- 1 - !"! #" $$ %% &$' () " * ( ) ! Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " # ! " $ $$ % $& & !! ' ()) *$+$", + "! (-*$+$", ' $ %-&. ! " . + & ' !%,%!,+ +&!,% - 3 - ' ' ( ( * ) ! ! " ! " , ! " $ $% % $+ - 4 - & ! ' ()) ' ' " (-*$+$", ! *$+$", !. / !! #,+ ' !%,%!,+ +&!,% ' - 5 - ,,%"0 ",,,,,0 ' ( ' 1 ' " 2344567867 9:;7<56= 36; 3>3?; ;3=5; !%,%!,+ @3AA5; BC ?86D8@34 8A=?8D= 36; 5AA8E6A ':;75 36; ?86D8@34 E=E?DD8;56=438<A?8B:6348;3?FE?A2E?=1=?8B:634186 6E+&!,%=28A3@@53436;D?EAA0EB95D=8E63?5F845;BC 86A:?5?3A>5443AD438<36=A ! ?8 A@3448 453?65; DE:6A54 A:B<8==5; 3@@534 >3A BC 86A:?5? D2344567867 3>3?; E6 G:36=:< = >3A A:B<8==5;3A@5?D438<36=AE6$,!,%*8A236>3A;?8H5? EF4E??C6E0 # & +4E3;5;>8=2A:73?D365>256;?8H5?EF ?3D=E?0?3845? 6E0 +0!%$#!%%, ;?EH5 8= 86 ?3A2 36; 65748756= <3665? 36; ;3A25; 37386A= 4E??C D3:A867 3DD8;56= 6 A38; 3DD8;56= 8A236 A:A=3865; F3=34 869:?85A 36; ;85; 438<867 DE<@56A3=8E6 28A >8F5 D284;?56 @3?56=A 36; :60 <3??85; A8A=5? F845; D438< @5=8=8E6 :6;5? 5D=8E6 %% EF E=E? 528D45AD=37386A=E>65?36;86A:?5?EF=?3D=E?0=?3845? - 6 - 5A@8=5 6E=8D5 E>65? ;8; 6E= 3@@53? 36; >3A @43D5;5I0@3?=56A:?5?E@@EA5;D438<@5=8=8E6;56C86756=8?5 D438< @5=8=8E6 3H5?<56=A 36; 34AE 34457867 H8E43=8E6 EF =5?<A 36;DE6;8=8E6AEF@E48DCBC86A:?5; " 3A5; E6 @453;867A =?834 E:?= F?3<5; 8AA:5A 36; ?5DE?;5;5H8;56D5438<36=6E>3A5I3<865;3A036; IA0 =E # 7E= <3?J5; 5A@E6;56=A ;8; 6E= 453; 36C 5H8;56D5 $ 6 DE6A8;5?3=8E6 =?8B:634 254; 3DD8;56= EDD:??5; ;:5=E?3A236;65748756=;?8H867EF?3D=E?0384E?BC8=A;?8H5? 453;867 =E ;53=2 EF 8A236 D438<36=A B5867 56=8=45; FE? DE<@56A3=8E63AA5AA5;BC8=3AFE44E>A 4 E 53;A <E:6= E>3?;A 4EAA EF ;5@56;56DC 36; F:=:?586DE<5 A!+,,%"0 ! E>3?;ADE6AE?=8:<=EA=@5=8=8E65? A,,,,0 5=8=8E65?A6E!=E";:5=E;53=2EF =258?F3=25? A,,,,0 " 5=8=8E65?A 6E$ 36; % ;:5 =E ;53=2 EF=258?AE6 A,,,,0 $ 5=8=8E65? 6E& ;:5 =E ;53=2 EF 25? B?E=25? A,,,,0 % E>3?;A=?36A@E?=3=8E6EF;53;BE;C A,,,,0 +,- . /( - 7 - % 8AA3=8AF85;>8=2A3<5=25A53@@534A>5?5F845;BC D438<36=A3A>5443A86A:?5? & =>3AA:B<8==5;=3J8676E=5EF63=:?5EF;3<375A A:A=3865;BCBE=2H528D45A65748756D58AE6@3?=EF;?8H5?AEF BE=2 H528D45A 25?5FE?5 =25?5 E:72= =E 23H5 B556 3@@E?=8E6<56=EF65748756D5EF;?8H5?AEFBE=2H528D45A 5?54C E6 7?E:6; =23= @E48D5 23; D23?75 A255=5; E64C ;?8H5? EF ?3D=E?0?3845? =?8B:634 >3A 6E= 9:A=8F85; 86 F3A=56867 56=8?5 483B848=CE686A:?5?=>3AF:?=25?A:B<8==5;=2E:72D438<36=A A=3=5; =23= ;5D53A5; 8A2E? >3A >E?J867 3A 3 ;?8H5? >8=2 <E6=24C 86DE<5 EF A!,,,0 >8=2 23==3 EF A!$,0 @5? ;3C=25CF3845;=EA:BA=36=83=5A3<5>8=2A@5D8F8D<3=5?83436; =?8B:634DE6A8;5?5;28A86DE<53=A,,,,0@<>28D2>3A 28725?=23686DE<5@?5AD?8B5;FE?C53?!,%3=A+&$,0 6 A38;7?E:6;AE:72=FE??5;:D=8E6 + 6 E=25? 236; ?8 36;55@J:<3? 893C 3=84 453?65; DE:6A54 FE? D438<36=A E@@EA5; 86A:?5?A 3@@534 36; AE:72= 56236D5<56= = >3A A:B<8==5; DE<@4836= @E= 36D2363<336;D23?75A255=3=IA0=E&8<@48D3=5;;?8H5? EF ?3D=E?0?3845? 3A 65748756= 86 D3:A867 3DD8;56= 25?5 >3A - 8 - 6E5H8;56D545;BC86A:?5?=EA:@@E?=344573=8E6AEF65748756D5 37386A=;?8H5?EF?3D=E?0?3845? 5?54CE67?E:6;EF;3<375A A:A=3865;BCE??C8=D366E=B58<@485;=23=;?8H5?EFE??C>3A 65748756= # 6 G:36=:< 8= >3A A:B<8==5; =23= ;5D53A5; >3A >E?J867 3A ;?8H5? 53?6867 A!,,,0 @< 3A A343?C 36; A!$,0 3A ;384C B23==3 E A:BA=36=83=5 28A 3HED3=8E6 D438<36=A23;@?E;:D5;;?8H86748D56A5EF;5D53A5;3=I0+ 3<5>E:4;86;8D3=5=23=2523;;?8H86748D56A5=E;?8H5? >8=2 =?36A@E?= 56;E?A5<56= 36; :A 25?5FE?5 ;5=5?<863=8E6EF<E6=24C86DE<56E=8E6344C>3A6E=9:A=8F85;= >3A F:?=25? A:B<8==5; =?8B:634 5??5; 86 6E= 3;;867 F:=:?5 @?EA@5D=A = >3A 34AE A:B<8==5; =23= D438<36=A >5?5 >8F5 =2?55 D284;?56 @3?56=A 36; :6<3??85; A8A=5? 5A@8=5 A3<5 ;5;:D=8E6=E>3?;A@5?AE6345I@56A5A3= ?;8AE628725?A8;5 = >3A A:B<8==5; 3>3?; EF DE<@56A3=8E6 :6;5? E=25? 253;A >3A 34AE 6E= 3A @5? ;5D8A8E6 86 D3A5 EF !"#0$!%&# &36;AE:72= FE?56236D5<56= 1 !,&%%+, - 9 - , 53?; DE:6A54 36; @5?:A5; 9:;7<56= 36; 3>3?; 36;D5?=8F8D3=5DE@CEF;5@EA8=36;5I28B8=A<3;53H3843B45FE? @5?:A34BC453?65;DE:6A54FE?3@@54436= 6 H85> EF 3BEH5 @E86=A =23= >E:4; 3?8A5 FE? DE6A8;5?3=8E63?5 825=25?=?8B:634>3A9:A=8F85;862E4;867;?8H5?EF 86A:?5;H528D45AE454C65748756=86D3:A8673DD8;56=K 8825=25?3AA5AA<56=EFDE<@56A3=8E6BC=?8B:634 D344AFE?<E;8F8D3=8E6K %12+2 ! 6 E?;5? =E 5A=3B48A2 3D=8E63B45 3@@534 37386A= 86A:?5? D438<36=A ?5485; :@E6 @E48D5 86H5A=873=8E6 ?5DE?;A 63<54C E<@4386= @E= 36D2363<3 36; 23?75 255= <3?J5; 3A IA0 =E 36; & 3<5 >E:4; ?5H534 =23= 3F=5? 86H5A=873=8E6@E48D523;F845;23?75255=E64C37386A=;?8H5? EF ?3D=E?0?3845? 2E:72 I0% E=E? 528D45 6A@5D=E?LA 5@E?=>E:4;A:BA=36=83=5;3<375AA:A=3865;=EF?E6=A8;5EF E??C 8= 34AE A:A=3865; ;3<375A =E F?E6= 36; ?872= A8;5 EF ?3D=E?6786536;?3845?@E=36D2363<3>E:4;?5H534=23= E??C >3A <EH867 F?E< E:=2 =E E?=2 >2845 ?3D=E?0?3845? - 10 - >3A<EH867F?E< E?=2=EE:=2DD8;56=EDD:??5;E6+F= >8;5 ?E3; >8=2 $ F= J3D223 ?E3; 36; 3DD8;56= EDD:??5; 3= ;8A=36D5EF%F=F?E<5A=5?65;75EF?E3;28A>E:4;86;8D3=5 =23=;?8H5?EF?3D=E?0?3845?23;=3J568=E6>?E67A8;5BC F= E?5EH5? 86A:?5? ;8; 6E= 453; 36C 5H8;56D5 H56 ?5A:4= EF D?8<8634@?EA5D:=8E6EF;?8H5?EF?3D=E??3845?8A6E=;8AD4EA5; 25?5FE?53@@E?=8E6<56=EF65748756D5BC=?8B:634E64C37386A= ;?8H5? EF ?3D=E?0?3845? >E:4; B5 F:44C 9:A=8F85; 56D5 @E86= 6E8A36A>5?5;863FF8?<3=8H5 %12+2 6AEF3? 3A <E6=24C 86DE<5 =2E:72 D438<36=A A=3=5; =23= 8A2E? >3A >E?J867 3A ;?8H5? 36; 53?6867 A!,,,0 @< >8=2 A!$,0 ;384C B23=3 A3<5 >3A 6E= A:BA=36=83=5; := BC @?E;:D=8E6 EF ;?8H867 48D56A5 3A 0+ 3HED3=8E6 8A 5A=3B48A25; A ?872=4C A:B<8==5; I0+ >E:4; 86;8D3=5 =23= ;5D53A5; 23; 254; 48D56A5 FE? ;?8H867 >8=2 =?36A@E?= 56;E?A5<56= 36; :A 6;5? A8<843? D8?D:<A=36D5A =28A E:?= 86 6E!,& !,! 3AA5AA5; 86DE<5EF;?8H5?EFE??C>8=2=?36A@E?=56;E?A5<56=36; - 11 - :A3=A!,,,,025?5FE?5<E6=24C86DE<5EF;5D53A5;8A DE6A8;5?5;3=A!,,,,0 " 438<36=A 3?5 >8F5 =2?55 D284;?56 @3?56=A 36; :6<3??85; A8A=5? EF ;5D53A5; H56 8F :6<3??85; A8A=5? 8A 5ID4:;5;F?E<;5@56;56DC3AA25>E:4;B5;5@56;56=E625? F3=25?6:<B5?EF;5@56;56=A8AA8IA@5?;5D8A8E686%3,2,4 5+61 A:@?3 "=2 23A =E B5 ;5;:D=5; =E>3?;A @5?AE634 5I@56A5A 5D53A5; >3A 375; ! C53?A EF 375 36; A54F 5<@4EC5; 25?5FE?5 ",M 23A =E B5 3;;5; =E>3?;A F:=:?5 @?EA@5D=A :4=8@485? 3@@48D3B45 >E:4; B5 % 25?5FE?5 DE<@56A3=8E6 =E>3?;A 4EAA EF ;5@56;56DC >E:4; B5 A", !,,,0NA!,,,,0O",M0PQI!I% $ @3?= F?E< 3BEH5 D438<36=A >E:4; B5 56=8=45; FE? A",,,,0 53D2 =E>3?;A A@E:A34 F84834 36; @3?56=34 DE6AE?=8:<85=E=34EFA!",,,,0A",,,,I% % @3?= F?E< 3BEH5 D438<36=A >E:4; B5 56=8=45; FE? A$,,,0=E>3?;AF:65?345I@56A5A36;A$,,,0=E>3?;A 4EAAEF5A=3=52:ADE<@56A3=8E6 :6;5?DE6H56=8E634 253;A >E:4; B5 A!&,,,,0 A @5? ;5D8A8E6 86 %3,2,4 5+61 A:@?3 ,M 5AD343=8E6 23A =E B5 3;;5; =E 3<E:6= :6;5? - 12 - DE6H56=8E634 253;A 5H5?C =2?55 C53?A 86D5 A8I C53?A 23A 543@A5;3F=5?A38;;5D8A8E6!,M23A=EB53;;5;3<5>E:4; B5A$",,,02:A=E=343>3?;>E:4;B5A" $%,,,03A FE44E>A 5,7.89:52.,+12 9;2+ EAAEF;5@56;56DC A", !,,,0 E6H56=8E634253;A A!&,,,,0 AD343=8E6!,M A$",,,0 +,- ./ ( & E86= 6E! 8A 36A>5?5; @3?=4C 86 3FF8?<3=8H5 E6A5G:56=4CFE44E>867 8 6E!,! $!,+ F845; BC 86A:?5? 8A ;8A<8AA5;<E:6=86;5@EA8=8AE?;5?5;=EB5 =?36A<8==5;=E?8B:634FE?;8AB:?A34 88 ?EB6E!,,,%!,#F845;BCD438<36=A8A 344E>5; 86 @3?= ':;7<56= 36; 3>3?; ;3=5; !%,%!,+ @3AA5; BC ?86D8@34 8A=?8D= 36; 5AA8E6A ':;75 36; ?86D8@34 E=E? DD8;56= 438<A?8B:6348;3?86 6E+&!,%8A - 13 - <E;8F85; E<@56A3=8E6 8A 56236D5; =E A" $%,,,0 3A 37386A= A ,,%"0 3>3?;5; BC =?8B:634 >8=2 86=5?5A= 3= %M @3 F?E<;3=5EFD438<@5=8=8E6=844;5@EA8= 888 6A:?5?=E;5@EA8=A38;DE<@56A3=8E6>8=286A8I >55JA 8H 6 ;5@EA8= D438<36= 6E0>8F5 8A 254; 56=8=45; FE?!,MEF3>3?;3<E:6=36;53D2EF25?D284; FE?$M53D2 H 438<36= 6E$0<E=25? 8A 56=8=45; FE? !,M 36; D438<36= 6E%0F3=25? 8A 56=8=45; FE? ?5<386867 $MEF3>3?;3<E:6= H8 6=8?5 3>3?; 3<E:6= 3@@E?=8E65; 86 F3HE:? EF D284;?56=EB5J5@=86F8I5;;5@EA8=FE?3@5?8E; EF$C53?A>8=248B5?=C=E=25<=E>8=2;?3>A38; 3<E:6= 86 D3A5 8= 8A 655;5; FE? =258? 28725? 5;:D3=8E6E?<3??8375@:?@EA5A H88 !$M EF 3@@E?=8E6<56= 86 F3HE:? EF >8F5 36; <E=25?85D438<36=A6E36;$?5A@5D=8H54C 8A E?;5?5; =E B5 ?5453A5; >8=2 ?5<386867 3<E:6==EB5J5@=86;5@EA8=FE? C53?A - 14 - H888 @@E?=8E6<56= EF $M 86 F3HE:? EF D438<36= 6E%0F3=25?8AE?;5?5;=EB5?5453A5; 7( &$$ ' " ' 8A= E4 E"