- 1 - ! " #$ " #$ !$%! "" &%' ( !!"! # $ % " &' ( ( ) ' $&'% ()* ( '(+ + Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - *)!) , ' ()- ( + ' (" ( &'. - ( '( + + *)!) . '. () (& +,,,-!* '( + + *)!) # $ " % "-,$"% & & )"")!), "')!)) / - 3 - & ( ( 0 0 $ $(0 % 123 455647 23 89 :16 ;742<4=:3 >276? @=?6A 6;:2B= "-,$"%B>:16B:BA612;763;:"**862=C4CCA26D6?89 :16E@?C<6=:4=?4F4A??4:6?)"")!),54336?89:16 6=2BA 2D27 @?C6 4=? 4?C2A2 2= B"')!))366G2=C6=14=;6<6=:B>;B<56=34:2B= ) 4;:3 C2D2=C A236 :B :16 >272=C B> :16 455647 8A26>79 3:4:6? 4A6 :14: B= !!)!)) ?6;6436? 4<@7@ 'B4=<4=:1.4774554F435AB;66?2=C43452772B=A2?6A 47B=C F2:1 A 484==4 2= :162A 82G6 864A2=C 6CB+ ,,,-!*>AB<=5@A:B14A<45@A16342?82G6F43 ?A2D6= 89 484==4 &16= :169 ;4<6 =64A =45@A @376547724:6B=42=AB4?4:48B@:),!5<:16A2?6A - 4 - B> 82G6 6CB+,,,-!* ?ABD6 2= 4 A431 4=? =6C72C6=: <4==6A 4=? ?4316? :B :16 82G6 864A2=C 6CB"! ! 3 4 A63@7: 4<@7@ 3@3:42=6? 2=E@A263 4=? 16 F43 ?6;74A6? 8AB@C1: ?64? 89 :16 BD: B352:474?C2A164;;2?6=:F43;4@36?89:16A2?6AB> 82G6?@6:B123A4314=?=6C72C6=:?A2D2=C , 6;6436? F43 1476 4=? 1647:19 4: :16 :2<6 B> 4;;2?6=:4=?F4364A=2=C3)!!!!'56A<B=:1>AB<123 ;BB726 FBAG 16 56:2:2B=6A B" 143 7B3: 16A 1@384=? 4=? 56:2:2B=6A B3) :B 14D6 7B3: :162A >4:16A 4=? 56:2:2B=6A B 143 7B3: 16A 3B= 16 56:2:2B=6A3 F6A6 :B:4779?656=?2=CB=:162=;B<6B>?6;6436?6=;6:16 ;742<4=:3 >276? :16 ;742< 56:2:2B= @=?6A 6;:2B= " B> B:BA 612;763 ;: 86>BA6 :16 742<3 A28@=47 366G2=C ;B<56=34:2B=>BA:162=E@A2633@3:42=6?2=:16AB4?:A4>>2; 4;;2?6=: @A3@4=::B:163@<<B=3A635B=?6=:B)143 45564A6? 4=? >276? 3:4:6<6=: B> B8E6;:2B=3 16 - 5 - A635B=?6=: B" ?2? =B: 45564A 4=? 16 F43 574;6? =:1684323B>:165764?2=C3B>:1654A:263:16 742<3A28@=47>A4<6?:16233@634=?:16A64>:6AA6;BA?6? :166D2?6=;6 = BA?6A :B 5ABD6:16 ;436 ;742<4=:B" CB: 6H4<2=6? 16A367> 43 &" 4=? CB: 6H1282:6? ?B;@<6=:3 =4<679 H" :B H = 86147> B> A635B=?6=:3 B=6 F2:=633 23 6H4<2=6? 43 &" 4=? CB: <4AG6?B=6?B;@<6=:43H" 16 742<3A28@=4789:162<5@C=6?E@?C<6=: 167?:14: :16 4;;2?6=: :BBG574;6B= 4;;B@=:B> A431 4=? =6C72C6=: A2?2=C B> :16 A2?6A B> :16 B>>6=?2=C D612;76 43 4 A63@7: B> F12;1 ?6;6436? 3@3:42=6? 2=E@A263 4=? 3@;;@<86? :B :16 2=E@A263 16 A28@=47 @5B= ;B=32?6A2=C :16 BA47 4=? ?B;@<6=:4A9 6D2?6=;6 574;6? 86>BA6 2: 167? :14: :16 ;742<4=:3 4A6 6=:2:76? :B ;B<56=34:2B=B>3")*!!!'47B=CF2:12=:6A63:4::16 A4:6 B> I 54 4=? ?2A6;:6? A635B=?6=: B) :B ?65B32: - 6 - :16;B<56=34:2B=62=C?2334:23>26?F2:1:16J@4=:@<B> ;B<56=34:2B=:123455647143866=>276? - 16764A=6?;B@=367>BA:16;742<4=:3A4236?:16 >B77BF2=C;B=:6=:2B=3( 4% 16 764A=6? ;B@=367 45564A2=C >BA :16 2=3@A4=;6;B<54=9143;B=:6=?6?:14:43B=:16?4:6B> :16 4;;2?6=: :16 B>>6=?2=C D612;76 F43 ;BD6A6? F2:1 ;: B72;9 4=? B=79 7248272:9 4AB@36 2= A6356;: B> :12A? 54A:9 D6=:1B@C1A28@=47143167?:14::162=3@A4=;6;B<54=9 23 =B: 724876 :B 549 :16 ;B<56=34:2B= :B :16 :12A? 54A:9 :1652772B=A2?6AF1BF43?2A6;:6?:B549:16;B<56=34:2B= 4<B@=:F2:17286A:9:BA6;BD6A:1634<6123?2A6;:2B=B> :16A28@=4723;B=:A4A9:B:16E@?C<6=:B>:1656H B@A: 2=:16;436B> A65BA:6?2= ! 8% 6 143 473B A6726? B= :16 E@?C<6=: B> :123 B@A: 2= :16 ;436 B> - 7 - " # A65BA:6? 2= $%& ' :B;B=:6=?:14:B=;6:16B>>6=?2=C D612;7623=B:;BD6A6?F2:1D472?5B72;92=3@A4=;6;B<54=9 ;4==B: 86 ?2A6;:6? :B 549 :16 ;B<56=34:2B= 4<B@=: 6=;6B=:1636CAB@=?35A496?:B34??767248272:9B=:16 BF=6AB>:16D612;7689477BF2=C:16455647 * 16 A635B=?6=: ;742<4=:3 4A6 36AD6? 4=? @=A65A636=:6? 64A? :16 764A=6? ;B@=367 >BA :16 4556774=: 56A@36? :16 E@?C<6=: 4=? 4F4A? 2=;7@?2=C :16 455647 5456A3 "! :23 =B: 2= ?235@:6 :14:?6;6436?4<@7@ ?26? 2= 4 AB4? :A4>>2; 4;;2?6=: B= !!)!)) ?@6 :B :16 2=E@A263 3@3:42=6? 2= :16 4;;2?6=: ;4@36? 89 :16 A2?6A B> :16 B>>6=?2=C D612;76 26 B:BA;9;76 6CB+,, ,-!* :23 =B: 2= ?235@:6:14:?6;6436? F43 5AB;66?2=C B= :16 <B:BA;9;76 43 4 52772B= A2?6A : 23 473B =B: 2= ?235@:6:14::16342?<B:BA;9;76F43233@6?F2:12=3@A4=;6 - 8 - 5B72;9F12;1F43:FBF16676A8@=?765B72;94=?34<623 14D2=C 54;G4C6 ;BD6A4C6 D472? >AB< )*"!)!" :B )-"!)!)! F16A643 :16 4;;2?6=: 2= :16 ;436 B= 14=? B;;@AA6?B=!!)!))16342?<B:BA;9;76F4314D2=C 8432;:12A?54A:97248272:9B=794=?5B72;9F43;BD6A6?>AB< )*"!)!)!:B )-"!)!) @A:16A:165B72;9F43 D472? >BA >2D6 964A3 16 ;B<5A616=32D6 5B72;9 F43 D472? >BA B=79 B=6 964A 16 4;;2?6=: F43 B;;@AA6? 4>:6A :16 ;B<576:2B= B> B=6 964A 14: <64=3 :B 349 43 B= :16 ?4:6B>4;;2?6=::165B72;9;BD6A4C6F43B=79>BA:16:12A? 54A:9 16A6>BA6 :16 2=3@A4=;6 ;B<54=9 23 =B: 724876 :B 549 :16 ;B<56=34:2B= 32=;6 ?6;6436? F43 :A4D672=C 43 4 52772B=A2?6A "" 123 B@A: 2= :16 ;436 B> " # $% 143 ;B=32?6A6? :16 32<274A 233@6 4=? 167? :14: 2= A6356;:B>52772B=A2?6A23;B=;6A=6?1623=B:4:12A?54A:9 16 2=3@A4=;6 ;B<54=9 23 =B: 724876 :B 549 :16 ;B<56=34:2B= 16 A676D4=: 54A4CA451 B3) :B ) B> :16342?E@?C<6=:236H:A4;:6?43@=?6A( - 9 - ! " #$ " %& '( ) ) * '# ' ! ') ) * ! # ' ) ! '' '( )! ) ' ' ! ' ! ! ( ' ! + " ! ) ,) ! ' #) - ./ )!) "' 0 ./ ( ' ' ' ' ' ' )! ) # ' 1 ! ' ) ! ' ' ( )! ) ' $(' '! ' ! , ' ' ! ' ) ) - 10 - 2 3 ' 4 56 ) ' ' ' ! ' ' ' ! ' ) ) ( ' ' ' ' ' 77! 2 " ) - ( ' 8 ! 9 " (3 :.; < =5; ( ' ' ' ' ' !" ) ) < .=5%.& ! ! ' ! ! ! " ) ! ! !>") ' ( ' '" ! ! ' ? " ! ! '@ ' ' ' ' ' !" / ?! ) " ) , - 11 - ) ' 6 A3 ' ' ' !" - ' 3;::>7 '" 3:>7 ! ) ' 77! 4 ") =D26FB>:164>BA6342??6;232B=3:16A28@=47 143 ;B<<2::6? 4= 6AABA 2= ?2A6;:2=C :16 2=3@A4=;6 ;B<54=9:B549:16;B<56=34:2B=4<B@=:F2:17286A:9:B A6;BD6A>AB<:16BF=6AB>:16B>>6=?2=CD612;76B:14: 6H:6=::16455647A6J@2A63:B86477BF6? ", =:16A63@7:F65433:16>B77BF2=C( 4%1645564723( 8% 16 E@?C<6=: 4=? 4F4A? B> :16 742<3 A28@=47 23 <B?2>26? :B :16 6H:6=: :14: >43:6=2=CB>7248272:9B=:162=3@A4=;6;B<54=9 - 12 - :B 549 ;B<56=34:2B=23 36: 432?6 16 BF=6A B>:16B>>6=?2=CD612;7626A635B=?6=:B 23 ?2A6;:6? :B 549 :16 6=:2A6 ;B<56=34:2B= 43 4F4A?6?89:16A28@=47:B:16;742<4=:347B=C F2:12=:6A63: ;% 164<B@=:2=?65B32:86>BA6:123 B@A:<4?6 89:16 =3@A4=;6;B<54=93147786:A4=3<2::6? :B :16 A28@=47 4=? 2=3@A4=;6 ;B<54=9 23 56A<2::6?:BF2:1?A4F:16342?4<B@=: )* &" ' $ )* &!$%!' $ 23:B("7B(