Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 63864 (KAR)
PARVATI D/O NARASANNA BAGALI v. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER AND ORS
WP/200071/2023 · 2025-09-17
Jyoti Mulimani
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63864 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 63864 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#!$$ !! %&'
! "
# $$ %
# &
'
(
'(
'
#$ $
)(
Digitally signed by PREMCHANDRA M R Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
&
&# # #
#$ $
)( ! "
$#$%
(* $ % +"&&
% '', %
%$%
%
-
. /0#12034 $56789:4 ;25:<=6 2: >=386? 2? 948;34: 838@8:?2903=A=04042:=9948664789@5:835789?29 9=<A2:B=:0< 02 ( 8:B 94
$49=/803 ;25:<=6 ?29 9=<A2:B=:0<8:B"8&38C=8AA=89=B4:A=9<2: 25:<=6 /0#12034 $56789:4 <5>/40< 0380 <3= 38< 4:<095;042:<02/87=<5>/4<<42:4:03=/800=9 3=2986<5>/4<<42:/8B=>1;25:<=6?2903=A=04042:=94< A68;=B2:9=;29B
- 3 -
' 3=A=04042:8C=9/=:0<89=8<5:B=9 3= <5>@=;0 /800=9 2? 03= 940 =04042: 4< 68:B >=894:D 12 8 ;299=<A2:B4:D 02 :=E 12 ' /=8<594:D ;9=(5:08<<40580=B80#4D8978686578:B4<094;084;359 04<<84B038003=<84B68:BE8<2E:=B>103=A=04042:=9.< ?803=9:8/=61898<8::8
8D864=B4=B4:F8:B34<E4?= :8/=615BB8//886<2B4=B3=A=04042:=9;2:0=:B<0380<3= 4<03=<26=<59C4C292?898<8::8<5;;==B<0234<=:049==<080= 0 4< <080=B 0380 8668118 22BB8:898<8::8 G 03= ?25903 9=<A2:B=:0 E32 4< 03= <2: 2? 03= A89=:086 5:;6= 2? 03= A=04042:=9 /8:8D=B 02 D=0 34< :8/= =:0=9=B 4: 03= 4:
265/: 2<F 8:B ' E403250 8:1 94D30 0406= 8:B 4:0=9=<0 4:
F 2:0=:B4:D 0380 03= 508042:
9B=9 2 B80=B (F 8:B 508042: 2 B80=B ' (F 89= >2D5< 03= A=04042:=9 ?46=B 8: 8AA=86 >=?29= <<4<08:0 2//4<<42:=9 84;359 4: AA=86 2 ' ' : 8AA64;8042: 5:B=9 =;042: 2? 03= 4/408042: ;0 E8< 86<2 ?46=B 02 ;2:B2:= 03= B=681 3= <<4<08:0 2//4<<42:=9 C4B= 29B=9 B80=B , ' ' B4</4<<=B 03= 8AA=86 2: 03= D925:B 2? B=681 8:B 68;3=< < 8D84:<0 03= <84B 29B=9 03= A=04042:=9 A9=?=99=B 8
- 4 -
=C4<42: =04042: >=?29= 03= =A501 2//4<<42:=9 84;359 3= =A501 2//4<<42:=9 C4B= 29B=9 B80=B ', ' '' ;2:?49/=B 03= 29B=9 2? 03= <<4<08:0 2//4<<42:=9 8:B B4</4<<=B03==C4<42:=04042::B=903=<=;49;5/<08:;=<03= A=04042:=94<>=?29=034<2590 ( 25:<=6 ?29 03= 9=<A=;04C= A8904=< 59D=B <=C=986 ;2:0=:042:< /0#12034$56789:4;25:<=6?2903=A=04042:=9<5>/40< 0380 03= 29B=9< A8<<=B >1 03= <<4<08:0 2//4<<42:=9 8:B =A5012//4<<42:=989=34D36189>409891A=9C=9<=8:B466=D86 =H0 <3= <5>/40< 0380 0380 03= =:B29<=/=:0 B80=B ( ' ' 4<<5=B>103=838<46B89;6=8961=<08>64<3=<03=?8;0 038003==:0914:03= 4<2:03=>8<4<2?8>2D5</508042:
=:;= 03= B4</4<<86 2? 8AA=86 8:B 03= 9=C4<42: 89= :20 @5<04?4=B ?5903=9 <5>/4<<42: 4< /8B= 0380 03= D=:=862D1 80 ::=H59=#;6=8961=<08>64<3=<03=?8;0038003=A=04042:=94<03= <26=<59C4C4:D3=492?B=;=8<=B89<8::8
8D864
- 5 -
25:<=6 C=3=/=:061 ;2:0=:B=B 0380 03= 738<98 A838:4 E34;3 4< 03= >8<4; 9=;29B 2? 94D30 2? 034< 9=D42: 9=?6=;0< 03= :8/= 2?
89<8::8 8:B 738<98 A838:4 4< :20 2:61 8 >8<4;
9=C=:5= 9=;29B >50 03= <8/= 4< 09=80=B 2: A89 E403 03= 0406= B2;5/=:0 8<061 <3= <5>/40< 0380 03= A=04042:=9 38B <32E:
<5??4;4=:0 9=8<2: 02 ;2:B2:= 03= B=681 25:<=6 03=9=?29= <5>/40< 0380 03= 29B=9 A8<<=B >1 03= <<4<08:0 2//4<<42:=9 8:B03==A5012//4<<42:=989=648>6=02>=<=08<4B= ?29 9=<A2:B=:0< 02 ( 8:B 94
$49=/803 ;25:<=6 ?29 9=<A2:B=:0< 8:B "8& @24:061 <5>/40< 0380 03= A=04042:=938<I5=<042:=B03=/508042:=:094=<2?F8?0=98 68A<=2?(,1=89<3=1@5<04?4=B03=8;042:2:03=A8902?03= 9=C=:5= 850329404=< ;;29B4:D61 03=1 A981=B ?29 B4</4<<86 2? 03=940=04042:
=89B03=89D5/=:0<8:BA=95<=B03=940A8A=9< E403;89=
3=4<<5=?866<E4034:8:8992E;2/A8<<8:B9=680=< 02;3866=:D4:D03=/508042:=:094=<2?F04<:204:B4<A50=
- 6 -
0380 ;=9084: /508042: =:094=< E=9= /8B= 4: 2 B80=B (F 8:B 2 B80=B ' (F 098:D=61 03= A=04042:=98?0=9868A<=2?86/2<0(,1=89<;3866=:D=B03=<8/= >=?29=03=<<4<08:02//4<<42:=9 D22BB=862?89D5/=:04<;8:C8<<=B2:64/408042:< 869=8B1:20=B8>2C=03=/508042:=:094=</8B=4:FE=9= I5=<042:=B4:' ' 4=8?0=9868A<=2?86/2<0(,1=89<3= <<4<08:0 2//4<<42:=9 =H0=:<2 9=?=99=B 02 03= /80=9486 2:
9=;29B 8:B 94D3061 9=@=;0=B 03= 8AA=86 8:B 03= <8/= E8< ;2:?49/=B >1 03= =A501 2//4<<42:=9 %5903=9/29= 03= 2:.>6= A=H 2590 4:
! "B4<A2<=B2?2:' F' '38<3=6B0380 03= ;2:<0405042:86 ;2590< 25D30 02 >= ;2D:4J8:0 2? 03= 8A8031 8:B A8:D< 2? 8 A94C80= 6404D8:0 404D8:0< ;8::20 >= A68;=B 4:
<4058042:< 2? A=9A=0586 6404D8042:< E3=9=4: 03= ?9540< 2? 03=49 B=;9==<29?8C2598>6=29B=9<89=?95<0980=B80680=9<08D=<3= A=H259038<86<23=6B0380:26404D8:0<3256B>=A=9/400=B02 >= <2 6=0389D4; 8:B 8A803=04; /5;3 6=<< >= A=9/400=B >1 03= ;2590<02/4<5<=03=A92;=<<2?68E?4:B:24:?49/4014:03=
- 7 -
29B=9< A8<<=B>1 03= <<4<08:0 2//4<<42:=9 8:B 03= =A501 2//4<<42:=93=940=04042:4<B=C24B2?/=940<8:B4<648>6= 02>=9=@=;0=B , =<5608:06103=940=04042:4<#$%$&'$( =;85<= 2? 9=@=;042: 2? 03= 940 =04042: A=:B4:D 4:0=962;50291 8AA64;8042:< 4? 8:1 89= B4<A2<=B 2? 8:B 4:0=94/ B49=;042:<4?8:1<08:B<B4<;389D=B
(& %$ !!' $
4<0262'