523@,98::060,53,528>7328<9,3 37,:05/2:625;063025.,62./,/@437,.0-1)8/>,625:0.=,/@4 37,$0.93<<,11-3,)8/>,
5:2.385-3,14 37, 1,-.5,/ )8/>, 05 37, $0.93 <<,11-3, 28.3 /0/ 523 @,932? 709 -33,53025 32 37,9, -9<,639 2: 37, =-33,. ,;,5 05 37, -@9,56, 2: -54 >.285/9 @,05> .-09,/ 25 @,7-1: 2: 37, -<<,11-53 05 37, -<<,-1 =,=2 -9 37, 1,-.5,/ )8/>,0537,$0.93<<,11-3,28.3?-9.,D80.,/3262590/,.37, 6-9,2:37,-<<,11-53@237251-?-5/25:-639
709 28.3 @,05> 37, 28.3 2:.,;09025 7-;05> .,>-./ 32 37,10=03,/962<,05.,;090305>053237,:-638-1-9<,639/2523 :05/37-337,>.285/98.>,/25@,7-1:2:37,.,;09025<,303025,. ?281/-::,6337,6-9,2:37,.,;09025<,303025,.98679,.02891492 -9328<9,337,:05/05>2:37,625;063025 * 5 ;0,? 2: 37, :2.,>205> /096899025 625;063025 2: 37, .,;09025<,303025,.5,,/932@,=-053-05,/
- 15 -
' -;05>7,1/3789030952306,/37-337,1,-.5,/.0-1)8/>, 7-9 -?-./,/ 25, 4,-.
.0>2.289 0=<.0925=,53 :2. 37, 2::,56, <85097-@1, 85/,. ,63025 % 2: 37, 5/0-5 ,5-1 2/, -5/ 37.,,=25379.0>2.2890=<.0925=,53:2.37,2::,56,<85097-@1, 85/,. ,63025 '& 2: 37, 5/0-5 ,5-1 2/, -<-.3 :.2= 0=<2905> 37, :05, -=2853 2: 9 %%%% -5/ 9 %%% .,9<,630;,14
(037.,>-./3237,2::,56,<85097-@1,85/,.,63025 ' 2:37,5/0-5232.,7061,963.0-128.37-90=<29,/:05,2: 9%% ?037/,:-8139,53,56, & 5 5/0-5 B8.09<.8/,56, 37,., 09 52 <.2<,. 9,53,5605> <21064 5@-.,.,-/05>2:,630259'&-5/%2:37,5/0-5 ,5-1 2/, 37, :.-=,.9 2: 37, 1,>091-3025 /0/ 523 ,5;09->, 0=<2905>2:.0>2.2890=<.0925=,53:2.3729,2::,56,9 % 3 09 -192 52306,-@1, 37-3 05 @237 2::,56,9 37,., ?-9 52 62=<8192.4<85097=,532:0=<.0925=,53-3-11
2?,;,.3-A05>523,2:37,>-112<05>3.,5/2:/,-3792: 78=-5@,05>05.2-/3.-::06-660/,539-:3,.98.;,405>37,6-9, 1-?2537,0998,25H@1,<,C28.30537,6-9,2:
- 16 -
! "# .,<2.3,/ 05 $$ % 7-97,1/-985/,. '% ' 5 '# 6 + . +
+
+
7
+
. . " . #$%/& +
% 8 & 9 +
7. . + + + + . "
. &
. . + : + ;. . . + .. + . ; : : +
+
<
. +<
. + <
"
- 17 -
; . : . + . +
+
. 2 0
"
"
+ + . + . = > + ;" $$$ (1
7,.,:2., 3709 28.3 09 2: 37, 62590/,.,/ 2<05025 37-3 37,.,97281/@,-31,-93=050=8=0=<.0925=,532:90C=25379 ?7,.,37,78=-510:,7-9@,,5129325-6628532:5,>10>,53-63 2: -5 -6689,/ <85097-@1, 85/,. ,63025 % 2: 37, 5/0-5 ,5-12/,
5 37, 93-383, ?7,5 37,., 09 52 .0>2.289 0=<.0925=,53 <.,96.0@,/1,-.5,/.0-1)8/>,0=<2905>.0>2.2890=<.0925=,53 :2.37.,,=25379:2.37,2::,56,<85097-@1,85/,.,63025'& 2:37,5/0-5,5-12/,-5/25,4,-..0>2.2890=<.0925=,53 :2. 37, 2::,56, <85097-@1, 85/,. ,63025 % 2: 37, 5/0-5 ,5-12/,5,,/9.,62590/,.-3025
2?,;,. 1,-.5,/ )8/>, 05 37, $0.93 <<,11-3, 28.3 =2/0:0,/ 37, 9,53,56, -5/ .,/86,/ 37, 0=<.0925=,53 :2. 37,
- 18 -
2::,56, <85097-@1, 85/,. ,63025 % 2: 37, 5/0-5 ,5-1 2/, :.2= 25, 4,-. 32 90C =25379 -5/ /0/ 523 =2/0:4 37, 0=<.0925=,53:2.37,2::,56,<85097-@1,85/,.,63025'&2: 37, 5/0-5 ,5-1 2/, -5/ ,63025 ' 2: 37, 5/0-5 232. ,7061,63
309-19252306,/:.2=37, ./,.2:37,1,-.5,/)8/>,05 37,$0.93<<,11-3,28.337-3,;,53728>737,.,09529,53,56, 2: 0=<.0925=,53 2. :05, :2. 37, 2::,56, <85097-@1, 85/,. ,63025 %2: 37, 5/0-5 232. ,7061, 63 -9 37,., ?-9 52 67-.>, -3 -11 -5/ 625;063025 :2. 37, 2::,56, 37, 2<,.-30;, <2.3025 2: 37, ./,. 2: 37, 1,-.5,/ $0.93 <<,11-3, )8/>, 0562.<2.-3,9 37, 9,53,56, 09 625:0.=,/ :2. 37, 2::,56, <85097-@1, 85/,. ,63025 % 2: 37, 5/0-5 232.
,7061, 63 -5/:2.37,2::,56,<85097-@1,85/,.,630259'&-5/ 2: 37,5/0-5,5-12/, * ,-.5,/ )8/>, 05 37, $0.93 <<,11-3, 28.3 >23 625:89,/ ?701, =2/0:405> 37, 9,53,56, -9 32 37, 962<, -5/ -=@03 2: ,63025 % 2: 37, 5/0-5 232. ,7061, 63 ?7,.,05 1,-.5,/ .0-1 )8/>, 7-9 2514 /0.,63,/ 37, 2::06, 32 98<<14 2./,. 2: 625;0630253237,2-/.-::06 ::060-19323-A,5,6,99-.4-63025
- 19 -
2 -192 ,63025 '" # 2: 37, 2/, 2: .0=05-1 .26,/8., 6253,=<1-3,9-@283<-4=,532:62=<,59-3025-=2853 ' 7,.,:2.,2<,.-30;,<2.30252:37,B8/>=,532:37,$0.93 <<,11-3,28.309523<.2<,.14?2./,/-5/03/2,9523625;,4 <.2<,.=,-505>
,37-3?7-303=-4056,37,.,09251425,/,-37-5/ 37,05B8.,/129370910:,2537,5,C3/-42:37,-660/,530537, 729<03-12::,56,85/,.,63025'&=,.>,9?0372::,56,85/,. ,63025%2:37,5/0-5,5-12/, & 7,.,:2., 9056, 2514 25, <,.925 09 05B8.,/ ?72 1293 709 10:, ?7,5 37,., 09 9,53,56, 37-3 7-9 @,,5 -?-./,/ :2. 37, 2::,56, <85097-@1, 85/,. ,63025 % 2: 37, 5/0-5 ,5-1 2/, 52 9,<-.-3, 9,53,56, 2: 0=<.0925=,53 09
<,.=0990@1,:2.37,2::,56,<85097-@1,85/,.,63025'&2:37, 5/0-5,5-12/,05;0,?2:/263.05,2:=,.>,. *% $8.37,. 9056, 37, 2::,56, 85/,. ,63025 % 2: 37, 5/0-5,5-12/,0962590/,.,/-9523-7,052892::,56,@83 ?7,.,-78=-510:,0912931,>091-32.90537,0.?09/2=3728>73 37-3 3?2 4,-.9 09 37, =-C0=8= <85097=,53 056, 37, $0.93
- 20 -
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
' ! (
- 21 -
.,<2.3,/ 05 )% -5/ * ! (
.,<2.3,/05$+,%- * 5;0,?2:37,:2.,>205>/09689902537,:2112?05>
"0# 7, .0=05-1 ,;09025 <,303025 09 .. /
"00# (701, =-053-0505> 37, 625;063025 2: 37, -6689,/ :2. 37, 2::,56, <85097-@1, 85/,. ,630259 '&-5/%2:37,5/0-5,5-12/,9,53,56,2: 0=<.0925=,53 2./,.,/ @4 37, .0-1 28.3 =2/0:0,/ @4 37, $0.93 <<,11-3, 28.3 09 :8.37,.=2/0:0,/@4 /0.,6305>37,.,;09025<,303025,. -6689,/3285/,.>2 90=<1,0=<.0925=,53:2.-<,.02/2:90C=25379:2. 37, 2::,56, <85097-@1, 85/,. ,63025 % 2: 37, 5/0-5,5-12/,
"000# ,932:37,9,53,56,?037.,>-./3237,:05,05 .,9<,63 2: 37, 2::,56, <85097-@1, 85/,. ,630259 '&-5/%2:37,5/0-5,5-12/,-5/,63025 ' 2: 37, 5/0-5 232. ,7061,9 63 93-5/9 85-13,.,/
"0;# 2 -192 37, 2./,.
2: 62=<,59-3025 -?-./,/ @437,.0-128.393-5/985-13,.,/
- 22 -
";# 0=,09>.-53,/:2.37,,;09025<,303025,.32 98..,5/,. @,:2., 37, .0-1 28.3 :2. 9,.;05> .,=-0505> <2.3025 2: 37, 9,53,56, 3011 %37 8>893 %
";0# ,>093.4 09 /0.,63,/ 32 .,38.5 37, .0-1 28.3 ,62./9 -125> ?037 62<4 2: 3709 ./,. :2. 099805> 37,=2/0:0,/625;063025?-..-53
-* %$) ! A6= 0932 12*