Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63864 (PNJ)
JASBIR SINGH ALIAS JASVIR SINGH v. FINANCIAL COMMISSIONER (APPEALS) AND OTHERS
CWP/17464/2022 · 2025-01-21
Harsh Bunger
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63864 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63864 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
!" !
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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document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
$$(@6/(- B- $ '2( +%,( )* % & ' (%% )**! +, #4#3 AE#'>%, 2(3&.<'2(!#4#,#)$ ($+2)*'2#,)6/''2%'+2)#+()*'2(!#,'/#+' )33(+')/+%$$)'.(3#12'3<,('%,#&((4($#*'>)4#(>,%/(8),,#.3( 6$3(,,'2(/(#,%$<8%'($'#33(1%3#'<)/8(/4(/,#'<'2(/(#$-'#,%3,)>(33 (,'%.3#,2(& '2%' '2( 3(%/$(& )33(+')/ #, '2( 7%#$ %6'2)/#'< *)/ %88)#$'7($' )* '2( ;%7.%/&%/- ' #, '2( )33(+')/ >2) $)' )$3< SANJIV KUMAR SHARMA 2025.02.15 16:56 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document
%88/(+#%'(,'2(%$'(+(&($',)*%33'2(+%$&#&%'(,#$'2(*/%<.6'%3,) 8(/,)$%33<#$'(/%+',>#'2'2(7- - $4#(>)*'2(%.)4(&#,+6,,#)$%7)*'2(+)$,#&(/(&4#(> '2%' 3(%/$(& !#4#,#)$%3 )77#,,#)$(/ %, >(33 %, 3(%/$(& #$%$+#%3 )77#,,#)$(/ 2%4( (//(& #$ 3%> %$& *%+', #$ ,(''#$1 %,#&( 3(%/$(& )33(+')/:,)/&(/&%'(&B- - $$(@6/(-
- (,63'%$'3< '2( #$,'%$' >/#' 8('#'#)$ #, %33)>(& %$& '2( #7861$(&)/&(/&%'(&B-- $$(@6/(A8%,,(&.<3(%/$(& !#4#,#)$%3)77#,,#)$(/%$&)/&(/&%'(& - A-
$$(@6/( 8%,,(&.<3(%/$(&#$%$+#%3)77#,,#)$(/%/(,('%,#&(%$&'2()/&(/ &%'(&B- - $$(@6/(8%,,(&.<3(%/$(&)33(+')/%88)#$'#$1 '2( 8('#'#)$(/ %, ;%7.%/&%/ )* 4#33%1( #/C%86/ (2,#3 %$& !#,'/#+' ),2#%/86/#,7%#$'%#$(&- - ($&#$1%883#+%'#)$,#*%$<,2%33%3,),'%$&+3),(&-
0
! - -
,9?, 2('2(/,8(%?#$1/(%,)$(&
"(,) 2('2(//(8)/'%.3(
"(,) SANJIV KUMAR SHARMA 2025.02.15 16:56 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document